Comparability assessments of process and product changes made during development of two different monoclonal antibodies.

To assess the impact of manufacturing changes on antibody structure and function during the course of product development, three comparability studies were performed for each of two different IgG1 monoclonal antibody product candidates. Comparability study #1 evaluated the effect of changing the cell line and bulk drug substance manufacturing process for cell culture and purification. Results indicated that these process changes led to differences in sialylation of N-glycans and/or C-terminal lysine levels. Comparability study #2 results confirmed that scale-up of the bulk process and transfer to the commercial site, combined with changing from a lyophilized to a liquid dosage form, did not impact the structural or functional integrity of the antibodies. Comparability study #3 examined possible differences arising when the liquid formulation filled into pre-filled syringes and vials. Results indicated nearly identical molecular structure, biological activity, and degradation profiles except for a small yet statistically significant increase in the levels of subvisible particles in pre-filled syringes. These results from comparability studies with two different monoclonal antibodies are discussed with respect to the timing of the manufacturing changes and overall comparability strategies to assure safety and efficacy during development.

An Industry Perspective on Forced Degradation Studies of Biopharmaceuticals: Survey Outcome and Recommendations.

The BioPhorum Development Group is an industry-wide consortium enabling networking and sharing of common practices for the development of biopharmaceuticals. Forced degradation studies (FDSs) are often used in biotherapeutic development to assess criticality of quality attributes and in comparability studies to ensure product manufacturing process consistency. To gain an understanding of current industry approaches for FDS, the BioPhorum Development Group-Forced Degradation Point Share group conducted an intercompany collaboration exercise, which included a benchmarking survey and group discussions around FDS of monoclonal antibodies. The results of this industry collaboration provide insights into the practicalities of these characterization studies and how they are being used to support the product lifecycle from innovation to marketed products. The survey requested feedback on the intended purpose, materials, conditions, number and length of time points used, and analytical techniques carried out to give a complete picture of the range of common industry practices. This article discusses the results of this global benchmarking survey across 12 companies and presents these as a guide to a common approach to FDS across the industry which can be used to guide the design of FDS based on chemistry and manufacturing control product life-cycle and biomolecule needs.

Using bispecific antibodies in forced degradation studies to analyze the structure-function relationships of symmetrically and asymmetrically modified antibodies.

Forced degradation experiments of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) aid in the identification of critical quality attributes (CQAs) by studying the impact of post-translational modifications (PTMs), such as oxidation, deamidation, glycation, and isomerization, on biological functions. Structure-function characterization of mAbs can be used to identify the PTM CQAs and develop appropriate analytical and process controls. However, the interpretation of forced degradation results can be complicated because samples may contain mixtures of asymmetrically and symmetrically modified mAbs with one or two modified chains. We present a process to selectively create symmetrically and asymmetrically modified antibodies for structure-function characterization using the bispecific DuoBody® platform. Parental molecules mAb1 and mAb2 were first stressed with peracetic acid to induce methionine oxidation. Bispecific antibodies were then prepared from a mixture of oxidized or unoxidized parental mAbs by a controlled Fab-arm exchange process. This process was used to systematically prepare four bispecific mAb products: symmetrically unoxidized, symmetrically oxidized, and both combinations of asymmetrically oxidized bispecific mAbs. Results of this study demonstrated chain-independent, 1:2 stoichiometric binding of the mAb Fc region to both FcRn receptor and to Protein A. The approach was also applied to create asymmetrically deamidated mAbs at the asparagine 330 residue. Results of this study support the proposed 1:1 stoichiometric binding relationship between the FcγRIIIa receptor and the mAb Fc. This approach should be generally applicable to study the potential impact of any modification on biological function.

Evaluation of a dual-wavelength size exclusion HPLC method with improved sensitivity to detect protein aggregates and its use to better characterize degradation pathways of an IgG1 monoclonal antibody.

The evaluation of a dual wavelength size exclusion high performance liquid chromatography (DW-SE-HPLC) method with improved sensitivity to detect aggregates in a high concentration IgG1 monoclonal antibody formulation is presented. This technique utilizes ultraviolet detection at two different wavelengths to monitor the levels of monomer, aggregate, and fragments and was shown to have improved sensitivity for the detection aggregates and fragments compared to light scattering (LS) detection. After assay optimization including the use of column conditioning, the limit of quantitation for aggregates was determined to be 0.04% with essentially complete recovery of aggregates from the column (>99.5%). The DW-SE-HPLC method was used to evaluate the level of protein aggregates generated by different environmental conditions such as exposure to elevated temperatures/acidic pH or intense light. The detection and characterization of protein aggregates by DW-SE-HPLC was compared with an orthogonal biophysical technique (sedimentation velocity analytical ultracentrifugation, SV-AUC). A good overall correlation was observed for levels of monomer, aggregates (dimer and multimers), and fragments as measured by the two analytical techniques (e.g., 6.0% vs. 5.3% and 14% vs. 11% for dimeric aggregates generated by elevated temperature/acidic pH and light exposure, respectively). The stability profile of a high concentration IgG1 monoclonal antibody formulation was investigated under stressed storage conditions (40 degrees C over 3 months) using the DW-SE-HPLC method including the loss of monomeric species with the concomitant accumulation of both aggregates and fragments. The nature and composition of the aggregates (primarily noncovalent dimers) and fragments (primarily loss of Fab from an intact IgG1) formed during storage were further characterized by a combination of LS measurements and mass spectroscopy analysis of deglycosylated IgG1 samples isolated by preparative SE-HPLC. The combination of DW-SE-HPLC, SV-AUC, LS, and mass spectroscopy results provided a detailed overall understanding the monomer, aggregate, fragment degradation pathway(s) for a high concentration IgG1 monoclonal antibody formulation during storage.

Expression, purification, and characterization of avian Thy-1 from Lec1 mammalian and Tn5 insect cells.

Structural studies of asparagine-linked glycoproteins are complicated by the oligosaccharide heterogeneity inherent to individual glycosylation sites. Herein, we report the cloning of a novel isoform of avian Thy-1 and the subsequent expression, purification, and characterization of a soluble form of Thy-1 from Lec1 mammalian and Tn5 insect cells. The novel isoform of Thy-1 differs from the previously reported chicken isoform by eight amino acid residues, but these changes do not alter the secondary structure content, the disulfide bond pattern, or the sites of glycosylation. The disulfide linkage pattern and glycoform distribution on each N-glycosylation site of recombinant chicken Thy-1 from both cell lines were determined by a combination of amino-terminal sequencing and mass spectrometry. The mass spectral data showed that the amino-terminal glutamine was modified to pyroglutamate. Recombinant Thy-1 from Lec1 cells contained (GlcNAc)(2)(Man)(5) on asparagine 60, whereas the oligosaccharides on asparagine 23 and 100 contained approximately 80% (GlcNAc)(2)(Man)(4) and approximately 20% (GlcNAc)(2)(Man)(5). The glycoforms on Thy-1 expressed in Tn5 cells were more heterogeneous, with the oligosaccharides ranging over (GlcNAc)(2)(Fuc)(0-2)(Man)(2-3) on each site. The ability to generate recombinant glycoproteins with restricted carbohydrate heterogeneity is the first step toward the systematic study of structure-function relationships in intact glycoproteins.