Emerging Roles for the Mitochondrial ATP Synthase Supercomplexes.

As pointed out by Gu et al. (Science 2019) in mammalian mitochondria, the H-shaped tetrameric structure of the ATP synthase, the cell powerhouse, consists of two V-shaped dimers linked by two IF1 in antiparallel arrangement. This supramolecular structure reveals new functional/structural roles of the enzyme complex in mitochondria.

Mitochondrial F-type ATP synthase: multiple enzyme functions revealed by the membrane-embedded FO structure.

Of the two main sectors of the F-type ATP synthase, the membrane-intrinsic FO domain is the one which, during evolution, has undergone the highest structural variations and changes in subunit composition. The FO complexity in mitochondria is apparently related to additional enzyme functions that lack in bacterial and thylakoid complexes. Indeed, the F-type ATP synthase has the main bioenergetic role to synthesize ATP by exploiting the electrochemical gradient built by respiratory complexes. The FO membrane domain, essential in the enzyme machinery, also participates in the bioenergetic cost of synthesizing ATP and in the formation of the cristae, thus contributing to mitochondrial morphology. The recent enzyme involvement in a high-conductance channel, which forms in the inner mitochondrial membrane and promotes the mitochondrial permeability transition, highlights a new F-type ATP synthase role. Point mutations which cause amino acid substitutions in FO subunits produce mitochondrial dysfunctions and lead to severe pathologies. The FO variability in different species, pointed out by cryo-EM analysis, mirrors the multiple enzyme functions and opens a new scenario in mitochondrial biology.

Ca2+ as cofactor of the mitochondrial H+ -translocating F1 FO -ATP(hydrol)ase.

The mitochondrial F1 FO -ATPase in the presence of the natural cofactor Mg2+ acts as the enzyme of life by synthesizing ATP, but it can also hydrolyze ATP to pump H+ . Interestingly, Mg2+ can be replaced by Ca2+ , but only to sustain ATP hydrolysis and not ATP synthesis. When Ca2+ inserts in F1 , the torque generation built by the chemomechanical coupling between F1 and the rotating central stalk was reported as unable to drive the transmembrane H+ flux within FO . However, the failed H+ translocation is not consistent with the oligomycin-sensitivity of the Ca2+ -dependent F1 FO -ATP(hydrol)ase. New enzyme roles in mitochondrial energy transduction are suggested by recent advances. Accordingly, the structural F1 FO -ATPase distortion driven by ATP hydrolysis sustained by Ca2+ is consistent with the permeability transition pore signal propagation pathway. The Ca2+ -activated F1 FO -ATPase, by forming the pore, may contribute to dissipate the transmembrane H+ gradient created by the same enzyme complex.

Relationship between serum concentration, functional parameters and cell bioenergetics in IPEC-J2 cell line.

The foetal bovine serum (FBS) concentration could influence functional parameters of IPEC-J2 cells. IPEC-J2 is a non-transformed continuous epithelial cell line that represents an established in vitro model to study porcine gut inflammation and alterations of intestinal integrity. This cell line also represents a good translational model thanks to the high similitudes between pig and human gastrointestinal tract. With the aim to assess if the FBS-dependent functional variations are linked to the bioenergetic aspects, the addition of 5% and 10% FBS in the IPEC-J2 culture medium were tested. Doubling time and TEER measurement indicated that cells cultured at higher FBS dose grow faster and as a more compact monolayer. 10% FBS increases ATP production and mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation (OxPhos) and does not affect glycolysis. Both at 5% and 10% FBS ATP production mainly comes from OxPhos and FBS concentration does not affect the cell respiration bioenergetic parameters. Noteworthy, IPEC-J2 treated with 5% and 10% FBS have a metabolic potential since both OxPhos and glycolysis increase by > 100% and < 50%, respectively in comparison with baseline metabolism. Moreover, glucose, fatty acids and glutamine constitute the preferred metabolic fuel for mitochondrial respiration at both FBS conditions tested. Accordingly, the cells flexibility to oxidize these substrates shows that IPEC-J2 mitochondria cannot maintain the basal ATP production without oxidizing all the substrates available irrespective of FBS concentration. To sum up, in IPEC-J2 cells OxPhos increases with the FBS-stimulated functional physiological parameters to fulfil ATP requirements.

The mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase exploits the dithiol redox state to modulate the permeability transition pore.

The dithiol reagents phenylarsine oxide (PAO) and dibromobimane (DBrB) have opposite effects on the F1FO-ATPase activity. PAO 20% increases ATP hydrolysis at 50 µM when the enzyme activity is activated by the natural cofactor Mg2+ and at 150 µM when it is activated by Ca2+. The PAO-driven F1FO-ATPase activation is reverted to the basal activity by 50 µM dithiothreitol (DTE). Conversely, 300 µM DBrB decreases the F1FO-ATPase activity by 25% when activated by Mg2+ and by 50% when activated by Ca2+. In both cases, the F1FO-ATPase inhibition by DBrB is insensitive to DTE. The mitochondrial permeability transition pore (mPTP) formation, related to the Ca2+-dependent F1FO-ATPase activity, is stimulated by PAO and desensitized by DBrB. Since PAO and DBrB apparently form adducts with different cysteine couples, the results highlight the crucial role of cross-linking of vicinal dithiols on the F1FO-ATPase, with (ir)reversible redox states, in the mPTP modulation.

Sulfide affects the mitochondrial respiration, the Ca2+-activated F1FO-ATPase activity and the permeability transition pore but does not change the Mg2+-activated F1FO-ATPase activity in swine heart mitochondria.

In mammalian cells enzymatic and non-enzymatic pathways produce H2S, a gaseous transmitter which recently emerged as promising therapeutic agent and modulator of mitochondrial bioenergetics. To explore this topic, the H2S donor NaHS, at micromolar concentrations, was tested on swine heart mitochondria. NaHS did not affect the F1FO-ATPase activated by the natural cofactor Mg2, but, when Mg2+ was replaced by Ca2+, a slight 15% enzyme inhibition at 100 µM NaHS was shown. Conversely, both the NADH-O2 and succinate-O2 oxidoreductase activities were totally inhibited by 200 µM NaHS with IC50 values of 61.6 ± 4.1 and 16.5 ± 4.6 µM NaHS, respectively. Since the mitochondrial respiration was equally inhibited by NaHS at both first or second respiratory substrates sites, the H2S generation may prevent the electron transfer from complexes I and II to downhill respiratory chain complexes, probably because H2S competes with O2 in complex IV, thus reducing membrane potential as a consequence of the cytochrome c oxidase activity inhibition. The Complex IV blockage by H2S was consistent with the linear concentration-dependent NADH-O2 oxidoreductase inhibition and exponential succinate-O2 oxidoreductase inhibition by NaHS, whereas the coupling between substrate oxidation and phosphorylation was unaffected by NaHS. Even if H2S is known to cause sulfhydration of cysteine residues, thiol oxidizing (GSSG) or reducing (DTE) agents, did not affect the F1FO-ATPase activities and mitochondrial respiration, thus ruling out any involvement of post-translational modifications of thiols. The permeability transition pore, the lethal channel which forms when the F1FO-ATPase is stimulated by Ca2+, did not open in the presence of NaHS, which showed a similar effect to ruthenium red, thus suggesting a putative Ca2+ transport cycle inhibition.

Phenylglyoxal inhibition of the mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase activated by Mg2+ or by Ca2+ provides clues on the mitochondrial permeability transition pore.

Phenylglyoxal (PGO), known to cause post-translational modifications of Arg residues, was used to highlight the role of arginine residues of the F1FO-ATPase, which may be crucial to yield the mitochondrial permeability transition pore (mPTP). In swine heart mitochondria PGO inhibits ATP hydrolysis by the F1FO-ATPase either sustained by the natural cofactor Mg2+ or by Ca2+ by a similar uncompetitive inhibition mechanism, namely the tertiary complex (ESI) only forms when the ATP substrate is already bound to the enzyme, and with similar strength, as shown by the similar K'i values (0.82 ± 0.07 mM in presence of Mg2+ and 0.64 ± 0.05 mM in the presence of Ca2+). Multiple inhibitor analysis indicates that features of the F1 catalytic sites and/or the FO proton binding sites are apparently unaffected by PGO. However, PGO and F1 or FO inhibitors can bind the enzyme combine simultaneously. However they mutually hinder to bind the Mg2+-activated F1FO-ATPase, whereas they do not mutually exclude to bind the Ca2+-activated F1FO-ATPase. The putative formation of PGO-arginine adducts, and the consequent spatial rearrangement in the enzyme structure, inhibits the F1FO-ATPase activity but, as shown by the calcium retention capacity evaluation in intact mitochondria, apparently favours the mPTP formation.

Effects of Hydrogen Sulfide Donor NaHS on Porcine Vascular Wall-Mesenchymal Stem Cells.

Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is now considered not only for its toxicity, but also as an endogenously produced gas transmitter with multiple physiological roles, also in maintaining and regulating stem cell physiology. In the present work, we evaluated the effect of a common H2S donor, NaHS, on porcine vascular wall-mesenchymal stem cells (pVW-MSCs). pVW-MSCs were treated for 24 h with increasing doses of NaHS, and the cell viability, cell cycle, and reactive oxygen species (ROS) production were evaluated. Moreover, the long-term effects of NaHS administration on the noteworthy characteristics of pVW-MSCs were analyzed. The MTT test revealed no alteration in cell viability, however, the cell cycle analysis demonstrated that the highest NaHS dose tested (300 µM) determined a block in S phase, which did not depend on the ROS production. Moreover, NaHS (10 µM), continuously administered in culture for 21 days, was able to significantly reduce NG2, Nestin and PDGFR-ß expression. The pro-angiogenic attitude of pVW-MSCs was partially reduced by NaHS: the cells maintained the ability to grow in spheroid and sprouting from that, but endothelial markers (Factor VIII and CD31) were reduced. In conclusion, NaHS can be toxic for pVW-MSCs in high doses, while in low doses, it influences cellular physiology, by affecting the gene expression with a slowing down of the endothelial lineage.

Characterization of metabolic profiles and lipopolysaccharide effects on porcine vascular wall mesenchymal stem cells.

The link between metabolic remodeling and stem cell fate is still unclear. To explore this topic, the metabolic profile of porcine vascular wall mesenchymal stem cells (pVW-MSCs) was investigated. At the first and second cell passages, pVW-MSCs exploit both glycolysis and cellular respiration to synthesize adenosine triphosphate (ATP), but in the subsequent (third to eighth) passages they do not show any mitochondrial ATP turnover. Interestingly, when the first passage pVW-MSCs are exposed to 0.1 or 10 µg/ml lipopolysaccharides (LPSs) for 4 hr, even if ATP synthesis is prevented, the spare respiratory capacity is retained and the glycolytic capacity is unaffected. In contrast, the exposure of pVW-MSCs at the fifth passage to 10 µg/ml LPS stimulates mitochondrial ATP synthesis. Flow cytometry rules out any reactive oxygen species (ROS) involvement in the LPS effects, thus suggesting that the pVW-MSC metabolic pattern is modulated by culture conditions via ROS-independent mechanisms.

Crucial aminoacids in the FO sector of the F1FO-ATP synthase address H+ across the inner mitochondrial membrane: molecular implications in mitochondrial dysfunctions.

The eukaryotic F1FO-ATP synthase/hydrolase activity is coupled to H+ translocation through the inner mitochondrial membrane. According to a recent model, two asymmetric H+ half-channels in the a subunit translate a transmembrane vertical H+ flux into the rotor rotation required for ATP synthesis/hydrolysis. Along the H+ pathway, conserved aminoacid residues, mainly glutamate, address H+ both in the downhill and uphill transmembrane movements to synthesize or hydrolyze ATP, respectively. Point mutations responsible for these aminoacid changes affect H+ transfer through the membrane and, as a cascade, result in mitochondrial dysfunctions and related pathologies. The involvement of specific aminoacid residues in driving H+ along their transmembrane pathway within a subunit, sustained by the literature and calculated data, leads to depict a model consistent with some mitochondrial disorders.

The inhibition of the mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase activity when activated by Ca2+ opens new regulatory roles for NAD.

The mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase is uncompetitively inhibited by NAD+ only when the natural cofactor Mg2+ is replaced by Ca2+, a mode putatively involved in cell death. The Ca2+-dependent F1FO-ATPase is also inhibited when NAD+ concentration in mitochondria is raised by acetoacetate. The enzyme inhibition by NAD+ cannot be ascribed to any de-ac(et)ylation or ADP-ribosylation by sirtuines, as it is not reversed by nicotinamide. Moreover, the addition of acetyl-CoA or palmitate, which would favor the enzyme ac(et)ylation, does not affect the F1FO-ATPase activity. Consistently, NAD+ may play a new role, not associated with redox and non-redox enzymatic reactions, in the Ca2+-dependent regulation of the F1FO-ATPase activity.

Preferential nitrite inhibition of the mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase activities when activated by Ca(2+) in replacement of the natural cofactor Mg(2+).

BACKGROUND: The mitochondrial F1FO-ATP synthase has not only the known life function in building most cellular ATP, but also, as recently hinted, an amazing involvement in cell death. Accordingly, the two-faced enzyme complex, which catalyzes both ATP synthesis and ATP hydrolysis, has been involved in the mitochondrial permeability transition, the master player in apoptosis and necrosis. Nitrite, a cellular nitric oxide reservoir, has a recognized role in cardiovascular protection, through still unclear mechanisms. METHODS: In swine heart mitochondria the effect of nitrite on the F1FO-ATPase activity activated by Ca(2+), henceforth defined as Ca-ATPase(s), or by the natural cofactor Mg(2+), was investigated by evaluating ATP hydrolysis under different assay conditions. RESULTS: Ca(2+) is far less efficient than the natural cofactor Mg(2+) in the ATPase activation. However, when activated by Ca(2+) the ATPase activity is especially responsive to nitrite, which acts as uncompetitive inhibitor and up to 2 mM inhibits the Ca2+-activated-ATPase(s), probably by promoting dytirosine formation on the enzyme proteins, leaving the Mg-ATPase(s) unaffected. Most likely these ATPases refer to the same F1FO complex, even if coexistent ATPases may overlap. CONCLUSIONS: The preferential inhibition by nitrite of the Ca-ATPase(s), due to post-translational tyrosine modifications, may prevent the calcium-dependent functionality of the mitochondrial F1FO complex and related events. GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE: In mitochondria the preferential inhibition of the Ca-ATPase activity/ies by nitrite concentrations which do not affect the coexistent Mg-ATPase(s) may quench the negative events linked to the calcium-dependent functioning mode of the F1FO complex under pathological conditions.

Post-translational modifications of the mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase.

BACKGROUND: The mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase has the main role in synthesizing most of ATP, thus providing energy to living cells, but it also works in reverse and hydrolyzes ATP, depending on the transmembrane electrochemical gradient. Within the same complex the vital role of the enzyme of life coexists with that of molecular switch to trigger programmed cell death. The two-faced vital/lethal role makes the enzyme complex an intriguing biochemical target to fight pathogens resistant to traditional therapies and diseases linked to mitochondrial dysfunctions. A variety of post-translational modifications (PTMs) of selected F1FO-ATPase aminoacids have been reported to affect the enzyme function. SCOPE OF REVIEW: By reviewing the known PTMs of aminoacid side chains of both F1 and FO sectors according to the most recent advances, the main aim is to highlight how local chemical changes may constitute the molecular key leading to pathological or physiological events. MAJOR CONCLUSIONS: PTMs represent the chemical tool to modulate the F1FO-ATPase activity in response to different stimuli. Some PTMs are required to ensure the enzyme catalysis or, conversely, to inactivate the enzyme function. Each covalent modification of the F1FO-ATPase, which occur in response to local changes, is the result of a selective molecular mechanism which, by translating a chemical modification into a biochemical effect, guarantees the enzyme tuning under changing conditions. GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE: Once highlighted how the molecular mechanism works, some PTMs may be exploited to modulate the effect of drugs targeting the enzyme complex or constitute promising tools for F1FO-ATPase-targeted therapeutic strategies.

The c-Ring of the F1FO-ATP Synthase: Facts and Perspectives.

The F1FO-ATP synthase is the only enzyme in nature endowed with bi-functional catalytic mechanism of synthesis and hydrolysis of ATP. The enzyme functions, not only confined to energy transduction, are tied to three intrinsic features of the annular arrangement of c subunits which constitutes the so-called c-ring, the core of the membrane-embedded FO domain: (i) the c-ring constitution is linked to the number of ions (H(+) or Na(+)) channeled across the membrane during the dissipation of the transmembrane electrochemical gradient, which in turn determines the species-specific bioenergetic cost of ATP, the "molecular currency unit" of energy transfer in all living beings; (ii) the c-ring is increasingly involved in the mitochondrial permeability transition, an event linked to cell death and to most mitochondrial dysfunctions; (iii) the c subunit species-specific amino acid sequence and susceptibility to post-translational modifications can address antibacterial drug design according to the model of enzyme inhibitors which target the c subunits. Therefore, the simple c-ring structure not only allows the F1FO-ATP synthase to perform the two opposite tasks of molecular machine of cell life and death, but it also amplifies the enzyme's potential role as a drug target.

Thiol oxidation is crucial in the desensitization of the mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase to oligomycin and other macrolide antibiotics.

BACKGROUND: The macrolide antibiotics oligomycin, venturicidin and bafilomycin, sharing the polyketide ring and differing in the deoxysugar moiety, are known to block the transmembrane ion channel of ion-pumping ATPases; oligomycins are selective inhibitors of mitochondrial ATP synthases. METHODS: The inhibition mechanism of macrolides was explored on swine heart mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase by kinetic analyses. The amphiphilic membrane toxicant tributyltin (TBT) and the thiol reducing agent dithioerythritol (DTE) were used to elucidate the nature of the macrolide-enzyme interaction. RESULTS: When individually tested, the macrolide antibiotics acted as uncompetitive inhibitors of the ATPase activity. Binary mixtures of macrolide inhibitors I1 and I2 pointed out a non-exclusive mechanism, indicating that each macrolide binds to its binding site on the enzyme. When co-present, the two macrolides acted synergistically in the formed quaternary complex (ESI1I2), thus mutually strengthening the enzyme inhibition. The enzyme inhibition by macrolides displaying a shared mechanism was dose-dependently reduced by TBT≥1µM. The TBT-driven enzyme desensitization was reversed by DTE. CONCLUSIONS: The macrolides tested share uncompetitive inhibition mechanism by binding to a specific site in a common macrolide-binding region of FO. The oxidation of highly conserved thiols in the ATP synthase c-ring of FO weakens the interaction between the enzyme and the macrolides. The native macrolide-inhibited enzyme conformation can be restored by reducing crucial thiols oxidized by TBT. GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE: The findings, by elucidating the macrolide inhibitory mechanism on FO, indirectly cast light on the F1FO torque generation involving crucial amino acid residues and may address drug design and antimicrobial therapy.

Opposite rotation directions in the synthesis and hydrolysis of ATP by the ATP synthase: hints from a subunit asymmetry.

The ATP synthase can be imagined as a reversible H(+)-translocating channel embedded in the membrane, FO portion, coupled to a protruding catalytic portion, F1. Under physiological conditions the F1FO complex synthesizes ATP by exploiting the transmembrane electrochemical gradient of protons and their downhill movement. Alternatively, under other patho-physiological conditions it exploits ATP hydrolysis to energize the membrane by uphill pumping protons. The reversibility of the mechanism is guaranteed by the structural coupling between the hydrophilic F1 and the hydrophobic FO. Which of the two opposite processes wins in the energy-transducing membrane complex depends on the thermodynamic balance between the protonmotive force (Δp) and the phosphorylation potential of ATP (ΔG P). Accordingly, while Δp prevalence drives ATP synthesis by translocating protons from the membrane P-side to the N-side and generating anticlockwise torque rotation (viewed from the matrix), ΔG P drives ATP hydrolysis by chemomechanical coupling of FO to F1 with clockwise torque. The direction of rotation is the same in all the ATP synthases, due to the conserved steric arrangement of the chiral a subunit of FO. The ability of this coupled bi-functional complex to produce opposite rotations in ATP synthesis and hydrolysis is explained on the basis of the a subunit asymmetry.

Mussel and mammalian ATP synthase share the same bioenergetic cost of ATP.

The molecular mechanism by which the membrane-embedded FO sector of the mitochondrial ATP synthase translocates protons, thus dissipating the transmembrane protonmotive force and leading to ATP synthesis, involves the neutralization of the carboxylate residues of the c-ring. Carboxylates are thought to constitute the binding sites for ion translocation. In order to cast light on this mechanism, we exploited N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, which covalently binds to FO c-ring carboxylates, and ionophores which selectively modulate the transmembrane electric (Δφ) and chemical (ΔpH) gradients such as valinomycin, nigericin and dinitrophenol. ATP hydrolysis was evaluated in mitochondrial preparations and/or inside-out submitochondrial particles from mussel and mammalian tissues under different experimental conditions. The experiments pointed out striking similarities between mussel and mammalian mitochondrial ATP synthase. Our results support the hypothesis that the ATP synthase of Mytilus galloprovincialis induces intersubunit torque generation and translocates H(+) by coordinating the hydronium ion (H3O(+)) in the ion binding site of FO. Our results are consistent with the hypothesis that in mussel mitochondria the main component of the electrochemical gradient driving proton flux and ATP synthesis is Δφ. Therefore, mussel FO probably contains a small c-ring, which implies a low bioenergetic cost of making ATP as in mammals. These features which make mussel mitochondria as efficient in ATP production as mammalian ones may be especially advantageous in facultative aerobic species which intermittently exploit mitochondrial respiration to generate ATP.

Incoming news on the F-type ATPase structure and functions in mammalian mitochondria.

•Recent findings of cryo-EM structures of mammalian F1FO-ATPase.•The membrane-embedded domain of the F1FO-ATPase and the permeability transition pore.•The Ca2+-activated 1FO-ATPase role in the mPTP is consistent with recent cryo-EM findings.•The membrane-embedded FO participates in mPTP formation in mammalian mitochondria.•Conformational changes within FO modify the inner mitochondrial membrane shape.

The inhibition of gadolinium ion (Gd3+) on the mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase is linked to the modulation of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore.

The mitochondrial permeability transition pore (PTP), which drives regulated cell death when Ca2+ concentration suddenly increases in mitochondria, was related to changes in the Ca2+-activated F1FO-ATPase. The effects of the gadolinium cation (Gd3+), widely used for diagnosis and therapy, and reported as PTP blocker, were evaluated on the F1FO-ATPase activated by Mg2+ or Ca2+ and on the PTP. Gd3+ more effectively inhibits the Ca2+-activated F1FO-ATPase than the Mg2+-activated F1FO-ATPase by a mixed-type inhibition on the former and by uncompetitive mechanism on the latter. Most likely Gd3+ binding to F1, is favoured by Ca2+ insertion. The maximal inactivation rates (kinact) of pseudo-first order inactivation are similar either when the F1FO-ATPase is activated by Ca2+ or by Mg2+. The half-maximal inactivator concentrations (KI) are 2.35 ± 0.35 mM and 0.72 ± 0.11 mM, respectively. The potency of a mechanism-based inhibitor (kinact/KI) also highlights a higher inhibition efficiency of Gd3+ on the Ca2+-activated F1FO-ATPase (0.59 ± 0.09 mM-1∙s-1) than on the Mg2+-activated F1FO-ATPase (0.13 ± 0.02 mM-1∙s-1). Consistently, the PTP is desensitized in presence of Gd3+. The Gd3+ inhibition on both the mitochondrial Ca2+-activated F1FO-ATPase and the PTP strengthens the link between the PTP and the F1FO-ATPase when activated by Ca2+ and provides insights on the biological effects of Gd3+.

Mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase and permeability transition pore response to sulfide in the midgut gland of Mytilus galloprovincialis.

The molecular mechanisms which rule the formation and opening of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore (mPTP), the lethal mechanism which permeabilizes mitochondria to water and solutes and drives the cell to death, are still unclear and particularly little investigated in invertebrates. Since Ca2+ increase in mitochondria is accompanied by mPTP opening and the participation of the mitochondrial F1FO-ATPase in the mPTP is increasingly sustained, the substitution of the natural cofactor Mg2+ by Ca2+ in the F1FO-ATPase activation has been involved in the mPTP mechanism. In mussel midgut gland mitochondria the similar kinetic properties of the Mg2+- or Ca2+-dependent F1FO-ATPase activities, namely the same affinity for ATP and bi-site activation kinetics by the ATP substrate, in spite of the higher enzyme activity and coupling efficiency of the Mg2+-dependent F1FO-ATPase, suggest that both enzyme activities are involved in the bioenergetic machinery. Other than being a mitochondrial poison and environmental contaminant, sulfide at low concentrations acts as gaseous mediator and can induce post-translational modifications of proteins. The sulfide donor NaHS, at micromolar concentrations, does not alter the two F1FO-ATPase activities, but desensitizes the mPTP to Ca2+ input. Unexpectedly, NaHS, under the conditions tested, points out a chemical refractoriness of both F1FO-ATPase activities and a failed relationship between the Ca2+-dependent F1FO-ATPase and the mPTP in mussels. The findings suggest that mPTP role and regulation may be different in different taxa and that the F1FO-ATPase insensitivity to NaHS may allow mussels to cope with environmental sulfide.