RESUMO
Purpose: To compare objective and subjective outcomes of the multifocal intraocular lenses ReSTOR SN6AD1 and Tecnis ZKB00, extended depth of focus IOL Symfony ZXR00, and trifocal IOL PanOptix TFNT00. Methods: This study included 262 patients (524 eyes) who had phacoemulsification with IOL implantation, 128 eyes with SN6AD1, 124 eyes with ZKB00, 136 eyes with ZXR00, and 136 eyes with TFNT00. Objective outcomes included one-month postoperative uncorrected (U) and corrected (C) distance (D) and near (N) visual acuities (VA). Subjective outcomes included photic phenomena, spectacle use, and spectacle-independent visual function. Results: Spectacle use (%) in the SN6AD1, ZKB00 ZXR00, and TFNT00 groups was 39, 64, 87, and 37 respectively (P < 0.0001). Presence of photic phenomena (%) for SN6AD1, ZKB00, ZXR00, and TFNT00 was 66, 61, and 67, and 73, respectively (P = 0.57). Spectacle-independent mean VF-14 score (%) for SN6AD1, ZKB00, ZXR00, and TFNT00 was 89.5, 87.2, 80.9, and 83.6, respectively (P < 0.01). Conclusion: All four IOLs provided excellent postoperative visual acuity and equally high rates of photic phenomena. SN6AD1 and TFNT00 provided the least spectacle use while ZXR00 had the highest spectacle use.
RESUMO
PURPOSE: To evaluate whether orientation of the optic-haptic junction of an intraocular lens (IOL) during cataract surgery could decrease the incidence and/or severity of positive and negative dysphotopsia. DESIGN: Prospective, randomized controlled trial. METHODS: A total of 163 patients (326 eyes) in a private practice scheduled to have bilateral implantation of a Tecnis monofocal IOL (ZCB00) (Johnson & Johnson Vision) were randomly assigned to have the optic-haptic junction positioned vertically, horizontally, superonasally, or inferonasally. Patients with known visual field defects or best-corrected vision less than 20/80 were excluded. Patients were surveyed for positive and negative dysphotopsia symptoms at 1 week and 4-6 weeks after surgery. Patients were blinded to the orientation whereas researchers were not. Data were analyzed to compare the differences in positive and negative dysphotopsia incidence and severity. RESULTS: IOL oriented vertically in 82 eyes (25.2%), horizontally in 72 eyes (22.1%), superonasally in 94 eyes (28.8%), and inferonasally in 78 eyes (23.9%). Significant differences were noted between orientations in incidence of negative dysphotopsia at 1 week postoperatively (P = .019) and 4-6 weeks postoperatively (P = .002). Patients in the superonasal group had the worst outcome at both time periods, and the horizontal group had the best outcome at 4-6 weeks. No differences were noted for positive dysphotopsia incidence or severity. CONCLUSIONS: The orientation of the optic-haptic junction of a monofocal IOL was significantly associated with incidence of negative dysphotopsia after surgery, with the horizontal orientation performing best at 4-6 weeks.