Cytokine release assays: current practices and future directions.

As a result of the CD28 superagonist biotherapeutic monoclonal antibody (TGN 1412) "cytokine storm" incident, cytokine release assays (CRA) have become hazard identification and prospective risk assessment tools for screening novel biotherapeutics directed against targets having a potential risk for eliciting adverse pro-inflammatory clinical infusion reactions. Different laboratories may have different strategies, assay formats, and approaches to the reporting, interpretation, and use of data for either decision making or risk assessment. Additionally, many independent contract research organizations (CROs), academic and government laboratories are involved in some aspect of CRA work. As a result, while some pharmaceutical companies are providing CRA data as part of the regulatory submissions when necessary, technical and regulatory practices are still evolving to provide data predictive of cytokine release in humans and that are relevant to safety. This manuscript provides an overview of different approaches employed by the pharmaceutical industry and CROs, for the use and application of CRA based upon a survey and post survey follow up conducted by ILSI-Health and Environmental Sciences Institute (HESI) Immunotoxicology Committee CRA Working Group. Also discussed is ongoing research in the academic sector, the regulatory environment, current limitations of the assays, and future directions and recommendations for cytokine release assays.

Design, synthesis, and evaluation of A/C/D-ring analogs of the fungal metabolite K-76 as potential complement inhibitors.

The terpenoid 6,7-diformyl-3',4',4a',5',6',7',8',8a'-octahydro-4,6',7'-trihydrox y-2',5',5', 8a'-tetramethylspiro[1'(2'H)-naphthalene-2(3H)-benzofuran] (1a; K-76), a natural product of fungal origin, and its monocarboxylate sodium salt 1c (R = COONa; K-76COONa) inhibit the classical and alternative pathways of complement, and 1c was shown to inhibit the classical pathway at the C5 activation step. In an attempt to elucidate the essential pharmacophore of 1a,c, the natural product was used as a "topographical model" for the design of partial analogs retaining the desired complement inhibiting potency. Therefore, A/C/D-ring analogs have been synthesized, as shown in Scheme 1 using 3-methoxyphenol (3) and limonene chloride (5) as starting materials, which contain functional groups similar to those found on the natural product. The use of (4R)-(+)- and (4S)(-)-limonene chloride (5a,b, respectively) provided two series of compounds differing in the stereochemistry of the C-4 chiral center (limonene moiety numbering). The in vitro assay results of the inhibition of anaphylatoxin production and classical complement-mediated hemolysis revealed that 7-carboxy-2-(R,S)-methyl-2-(1'-methylcyclohexen-(4'R)-yl)-4-met hoxybenzofuran (13a) and 7-carboxy-2-(R,S)-methyl-2-(1'-methylcyclohexen-(4'S)-yl)-4-met hoxybenzofuran (13b) were active in the same range of concentrations as the natural product.

Complement activation as a cause for primary graft failure in an isogeneic rat model of hypothermic lung preservation and transplantation.

Although agents that inhibit complement activation may be beneficial in discordant xenotransplantation, it is not known whether local complement activation occurs and is deleterious after isogeneic lung transplantation. Lungs were harvested from Lewis rats subjected to 4 degrees C 6-hr preservation followed by transplantation into strain-, gender-, and weight-matched recipients. Transplanted lungs demonstrated increased immunostaining for C5b-9 compared with nontransplanted controls, confirming local complement activation in this isograft model. To investigate the physiologic relevance of complement activation in the transplanted lung, the native pulmonary artery was ligated after transplantation, and pulmonary vascular resistance (mmHg/ml/min), arterial oxygenation (mmHg), graft neutrophil infiltration (myeloperoxidase activity, deltaAbs 460 nm/min), and recipient survival were measured at 30 min. Animals received either saline (control; n=22) or soluble complement receptor type-1 (sCR1, 15 mg/kg; n=19) 2 min before reperfusion. Animals treated with sCR1 showed a marked reduction in serum complement hemolytic activity (CH50; 90% lower than that of control animals, P<0.001). Compared with controls, sCR1-treated animals showed reduced pulmonary vascular resistance (2.9+/-1.1 vs. 8.5+/-1.5 mmHg/ml/min, P<0.05), improved arterial oxygenation (194+/-34 vs. 91+/-17 mmHg, P<0.05), decreased neutrophil infiltration (35% decrease, P<0.005), and improved recipient survival (74% vs. 23%, P<0.005). In parallel with the reduction in complement hemolytic activity in sCR1-treated animals, immunohistology of the transplanted lung revealed decreased C5b-9 deposition compared with controls. Taken together, these data indicate that complement activation occurs after lung preservation and transplantation in an isograft model, and that inhibiting complement activation improves outcome after transplantation.

Effect of repetitive high-dose treatment with soluble complement receptor type 1 and cobra venom factor on discordant xenograft survival.

Hyperacute xenograft rejection may be modified by the activation and depletion of complement (C) using cobra venom factor (CVF). This method of prolonging xenograft survival is toxic and associated with systemic inflammation, which may potentially contribute to the pathologic features of delayed xenograft rejection. Soluble complement receptor type 1 (sCR1) inhibits both the classical and alternative C pathways and thus limits the production of proinflammatory products such as the anaphylatoxins. Hence, we investigated the effects of various sCR1 and CVF regimens, and combinations thereof, in the discordant guinea pig-to-Lewis rat cardiac xenograft model. Mean graft survival time (MST) was significantly prolonged with repetitive dosing (MST=22 hr) or continuous infusion of sCR1 (MST=32 hr) as compared with unmodified controls (MST=15 min). However, sCR1 did not prevent intragraft deposition of C3 or neutrophil infiltration and resulted in only partial inhibition of C-mediated hemolytic activity in vitro. Grafts in rats treated with a single dose of CVF (MST=67 hr) or repetitive doses of CVF (MST=69 hr) survived significantly longer than those treated with sCR1 alone, and lacked C3 deposition or neutrophil accumulation. Sera from these animals were completely depleted of C-mediated hemolytic activity. Animals treated with a single dose of CVF, or sCRI plus a single dose of CVF (MST=64 hr), had similar xenograft survival times. However, immunohistologic studies showed that addition of sCR1 to a single dose of CVF resulted in decreased macrophage activation and reduced levels of cytokines (tumor necrosis factor-alpha and interleukin-1beta) within xenografts as compared with that in recipients treated with CVF alone. Such decreased macrophage activation may result from the binding of C4b by sCR1, since combination therapy was associated with decreased intragraft C4b as compared with either therapy alone. High doses of sCR1 were well tolerated by rats and significantly prolonged discordant xenograft survival (MST=32 hr), although not to the same extent as CVF. The modification of the intragraft immune responses seen with CVF/sCR1 combination therapy may augment further therapeutic manipulations to achieve discordant xenograft survival without the attendant toxicity associated with repeated CVF administration.

Cell surface expression of the C3b/C4b receptor (CR1) protects Chinese hamster ovary cells from lysis by human complement.

The C3b/C4b receptor, also known as complement receptor type 1 (CR1, CD35), is a single chain glycoprotein consisting of 30 repeating homologous protein domains known as short consensus repeats (SCR) followed by transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains. A series of recombinant proteins derived from CR1 has been prepared and assessed for the capacity to inhibit complement lysis of the host Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. The full-length recombinant CR1 inhibited human complement-mediated CHO cell lysis, and the efficiency of inhibition was directly proportional to the number of receptors/cell. The SCR 15-18 of CR1, but not SCR 15-16, inhibited complement lysis of the host CHO cell, bound monomeric C3b (Kd,app = 6.5 x 10(-7) M), and dimeric C3b (Kd = 1.8 x 10(-8) M), and served as a cofactor in the proteolysis of C3b by factor I, confirming and extending the observations of Fearon and colleagues (Kalli, K. R., Hsu, P., Bartow, T. J., Ahearn, J. M., Matsumoto, A. K., Klickstein, L. B., and Fearon, D. T. (1991) J. Exp. Med. 174, 1451-1460). The SCR 1-4 of CR1, but not SCR 1-2, also inhibited complement lysis of the host CHO cell, indicating that more than two SCR are necessary and that four SCR are sufficient for optimal C4b binding to CR1. Thus, the structural requirements for C4b binding are analogous to those for C3b binding, namely, four SCR of CR1 form the binding sites for each of these proteins. CR1 has long been recognized to regulate extrinsic complement activation, that is, to bind to and promote the degradation of fluid phase C3b and of C3b attached to immune complex. These results demonstrate that CR1 is also an intrinsic regulator of complement activation in that, under appropriate conditions, CR1 inhibits complement-mediated lysis of the cell on which it is expressed.

Interleukin-2-induced lung injury. The role of complement.

Pulmonary edema and sepsis-like syndrome are grave complications of interleukin-2 (IL-2) therapy. Recent animal studies have suggested IL-2-induced microvascular injury as the underlying mechanism. Since complement factors have been shown to mediate increased vascular permeability in diverse conditions that lead to pulmonary injury and recombinant human IL-2 is known to activate the complement system in patients undergoing IL-2 therapy, we hypothesized that complement factors play a pivotal role in the development of increased vascular permeability after IL-2 treatment. To test this hypothesis, we evaluated the capacity of recombinant soluble human complement receptor type 1 (sCR1, BRL 55730), a new highly specific complement inhibitor, to attenuate IL-2-induced lung injury in the rat. Recombinant human IL-2 (intravenously for 60 minutes) at 10(6) U per rat (n = 4) elevated lung water content (37 +/- 6%, P < .05), myeloperoxidase activity (162 +/- 49%, P < .05), and serum thromboxane B2 (30 +/- 1 pg/100 microL, P < .01) and had no effect on serum tumor necrosis factor-alpha sCR-1 at 30 mg/kg (n = 5), but not at 10 mg/kg (n = 6), attenuated the elevation of lung water content (18 +/- 2%, P < .05) and myeloperoxidase activity (42 +/- 9%, P < .05) but failed to alter serum thromboxane B2 response to IL-2. These data suggest the involvement of complement in the pathogenesis of IL-2-induced pulmonary microvascular injury and point to the potential therapeutic capacity of complement inhibitors in combating this toxic effect of IL-2 therapy.

A soluble deletion mutant of the human complement receptor type 1, which lacks the C4b binding site, is a selective inhibitor of the alternative complement pathway.

The human complement receptor type 1 (CR1, CD35), is a single-chain glycoprotein consisting of 30 repeating homologous protein domains known as short consensus repeats (SCR) followed by transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains. The SCR themselves, considered in groups of seven, form long homologous repeats (LHR) which have been designated LHR-A, -B, -C, and -D for the most common human allotype of CR1. A soluble deletion mutant of CR1 which lacks the first seven N-terminal SCR (LHR-A) as well as the transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains was produced and characterized. The resulting protein, designated sCR1[desLHR-A], lacks the C4b binding site found in LHR-A, but retains the two C3b binding sites found in LHR-B and -C, respectively. The functional activities of sCR1[desLHR-A] were quantitatively compared in vitro to those of soluble complement receptor type 1 (sCR1) which has been shown to retain all known functions of the native cell surface receptor. sCR1[desLHR-A] and sCR1 competed equally for the binding of dimeric C3b to erythrocyte CR1. sCR1[desLHR-A] and sCR1 were similar in their capacity to serve as a cofactor in the factor I-mediated degradation of the C3b and C4b alpha chains. sCR1[desLHR-A] and sCR1 were comparable in their capacity to inhibit erythrocyte lysis and anaphylatoxin production mediated by the alternative complement pathway. sCR1[desLHR-A], however, was significantly less effective an inhibitor of erythrocyte lysis and anaphylatoxin production than sCR1 under conditions which allow classical pathway activation. These results demonstrate sCR1[desLHR-A] to be a selective inhibitor of the alternative complement pathway in vitro.

Isolation of human immunodeficiency virus from hemophiliacs: correlation with clinical symptoms and immunologic abnormalities.

As part of a prospective study of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection in hemophilia, peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMs) from 72 individuals without acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS) or AIDS-related complex (ARC) were cultured for virus. HIV was isolated from PBMs from 16 (24%) of 66 patients with hemophilia who were seropositive for HIV and from none of six seronegative patients. Cells from five of six patients from which HIV was isolated were again successfully cultured for virus 3 to 12 months later. HIV core P24 antigen was detected in serum from seven of 15 patients with HIV-positive cells and from eight of 50 with HIV-negative cells. Patients with hemophilia with isolation-positive cells had significantly fewer T helper cells and significantly lower T helper/T suppressor ratios, pokeweed mitogen responsiveness, and total platelet counts than did those whose cells did not yield HIV on cultivation. HIV neutralizing antibody titers did not differ between hemophiliacs with or without HIV-positive PBMs. Three of the 16 patients with virus-positive cells developed AIDS, and two ARC, within 18 months of the study, compared with three of 50 seropositive hemophiliacs whose cells did not yield virus, who developed ARC during the same period. The significant decrease in the number of T helper cells, decreased platelet counts, and higher rate of progression to AIDS in the group with HIV isolation may reflect a heavier virus load, indicating that the ability to culture HIV may be an early marker of more significant disease.

Recombinant soluble human complement receptor type 1 inhibits inflammation in the reversed passive arthus reaction in rats.

The human CR1 was genetically engineered by site directed mutagenesis into a truncated form which was secreted from transfected Chinese hamster ovary cells. This soluble recombinant CR1 (sCR1) was purified from the supernatants of the Chinese hamster ovary cells cultured in a hollow fiber bioreactor. sCR1 inhibits the C3 and C5 convertases of the classical and the alternative pathways in vitro. The ability of sCR1 to inhibit the immune complex-mediated inflammation in vivo was tested in a rat reversed passive Arthus reaction model. Administration of sCR1 at the dermal sites reduced the Arthus vasculitis in a dose-dependent manner as judged by both gross and microscopic examination, as well as by immunohistologic localization of C3 and C5b-9 neoantigen deposits. These data suggest that sCR1 inhibits the Arthus reaction by interrupting the activation of the C cascade, hence limiting the detrimental immune complex-induced tissue damage in vivo.

Recombinant glycoproteins that inhibit complement activation and also bind the selectin adhesion molecules.

Soluble human complement receptor type 1 (sCR1, TP10) has been expressed in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) DUKX-B11 cells and shown to inhibit the classical and alternative complement pathways in vitro and in vivo. A truncated version of sCR1 lacking the long homologous repeat-A domain (LHR-A) containing the C4b binding site has similarly been expressed and designated sCR1[desLHR-A]. sCR1[desLHR-A] was shown to be a selective inhibitor of the alternative complement pathway in vitro and to function in vivo. In this study, sCR1 and sCR1[desLHR-A] were expressed in CHO LEC11 cells with an active alpha(1,3)-fucosyltransferase, which makes possible the biosynthesis of the sialyl-Lewisx (sLex) tetrasaccharide (NeuNAcalpha2-3Galbeta1-4(Fucalpha1-3)GlcNAc) during post-translational glycosylation. The resulting glycoproteins, designated sCR1sLex and sCR1[desLHR-A]sLex, respectively, retained the complement regulatory activities of their DUKX B11 counterparts, which lack alpha(1-3)-fucose. Carbohydrate analysis of purified sCR1sLex and sCR1[desLHR-A]sLex indicated an average incorporation of 10 and 8 mol of sLex/mol of glycoprotein, respectively. sLex is a carbohydrate ligand for the selectin adhesion molecules. sCR1sLex was shown to specifically bind CHO cells expressing cell surface E-selectin. sCR1[desLHR-A]sLex inhibited the binding of the monocytic cell line U937 to human aortic endothelial cells, which had been activated with tumor necrosis factor-alpha to up-regulate the expression of E-selectin. sCR1sLex inhibited the binding of U937 cells to surface-adsorbed P-selectin-IgG. sCR1sLex and sCR1[desLHR-A]sLex have thus demonstrated both complement regulatory activity and the capacity to bind selectins and to inhibit selectin-mediated cell adhesion in vitro.