Ethics consultations masking economic dilemmas in patient care.

The ethical and economic aspects of treatment decisions are often intimately entwined. We demonstrate how clinical economic questions were raised in clinical ethics consultations involving three patients: a 49-year-old retarded man who required short-term tube feeding; a 74-year-old man with metastatic prostatic cancer whose relatives disagreed about whether or not he should have surgical treatment; and a 55-year-old man whose health maintenance organization declined to pay for liver transplantation. Ethics consultants can help to clarify financial constraints and to resolve financial conflicts of interest. All physicians must develop the ability to unmask economic issues in medical care.

Willingness to perform euthanasia. A survey of physician attitudes.

BACKGROUND: In the United States, few studies have examined important variables in physician attitudes toward the practice of euthanasia, such as the patient's underlying disease, mental capacity, and age, and the physician's specialty and religion. We administered a case-based survey to analyze the impact of such specific variables on physician attitudes toward the practice. METHODS: A four-section survey solicited (1) physician responses to three hypothetical cases in which patients requested euthanasia; (2) physicians' general opinions about euthanasia and how its legalization might affect them personally and professionally; and (3) demographic information. Analysis focused on physicians' characteristics as they related to their responses to the various aspects of euthanasia elicited in the survey. Univariate and multivariate analyses, using logistic regression, were performed. RESULTS: Completed and analyzable surveys were returned by 740 physicians. We found that physicians felt more comfortable with euthanasia requests from nondecisional, nonterminal patients who had left advance directives than they did with requests from decisional patients suffering from grave illnesses or injuries, or from decisional patients who had early signs of a progressive but nonlethal neurologic disease. We also found that physicians' specialties and religions correlated with their responses to the hypothetical cases and with their generalized attitudes toward euthanasia. CONCLUSIONS: Given the disparity in responding physicians' attitudes toward euthanasia, along with the fact that values based on religious affiliation or profession may underlie many physicians' opposition to the practice, we conclude that if euthanasia is to be legalized, safeguards protective of patients and physicians must be incorporated.

A survey of sued and nonsued physicians and suing patients.

To systematically assess the impact of malpractice litigation on the doctor-patient relationship and to collect data that might suggest effective tort reform, we surveyed 642 sued physicians, nonsued physicians, and suing patients in Wisconsin. Parallel forms of survey instruments obtained information regarding changes in physicians' practices, changes in attitudes toward patients or physicians, and changes in physical and emotional well-being as a result of malpractice litigation or the threat of the same. In addition, opinions regarding causes and deterrents of malpractice litigation were obtained. Results suggested that claims or threats of malpractice suits had a negative impact on physicians' practices and emotional well-being; that this negative impact was more pronounced when the sued physician had been more personally involved with his patient prior to the malpractice claim; and that suing patients' and sued physicians' understanding of their relationship before the malpractice claim significantly differed. All respondents viewed improved physician-patient communication as the most effective method of preventing malpractice claims. Informal, alternative dispute resolution mechanisms in hospitals and clinics and improved peer review may decrease litigation and its deleterious effects.

Talking to comatose patients.

Physicians may not talk to comatose patients for several reasons. Comatose patients do not seem to hear or respond. Speaking may not affect their clinical outcome; time spent with them takes time away from other, more "viable" patients. Comatose patients may, however, hear; many have normal brain-stem auditory evoked responses and normal physiologic responses to auditory stimuli. Not talking to comatose patients may promote the notion that they are dead or nearly dead; not talking may become a self-fulfilling prophecy, influencing physicians to inappropriately withhold or withdraw therapy. Because comatose patients are especially vulnerable, and because some comatose patients may recover, physicians should consider talking to these patients. Our analysis suggests that families, medical students, and house staff would benefit from the humane example modeled by those clinicians who care for and talk to all patients.

The total artificial heart. An ethics perspective on current clinical research and deployment.

The development of the total artificial heart (TAH) as a support before cardiac transplantation and as a possible permanent prosthesis has generated intense debate. The social commitment to TAH research entails immense health care costs because of the cost of the implant itself and also because of the large number of patients whose interests impel the research. The deployment of the pre-transplant TAH during the current shortage of donor hearts means that the TAH creates its own incentive as a way to compete in an expanded pool of donor heart candidates. Policies to address the orderly deployment and costs of the pretransplant TAH are needed. Research design and current pre-transplant clinical applications require careful consideration of planning for the termination of TAH support for severely injured but not brain dead patients.

Emergency detention of the elderly: demographics, diagnoses, and outcome.

Involuntary medical detention is an increasing problem in many large teaching hospitals. Forty-two elderly patients involuntarily admitted for protective service to the general medical wards were compared with an age-matched group of 25 elderly persons voluntarily seeking care in the same institution. The comparison showed that most of the involuntarily admitted patients were more than 70 years of age, and more of them lived alone. On admission they had more dementia and dehydration but less urinary-tract infection than did the controls. Their hospital stays were longer. There was no difference between the groups with respect to discharge dispositions.

A survey of competencies and concerns in end-of-life care for physician trainees.

A survey was developed to explore physician trainee competencies and concerns surrounding end-of-life care. Thirty-one medical students, interns, and residents from the Department of Internal Medicine completed the survey in August 1996. The survey instrument found differing levels of competence/concern among medical students, interns, and residents. Self-reported competence increased with level of training. All trainees indicated the least comfort around discussions of hydration and feeding withdrawal. Both residents and interns indicated concern about potential illegality, breach of ethics or potential malpractice when reviewing eight currently legal and ethical end-of-life scenarios involving pain management or treatment withdrawal. Pain management, ethical issues, and delirium were the top three topics for which residents indicated an interest in future educational sessions. Results from the survey will be used to guide the development of educational initiatives that address trainee concerns. The competence/concern survey adds an important dimension to understanding how best to incorporate end-of-life education into residency training programs.

Pseudoascites in the clinical setting: avoiding unwarranted and futile paracenteses.

Ascites is diagnosed on physical exam by findings of abdominal distension, bulging flanks, shifting dullness and a prominent fluid wave. However, as the following cases demonstrate, these signs may also be positive in pseudoascites due to thick layers of adipose tissue in the abdomen. A history of recent food binging and a lack of a prolonged prothrombin time should raise the index of suspicion for pseudoascites in a patient with a protuberant abdomen. In light of equivocal physical signs, physicians may employ ultrasonography to prevent patients with pseudoascites from suffering multiple futile attempts at paracentesis.