The contribution of birth plans to shared decision-making from the perspectives of women, their partners and their healthcare providers.

BACKGROUND: The birth plan is a document expressing a pregnant woman's childbirth preferences, enabling communication of expectations and facilitating discussions among women, their partners, and healthcare providers for key birthing decisions. There has been limited research on the role of birth plans in shared decision-making (SDM). Our study aims to explore how the use of birth plans can contribute to SDM from women's, partners, and healthcare providers' perspectives. METHODS: We conducted in-depth interviews with women, their partners, and their healthcare providers. We used a thematic analysis to identify themes and subthemes. Furthermore, we created a grounded theory about the role of birth plans as a tool in SDM. RESULTS: Three main themes were created: ''Creating a birth plan", ''Getting all on board" and ''Birth plans in the daily practice of decision-making". Most women, partners, and healthcare providers agreed that birth plans can facilitate communication and SDM. Women and their partners viewed the birth plan as a tool to prepare for birth. Most healthcare providers mentioned the birth plan as a tool to get to know the women, their partners, and their preferences. Barriers are the attitude of healthcare providers toward birth plans, such as their evident resistance to the birth plan itself or to certain preferences. Another barrier is the assumption women and their partners may have that these plans can accurately predict the childbirth experience, enhancing the chance of a disappointing, negative experience. Some healthcare providers view birth plans as barriers to SDM. CONCLUSION: The use of a birth plan seems to promote women's, partners', and healthcare providers' involvement in the birth process, and seems suitable to facilitate SDM. Further research is required to explore strategies for overcoming barriers, including healthcare providers' attitudes toward birth plans and the expectations of women and their partners regarding their role.

The role of birth plans for shared decision-making around birth choices of pregnant women in maternity care: A scoping review.

BACKGROUND: Birth plans can be used to facilitate shared decision-making in childbirth. A birth plan is a document reflecting women's preferences for birth, which they discuss with their maternity care provider. AIM: This scoping review aims to synthesize current findings on the role of birth plans for shared decision-making around birth choices of pregnant women in maternity care. METHODS: We conducted a scoping review using the Joanna Briggs Institute three-step search strategy in multiple databases PubMed, EMBASE, CINAHL, Web of Science, PsycINFO. We synthesized the results using a metasynthesis approach to identify themes and subthemes. RESULTS: From the 21 articles included, five themes were identified: birth plan as a tool for shared decision-making, autonomy, sense of control, professionalism of the care provider, and trust. Primarily, midwives seemed to use birth plans to explore and facilitate women's choices around birth. Other healthcare providers involved in studies were obstetricians and nurses. The interrelationship between care providers and women, the attitude of care providers and women towards each other and the birth plan, and how providers and women use the birth plan influence shared decision-making. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: Birth plans can facilitate shared decision-making, and women's sense of autonomy and control before, during, and after giving birth. When discussing the birth plan, exploring different scenarios may help women prepare for unforeseen circumstances. This will likely facilitate shared decision-making even if the birth process is not unfolding as hoped for.