Ligand-Centered Hydrogen Evolution with Ni(II) and Pd(II)DMTH.

In this study, we report a pair of electrocatalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) based on the noninnocent ligand diacetyl-2-(4-methyl-3-thiosemicarbazone)-3-(2-pyridinehydrazone) (H2DMTH, H2L1). The neutral complexes NiL1 and PdL1 were synthesized and characterized by spectroscopic and electrochemical methods. The complexes contain a non-coordinating, basic hydrazino nitrogen that is protonated during the HER. The pKa of this nitrogen was determined by spectrophotometric titration in acetonitrile to be 12.71 for NiL1 and 13.03 for PdL1. Cyclic voltammograms of both NiL1 and PdL1 in acetonitrile exhibit diffusion-controlled, reversible ligand-centered events at -1.83 and -1.79 V (vs ferrocenium/ferrocene) for NiL1 and PdL1, respectively. A quasi-reversible, ligand-centered event is observed at -2.43 and -2.34 V for NiL1 and PdL1, respectively. The HER activity in acetonitrile was evaluated using a series of neutral and cationic acids for each catalyst. Kinetic isotope effect (KIE) studies suggest that the precatalytic event observed is associated with a proton-coupled electron transfer step. The highest turnover frequency values observed were 6150 s-1 at an overpotential of 0.74 V for NiL1 and 8280 s-1 at an overpotential of 0.44 V for PdL1. Density functional theory (DFT) computations suggest both complexes follow a ligand-centered HER mechanism where the metals remain in the +2 oxidation state.

Light Mediated Properties of a Thiolato-Derivative of Vitamin B12.

Vitamin B12 derivatives (Cbls = cobalamins) exhibit photolytic properties upon excitation with light. These properties can be modulated by several factors including the nature of the axial ligands. Upon excitation, homolytic cleavage of the organometallic bond to the upper axial ligand takes place in photolabile Cbls. The photosensitive nature of Cbls has made them potential candidates for light-activated drug delivery. The addition of a fluorophore to the nucleotide loop of thiolato Cbls has been shown to shift the region of photohomolysis to within the optical window of tissue (600-900 nm). With this possibility, there is a need to analyze photolytic properties of unique Cbls which contain a Co-S bond. Herein, the photodissociation of one such Cbl, namely, N-acetylcysteinylcobalamin (NACCbl), is analyzed based on density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT (TD-DFT) calculations. The S0 and S1 potential energy surfaces (PESs), as a function of axial bond lengths, were computed to determine the mechanism of photodissociation. Like other Cbls, the S1 PES contains metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT) and ligand field (LF) regions, but there are some unique differences. Interestingly, the S1 PES of NACCbl contains three distinct minima regions opening several possibilities for the mechanism of radical pair (RP) formation. The mild photoresponsiveness, observed experimentally, can be attributed to the small gap in energy between the S1 and S0 PESs. Compared to other Cbls, the gap shown for NACCbl is neither exactly in line with the alkyl Cbls nor the nonalkyl Cbls.

Utilizing Charge Effects and Minimizing Intramolecular Proton Rearrangement to Improve the Overpotential of a Thiosemicarbazonato Zinc HER Catalyst.

The zinc(II) complex of diacetyl-2-(4-methyl-3-thiosemicarbazone)-3-(2-hydrazonepyridine), ZnL1 (1), was prepared and evaluated as a precatalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) under homogeneous conditions in acetonitrile. Complex 1 is protonated on the noncoordinating nitrogen of the hydrazonepyridine moiety to yield the active catalyst Zn(HL1)OAc (2) upon addition of acetic acid. Addition of methyl iodide to 1 yields the corresponding methylated derivative ZnL2I (3). In solution, partial dissociation of the coordinated iodide yields the cationic derivative 3'. Complexes 1-3 were characterized by 1H NMR, FT-IR, and UV-visible spectroscopies. The solid-state structures of 2 and 3 were determined by single crystal X-ray diffraction. HER studies conducted in acetonitrile with acetic acid as the proton source yield a turnover frequency (TOF) of 7700 s-1 for solutions of 1 at an overpotential of 1.27 V and a TOF of 6700 s-1 for solutions of 3 at an overpotential of 0.56 V. For both complexes, the required potential for catalysis, Ecat/2, is larger than the thermodynamic reduction potential, E1/2, indicative of a kinetic barrier attributed to intramolecular proton rearrangement. The effect is larger for solutions of 1 (+440 mV) than for solutions of 3 (+160 mV). Controlled potential coulometry studies were used to determine faradaic efficiencies of 71 and 89% for solutions of 1 and 3, respectively. For both catalysts, extensive cycling of potential under catalytic conditions results in the deposition of a film on the glassy carbon electrode surface that is active as an HER catalyst. Analysis of the film of 3 by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy indicates the complex remains intact upon deposition. A proposed ligand-centered HER mechanism with 1 as a precatalyst to 2 is supported computationally using density functional theory (DFT). All catalytic intermediates in the mechanism were structurally and energetically characterized with the DFT/B3LYP/6-311g(d,p) in solution phase using a polarizable continuum model (PCM). The thermodynamic feasibility of the mechanism is supported by calculation of equilibrium constants or reduction potentials for each proposed step.

Photolytic Properties of Antivitamins B12.

Antivitamins B12 represent an important class of vitamin B12 analogues that have gained recent interest in several research areas. In particular, 4-ethylphenylcobalamin (EtPhCbl) and phenylethynylcobalamin (PhEtyCbl) exemplify two such antivitamins B12 which have been characterized structurally and chemically. From a spectroscopic point of view, EtPhCbl is photolabile with a very low quantum yield of photoproducts, while PhEtyCbl is incredibly photostable. Herein, DFT and TD-DFT computations are provided to explore the photolytic properties of these compounds to shed light on the electronic properties that are indicative of these differences. Potential energy surfaces (PESs) were constructed to investigate the mechanisms of photodissociation leading to radical pair (RP) formation and the mechanisms of deactivation to the ground state. The S1 PESs for each antimetabolite contain two energy minima, one being the metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT) and another the ligand-field (LF) state. There are two possible pathways for photodissociation that can be identified for EtPhCbl but only one (path B) is energetically feasible and involves the lengthening of the Co-NIm bond through the MLCT region followed by the lengthening of the Co-C bond through the LF region. For PhEtyCbl, there is not an energetically favorable path for photolysis; rather, internal conversion (IC) is the significantly preferred photophysical event.

Off to the Races: Comparison of Excited State Dynamics in Vitamin B12 Derivatives Hydroxocobalamin and Aquocobalamin.

Ultrafast time-resolved spectroscopy was used to study the photochemistry of hydroxocobalamin (HOCbl) and aquocobalamin (H2OCbl+) in solution. Spectroscopic measurements and TD-DFT simulations provide a consistent picture of the spectroscopy and photochemistry. Excitation of H2OCbl+ results in formation of an excited state followed by rapid internal conversion to the ground state (0.35 ± 0.15 ps) through an S1/S0 seam at a slightly elongated Co-O bond length and a significantly elongated Co-NIm bond length. In contrast, the initial elongation of the axial bonds in HOCbl is followed by contraction to an excited state minimum with bonds slightly shorter than those in the ground state. Internal conversion to the ground state follows on a picosecond time scale (5.3 ± 0.4 ps). For both compounds, photodissociation forming cob(II)alamin and hydroxyl radicals (∼1.5% yield) requires excitation to highly excited states. Dissociation is mediated by competition between internal conversion to the S1 surface and prompt bond cleavage.

Ultrafast X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure Reveals Ballistic Excited State Structural Dynamics.

Polarized ultrafast time-resolved X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) allows characterization of excited state dynamics following excitation. Excitation of vitamin B12, cyanocobalamin (CNCbl), in the αß-band at 550 nm and the γ-band at 365 nm was used to uniquely resolve axial and equatorial contributions to the excited state dynamics. The structural evolution of the excited molecule is best described by a coherent ballistic trajectory on the excited state potential energy surface. Prompt expansion of the Co cavity by ca. 0.03 Å is followed by significant elongation of the axial bonds (>0.25 Å) over the first 190 fs. Subsequent contraction of the Co cavity in both axial and equatorial directions results in the relaxed S1 excited state structure within 500 fs of excitation.

Photodissociation of ethylphenylcobalamin antivitamin B12.

Biologically active forms of cobalamins are crucial cofactors in biochemical reactions and these metabolites can be inhibited by their structurally similar analogues known as antivitamins B12. Phenylethynylcobalamin (PhEtyCbl) or 4-ethylphenylcobalamin (EtPhCbl) exemplify recently synthesized and structurally characterized antivitamins B12. Herein, DFT and TD-DFT studies of EtPhCbl are provided to explore its photochemical behavior, which may lead to design of arylcobalamins that can be used as therapeutic agents in light activated drug applications. To understand the photolability of EtPhCbl, a potential energy surface (PES) for the photodissociation of the Co-C bond was constructed. The S1 PES contains two energy minima, one being metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT) and another the ligand-field (LF) state. There are two possible pathways for photodissociation: the first pathway (path A) involves initially lengthening the Co-C bond from the MLCT minimum and then elongation of Co-NIm while the second pathway (path B) involves the lengthening of the Co-NIm bond through the MLCT region followed by the lengthening of the Co-C bond through the LF region. It is shown that photodissociation involving path A is not energetically favorable whereas preferable photodissociation of the Co-C bond involves path B.

Photolytic properties of B12-dependent enzymes: A theoretical perspective.

The biologically active vitamin B12 derivates, methylcobalamin (MeCbl) and adenosylcobalamin (AdoCbl), are ubiquitous organometallic cofactors. In addition to their key roles in enzymatic catalysis, B12 cofactors have complex photolytic properties which have been the target of experimental and theoretical studies. With the recent discovery of B12-dependent photoreceptors, there is an increased need to elucidate the underlying photochemical mechanisms of these systems. This book chapter summarizes the photolytic properties of MeCbl- and AdoCbl-dependent enzymes with particular emphasis on the effect of the environment of the cofactor on the excited state processes. These systems include isolated MeCbl and AdoCbl as well as the enzymes, ethanolamine ammonia-lyase (EAL), glutamate mutase (GLM), methionine synthase (MetH), and photoreceptor CarH. Central to determining the photodissociation mechanism of each system is the analysis of the lowest singlet excited state (S1) potential energy surface (PES). Time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT), employing BP86/TZVPP, is widely used to construct such PESs. Regardless of the environment, the topology of the S1 PES of AdoCbl or MeCbl is marked by characteristic features, namely the metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT) and ligand field (LF) regions. Conversely, the relative energetics of these electronic states are affected by the environment. Applications and outlooks for Cbl photochemistry are also discussed.

Photoproduct formation in coenzyme B12-dependent CarH via a singlet pathway.

The CarH photoreceptor exploits of the light-sensing ability of coenzyme B12 ( adenosylcobalamin = AdoCbl) to perform its catalytic function, which includes large-scale structural changes to regulate transcription. In daylight, transcription is activated in CarH via the photo-cleavage of the Co-C5' bond of coenzyme B12. Subsequently, the photoproduct, 4',5'-anhydroadenosine (anhAdo) is formed inducing dissociation of the CarH tetramer from DNA. Several experimental studies have proposed that hydridocoblamin (HCbl) may be formed in process with anhAdo. The photolytic cleavage of the Co-C5' bond of AdoCbl was previously investigated using photochemical techniques and the involvement of both singlet and triplet excited states were explored. Herein, QM/MM calculations were employed to probe (1) the photolytic processes which may involve singlet excited states, (2) the mechanism of anhAdo formation, and (3) whether HCbl is a viable intermediate in CarH. Time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations indicate that the mechanism of photodissociation of the Ado ligand involves the ligand field (LF) portion of the lowest singlet excited state (S1) potential energy surface (PES). This is followed by deactivation to a point on the S0 PES where the Co-C5' bond remains broken. This species corresponds to a singlet diradical intermediate. From this point, the PES for anhAdo formation was explored, using the Co-C5' and Co-C4' bond distances as active coordinates, and a local minimum representing anhAdo and HCbl formation was found. The transition state (TS) for the formation of the Co-H bond of HCbl was located and its identity was confirmed by a single imaginary frequency of i1592 cm-1. Comparisons to experimental studies and the potential role of rotation around the N-glycosidic bond of the Ado ligand were discussed.

Computational investigations of B12-dependent enzymatic reactions.

Nature employs two biologically active forms of vitamin B12, adenosylcobalamin (or coenzyme B12) and methylcobalamin, as cofactors in molecular transformations both in bacteria and mammals. Computational chemistry, guided by experimental data, has been used to explore fundamental characteristics of these enzymatic reactions. In particular, the quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) method has proven to be a powerful tool in elucidating important characteristics of B12-dependent enzymatic reactions. Herein, we will present a brief tutorial in conducting QM/MM calculations for B12 enzymatic reactions. We will summarize recent contributions that target the use of QM/MM calculations in both photochemical and enzymatic reactions including AdoCbl-dependent ethanolamine ammonia lyase, glutamate mutase, and photoreceptor CarH.

Electronic and photolytic properties of hydridocobalamin.

Hydridocobalamin (HCbl), is a known member of the B12 family of molecules (cobalamins, Cbls) yet unlike other well-studied Cbls, little is known of the electronic and photolytic properties of this species. Interest in HCbl has increased significantly in recent years when at least three experimentally proposed mechanisms implicate HCbl as an intermediary in the photoreaction of coenzyme B12-dependent photoreceptor CarH. Specifically, cleavage of the Co-C5' bond of coenzyme B12 could lead to a ß-hydride or ß­hydrogen elimination reaction to form HCbl. HCbl is known to be a transient species where the oxidation state of the Co is variable; Co(I)-H+ ↔ Co(II)-H â†” Co(III)-H-. Further, HCbl is a very unstable with a pKa of ~1. This complicates experimental studies and to the best of our knowledge there are no available crystal structures of HCbl - either for the isolated molecule or bound to an enzyme. In this study, the electronic structure, photolytic properties, and reactivity of HCbl were explored to determine the preferred oxidation state as well as its potential role in the formation of the photoproduct in CarH. Natural bond orbital (NBO) analysis was performed to determine the oxidation state of Co in isolated HCbl. Based on the NBO analysis of HCbl, Co clearly had excess negative charge, which is in stark contrast to other alkylCbls where the Co ion is marked by significant positive charge. In sum, NBO results indicate that the CoH bond is strongly polarized and almost ionic. It can be described as protonated Co(I). In addition, DFT was used to explore the bond dissociation energy of HCbl based on homolytic cleavage of the CoH bond. TD-DFT calculations were used to compare computed electronic transitions to the experimentally determined absorption spectrum. The photoreaction of CarH was explored using an isolated model system and a pathway for hydrogen transfer was found. Finally, quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) calculations were employed to investigate the formation of HCbl in CarH.

Why is CarH photolytically active in comparison to other B12-dependent enzymes?

The discovery of naturally occurring B12-depedent photoreceptors has allowed for applications of cobalamins (Cbls) in optogenetics and synthetic biology to emerge. However, theoretical investigations of the complex mechanisms of these systems have been lacking. Adenosylcobalamin (AdoCbl)-dependent photoreceptor, CarH, is one example and it relies on daylight to perform its catalytic function. Typically, in enzymes employing AdoCbl as their cofactor, the Co-C5' bond activation and cleavage is triggered by substrate binding. The cleavage of the Co-C5' bond is homolytic resulting in radical pair formation. However, in CarH, this bond is instead activated by light. To explore this peculiarity, the ground and first excited state potential energy surfaces (PESs) were constructed using the quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) framework and compared with other AdoCbl-dependent enzymes. QM/MM results indicate that CarH is photolytically active as a result of the AdoCbl dual role, acting as a radical generator and as a substrate. Photo-cleavage of the Co-C5' bond and subsequent H-atom abstraction is possible because of the specific orientation of the H-C4' bond with respect to the Co(II) center. Comparison with other AdoCbl-dependent enzymes indicate that the protein environment in the CarH active center alters the photochemistry of AdoCbl by controlling the stereochemistry of the ribose moiety.

Can photolysis of the CoC bond in coenzyme B12-dependent enzymes be used to mimic the native reaction?

Coenzyme B12 (Adenosylcobalamin = AdoCbl)-dependent enzymes catalyze complex molecular transformations where cleavage of the CoC bond initiates the catalytic cycle. Alternatively, the CoC bond can be cleaved with light. In both cases, rupture of the CoC bond results in the formation of Co(II)/Ado radical pair (RP). Within the field of B12 chemistry, there has been a suspicion that photolytic cleavage can be used as a probe or a direct comparison of the native reaction. Herein, we seek to resolve what the connection between light induced RP formation and the native catalytic cycle is. We used a combined QM/MM approach to construct PESs for AdoCbl-dependent ethanolamine ammonia-lyase (EAL) as a function of axial bonds to describe the reaction mechanism. We have found that there is no direct comparison that can be made between photolysis and enzymatic cleavage as the mechanism associated with these involves different electronic states. With that being said, we have explored an alternate hypothesis for the connection which involves the one-electron reduced form of the AdoCbl cofactor. This hypothesis is in line with the concept based on proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET), which involves the formation of AdoCbl cofactor-tyrosine diradical complex. The topology of the PES for the one-electron reduced (D1) cofactor is very similar to the PES associated with photo-induced cleavage (S1). Both surfaces contain two energy minima that are, similarly, the result of two distinct electronic states. Thus, it appears that the reaction mechanism associated with the D1 surface and the S1 surface are very similar, providing a plausible connection between photolysis and native catalysis.

Photolytic Cleavage of Co-C Bond in Coenzyme B12-Dependent Glutamate Mutase.

Glutamate mutase (GLM) is a coenzyme B12-dependent enzyme that catalyzes the conversion of S-glutamate to (2 S,3 S)-3-methyl aspartate. The initial step in the catalytic process is the homolytic cleavage of the coenzyme's Co-C bond upon binding of a substrate. Alternatively, the Co-C bond can be cleaved using light. To investigate the photolytic cleavage of the Co-C bond in GLM, we applied a combined density functional theory/molecular mechanics (DFT/MM) and time-dependent-DFT/MM method to scrutinize the ground and the low-lying excited states. Potential energy surfaces (PESs) were generated as a function of axial bond lengths to describe the photodissociation mechanism. The S1 PES was characterized as the crossing of two electronic states, metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT), and ligand field (LF). In GLM, radical pairs generate from the LF state. Two pathways, path A and path B, were identified as possible channels to connect the MLCT and LF electronic states. The S1 PES in GLM was compared with the S1 PES for coenzyme B12-dependent ethanolamine ammonia lyase as well as the isolated AdoCbl cofactor. Finally, the theoretical insights related to the photodissociation mechanism were compared with transient absorption spectroscopy, electron paramagnetic resonance, and resonance Raman spectroscopy.

Probing the Excited State of Methylcobalamin Using Polarized Time-Resolved X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy.

We use picosecond time-resolved polarized X-ray absorption near-edge structure (XANES) measurements to probe the structure of the long-lived photoexcited state of methylcobalamin (MeCbl) and the cob(II)alamin photoproduct formed following photoexcitation of adenosylcobalamin (AdoCbl, coenzyme B12). For MeCbl, we used 520 nm excitation and a time delay of 100 ps to avoid the formation of cob(II)alamin. We find only small spectral changes in the equatorial and axial directions, which we interpret as arising from small (<∼0.05 Å) changes in both the equatorial and axial distances. This confirms expectations based on prior UV-visible transient absorption measurements and theoretical simulations. We do not find evidence for the significant elongation of the Co-C bond reported by Subramanian [ J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2018 , 9 , 1542 - 1546 ] following 400 nm excitation. For AdoCbl, we resolve the difference XANES contributions along three unique molecular axes by exciting with both 540 and 365 nm light, demonstrating that the spectral changes are predominantly polarized along the axial direction, consistent with the loss of axial ligation. These data suggest that the microsecond "recombination product" identified by Subramanian et al. is actually the cob(II)alamin photoproduct that is produced following bond homolysis of MeCbl with 400 nm excitation. Our results highlight the pronounced advantage of using polarization-selective transient X-ray absorption for isolating structural dynamics in systems undergoing atomic displacements that are strongly correlated to the exciting optical polarization.