In vivo angiogenesis by platelet-derived wound-healing formula in injured spinal cord.

In vivo angiogenesis was investigated using platelet-derived wound-healing formula (PDWHF) in the injured cat spinal cord. Twenty-two gauge teflon sheaths, which had been coated with PDWHF-Hydron or only with Hydron, were inserted into the spinal cords of cats and the injured cats were maintained for 3 weeks. Selection of PDWHF-Hydron or Hydron was double blinded. The PDWHF-Hydron group showed notable neovascularization as well as dilation around the injury site, and this was statistically significant when compared to the control group. PDWHF seems to play a role in the healing processes of spinal cord injury and may have important interactions with other growth factors and in particular neurogenic growth factor.

The effect of spinal distraction on regional spinal cord blood flow in cats.

Distraction is considered to be a factor in many spinal cord injuries. With a specially designed distraction apparatus and the 14C-antipyrine autoradiographic technique, the effect of distraction on spinal cord blood flow (SCBF) in cats was studied. Distraction was performed at L2-3 at a rate of 0.25 cm/10 min, and the spinal evoked response (SER) was monitored by stimulating the sciatic nerve and recording at T-13. The SCBF was assessed in five control animals, four animals in whom the SER was markedly altered by distraction, and five animals after the SER had been abolished and an additional 0.5 cm distraction applied. Control cats had gray- and white-matter flows of 44.5 +/- 1.4 (SEM) and 10.5 +/- 0.4 ml/100 gm/min, respectively. Distraction to the point of marked SER alteration caused a 50% loss of SCBF at and caudal to the distraction site. An additional 0.5 cm distraction produced total abolition of SCBF at the distraction site and for a considerable distance rostral and caudal to it. Thus, it is shown that spinal distraction causes cord ischemia similar to that seen with other types of spinal cord injury. In addition, distraction severe enough to cause loss of the SER has already produced severe cord ischemia.

Management of pseudarthrosis after arthrodesis of the spine for idiopathic scoliosis.

Sixty-three first, second, or third-time repairs of one or more pseudarthroses were done in fifty-one patients who had had an arthrodesis for idiopathic scoliosis. Forty-five of the patients were female and six were male. The average age was 30.2 years. The indications for the sixty-three repairs were pain (twenty-five repairs), progression of the curve (sixteen), both pain and progression of the curve (twelve), and radiographic changes only (ten). Failure of the implant was identified before 27 per cent of the sixty-three procedures. The pseudarthroses were diagnosed an average of 2.8 years after the initial arthrodeses. Sixty-eight per cent of the defects were visible on plain radiographs preoperatively and 32 per cent were identified at operation. During the time between the original arthrodeses and the repairs of the pseudarthroses, the scolioses increased by a mean of 7 degrees and the kyphoses, by a mean of 10 degrees. Harrington distraction was the most commonly used instrumentation (twenty-six [41 per cent] of the sixty-three procedures), and autogenous iliac bone was the most commonly used material for the graft (thirty-three [52 per cent] of the procedures).

Spinal sensory and motor tract activation after epidural electrical stimulation in the cat.

Somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) after peripheral nerve stimulation and motor evoked potentials (MEPs) after transcranial stimulation have been routinely used as monitors of the viability of pathways in the posterior and anterior spinal cord, respectively, in patients undergoing spinal cord surgery. To assess total spinal cord function, both of these procedures must be performed simultaneously, which is both cumbersome and technically difficult. The objectives of this study were to demonstrate both sensory and motor spinal tract activation after epidural electrical stimulation of the cat spinal cord. Thirty-seven adult mongrel cats were anesthetized with ketamine, intubated, and maintained with Ethrane and nitrous oxide. Stimulating electrodes were placed over the right dorsolateral spinal cord epidurally at T7 after a laminectomy. Recording electrodes were placed over the right L3 spinal cord epidurally, on the right L7 dorsal and ventral nerve roots, on the right and left sciatic nerves in the popliteal fossa, and in the right gastrocnemius muscle. After epidural stimulation of the spinal cord at T11, distinct reproducible potentials were recorded at each site. Activity in the L7 dorsal root implicated activation of spinal sensory tracts. Activity in the L7 ventral root and in the gastrocnemius implicated activation of spinal motoneurons.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Delayed anterior decompression in patients with spinal cord and cauda equina injuries of the thoracolumbar spine.

Forty-nine patients with complete and incomplete injuries of the spinal cord or cauda equina who had undergone anterior decompression at a minimum of 3 months after injury were examined. Follow-up was from 12 months to 19 years. Postoperative neurologic improvement occurred in 46.5% of patients with incomplete injuries. If the surgery was performed less than 2 years after injury, neurologic improvement occurred in 68% with an improvement in Frankel grade of 32%. Bladder function improved in 27% of patients and if operated on less than 2 years after injury improvement occurred in 43%. Conus medullaris decompression resulted in a 50% improvement. There was an 83% improvement in the pattern of pain after decompression. Of 23 patients with preoperative spasticity, 10 improved but 6 were worse after surgery.

Reduction of high-grade spondylolisthesis using Edwards instrumentation.

STUDY DESIGN: Sixteen patients with high-grade spondylolisthesis (Grade III or higher) who underwent posterior decompression and reduction using the Edwards Modular Spine System (Spinal System Ltd., Baltimore, MD) were reviewed clinically and radiographically. OBJECTIVES: This study was undertaken to determine the efficacy of one specific reduction technique to treat patients with high-grade spondylolisthesis where there has been a loss of sagittal balance, intractable pain, and/or neurologic deficit. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The average age of our patients was 20 years. Preoperative slippage averaged 89%; preoperative slip angle averaged 50 degrees. Indications for surgery were back and leg pain, progression of slippage (in 9 patients), and/or the inability to stand upright with the knees straight. METHODS: Pre- and postoperative radiographic films were reviewed. The percent slip and the slip angle were measured pre- and postoperatively. Clinical data were obtained via chart review, telephone interview, and/or office visit. RESULTS: The average preoperative slip was 89%; postoperatively, the average slip was 29%. Slip angle averaged 50 degrees preoperatively and improved to a postoperative average of 24 degrees. Three patients had neurologic impairment postoperatively; one did not resolve. Four patients had hardware failure; all were revised. Ten patients had an excellent result, 5 patients had a good result, and 1 patient had a fair result. The average follow-up was 3.8 years. CONCLUSION: This procedure is technically demanding and is subject to the known risks of surgical treatment for high-grade spondylolisthesis. For select patients, it may be effective for reducing severe deformity and can be expected to afford good to excellent results. Improved sacral fixation may reduce the rate of hardware-related complications.

Differences in sensitivity between magnetic motor-evoked potentials and somatosensory-evoked potentials in experimental spinal cord lesions.

STUDY DESIGN: Graded posterior spinal cord compression and partial sectioning of the spinal cord were performed, and magnetically induced descending spinal cord potentials were recorded. OBJECTIVES: To compare the sensitivity of transcranial magnetic motor-evoked potentials in the spinal cord and other spinal cord evoked potentials to spinal cord lesions. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Somatosensory-evoked potentials have been the standard technique for monitoring spinal cord function during spinal surgery. These potentials, however, do not necessarily reflect descending motor tract function. Transcranial electric or magnetic stimulation for motor-evoked potentials is a more direct measure of motor tract function. However, more research on magnetic motor-evoked potentials is needed. METHODS: Fifteen adult cats were used. Graded posterior spinal cord compression was performed at L2 in 10 cats, and partial sectioning of the spinal cord was performed at L2 in five cats. The location sequence of lesioning was dorsal column section, dorsal 1/2 section, dorsal 2/3 section, and total spinal cord section. Magnetic motor-evoked potentials were recorded by epidural catheter electrodes placed above at, and below the lesion. Electric motor evoked potentials and spinal and cortical somatosensory-evoked potentials were recorded serially for a comparison of their sensitivity to spinal cord dysfunction. RESULTS: In posterior spinal cord compression, N1 amplitude of magnetic motor-evoked potentials at and below the lesion decreased after 1 minute of compression with a 70 g weight, and N1 and N2 amplitude disappeared after 1 minute of compression with a 100 to 120-g weight. Electric motor-evoked potentials changed at amplitudes comparable with those shown by magnetic motor-evoked potentials. Spinal somatosensory-evoked potentials showed the most sensitive changes to spinal cord posterior compression and disappeared after 1 minute of compression with 80 g Cortical somatosensory-evoked potentials in five cats were not sensitive enough for spinal cord posterior compression injury and did not disappear even after 1 minute of compression with 120 g. In magnetic motor-evoked potentials, after dorsal hemisectioning of the spinal cord only N3 disappeared; N1 and N2 disappeared after ventral spinal cord sectioning in spinal somatosensory-evoked potentials, amplitudes decreased after dorsal column sectioning, and all negative peaks disappeared after dorsal hemisectioning of the spinal cord. CONCLUSIONS: Posterior compression injuries are diagnosed more easily with spinal somatosensory-evoked potentials. Motor-evoked potentials were slightly less sensitive, but they were significantly more useful in diagnosing posterior compression injuries than were cortical somatosensory-evoked potentials.

The effects of immobilization of long segments of the spine on the adjacent and distal facet force and lumbosacral motion.

Long levels of spinal instrumentation and fusion are common in surgery for spinal deformity. The effect on the remaining mobile segments is not well understood. The changes in lumbar facet loading and lumbosacral motion were evaluated as the number of immobilized levels increased. Four fresh canine cadaveric spines from T6 to sacrum were used. Lumbosacral motion was measured with an instrumented spatial linkage device, and facet loads were measured at L1, L4, and L7 using a strain gauge technique. Lumbosacral motion and facet loading were significantly increased (P < 0.05) after immobilization of proximal segments, and the amount of the increase was dependent on the number of immobilized segments (P < 0.05). This indicates that immobilization of long segments of the spine influences the remaining mobile segments by increasing the load and motion not only at the immediately adjacent segment but also at the distal segments.

Application of polyvinyl alcohol hydrogel membrane as anti-adhesive interposition after spinal surgery.

STUDY DESIGN: Three inflammatory and adhesive changes inside the spinal canal were analyzed histopathologically in cats. OBJECTIVE: To investigate the usefulness of a polyvinyl alcohol hydrogel sheet as an interposition over the dura to prevent inflammatory and adhesive reaction after laminectomy. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: A major concern after laminectomy is scar tissue formation that may result in extradural compression or make subsequent surgery to the same area difficult and hazardous. METHODS: Wide laminectomy was performed at L5 in 30 adult cats. The dura was covered with a polyvinyl alcohol hydrogel sheet, free fat graft, or without interposition as a control. Animals were killed at 3 or 12 weeks. RESULTS: In the control group, adhesion of the exposed dura was apparent. Thick, fibrous connective tissue was observed between the dura and the paravertebral muscles. In the fat graft group, the dura was separated from the scar tissue by living grafted fat. However, the dura was adherent to the grafted fat and fibroblasts migrated into the interstitial space. In the polyvinyl alcohol hydrogel group, only a thin synovium-like layer was formed around the polyvinyl alcohol hydrogel sheet. CONCLUSIONS: Polyvinyl alcohol hydrogel is made of water and alcohol, and has been shown to be nontoxic to tissues. This is permeable to low molecular weight, but impermeable to large cells such as fibroblasts. Thus, the polyvinyl alcohol hydrogel sheet prevents migration of inflammatory cells and subsequently reduces intraspinal canal scar tissue formation and adhesive reaction. Other beneficial properties are extreme elasticity and low friction, which eliminate mechanical reaction to the spinal cord. The polyvinyl alcohol hydrogel sheet is believed to be useful in eliminating scar tissue formation and does not interfere with the dynamic gliding movement of the spinal cord and nerve roots.

Decompensation after Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation of idiopathic scoliosis.

Spinal decompensation after corrective surgery for scoliosis appears to be a significant problem after Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation (CDI). CDI produces torsional changes in the instrumented and uninstrumented spine that could result in spinal imbalance. Preoperative and postoperative three-dimensional analysis including computed tomography (CT) scans to measure vertebral rotation and segmental rotation were performed to evaluate the importance of torsional changes. Moe/King Type II deformities had a substantially greater risk of imbalance. Deformities instrumented over fewer spinal segments were less likely to decompensate. Specifically, instrumentation excluding the mobile transition segment, determined by maximum segmental rotation and segmental Cobb angle, was likely to decompensate. Derotation and deformity correction excessive in relation to preoperative side bending flexibility and segmental rotation frequently resulted in imbalance. Spinal imbalance after CDI can be reduced by avoiding overcorrection and inclusion of mobile transition segments.

Changes in vertebral rotation after Harrington and Luque instrumentation for idiopathic scoliosis.

This study was carried out to analyze the three-dimensional and in particular the rotational correction obtained after spine instrumentation for idiopathic scoliosis. Preoperative and postoperative radiographs and computed tomographic scans with single axial cuts through each vertebral level were obtained for 14 patients: 4 Harrington, 7 Luque, and 3 Harrington-Luque. Rotation of vertebrae relative to the spinal axis and rotation between vertebrae (segmental rotation) were measured from computed tomographic scans of instrumented and uninstrumented segments. The derotation and changes occurring after surgery were calculated. Before operation, rotation was maximal at the apex, and close to 0 at the end vertebra; segmental rotation was greatest at the end of the curve, and minimal at the apex. After Harrington instrumentation the apical vertebrae showed a median derotation of 16%, after Luque instrumentation it was 12% and after Harrington-Luque instrumentation it was 13%. Segmental derotation did not uniformly occur. Major derotation was obtained at the end vertebrae and 39% of the total derotation occurred outside of the instrumented levels of the spine.

Rotational changes of the vertebral-pelvic axis following Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation.

Ten consecutive patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis and King-Moe curve Types II and III, scheduled consecutively for Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation, underwent pre- and postoperative computed tomography scans with axial slices through each vertebra, and including the pelvis. Vertebral rotation was measured and referenced to the pelvis. Average derotation of the thoracic apex after surgery was 9%. King-Moe Type II curves tended to derotate more successfully (average 26% improvement), while Type III curves derotated very little, if at all (average 1.3% worsening of the rotational deformity). Type II curves often showed segmental rotational changes outside the levels of instrumentation, while Type III curves did not; more frequently the spinal-pelvic axis rotated en bloc. It appears, therefore, that Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation does not consistently or predictably derotate the thoracic apex relative to the pelvis, and coronal plane correction may only be apparent, due to transmitted torque and rotation of the entire spinal-pelvic axis.

Radiographic evaluation of instability in spondylolisthesis.

STUDY DESIGN: The amount of intervertebral motion seen during dynamic radiography when imaged with the patient in the standing position was compared with that obtained with the patient in the lateral decubitus position. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Regarding analysis of spondylolisthesis, whether flexion/extension radiographs should be obtained with the patient in the lateral decubitus or standing position has been anecdotal. METHODS: Fifty consecutive adult patients with spondylolisthesis underwent flexion/extension lumbar spine radiographs in both positions. Abnormal motion was considered above 12 degrees dynamic angulation or 8% translation. RESULTS: Thirty-one of 50 patients displayed abnormal translation. Of these, 18 had abnormal motion only when they were examined in the lateral decubitus position and not when standing. Nine displayed excessive motion in both positions. Only four displayed more translation while standing. There was no statistical difference in the evaluation of dynamic angulation based on patient position. Neither age, degree of slip, listhetic level, nor type of spondylolisthesis correlated with abnormal motion. CONCLUSIONS: When spondylolisthesis is being analyzed, to maximize motion, flexion/extension radiographs should be obtained in the lateral decubitus position.

The effects of volatile anesthetics on the relative amplitudes and latencies of spinal and muscle potentials evoked by transcranial magnetic stimulation.

STUDY DESIGN: The effects of halothane, enflurane, or isoflurane on motor-evoked potentials via transcranial magnetic stimulation were investigated in cats. Time and dose effects on muscle potentials and spinal potentials were determined by measuring relative changes in amplitudes and latencies. METHODS: In 16 cats, muscle potentials and spinal potentials were evoked transcranially using magnetic stimulation. Potentials were recorded every 2 minutes for 10 minutes at end-tidal anesthetic concentrations of 0.25%, 0.5%, 0.75%, or 1.0%, and for 10 minutes after agents were removed. RESULTS: These anesthetics significantly attenuated the amplitude, but not the latency of muscle potentials. Effects were reversible and time and dose dependent. In contrast, these agents had little or no effect on amplitudes or latencies of spinal potentials. CONCLUSIONS: Monitoring intraoperative changes in spinal potentials may provide useful information regarding motor pathway assessment, because anesthetics have minimal effects on spinal potentials, whereas this is not so for muscle potentials.

Lumbosacral chordoma. Prognostic factors and treatment.

STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective analysis. OBJECTIVES: To analyze the prognostic factors in patients with chordomas, the success of various treatments, the diagnostic value of open versus needle biopsy, the neurologic impairment after sacral nerve resection, and the clinical presentation and site of origin. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Staging of chordomas has not been of much value, compared with other bone tumors, because for chordomas, grade is similar, metastasis is infrequent at presentation, and the prognostic significance of size is uncertain. METHODS: A review of patients with chordoma from 1965 through 1996 found 23 cases (mean age of patients, 55 years). The mean follow-up was 84 months. Mean tumor size was 81 mm (range, 35-135 mm), location was lumbar (n = 6), S1 (n = 4), S2 (n = 3), S3 (n = 7), S4 (n = 2), and S5 (n = 1). RESULTS: No tumors were found in the higher sacrum (S1-S2) alone, without involvement of the lower sacrum. Survival analysis at 5 years showed overall survival (OS) 86%, continuous disease-free survival (CDFS) 58%, and local recurrence-free survival (LRFS) 60%. The location of tumor, defined by highest level of involvement (lumbar vs. sacrum) was of prognostic significance for OS (P = 0.01; log-rank test), CDFS (P = 0.036), but not for LRFS (P = 0.189). Results of multivariate regression showed that location was significant for OS (P = 0.007), CDFS (P = 0.008), and LRFS (P = 0.001). For patients with positive margins (n = 16), initial radiation correlated with longer CDFS (P = 0.002; Mantel-Cox) and LRFS (P = 0.005, Mantel-Cox), but was not significant for OS (P = 0.41). For patients who received no radiation, a positive margin correlated with a shorter CDFS (P = 0.04), a trend to shorter LRFS (P = 0.08), but no difference in OS. Therefore, both a tumor-free margin and initial radiation correlated with a longer survival. No patients had urinary or bowel dysfunction when both S3 nerves were preserved. If one S3 nerve was preserved, 1 of 3 patients had partial urinary incontinence and 2 of 3 patients required bowel medications. If both S3 nerves were resected, all patients required intermittent urinary catheterization and bowel medications. If both S2 nerves were resected, there was complete urinary and bowel incontinence. CONCLUSIONS: The highest level of tumor involvement was prognostically significant for OS, CDFS, and LRFS. Radiation was of value when complete excision was not achieved. Bilateral S3 nerve preservation is necessary to ensure retention of normal urinary and bowel function.

Electrophysiologic evaluation of intermittent sacral nerve dysfunction in lumbar spinal canal stenosis.

Intermittent sacral nerve dysfunction, induced by walking in lumbar spinal canal stenosis, may cause symptoms including hyperesthesia and pain in perineum, urinary bladder incontinence, and penile erection. However, it is difficult to objectively document these symptoms. Evoked external urethral sphincter potentials by conus medullaris stimulation were measured both before walking and after walking in five patients who complained of sexual organ or urinary dysfunction during walking, and were compared with simultaneously induced sacral nerve symptoms. These potentials were also measured during surgery. Sacral nerve symptoms were reproduced by walking 80-350 meters (average 177.5 m). These potentials disappeared in one patient and were decreased in four patients at the time when the claudicant symptoms disabled the patient during walking. The amplitude subsequently recovered in keeping with relief of those symptoms during rest. Monitoring of these potentials during surgery showed an increase of amplitude shortly after the decompression procedure of the cauda equina. In conclusion, this measuring method was valuable as an objective evaluation of intermittent sacral nerve dysfunction in lumbar spinal canal stenosis.

Does scoliosis have a psychological impact and does gender make a difference?

STUDY DESIGN: A population-based case-control study, we identified adolescents with and without scoliosis in Minnesota who were 12 through 18 years of age. Matched control subjects were randomly selected from school children who did not have scoliosis or any other condition. Information on scoliosis was obtained by a self-administered questionnaire, the Adolescent Health Survey. Collected on more than 75,000 school age adolescents, with established validity and reliability, a secondary analysis of adolescents with scoliosis was performed as compared with a normative peer group. OBJECTIVE: To describe and characterize the psychosocial impact of scoliosis on the areas of peer relations, body image, and health-compromising behavior, such as suicidal thought and alcohol consumption. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The impact of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis has not been assessed using generic health status measures appropriate for adolescents. Previous studies have concentrated on the health status of adults by measuring work status, marriage status, and other adult measures. The purpose of this study was to study the health status of patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis, using the Adolescent Health Survey, a generic health status measure with established validity and reliability. METHODS: Body image, peer relations, social and high-risk behavior, and comparative health were assessed to determine if scoliosis was an independent risk factor and to determine if scoliosis was associated with these psychosocial issues. RESULTS: Six hundred eighty-five cases of scoliosis were identified from the 34,706 adolescents. The prevalence was 1.97%. Of the 685 adolescents with scoliosis and their control subjects, the adjusted odds ratio for having suicidal thought among adolescent with scoliosis, compared to adolescents without scoliosis, was 1.40 (P value of 0.04) after adjustment for race, gender, socioeconomic status, and age. The adjusted odds ratio for having feelings about poor body development among adolescents with scoliosis was 1.82 (P value 0.001) compared with adolescents without scoliosis after adjustment for race, gender, socioeconomic status, and age. Scoliosis was an independent risk factor for suicidal thought, worry and concern over body development, and peer interactions after adjustment. CONCLUSION: Scoliosis is a significant risk factor for psychosocial issues and health-compromising behavior. Gender differences exist in male and female adolescents with scoliosis.

Extension of fusions to the pelvis in idiopathic scoliosis.

STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective study of patients after extension of previous scoliosis fusions to the pelvis. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether modern instrumentation and surgical techniques provide for increased fusion rates with fewer complications. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Traditionally, long fusions to the pelvis in adults with idiopathic scoliosis have resulted in high complication rates, including pseudarthrosis. METHODS: The hospital and clinic charts of 41 patients (40 female, 1 male) were reviewed 41 months (range: 24-116) after surgery for extension to the pelvis of previous scoliosis fusions. Thirty-nine of 41 had a combined anteroposterior fusion extension; two had posterior extension only. In 37 of 41 patients, Cotrel-Dubousset (CD) instrumentation was used; in two, Isola (Acromed Corp., Cleveland, OH), in one, TSRH; (Sofamor-Danek, Memphis, TN), and in one, Synergy (Cross Medical Products, Columbus, OH). Parameters analyzed were fusion rate, sagittal and coronal balance, lumbar lordosis, length of fusion extension, and distal fixation method. RESULTS: Complications were seen in 30 of 41 patients. The pseudarthrosis rate was 37% (15/41) and was significantly related to the method of distal posterior fixation. With sacral fixation only, the rate was 53% (8/15), with iliac fixation only 42% (3/7), and with both iliac and sacral fixation 21% (4/19; P < 0.05). This was not correlated with fusion rate, and the length of fusion extension did not affect the pseudarthrosis rate or sagittal balance. CONCLUSION: When fixed to the ilium and sacrum, modern instrumentation appears capable of maintaining sagittal balance with lower rates of pseudarthrosis when previous scoliosis fusions are extended to the pelvis. The complication rate remains significant.

Lumbar fusion results related to diagnosis.

STUDY DESIGN: Pain outcome and functional outcome after primary lumbar fusion surgery were determined by a self-assessment questionnaire. The responses were correlated with various clinical parameters. OBJECTIVES: To determine the result of fusion surgery among patients in various diagnostic groups using semiquantitative outcome scales. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Most previous studies on the results of primary lumbar fusion have reported the presence of pain, but few have addressed function outcomes. Results of a literature review were inconclusive as to whether a patient's diagnosis is a predictor of improved results. METHODS: During the 3-year period from 1988 to 1990, 165 patients underwent a primary lumbar fusion procedure. They had a chart and radiograph review and were categorized into five major diagnostic groups: 1) pediatric, 2) grade I-II spondylolisthesis (low-slip), 3) grade III-IV spondylolisthesis (high-slip), 4) degenerative disc disease, and 5) postdiscectomy. At a follow-up period of 5 years (mean) after the fusion, patients were mailed a questionnaire in which they described their pain and functional status before and after their lumbar fusion surgery. Questionnaires were returned by 92% of the patients. The questionnaire scores, complications, and revision procedures were grouped by patient diagnosis and analyzed. RESULTS: Patient satisfaction with the results of primary lumbar fusion ranged from 69% (for the postdiscectomy group) to 100% (for the pediatric and high-slip groups). For all diagnostic groups, lumbar fusion resulted in a significant decrease in back pain and leg pain (visual analog scale), which was maintained throughout the follow-up period. For back pain, the pediatric and high-slip groups showed significantly more improvement than the degenerative disc disease or postdiscectomy groups. Leg pain among patients in the pediatric and high-slip groups was significantly more improved than leg pain among patients in the low-slip, degenerative disc disease, or postdiscectomy groups. There was no deterioration of pain scores during the follow-up period. After fusion, all groups had a significant decrease in Oswestry disability scores; patients in the pediatric and high-slip group had significantly more improvement than patients in the degenerative disc disease or postdiscectomy groups. High- and low-slip groups had a significant improvement in their pain drawing score. Medication use was substantially reduced in all groups. After fusion, a lack of improvement in back pain score or disability score was significantly correlated with pseudarthrosis. CONCLUSIONS: The outcome of primary lumbar fusion surgery was decreased pain and increased function for the majority of patients in all five diagnostic categories. The amount of improvement varied by diagnostic group. Patients with developmental conditions showed greater improvement than patients with degenerative conditions.

Chymopapain versus conventional surgery for lumbar disc herniation. 10-year results of treatment.

We reviewed two comparable groups of patients who had been treated for lumbar disc herniation by chymopapain chemonucleolysis (145) or conventional surgical discectomy (91). They were reviewed 10 years after treatment by questionnaire, followed by a personal interview by an independent observer. The results of the surgically treated groups were slightly better than those treated with chymopapain. In particular, there was significantly better early relief of leg and low back pain, and fewer patients needed a second procedure. Complications were few in both groups.