Alterations in Msx 1 and Msx 2 expression correlate with inhibition of outgrowth of chick facial primordia induced by retinoic acid.

Spatially-restricted expression domains of Msx 1 and Msx 2 in the developing chick face suggest that they may play a role in epithelial-mesenchymal interactions governing outgrowth of facial primordia. Retinoid application to developing chick faces reproducibly inhibits upper beak outgrowth but the lower beak is unaffected. In the normal face, high levels of Msx gene transcripts in upper and lower beak primordia correlate with regions of outgrowth. Following retinoid treatment, Msx 1 and Msx 2 transcripts are rapidly down-regulated in upper beak primordia where outgrowth is inhibited, but remain largely unchanged in lower beak primordia, where outgrowth is unaffected. Decreases in gene expression precede retinoid-induced morphological changes in the upper beak, suggesting that Msx gene products are involved in mediating the effect of retinoids on facial development.

Effects of retinoids on chick face development.

Local application of retinoic acid to chick embryos produces severe bilateral clefting of the primary palate but does not affect the lower beak. This paper reviews what is known about the basis and specificity of this retinoid-induced defect by examining three major developmental processes: morphogenesis, cell differentiation, and pattern formation. The conclusion reached is that neither cytotoxicity nor cartilage inhibition is the basis of the specific retinoid-induced defect. Retinoid treatment interferes with reciprocal epithelial-mesenchymal interactions in the upper beak. These interactions are involved in linking pattern formation--the spatial ordering of cell differentiation--to morphogenesis and outgrowth. These results suggest that retinoids are interfering with the process of pattern formation in the upper beak, a conclusion that is supported by the similarities between retinoid effects on face and limb development. Thus, it appears that retinoids may be acting as general signaling molecules throughout the developing embryo. In the lower beak, pattern-forming cues may occur earlier in development. Alternatively, the cells may be unresponsive to retinoids. The molecular basis for the specificity of the facial defect--as well as for the action of retinoids on developing systems--is discussed with reference to recent advances in molecular biology.

Epithelial-mesenchymal interactions in the development of chick facial primordia and the target of retinoid action.

The development of the chick face involves outgrowth of buds of tissue, accompanied by the differentiation of cartilage and bone in spatially defined patterns. To investigate the role of epithelial-mesenchymal interactions in facial morphogenesis, small fragments of facial tissue have been grafted to host chick wing buds to continue their development in isolation. Fragments of the frontonasal mass give rise to typical upper-beak-like structures: a long central rod of cartilage, the prenasal cartilage and an egg tooth. Meckel's cartilage, characteristic of the lower beak, develops from fragments of the mandible. Removal of the ectoderm prior to grafting leads to truncated development. In fragments of frontonasal mass mesenchyme only a small spur of cartilage differentiates and there is no outgrowth. The mandible is less affected; a rod of cartilage still forms but the amount of outgrowth is reduced. Retinoid treatment of chick embryos specifically affects the development of the upper beak and outgrowth and cartilage differentiation in the frontonasal mass are inhibited. The mandibles, however, are unaffected and develop normally. In order to investigate whether the epithelium or the mesenchyme of the frontonasal mass is the target of retinoid action, recombinations of retinoid-treated and untreated facial tissue have been grafted to host wing buds. Recombinations of retinoid-treated frontonasal mass ectoderm with untreated mesenchyme develop normally whereas recombinations of untreated ectoderm with retinoid-treated mesenchyme lead to truncations. The amount of outgrowth in fragments of mandibular tissue is slightly reduced when either the ectoderm or the mesenchyme has been treated with retinoids. These recombination experiments demonstrate that the mesenchyme of the frontonasal mass is the target of retinoid action. This suggests that retinoids interfere with the reciprocal epithelial-mesenchymal interactions necessary for outgrowth and normal upper beak development.

Quantitative analysis of the effect of retinoids on facial morphogenesis.

Retinoids have been applied to stage 20 chick embryos by using beads that act as controlled release carriers. With beads soaked in high concentrations of all-trans-retinoic acid, the face, in addition to the wing, is affected. Severe bilateral clefting of the primary palate results; the upper beak is completely missing, whereas the lower beak is unaffected. By using a scoring system that quantitates the severity of the upper beak defect, dose-response curves have been obtained. With beads soaked in progressively higher concentrations of retinoic acid, the upper beaks are increasingly truncated. The synthetic retinoid TTNPB also causes beak defects and is 30 times more potent than all-trans-retinoic acid. By removing beads soaked in retinoids at different times after implantation, the effect of varying the length of exposure of the developing face to retinoids has been examined. The production of beak defects is a two-step process and only a short exposure to retinoid is required to produce clefting. There are striking similarities in the dose-time relationships of retinoid treatments that are required to bring about beak defects and pattern changes in the limb. The outgrowth and development of spatially defined patterns of connective tissue within the upper beak appear analogous to processes involved in limb morphogenesis. We propose that retinoids may act by the same mechanisms in both systems. An unsolved puzzle is why retinoids specifically affect the development of the upper beak.

The patterns on chondrogenesis of cells from facial primordia of chick embryos in micromass culture.

Chondrogenesis of mesenchymal cells from the frontonasal mass, mandibles and maxillae of stage-24 chick embryos has been investigated in micromass (high-density) cultures. Distinct differences in the amount and pattern of cartilage differentiation are found. In cultures of frontonasal mass cells, a central sheet of cartilage develops; in cultures of mandible cells, less cartilage differentiates and nodules form; while in cultures of maxillae cells, virtually no chondrogenesis takes place. The same patterns of cartilage are found in cultures established from stage-20 embryos. At stage 28, frontonasal mass cultures form cartilage nodules and the number of nodules in mandible cultures is markedly decreased. There are striking parallels between the chondrogenic patterns of cells from the face and limb buds in micromass culture. The frontonasal mass cell cultures of stage-20 and -24 chick embryos resemble those established from the progress zone of limb buds. The progress zone is an undifferentiated region of the limb in which positional cues operate. Cultures established from the frontonasal mass of stage-28 chick embryos and from the mandibles of all stages resemble cultures of whole limb buds. These contain a mixture of committed and uncommitted cells. Ectoderm from facial primordia locally inhibits chondrogenesis in micromass cultures and this could provide a positional cue. The differences in chondrogenic potential of cells from facial primordia may underlie the specific retinoid effects on the frontonasal mass.

The effects of retinoids on cartilage differentiation in micromass cultures of chick facial primordia and the relationship to a specific facial defect.

Retinoids produce facial defects in chicken embryos. Outgrowth of the frontonasal mass with accompanying cartilage differentiation and pattern formation is inhibited. In contrast, the development of the mandibular primordia that give rise to the lower beak proceeds normally. To investigate whether the upper beak defect is based on the inhibition of cartilage differentiation specifically in the frontonasal mass, the effects of retinoids on chondrogenesis in micromass (high density) cultures of cells from facial primordia have been studied. When either 10(-6) M retinoic acid or 10(-8) M (E)-4-[2-(5,6,7,8-tetrahydro-5,5,8,8-tetramethyl-2-napthalenyl-1- propenyl]benzoic acid (TTNPB; a stable retinoid) is added to the culture medium, cartilage differentiation is inhibited. Both frontonasal mass and mandible cultures are equally affected. The concentration of TTNPB found in both facial primordia in vivo, after a treatment that produces the defect, is also about 10(-8) M. This rules out preferential accumulation of the retinoid by the frontonasal mass as an explanation for the defect. In fact, the concentration of retinoid found in vivo, should, from the culture studies, be sufficient to markedly inhibit chondrogenesis in both the frontonasal mass and mandibles. The effects of exposure to retinoids in the intact face appear to be different to those in culture. Furthermore, when cells from retinoid-treated facial primordia are cultured in micromass, the extent and pattern of chondrogenesis in frontonasal mass cultures is identical to that of cells from untreated primordia. Cartilage differentiation in mandible cultures is slightly affected. These findings suggest that retinoids do not produce the specific facial defect by directly interfering with cartilage differentiation.

Retinoids reprogramme pre-bud mesenchyme to give changes in limb pattern.

Retinoic acid was locally applied to presumptive limb regions of chick embryos to find out the earliest time at which the limb pattern can be reprogrammed. When beads soaked in retinoic acid were placed in the appropriate positions in embryos at stage 10 or older, duplicated or reduced leg patterns resulted. To pin point the time at which the cells in the limb rudiment respond to the retinoid, beads were removed at various times and the lengths of exposure required to reprogramme limb development found. The early limb rudiments require longer exposures to give duplications than late rudiments. The effective treatment periods last at least until stage 17 when the limb bud and apical ectodermal ridge develop. In contrast, the length of exposure to reduce the limb is constant at early stages. Retinoids first start acting to produce duplicated structures between stages 10 and 13. Therefore, retinoids appear to begin to reprogramme the cells as soon as they are determined to give rise to a limb.

Pattern formation in the facial primordia.

Pattern formation is the developmental process that leads to the spatial ordering of cell differentiation. We have explored the problem of pattern formation in the development of the face of chick embryos. At early stages, the developing face consists of a series of small buds of tissue, the facial primordia that encircle the primitive mouth. The concepts of positional information provide a framework for considering how the patterns of differentiated cells are generated in the face. We suggest that the cranial neural crest cells must first be informed to which facial primordium they belong and then of their position within that primordium. The cells of the early primordia appear indistinguishable. However, when the mesenchyme cells are placed in high-density culture, cartilage differentiates. The extent and pattern of cartilage differentiation is characteristic for the cell population of each facial primordium. Myogenic cells also differentiate in the cultures, but the proportion of myogenic cells is independent of the extent of chondrogenesis. Within the facial primordia, a set of epithelial-mesenchymal interactions appears to be required for outgrowth and pattern formation along the proximodistal axis of the chick beaks. In culture, face epithelium locally inhibits cartilage differentiation and suggests that another set of epithelial-mesenchymal interactions may be involved in cell patterning. The mechanisms involved in specifying the mediolateral axis of the face, for example, the midpoint of the upper beak, are not known. Vitamin A derivatives, collectively known as retinoids, affect the development of the face of chick embryos and lead to a specific facial defect. Upper beak development is inhibited but the lower beak develops normally. The response to retinoids could be related to the specification of cells to belong to the facial primordium that will form the upper beak. Alternatively, retinoids may interfere with positional cues that operate to inform cells of their position within that primordium.

Expression pattern of homeobox-containing genes during chick embryogenesis.

We have isolated, sequenced and examined the expression pattern of two tandemly arranged homeobox-containing genes from the chicken. The predicted amino acid sequences of the homeodomain and the adjacent carboxyterminal portion of the protein of the first gene is virtually identical (99%) to that of murine homeobox 2.1 and hence we refer to it as Ghox 2.1 (Gallus homeobox). The closest mouse homologue of the second homeodomain is Hox 2.2 (95% identical within the homeobox), and hence referred to as Ghox 2.2. Northern analysis of embryonic RNA reveals major transcripts of 2 kb for Ghox 2.1 and 1.7 kb for Ghox 2.2. To investigate the transcript pattern, embryos of various stages were dissected into heads, trunks and limb buds and the RNA was analysed by Northern blotting and RNase protection assays. Ghox 2.1 transcripts are present in all three regions. Ghox 2.2 RNA is found in trunks and limb buds, but it is strikingly absent from the developing head. In situ hybridization with 35S-labelled antisense riboprobes derived from Ghox 2.1 demonstrates that this gene is expressed at high levels in spinal chord, myelencephalon and mesonephros. Dorsal root ganglia and the lung rudiment also contain Ghox 2.1 message, but in somewhat lower amounts. Mid- and forebrain, the heart, presomitic mesenchyme and notochord do not contain detectable levels of Ghox 2.1 mRNA. Of particular interest is the expression of Ghox 2.1 in a well-defined patch of mesenchymal tissue situated in an anterioproximal region of the limb bud.

Molecular approaches to vertebrate limb morphogenesis.

It has long been proposed that concentration gradients of morphogens provide cues to specify cell fate in embryonic fields. Recent work in a variety of vertebrate systems give bona fide evidence that retinoic acid, the biologically active form of vitamin A, is a candidate for such a morphogen. In the developing chick wing, for example, locally applied retinoic acid triggers striking changes in the pattern along the anteroposterior axis. Instead of giving rise to a wing with the normal 234 digit pattern, wing buds treated with retinoic acid develop a 432234 mirror-image symmetrical digit pattern. For this review, we focus on three aspects of limb morphogenesis. (1) We summarize the experimental evidence supporting the notion that retinoic acid is a candidate morphogen. (2) Limb buds contain high levels of cellular retinoic-acid-binding protein (CRABP). Using order of magnitude calculations, we evaluate how the concentration of CRABP might affect the occupancy state of the retinoic acid receptor. (3) We discuss the spatio-temporal expression pattern of homeobox-containing genes in the developing limb and speculate about the possibility that retinoic acid influences the pattern of expression of homeobox genes.

Primary defects in the lens underlie complex anterior segment abnormalities of the Pax6 heterozygous eye.

We describe lens defects in heterozygous small eye mice, and autonomous deficiencies of Pax6(+/-) cells in the developing lens of Pax6(+/+) <--> Pax6(+/-) chimeras. Two separate defects of the lens were identified by analyzing the distribution of heterozygous cells in chimeras: Pax6(+/-) cells are less readily incorporated into the lens placode than wild type, and those that are incorporated into the lens are not maintained efficiently in the proliferating lens epithelium. The lens of chimeric eyes is, therefore, predominantly wild type from embryonic day 16.5 onwards, whereas heterozygous cells contribute normally to all other eye tissues. Eye size and defects of the iris and cornea are corrected in fetal and adult chimeras with up to 80% mutant cells. Therefore, these aspects of the phenotype may be secondary consequences of primary defects in the lens, which has clinical relevance for the human aniridia (PAX6(+/-)) phenotype.

Experimental analysis of the control of expression of the homeobox-gene Msx-1 in the developing limb and face.

Mouse mesenchyme was grafted into chick embryos to investigate the control of mesenchymal expression of Msx-1 in the developing limb and face. In situ hybridization, using species-specific probes, allows a comparison between Msx-1 expression in the graft and the host tissue. The results show that Msx-1 expression in both limb-to-limb and face-to-face grafts corresponds closely with the level of Msx-1 expression in the surrounding chick mesenchyme. Cells in grafts that end up within the host domain of Msx-1 express the gene irrespective of whether they were from normally expressing, or non-expressing, regions. Therefore Msx-1 expression in both the developing limb and the developing face appears to be position-dependent. Mesenchyme from each of the three major facial primordia behaved in the same way when grafted to the chick maxillary primordium. Reciprocal grafts between face and limb gave a different result: Msx-1 expression was activated when facial mesenchyme was grafted to the limb but not when limb mesenchyme was grafted to the face. This suggests either that there are quantitative or qualitative differences in two local signalling systems or that additional factors determine the responsiveness of the mesenchyme cells.