Investigation of oligosaccharides and allulose as sucrose replacers in low-moisture wire-cut cookies.

Non-digestible oligosaccharides (OS) and allulose have beneficial health properties and could reduce the amount of added sugar in baked goods. In this study allulose and various OS [fructo-oligosaccharides (FOS), galacto-oligosaccharides (GOS), lactosucrose (LOS), isomalto-oligosaccharides (IMO), Promitor 70R (P70R), and xylo-oligosaccharides (XOS)] were added to a wire-cut cookie formulation at concentrations determined to have similar effects on the gelatinization temperature (Tgel) of starch relative to sucrose. Different baking performance attributes of the doughs and cookies were assessed, including: appearance, spread, color, texture, and % moisture loss after baking. The results were correlated to: OS solution and solid properties and OS effects on starch thermal events (gelatinization, pasting, and retrogradation). The Tgel-matching formulation protocol was effective in producing reduced-sugar cookies which had similar appearance, color, and spread attributes compared to the sucrose control; however, cookie texture significantly varied. Cookies containing allulose were the least similar to the control, having darker color, reduced spread, and softer cake-like texture. The only OS cookies that matched the texture of the sucrose control contained LOS, while P70R cookies were the hardest. Cookie texture correlated strongly with the % total moisture loss after baking (r = -0.8763) and was best explained by OS solution viscosity: more viscous OS solutions limited moisture release and resulted in harder cookies. The Tgel of starch also correlated with OS solution viscosity (r = 0.7861) and should be accounted for in reduced sugar applications. The OS recommended as sucrose replacers in cookies based on principal component analysis groupings were: XOS > IMO > LOS > and GOS.

Oligosaccharide, sucrose, and allulose effects on the pasting and retrogradation behaviors of wheat starch.

The pasting and retrogradation behaviors of starch are altered by the presence of sugars and are important in dictating the storage stability and texture of starch-containing foods. The use of oligosaccharides (OS) and allulose in reduced-sugar formulations is being explored. The objectives of this study were to determine the impacts of different types and concentrations (0% to 60% w/w) of OS (fructo-OS, gluco-OS, isomalto-OS, gluco-dextrin, and xylo-OS) and allulose on the pasting and retrogradation attributes of wheat starch compared to starch in water (control) or sucrose solutions using DSC and rheometry. Physicochemical properties of the additives and their effects on amylose leaching were also considered. Significant differences in starch pasting, retrogradation, and amylose leaching were found between the control and additive solutions, influenced by additive type and concentration. Allulose increased starch paste viscosity and promoted retrogradation over time (60% conc. PV = 7628 cP; ΔHret, 14 = 3.18 J/g) compared to the control (PV = 1473 cP; ΔHret, 14 = 2.66 J/g) and all OS (PV = 14 to 1834 cP; ΔHret,14 = 0.34 to 3.08 J/g). In the allulose, sucrose, and xylo-OS solutions, compared to the other OS types, the gelatinization and pasting temperatures of starch were lower, more amylose leaching occurred, and pasting viscosities were higher. Increasing OS concentrations elevated gelatinization and pasting temperatures. In most 60% OS solutions these temperatures exceeded 95 °C thereby preventing starch gelatinization and pasting in the rheological analysis, and in conditions relevant for inhibiting starch gelatinization in low moisture-sweetened products. Fructose-analog additives (allulose and fructo-OS) promoted starch retrogradation more than the other additives, while xylo-OS was the only additive that limited retrogradation across all OS concentrations. The correlations and quantitative findings from this study will assist product developers in selecting health-promoting sugar replacer ingredients that impart desirable texture and shelf-life properties in starch-containing foods.

Mechanisms of the different effects of sucrose, glucose, fructose, and a glucose-fructose mixture on wheat starch gelatinization, pasting, and retrogradation.

The gelatinization, pasting, and retrogradation of starch influence texture, quality, and shelf-life attributes of many foods. The purpose of this work was to document the effects of a 50:50 glucose:fructose (glc:fru) mixture and sucrose solutions on these starch traits to provide a fundamental basis to explain the different texture and shelf-life attributes of baked goods formulated with these sugars. Differential scanning calorimetry, rapid visco analyzer, and oscillatory rheometry were used to quantify the effects of glucose, fructose, glc:fru mixture, and sucrose at different concentrations (0% to 60% w/w), on the gelatinization temperature, pasting, and retrogradation properties of wheat starch. Distinct differences were found between the effects of sucrose and those of the monosaccharides including the glc:fru mixture. Sucrose elevated Tgel and pasting temperature most and decreased other RVA parameters compared to the monosaccharides as concentration increased. Fructose and the glc:fru mixture promoted amylopectin retrogradation, while retrogradation was inhibited in sucrose and glucose solutions. The glc:fru mixture had similar effects on starch properties compared to fructose under static measurement conditions (DSC), and the effects were in between those of glucose and fructose under dynamic conditions when shear was applied (RVA and rheology). These effects are explained by the phase separation and/or solute partitioning of the monosaccharide constituents of the glc:fru mixture. Sugar solution physicochemical properties correlated strongly with starch gelatinization and retrogradation. The results substantiate the important relationship between sugar physicochemical properties and solution dynamics with starch thermal properties, which in turn affect the texture and structure of starch-containing food products. PRACTICAL APPLICATION: The quality attributes of starch-containing baked goods are influenced by how different amounts and types of sugars affect starch cooking properties. The underlying mechanisms of the different sugar effects involve solution viscosity, intermolecular hydrogen bonding, and phase separation. Substituting one sugar for another has less effect on these starch properties in products with lower sugar concentrations than in products with more sugar. Mixtures of sugars behave differently than single sugars in different conditions due to phase separation. Baked goods made with glucose:fructose mixtures in place of sucrose likely have higher amounts of gelatinized starch and increased firmness (i.e., staling or retrogradation) over time.

Oligosaccharides elevate the gelatinization temperature of wheat starch more than sucrose, paving the way for their use in reduced sugar starch-based formulations.

The gelatinization of wheat starch influences the final structure and texture of baked goods. Sucrose effectively elevates the gelatinization temperature (Tgel) of starch more than many sweeteners, and maintaining a higher Tgel has been a challenge while reducing the amount of sucrose in baked goods. The objective of this study was to quantify the effects of 14 different oligosaccharides (OS: maltose, isomaltulose, kestose, maltotriose, melezitose, raffinose, stachyose, a fructo-OS, a galacto-OS, an isomalto-OS, lactosucrose, a xylo-OS, and two glucose-based dextrins), allulose, and sucrose at different concentrations (0 to 60% w/w) on the Tgel of wheat starch using DSC, and to determine which OS physicochemical properties best explained the Tgel results. OS type and concentration significantly altered Tgel. Many OS elevated the Tgel as much as or more than sucrose at the same solution concentrations, while allulose did not. The onset Tgel in water was 60 °C, in 60% sucrose was 96 °C, in 60% allulose was 80 °C, and Tgel increased up to 107-108 °C in 60% fructo-OS and Nutriose® solutions. The effects of OS on Tgel correlated most strongly (r > 0.95) with two OS solution parameters: the solvent effective volume fraction (ϕw,eff, related to solute intermolecular hydrogen bond density) and solution viscosity, to a lesser extent with solution water activity, and not to the glass transition temperature of the OS. Based on Tgel elevation, many of the OS are promising sucrose replacements in baked goods, which could facilitate their use in desirable higher fiber, reduced sugar starch-based baked product formulations.

The effects of commercially available sweeteners (sucrose and sucrose replacers) on wheat starch gelatinization and pasting, and cookie baking.

A variety of sucrose replacers (SRs) are increasing in popularity for reducing sucrose usage in low moisture baked goods (cookies, biscuits, etc.). The goal of this study was to link SR physicochemical properties to their observed effects on starch thermal properties, including results from differential scanning calorimetry, rapid viscoanalysis, particle size analysis, and model wire-cut cookie baking performance. The 12 SRs examined in this study were: Truvia, Splenda, Swerve, coconut palm sugar, Monk Fruit, erythritol, Benefiber, Miralax, blue agave syrup, yacon syrup, Sukrín Fiber Gold Syrup, and date syrup. The onset gelatinization temperature (Tgel ) of wheat starch increased significantly (P < 0.05) as sucrose and SR concentration increased (0 to 60% w/w), with significant variations in Tgel found between different sweetener types at the same concentration. Generally, as solution concentration increased, the larger SRs (degree of polymerization [DP]> 10) decreased paste viscosity (peak and final), decreased granule swelling, and increased Tgel compared to the control (water). The smaller SRs (DP < 10) increased both paste viscosity (peak and final) and granule swelling, unlike the larger SRs, and did not increase Tgel as much as larger SRs. The SRs which performed similar to sucrose in model cookie baking (fracturability, spread, color, etc.) and effects on starch properties (Tgel , paste viscosity, and granule swelling) were yacon, Sukrín, date syrups, and coconut palm sugar. The results linking sweetener physicochemical properties to their effects on starch gelatinization, pasting, and swelling can be used to guide reformulation strategies for potentially reducing sugar and/or increasing fiber content in foods. PRACTICAL APPLICATION: Several commercially available natural sweeteners and polymers (coconut palm sugar, date syrup, yacon syrup, Sukrín Fiber Gold syrup, and Benefiber) show promise for reducing or replacing sucrose in cookies, and other low-moisture baked goods, based on their similar effects on wheat starch gelatinization, pasting, and swelling, as well as performance in cookie baking trials. Compared to sucrose, some of these ingredients have a lower glycemic response and higher dietary fiber content, and act as prebiotics, thereby providing potential health benefit.