Resistance Mechanisms to Anti-PD Cancer Immunotherapy.

The transformative success of antibodies targeting the PD-1 (programmed death 1)/B7-H1 (B7 homolog 1) pathway (anti-PD therapy) has revolutionized cancer treatment. However, only a fraction of patients with solid tumors and some hematopoietic malignancies respond to anti-PD therapy, and the reason for failure in other patients is less known. By dissecting the mechanisms underlying this resistance, current studies reveal that the tumor microenvironment is a major location for resistance to occur. Furthermore, the resistance mechanisms appear to be highly heterogeneous. Here, we discuss recent human cancer data identifying mechanisms of resistance to anti-PD therapy. We review evidence for immune-based resistance mechanisms such as loss of neoantigens, defects in antigen presentation and interferon signaling, immune inhibitory molecules, and exclusion of T cells. We also review the clinical evidence for emerging mechanisms of resistance to anti-PD therapy, such as alterations in metabolism, microbiota, and epigenetics. Finally, we discuss strategies to overcome anti-PD therapy resistance and emphasize the need to develop additional immunotherapies based on the concept of normalization cancer immunotherapy.

Cell Type Purification by Single-Cell Transcriptome-Trained Sorting.

Much of current molecular and cell biology research relies on the ability to purify cell types by fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). FACS typically relies on the ability to label cell types of interest with antibodies or fluorescent transgenic constructs. However, antibody availability is often limited, and genetic manipulation is labor intensive or impossible in the case of primary human tissue. To date, no systematic method exists to enrich for cell types without a priori knowledge of cell-type markers. Here, we propose GateID, a computational method that combines single-cell transcriptomics with FACS index sorting to purify cell types of choice using only native cellular properties such as cell size, granularity, and mitochondrial content. We validate GateID by purifying various cell types from zebrafish kidney marrow and the human pancreas to high purity without resorting to specific antibodies or transgenes.

A Paradigm Shift in Cancer Immunotherapy: From Enhancement to Normalization.

Harnessing an antitumor immune response has been a fundamental strategy in cancer immunotherapy. For over a century, efforts have primarily focused on amplifying immune activation mechanisms that are employed by humans to eliminate invaders such as viruses and bacteria. This "immune enhancement" strategy often results in rare objective responses and frequent immune-related adverse events (irAEs). However, in the last decade, cancer immunotherapies targeting the B7-H1/PD-1 pathway (anti-PD therapy), have achieved higher objective response rates in patients with much fewer irAEs. This more beneficial tumor response-to-toxicity profile stems from distinct mechanisms of action that restore tumor-induced immune deficiency selectively in the tumor microenvironment, here termed "immune normalization," which has led to its FDA approval in more than 10 cancer indications and facilitated its combination with different therapies. In this article, we wish to highlight the principles of immune normalization and learn from it, with the ultimate goal to guide better designs for future cancer immunotherapies.

The CUT&RUN greenlist: genomic regions of consistent noise are effective normalizing factors for quantitative epigenome mapping.

Cleavage Under Targets and Release Using Nuclease (CUT&RUN) is a recent development for epigenome mapping, but its unique methodology can hamper proper quantitative analyses. As traditional normalization approaches have been shown to be inaccurate, we sought to determine endogenous normalization factors based on the human genome regions of constant nonspecific signal. This constancy was determined by applying Shannon's information entropy, and the set of normalizer regions, which we named the 'Greenlist', was extensively validated using publicly available datasets. We demonstrate here that the greenlist normalization outperforms the current top standards, and remains consistent across different experimental setups, cell lines and antibodies; the approach can even be applied to different species or to CUT&Tag. Requiring no additional experimental steps and no added cost, this approach can be universally applied to CUT&RUN experiments to greatly minimize the interference of technical variation over the biological epigenome changes of interest.

Normalization of RNA-Seq data using adaptive trimmed mean with multi-reference.

The normalization of RNA sequencing data is a primary step for downstream analysis. The most popular method used for the normalization is the trimmed mean of M values (TMM) and DESeq. The TMM tries to trim away extreme log fold changes of the data to normalize the raw read counts based on the remaining non-deferentially expressed genes. However, the major problem with the TMM is that the values of trimming factor M are heuristic. This paper tries to estimate the adaptive value of M in TMM based on Jaeckel's Estimator, and each sample acts as a reference to find the scale factor of each sample. The presented approach is validated on SEQC, MAQC2, MAQC3, PICKRELL and two simulated datasets with two-group and three-group conditions by varying the percentage of differential expression and the number of replicates. The performance of the present approach is compared with various state-of-the-art methods, and it is better in terms of area under the receiver operating characteristic curve and differential expression.

Quantification Quality Control Emerges as a Crucial Factor to Enhance Single-Cell Proteomics Data Analysis.

Mass spectrometry (MS)-based single-cell proteomics (SCP) provides us the opportunity to unbiasedly explore biological variability within cells without the limitation of antibody availability. This field is rapidly developed with the main focuses on instrument advancement, sample preparation refinement, and signal boosting methods; however, the optimal data processing and analysis are rarely investigated which holds an arduous challenge because of the high proportion of missing values and batch effect. Here, we introduced a quantification quality control to intensify the identification of differentially expressed proteins (DEPs) by considering both within and across SCP data. Combining quantification quality control with isobaric matching between runs (IMBR) and PSM-level normalization, an additional 12% and 19% of proteins and peptides, with more than 90% of proteins/peptides containing valid values, were quantified. Clearly, quantification quality control was able to reduce quantification variations and q-values with the more apparent cell type separations. In addition, we found that PSM-level normalization performed similar to other protein-level normalizations but kept the original data profiles without the additional requirement of data manipulation. In proof of concept of our refined pipeline, six uniquely identified DEPs exhibiting varied fold-changes and playing critical roles for melanoma and monocyte functionalities were selected for validation using immunoblotting. Five out of six validated DEPs showed an identical trend with the SCP dataset, emphasizing the feasibility of combining the IMBR, cell quality control, and PSM-level normalization in SCP analysis, which is beneficial for future SCP studies.

Distinct Yet Proximal Face- and Body-Selective Brain Regions Enable Clutter-Tolerant Representations of the Face, Body, and Whole Person.

Faces and bodies are processed in separate but adjacent regions in the primate visual cortex. Yet, the functional significance of dividing the whole person into areas dedicated to its face and body components and their neighboring locations remains unknown. Here we hypothesized that this separation and proximity together with a normalization mechanism generate clutter-tolerant representations of the face, body, and whole person when presented in complex multi-category scenes. To test this hypothesis, we conducted a fMRI study, presenting images of a person within a multi-category scene to human male and female participants and assessed the contribution of each component to the response to the scene. Our results revealed a clutter-tolerant representation of the whole person in areas selective for both faces and bodies, typically located at the border between the two category-selective regions. Regions exclusively selective for faces or bodies demonstrated clutter-tolerant representations of their preferred category, corroborating earlier findings. Thus, the adjacent locations of face- and body-selective areas enable a hardwired machinery for decluttering of the whole person, without the need for a dedicated population of person-selective neurons. This distinct yet proximal functional organization of category-selective brain regions enhances the representation of the socially significant whole person, along with its face and body components, within multi-category scenes.

A normalization method that controls for total RNA abundance affects the identification of differentially expressed genes, revealing bias toward morning-expressed responses.

RNA-Sequencing is widely used to investigate changes in gene expression at the transcription level in plants. Most plant RNA-Seq analysis pipelines base the normalization approaches on the assumption that total transcript levels do not vary between samples. However, this assumption has not been demonstrated. In fact, many common experimental treatments and genetic alterations affect transcription efficiency or RNA stability, resulting in unequal transcript abundance. The addition of synthetic RNA controls is a simple correction that controls for variation in total mRNA levels. However, adding spike-ins appropriately is challenging with complex plant tissue, and carefully considering how they are added is essential to their successful use. We demonstrate that adding external RNA spike-ins as a normalization control produces differences in RNA-Seq analysis compared to traditional normalization methods, even between two times of day in untreated plants. We illustrate the use of RNA spike-ins with 3' RNA-Seq and present a normalization pipeline that accounts for differences in total transcriptional levels. We evaluate the effect of normalization methods on identifying differentially expressed genes in the context of identifying the effect of the time of day on gene expression and response to chilling stress in sorghum.

FastRNA: An efficient solution for PCA of single-cell RNA-sequencing data based on a batch-accounting count model.

Almost always, the analysis of single-cell RNA-sequencing (scRNA-seq) data begins with the generation of the low dimensional embedding of the data by principal-component analysis (PCA). Because scRNA-seq data are count data, log transformation is routinely applied to correct skewness prior to PCA, which is often argued to have added bias to data. Alternatively, studies have proposed methods that directly assume a count model and use approximately normally distributed count residuals for PCA. Despite their theoretical advantage of directly modeling count data, these methods are extremely slow for large datasets. In fact, when the data size grows, even the standard log normalization becomes inefficient. Here, we present FastRNA, a highly efficient solution for PCA of scRNA-seq data based on a count model accounting for both batches and cell size factors. Although we assume the same general count model as previous methods, our method uses two orders of magnitude less time and memory than the other count-based methods and an order of magnitude less time and memory than the standard log normalization. This achievement results from our unique algebraic optimization that completely avoids the formation of the large dense residual matrix in memory. In addition, our method enjoys a benefit that the batch effects are eliminated from data prior to PCA. Generating a batch-accounted PC of an atlas-scale dataset with 2 million cells takes less than a minute and 1 GB memory with our method.

HiConfidence: a novel approach uncovering the biological signal in Hi-C data affected by technical biases.

The chromatin interaction assays, particularly Hi-C, enable detailed studies of genome architecture in multiple organisms and model systems, resulting in a deeper understanding of gene expression regulation mechanisms mediated by epigenetics. However, the analysis and interpretation of Hi-C data remain challenging due to technical biases, limiting direct comparisons of datasets obtained in different experiments and laboratories. As a result, removing biases from Hi-C-generated chromatin contact matrices is a critical data analysis step. Our novel approach, HiConfidence, eliminates biases from the Hi-C data by weighing chromatin contacts according to their consistency between replicates so that low-quality replicates do not substantially influence the result. The algorithm is effective for the analysis of global changes in chromatin structures such as compartments and topologically associating domains. We apply the HiConfidence approach to several Hi-C datasets with significant technical biases, that could not be analyzed effectively using existing methods, and obtain meaningful biological conclusions. In particular, HiConfidence aids in the study of how changes in histone acetylation pattern affect chromatin organization in Drosophila melanogaster S2 cells. The method is freely available at GitHub: https://github.com/victorykobets/HiConfidence.

Differential variability analysis of single-cell gene expression data.

The advent of single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) technologies has enabled gene expression profiling at the single-cell resolution, thereby enabling the quantification and comparison of transcriptional variability among individual cells. Although alterations in transcriptional variability have been observed in various biological states, statistical methods for quantifying and testing differential variability between groups of cells are still lacking. To identify the best practices in differential variability analysis of single-cell gene expression data, we propose and compare 12 statistical pipelines using different combinations of methods for normalization, feature selection, dimensionality reduction and variability calculation. Using high-quality synthetic scRNA-seq datasets, we benchmarked the proposed pipelines and found that the most powerful and accurate pipeline performs simple library size normalization, retains all genes in analysis and uses denSNE-based distances to cluster medoids as the variability measure. By applying this pipeline to scRNA-seq datasets of COVID-19 and autism patients, we have identified cellular variability changes between patients with different severity status or between patients and healthy controls.

JLONMFSC: Clustering scRNA-seq data based on joint learning of non-negative matrix factorization and subspace clustering.

The development of single cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) has provided new perspectives to study biological problems at the single cell level. One of the key issues in scRNA-seq data analysis is to divide cells into several clusters for discovering the heterogeneity and diversity of cells. However, the existing scRNA-seq data are high-dimensional, sparse, and noisy, which challenges the existing single-cell clustering methods. In this study, we propose a joint learning framework (JLONMFSC) for clustering scRNA-seq data. In our method, the dimension of the original data is reduced to minimize the effect of noise. In addition, the graph regularized matrix factorization is used to learn the local features. Further, the Low-Rank Representation (LRR) subspace clustering is utilized to learn the global features. Finally, the joint learning of local features and global features is performed to obtain the results of clustering. We compare the proposed algorithm with eight state-of-the-art algorithms for clustering performance on six datasets, and the experimental results demonstrate that the JLONMFSC achieves better performance in all datasets. The code is avalable at https://github.com/lanbiolab/JLONMFSC.

Divisive normalization is an efficient code for multivariate Pareto-distributed environments.

Divisive normalization is a canonical computation in the brain, observed across neural systems, that is often considered to be an implementation of the efficient coding principle. We provide a theoretical result that makes the conditions under which divisive normalization is an efficient code analytically precise: We show that, in a low-noise regime, encoding an n-dimensional stimulus via divisive normalization is efficient if and only if its prevalence in the environment is described by a multivariate Pareto distribution. We generalize this multivariate analog of histogram equalization to allow for arbitrary metabolic costs of the representation, and show how different assumptions on costs are associated with different shapes of the distributions that divisive normalization efficiently encodes. Our result suggests that divisive normalization may have evolved to efficiently represent stimuli with Pareto distributions. We demonstrate that this efficiently encoded distribution is consistent with stylized features of naturalistic stimulus distributions such as their characteristic conditional variance dependence, and we provide empirical evidence suggesting that it may capture the statistics of filter responses to naturalistic images. Our theoretical finding also yields empirically testable predictions across sensory domains on how the divisive normalization parameters should be tuned to features of the input distribution.

Comparing preprocessing strategies for 3D-Gene microarray data of extracellular vesicle-derived miRNAs.

BACKGROUND: Extracellular vesicle-derived (EV)-miRNAs have potential to serve as biomarkers for the diagnosis of various diseases. miRNA microarrays are widely used to quantify circulating EV-miRNA levels, and the preprocessing of miRNA microarray data is critical for analytical accuracy and reliability. Thus, although microarray data have been used in various studies, the effects of preprocessing have not been studied for Toray's 3D-Gene chip, a widely used measurement method. We aimed to evaluate batch effect, missing value imputation accuracy, and the influence of preprocessing on measured values in 18 different preprocessing pipelines for EV-miRNA microarray data from two cohorts with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis using 3D-Gene technology. RESULTS: Eighteen different pipelines with different types and orders of missing value completion and normalization were used to preprocess the 3D-Gene microarray EV-miRNA data. Notable results were suppressed in the batch effects in all pipelines using the batch effect correction method ComBat. Furthermore, pipelines utilizing missForest for missing value imputation showed high agreement with measured values. In contrast, imputation using constant values for missing data exhibited low agreement. CONCLUSIONS: This study highlights the importance of selecting the appropriate preprocessing strategy for EV-miRNA microarray data when using 3D-Gene technology. These findings emphasize the importance of validating preprocessing approaches, particularly in the context of batch effect correction and missing value imputation, for reliably analyzing data in biomarker discovery and disease research.

Internal and external normalization of nascent RNA sequencing run-on experiments.

In experiments with significant perturbations to transcription, nascent RNA sequencing protocols are dependent on external spike-ins for reliable normalization. Unlike in RNA-seq, these spike-ins are not standardized and, in many cases, depend on a run-on reaction that is assumed to have constant efficiency across samples. To assess the validity of this assumption, we analyze a large number of published nascent RNA spike-ins to quantify their variability across existing normalization methods. Furthermore, we develop a new biologically-informed Bayesian model to estimate the error in spike-in based normalization estimates, which we term Virtual Spike-In (VSI). We apply this method both to published external spike-ins as well as using reads at the [Formula: see text] end of long genes, building on prior work from Mahat (Mol Cell 62(1):63-78, 2016. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molcel.2016.02.025 ) and Vihervaara (Nat Commun 8(1):255, 2017. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-017-00151-0 ). We find that spike-ins in existing nascent RNA experiments are typically under sequenced, with high variability between samples. Furthermore, we show that these high variability estimates can have significant downstream effects on analysis, complicating biological interpretations of results.

Feature-specific quantile normalization and feature-specific mean-variance normalization deliver robust bi-directional classification and feature selection performance between microarray and RNAseq data.

BACKGROUND: Cross-platform normalization seeks to minimize technological bias between microarray and RNAseq whole-transcriptome data. Incorporating multiple gene expression platforms permits external validation of experimental findings, and augments training sets for machine learning models. Here, we compare the performance of Feature Specific Quantile Normalization (FSQN) to a previously used but unvalidated and uncharacterized method we label as Feature Specific Mean Variance Normalization (FSMVN). We evaluate the performance of these methods for bidirectional normalization in the context of nested feature selection. RESULTS: FSQN and FSMVN provided clinically equivalent bidirectional model performance with and without feature selection for colon CMS and breast PAM50 classification. Using principal component analysis, we determine that these methods eliminate batch effects related to technological platforms. Without feature selection, no statistical difference was identified between the performance of FSQN and FSMVN of cross-platform data compared to within-platform distributions. Under optimal feature selection conditions, balanced accuracy was FSQN and FSMVN were statistically equivalent to the within-platform distribution performance in multivariable linear regression analysis. FSQN and FSMVN also provided similar performance to within-platform distributions as the number of selected genes used to create models decreases. CONCLUSIONS: In the context of generating supervised machine learning classifiers for molecular subtypes, FSQN and FSMVN are equally effective. Under optimal modeling conditions, FSQN and FSMVN provide equivalent model accuracy performance on cross-platform normalization data compared to within-platform data. Using cross-platform data should still be approached with caution as subtle performance differences may exist depending on the classification problem, training, and testing distributions.

A comparison of RNA-Seq data preprocessing pipelines for transcriptomic predictions across independent studies.

BACKGROUND: RNA sequencing combined with machine learning techniques has provided a modern approach to the molecular classification of cancer. Class predictors, reflecting the disease class, can be constructed for known tissue types using the gene expression measurements extracted from cancer patients. One challenge of current cancer predictors is that they often have suboptimal performance estimates when integrating molecular datasets generated from different labs. Often, the quality of the data is variable, procured differently, and contains unwanted noise hampering the ability of a predictive model to extract useful information. Data preprocessing methods can be applied in attempts to reduce these systematic variations and harmonize the datasets before they are used to build a machine learning model for resolving tissue of origins. RESULTS: We aimed to investigate the impact of data preprocessing steps-focusing on normalization, batch effect correction, and data scaling-through trial and comparison. Our goal was to improve the cross-study predictions of tissue of origin for common cancers on large-scale RNA-Seq datasets derived from thousands of patients and over a dozen tumor types. The results showed that the choice of data preprocessing operations affected the performance of the associated classifier models constructed for tissue of origin predictions in cancer. CONCLUSION: By using TCGA as a training set and applying data preprocessing methods, we demonstrated that batch effect correction improved performance measured by weighted F1-score in resolving tissue of origin against an independent GTEx test dataset. On the other hand, the use of data preprocessing operations worsened classification performance when the independent test dataset was aggregated from separate studies in ICGC and GEO. Therefore, based on our findings with these publicly available large-scale RNA-Seq datasets, the application of data preprocessing techniques to a machine learning pipeline is not always appropriate.

Data normalization for addressing the challenges in the analysis of single-cell transcriptomic datasets.

BACKGROUND: Normalization is a critical step in the analysis of single-cell RNA-sequencing (scRNA-seq) datasets. Its main goal is to make gene counts comparable within and between cells. To do so, normalization methods must account for technical and biological variability. Numerous normalization methods have been developed addressing different sources of dispersion and making specific assumptions about the count data. MAIN BODY: The selection of a normalization method has a direct impact on downstream analysis, for example differential gene expression and cluster identification. Thus, the objective of this review is to guide the reader in making an informed decision on the most appropriate normalization method to use. To this aim, we first give an overview of the different single cell sequencing platforms and methods commonly used including isolation and library preparation protocols. Next, we discuss the inherent sources of variability of scRNA-seq datasets. We describe the categories of normalization methods and include examples of each. We also delineate imputation and batch-effect correction methods. Furthermore, we describe data-driven metrics commonly used to evaluate the performance of normalization methods. We also discuss common scRNA-seq methods and toolkits used for integrated data analysis. CONCLUSIONS: According to the correction performed, normalization methods can be broadly classified as within and between-sample algorithms. Moreover, with respect to the mathematical model used, normalization methods can further be classified into: global scaling methods, generalized linear models, mixed methods, and machine learning-based methods. Each of these methods depict pros and cons and make different statistical assumptions. However, there is no better performing normalization method. Instead, metrics such as silhouette width, K-nearest neighbor batch-effect test, or Highly Variable Genes are recommended to assess the performance of normalization methods.

CT-guided spatial normalization of nuclear hybrid imaging adapted to enlarged ventricles: Impact on striatal uptake quantification.

INTRODUCTION: Spatial normalization is a prerequisite step for the quantitative analysis of SPECT or PET brain images using volume-of-interest (VOI) template or voxel-based analysis. MRI-guided spatial normalization is the gold standard, but the wide use of PET/CT or SPECT/CT in routine clinical practice makes CT-guided spatial normalization a necessary alternative. Ventricular enlargement is observed with aging, and it hampers the spatial normalization of the lateral ventricles and striatal regions, limiting their analysis. The aim of the present study was to propose a robust spatial normalization method based on CT scans that takes into account features of the aging brain to reduce bias in the CT-guided striatal analysis of SPECT images. METHODS: We propose an enhanced CT-guided spatial normalization pipeline based on SPM12. Performance of the proposed pipeline was assessed on visually normal [123I]-FP-CIT SPECT/CT images. SPM12 default CT-guided spatial normalization was used as reference method. The metrics assessed were the overlap between the spatially normalized lateral ventricles and caudate/putamen VOIs, and the computation of caudate and putamen specific binding ratios (SBR). RESULTS: In total 231 subjects (mean age ± SD = 61.9 ± 15.5 years) were included in the statistical analysis. The mean overlap between the spatially normalized lateral ventricles of subjects and the caudate VOI and the mean SBR of caudate were respectively 38.40 % (± SD = 19.48 %) of the VOI and 1.77 (± 0.79) when performing SPM12 default spatial normalization. The mean overlap decreased to 9.13 % (± SD = 1.41 %, P < 0.001) of the VOI and the SBR of caudate increased to 2.38 (± 0.51, P < 0.0001) when performing the proposed pipeline. Spatially normalized lateral ventricles did not overlap with putamen VOI using either method. The mean putamen SBR value derived from the proposed spatial normalization (2.75 ± 0.54) was not significantly different from that derived from the default SPM12 spatial normalization (2.83 ± 0.52, P > 0.05). CONCLUSION: The automatic CT-guided spatial normalization used herein led to a less biased spatial normalization of SPECT images, hence an improved semi-quantitative analysis. The proposed pipeline could be implemented in clinical routine to perform a more robust SBR computation using hybrid imaging.

PD-1: A critical player and target for immune normalization.

Immune system imbalances contribute to the pathogenesis of several different diseases, and immunotherapy shows great therapeutic efficacy against tumours and infectious diseases with immune-mediated derivations. In recent years, molecules targeting the programmed cell death protein 1 (PD-1) immune checkpoint have attracted much attention, and related signalling pathways have been studied clearly. At present, several inhibitors and antibodies targeting PD-1 have been utilized as anti-tumour therapies. However, increasing evidence indicates that PD-1 blockade also has different degrees of adverse side effects, and these new explorations into the therapeutic safety of PD-1 inhibitors contribute to the emerging concept that immune normalization, rather than immune enhancement, is the ultimate goal of disease treatment. In this review, we summarize recent advancements in PD-1 research with regard to immune normalization and targeted therapy.