Remodeling of the Cardiac Extracellular Matrix Proteome During Chronological and Pathological Aging.

Impaired extracellular matrix (ECM) remodeling is a hallmark of many chronic inflammatory disorders that can lead to cellular dysfunction, aging, and disease progression. The ECM of the aged heart and its effects on cardiac cells during chronological and pathological aging are poorly understood across species. For this purpose, we first used mass spectrometry-based proteomics to quantitatively characterize age-related remodeling of the left ventricle (LV) of mice and humans during chronological and pathological (Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome (HGPS)) aging. Of the approximately 300 ECM and ECM-associated proteins quantified (named as Matrisome), we identified 13 proteins that were increased during aging, including lactadherin (MFGE8), collagen VI α6 (COL6A6), vitronectin (VTN) and immunoglobulin heavy constant mu (IGHM), whereas fibulin-5 (FBLN5) was decreased in most of the data sets analyzed. We show that lactadherin accumulates with age in large cardiac blood vessels and when immobilized, triggers phosphorylation of several phosphosites of GSK3B, MAPK isoforms 1, 3, and 14, and MTOR kinases in aortic endothelial cells (ECs). In addition, immobilized lactadherin increased the expression of pro-inflammatory markers associated with an aging phenotype. These results extend our knowledge of the LV proteome remodeling induced by chronological and pathological aging in different species (mouse and human). The lactadherin-triggered changes in the proteome and phosphoproteome of ECs suggest a straight link between ECM component remodeling and the aging process of ECs, which may provide an additional layer to prevent cardiac aging.

Benefits and limits of decellularization on mass-spectrometry-based extracellular matrix proteome analysis of mouse kidney.

The extracellular matrix (ECM) is composed of collagens, ECM glycoproteins, and proteoglycans (also named core matrisome proteins) that are critical for tissue structure and function, and matrisome-associated proteins that balance the production and degradation of the ECM proteins. The identification and quantification of core matrisome proteins using mass spectrometry is often hindered by their low abundance and their propensity to form macromolecular insoluble structures. In this study, we aimed to investigate the added value of decellularization in identifying and quantifying core matrisome proteins in mouse kidney. The decellularization strategy combined freeze-thaw cycles and sodium dodecyl sulphate treatment. We found that decellularization preserved 95% of the core matrisome proteins detected in non-decellularized kidney and revealed few additional ones. Decellularization also led to an average of 59 times enrichment of 96% of the core matrisome proteins as the result of the successful removal of cellular and matrisome-associated proteins. However, the enrichment varied greatly among core matrisome proteins, resulting in a misrepresentation of the native ECM composition in decellularized kidney. This should be brought to the attention of the matrisome research community, as it highlights the need for caution when interpreting proteomic data obtained from a decellularized organ.

Therapeutic application of decellularized porcine small intestinal submucosa scaffold in conjunctiva reconstruction.

The objective of this study was to investigate the biological feasibility and surgical applicability of decellularized porcine small intestinal submucosa (DSIS) in conjunctiva reconstruction. A total of 52 Balb/c mice were included in the study. We obtained the DSIS by decellularization, evaluated the physical and biological properties of DSIS in vitro, and further evaluated the effect of surgical transplantation of DSIS scaffold in vivo. The histopathology and ultrastructural analysis results showed that the scaffold retained the integrity of the fibrous morphology while removing cells. Biomechanical analysis showed that the elongation at break of the DSIS (239.00 ± 12.51%) were better than that of natural mouse conjunctiva (170.70 ± 9.41%, P < 0.05). Moreover, in vivo experiments confirmed the excellent biocompatibility of the decellularized scaffolds. In the DSIS group, partial epithelialization occurred at day-3 after operation, and the conjunctival injury healed at day-7, which was significantly faster than that in human amniotic membrane (AM) and sham surgery (SHAM) group (P < 0.05). The number and distribution of goblet cells of transplanted DSIS were significantly better than those of the AM and SHAM groups. Consequently, the DSIS scaffold shows excellent biological characteristics and surgical applicability in the mouse conjunctival defect model, and DSIS is expected to be an alternative scaffold for conjunctival reconstruction.

Impact of NaOH based perfusion-decellularization protocol on mechanical resistance of structural bone allografts.

INTRODUCTION: To mitigate the post-operative complication rates associated with massive bone allografts, tissue engineering techniques have been employed to decellularize entire bones through perfusion with a sequence of solvents. Mechanical assessment was performed in order to compare conventional massive bone allografts and perfusion/decellularized massive bone allografts. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Ten porcine femurs were included. Five were decellularized by perfusion. The remaining 5 were left untreated as the "control" group. Biomechanical testing was conducted on each bone, encompassing five different assessments: screw pull-out, 3-points bending, torsion, compression and Vickers indentation. RESULTS: Under the experimental conditions of this study, all five destructive tested variables (maximum force until screw pull-out, maximum elongation until screw pull-out, energy to pull out the screw, fracture resistance in flexion and maximum constrain of compression) were statistically significantly superior in the control group. All seven nondestructive variables (Young's modulus in flexion, Young's modulus in shear stress, Young's modulus in compression, Elastic conventional limit in compression, lengthening to rupture in compression, resilience in compression and Vickers Hardness) showed no significant difference. DISCUSSION: Descriptive statistical results suggest a tendency for the biomechanical characteristics of decellularized bone to decrease compared with the control group. However, statistical inferences demonstrated a slight significant superiority of the control group with destructive mechanical stresses. Nondestructive mechanical tests (within the elastic phase of Young's modulus) were not significantly different.

3D bio scaffold support osteogenic differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells.

The regeneration of osteochondral lesions by tissue engineering techniques is challenging due to the lack of physicochemical characteristics and dual-lineage (osteogenesis and chondrogenesis). A scaffold with better mechanical properties and dual lineage capability is required for the regeneration of osteochondral defects. In this study, a hydrogel prepared from decellularized human umbilical cord tissue was developed and evaluated for osteochondral regeneration. Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) isolated from the umbilical cord were seeded with hydrogel for 28 days, and cell-hydrogel composites were cultured in basal and osteogenic media. Alizarin red staining, quantitative polymerase chain reaction, and immunofluorescent staining were used to confirm that the hydrogel was biocompatible and capable of inducing osteogenic differentiation in umbilical cord-derived MSCs. The findings demonstrate that human MSCs differentiated into an osteogenic lineage following 28 days of cultivation in basal and osteoinductive media. The expression was higher in the cell-hydrogel composites cultured in osteoinductive media, as evidenced by increased levels of messenger RNA and protein expression of osteogenic markers as compared to basal media cultured cell-hydrogel composites. Additionally, calcium deposits were also observed, which provide additional evidence of osteogenic differentiation. The findings demonstrate that the hydrogel is biocompatible with MSCs and possesses osteoinductive capability in vitro. It may be potentially useful for osteochondral regeneration.

Comparison of skeletal muscle decellularization protocols and recellularization with adipose-derived stem cells for tissue engineering.

Decellularization is a novel technique employed for scaffold manufacturing, as a strategy for skeletal muscle (SM) tissue engineering applications. However, poor decellularization efficacy is still a problem for the use of decellularized scaffolds as truly biocompatible biomaterials. For recellularization, adipose-derived stem cells (ASCs) are a good option, due to their immunomodulatory and pro-regenerative capacity, but few studies have described their combination with muscle-decellularized matrices (mDMs). This work aimed to evaluate the efficiency of four multi-step decellularization protocols to produce mDMs and to investigate in vitro biocompatibility with ASCs. Here, we described the different efficacies of muscle decellularization methods, suggesting the need for stricter standardization of the method, considering the large range of applications in SM tissue engineering, which is also a promising platform for preclinical studies with rat disease models using autologous cells.

The trend of allogeneic tendon decellularization: literature review.

Tendon injuries repair is a significant burden for orthopaedic surgeons. Finding a proper graft material to repair tendon is one of the main challenges in orthopaedics, for which the requirement of substitute for tendon repair would be different for each clinical application. Among biological scaffolds, the use of decellularized tendon increasingly represents an interesting approach to treat tendon injuries and several articles have investigated the approaches of tendon decellularization. To understand the outcomes of the the approaches of tendon decellularization on effect of tendon transplantation, a literature review was performed. This review was conducted by searching in Pubmed and Embase and 64 studies were included in this study. The findings revealed that the common approaches to decellularize tendon include chemical, physical, and enzymatic decellularization methods or their combination. With the development of tissue engineering, researchers also put forward new theories such as automatic acellular machine, 3D printing technology to manufacture acellular scaffold.

An overview of the production of tissue extracellular matrix and decellularization process.

Thousands of patients need an organ transplant yearly, while only a tiny percentage have this chance to receive a tissue/organ transplant. Nowadays, decellularized animal tissue is one of the most widely used methods to produce engineered scaffolds for transplantation. Decellularization is defined as physically or chemically removing cellular components from tissues while retaining structural and functional extracellular matrix (ECM) components and creating an ECM-derived scaffold. Then, decellularized scaffolds could be reseeded with different cells to fabricate an autologous graft. Effective decellularization methods preserve ECM structure and bioactivity through the application of the agents and techniques used throughout the process. The most valuable agents for the decellularization process depend on biological properties, cellular density, and the thickness of the desired tissue. ECM-derived scaffolds from various mammalian tissues have been recently used in research and preclinical applications in tissue engineering. Many studies have shown that decellularized ECM-derived scaffolds could be obtained from tissues and organs such as the liver, cartilage, bone, kidney, lung, and skin. This review addresses the significance of ECM in organisms and various decellularization agents utilized to prepare the ECM. Also, we describe the current knowledge of the decellularization of different tissues and their applications.

Biological parameters for quality evaluation of allografts from the Brazilian National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopedics tissue bank.

Bone allografts are clinically used in a variety of surgical procedures, and tissue banks are responsible for harvesting, processing, quality testing, storing, and delivering these materials for transplantation. In tissue banks, the bone is processed for the removal of all organic content, remaining only the tissue structure (scaffold). However, several studies have shown that even after using different processing methods, viable cells, functional proteins, and DNA may still persist in the tissue, which constitute the main causes of graft rejection. Therefore, the objective of this study was to establish techniques and biological parameters for quality validation of allografts. To this end, we propose the use of 3 combined methods such as microscopy, histology, and molecular biology techniques to evaluate the quality of allografts harvested and processed by the Brazilian National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopedics (INTO) tissue bank according to the donation criteria of the Brazilian National Health Surveillance Agency and the Brazilian National Transplant System. Bone fragments from different processing stages showed no viable cells on histology, an intact extracellular matrix on scanning electron microscopy, and gradual reduction in DNA amount. Different techniques were used to demonstrate the quality of allografts produced by the INTO tissue bank and to establish biological parameters for ensuring the safety and quality of these products. Future studies need to be undertaken to assess and validate the efficacy of the decellularization process in larger bone grafts with diverse architectural configurations.

Characterization and biocompatibility evaluation of acellular rat skin scaffolds for skin tissue engineering applications.

Utilization of acellular scaffolds, extracellular matrix (ECM) without cell content, is growing in tissue engineering, due to their high biocompatibility, bioactivity ad mechanical support. Hence, the purpose of this research was to study the characteristics and biocompatibility of decellularized rat skin scaffolds using the osmotic shock method. First, the skin of male Wistar rats was harvested and cut into 1 × 1 cm2 pieces. Then, some of the harvested parts were subjected to the decellularization process by applying osmotic shock. Comparison of control and scaffold samples was conducted in order to assure cell elimination and ECM conservation by means of histological evaluations, quantification of biochemical factors, measurement of DNA amount, and photographing the ultrastructure of the samples by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). In order to evaluate stem cell viability and adhesion to the scaffold, adipose-derived mesenchymal stem cells (AD-MSCs) were seeded on the acellular scaffolds. Subsequently, MTT test and SEM imaging of the scaffolds containing cultured cells were applied. The findings indicated that in the decellularized scaffolds prepared by osmotic shock method, not only the cell content was removed, but also the ECM components and its ultrastructure were preserved. Also, the 99% viability and adhesion of AD-MSCs cultured on the scaffolds indicate the biocompatibility of the decellularized skin scaffold. In conclusion, decellularized rat skin scaffolds are biocompatible and appropriate scaffolds for future investigations of tissue engineering applications.

Matched comparison of decellularized homografts and bovine jugular vein conduits for pulmonary valve replacement in congenital heart disease.

For decades, bovine jugular vein conduits (BJV) and classic cryopreserved homografts have been the two most widely used options for pulmonary valve replacement (PVR) in congenital heart disease. More recently, decellularized pulmonary homografts (DPH) have provided an alternative avenue for PVR. Matched comparison of patients who received DPH for PVR with patients who received bovine jugular vein conduits (BJV) considering patient age group, type of heart defect, and previous procedures. 319 DPH patients were matched to 319 BJV patients; the mean age of BJV patients was 15.3 (SD 9.5) years versus 19.1 (12.4) years in DPH patients (p = 0.001). The mean conduit diameter was 24.5 (3.5) mm for DPH and 20.3 (2.5) mm for BJV (p < 0.001). There was no difference in survival rates between the two groups after 10 years (97.0 vs. 98.1%, p = 0.45). The rate of freedom from endocarditis was significantly lower for BJV patients (87.1 vs. 96.5%, p = 0.006). Freedom from explantation was significantly lower for BJV at 10 years (81.7 vs. 95.5%, p = 0.001) as well as freedom from any significant degeneration at 10 years (39.6 vs. 65.4%, p < 0.001). 140 Patients, matched for age, heart defect type, prior procedures, and conduit sizes of 20-22 mm (± 2 mm), were compared separately; mean age BJV 8.7 (4.9) and DPH 9.5 (7.3) years (p = n.s.). DPH showed 20% higher freedom from explantation and degeneration in this subgroup (p = 0.232). Decellularized pulmonary homografts exhibit superior 10-year results to bovine jugular vein conduits in PVR.

Advantages and challenges in processing and quality control of decellularized heart valves.

More than 1000 donated aortic and pulmonary valves from predominantly European tissue banks were centrally decellularized and delivered to hospitals in Europe and Japan. Here, we report on the processing and quality controls before, during and after the decellularization of these allografts. Our experiences show that all tissue establishments, which provide native cardiovascular allografts for decellularization, meet comparably high-quality standards, regardless of their national origin. A total of 84% of all received allografts could be released as cell-free allografts. By far the most frequent reasons for rejection were non-release of the donor by the tissue establishment or severe contaminations of the native tissue donation. Only in 2% of all cases the specification for freedom from cells was not fulfilled, indicating that decellularization of human heart valves is a safe process with a very low discard ratio. In clinical use, cell-free cardiovascular allografts have been shown to be advantageous over conventional heart valve replacements, at least in young adults. These results open the discussion on the future gold standard and funding of this innovative therapeutic option for heart valve replacement.

Accelerated wound healing with resveratrol-loaded decellularized pericardium in mice model.

One of the key objectives of regenerative medicine is the design of skin tissue engineering scaffolds to promote wound healing. These scaffolds provide a fresh viewpoint on skin injury repair by emulating body tissues in their structure. A suitable platform for cellular processes can be provided by natural scaffolds made from decellularized tissues while retaining the primary components. Resveratrol (RES), which has qualities like angiogenesis, antioxidant, antibacterial, and anti-inflammatory, is also useful in the healing of wounds. In this investigation, RES-loaded decellularized sheep pericardium scaffolds were created and tested on full-thickness wounds in a mouse model. According to the in vivo findings, the groups in which the wound was treated with decellularized pericardium (DP) had better wound healing than the control group and showed more production of angiogenic and anti-inflammatory substances. The secretion of these factors was greater in RES-loaded decellularized pericardium (DP-RES) than in the scaffold without RES, and the macroscopic and histological data supported this. Therefore, the use of decellularization scaffolds with substances like RES for the regeneration of skin wounds can be further researched and evaluated in the preclinical stages.

Decellularized kidney capsule as a three-dimensional scaffold for tissue regeneration.

Tissue regeneration is thought to have considerable promise with the use of scaffolds designed for tissue engineering. Although polymer-based scaffolds for tissue engineering have been used extensively and developed quickly, their ability to mimic the in-vivo milieu, overcome immunogenicity, and have comparable mechanical or biochemical properties has limited their capability for repair. Fortunately, there is a compelling method to get around these challenges thanks to the development of extracellular matrix (ECM) scaffolds made from decellularized tissues. We used ECM decellularized sheep kidney capsule tissue in our research. Using detergents such as Triton-X100 and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), these scaffolds were decellularized. DNA content, histology, mechanical properties analysis, attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (ATR-FTIR), biocompatibility, hemocompatibility and scanning electron microscope (SEM) imaging were measured. The results showed that the three-dimensional (3D) structure of the ECM remained largely intact. The scaffolds mentioned above had several hydrophilic properties. The best biocompatibility and blood compatibility properties were reported in the SDS method of 0.5%. The best decellularization scaffold was introduced with 0.5% SDS. Therefore, it can be proposed as a scaffold that has ECM like natural tissue, for tissue engineering applications.

Development and validation of cryopreserved or freeze-dried decellularized human dermis for transplantation.

For decades, dermal tissue grafts have been used in various regenerative, reconstructive, and augmentative procedures across the body. To eliminate antigenicity and immunogenic response while still preserving the individual components and collective structural integrity of the extracellular matrix (ECM), dermis can be decellularized. Acellular dermal matrix (ADM) products like such are produced to accurately serve diverse clinical purposes. The aim of the present study is to evaluate the efficacy of a novel decellularization protocol of the human dermis, which eliminates residual human genetic material without compromising the biomechanical integrity and collagenous content of the tissue. Moreover, a freeze-drying protocol was validated. The results showed that though our decellularization protocol, human dermis can be decellularized obtaining a biocompatible matrix. The procedure is completely realized in GMP aseptic condition, avoiding tissue terminal sterilization.

Histological evaluation of decellularization of freeze dried and chemically treated indigenously prepared bovine pericardium membrane.

Decellularization is regarded as a xenogenic antigen-reduction technique because it effectively eliminates all cellular and nuclear components while mitigating any negative impact on the composition, biological functionality, and structural integrity of the remaining extracellular matrix. This study aimed to histologically evaluate native, freeze dried and chemically decellularized bovine pericardium membrane. Also, this study focused on preservation of extracellular matrix after decellularization. Bovine pericardium membrane was decellularized by freeze thaw cycle followed by freeze drying and 1% sodium dodecyl sulphate. Unprocessed pericardium was used as control. The effectiveness of Decellularization was assessed based on the reduction of histologically visible nuclei. Decellularization by freeze thaw cycle followed by freeze drying resulted in 17.84% reduction in nuclei content and decellularization by sodium dodecyl sulphate results in 92% reduction in nuclei content compare to control group. Picrosirius red staining for freeze dried group displayed loosely organised, thin collagen bundles that exhibit reddish-yellow birefringence and sodium dodecyl sulfate group revealed dense collagen bundles that are parallelly organised and compact, exhibiting reddish-yellow birefringence and showed good structural integrity. These results suggested that the sodium do decyl sulfate showed optimal decellularization results with better extracellular matrix preservation. It may be a suitable protocol for producing a suitable scaffold for periodontal tissue regeneration.

Biomechanical evaluation of a sheep tracheal scaffold.

Tissue engineering is a set of techniques for producing or reconstructing tissue that primarily aims to restore or improve the function of tissues in the human body. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the mechanical and histological characteristics of decellularized tracheal scaffolds prepared in comparison with fresh trachea for use in tracheal repair. In order to prepare the scaffold, sheep's trachea was prepared and after cleaning the waste tissues, they were decellularized. Then decellularized scaffolds were evaluated histologically and laboratory and numerical study of the nonlinear mechanical behavior of tracheal tissue and scaffold and their comparison. Examining the results of histological evaluations showed that the decellularization of the scaffolds was completely done. These results were confirmed by hematoxylin-eosin staining. Also, the exact hyperelastic properties of tracheal tissue and scaffold were used in biomechanical models, and according to the presented results, the five-term Mooney-Rivlin strain energy density function became a suitable behavioral model for modeling the hyperelastic behavior of trachea and scaffold. In total, the results of this research showed that the scaffolds obtained from decellularization by preserving the main compositions of the desired tissue can be a suitable platform for investigating cell behaviors.

Human Dermal Decellularized ECM Hydrogels as Scaffolds for 3D In Vitro Skin Aging Models.

Biomaterials play an important role in the development of advancing three dimensional (3D) in vitro skin models, providing valuable insights for drug testing and tissue-specific modeling. Commercial materials, such as collagen, fibrin or alginate, have been widely used in skin modeling. However, they do not adequately represent the molecular complexity of skin components. On this regard, the development of novel biomaterials that represent the complexity of tissues is becoming more important in the design of advanced models. In this study, we have obtained aged human decellularized dermal extracellular matrix (dECM) hydrogels extracted from cadaveric human skin and demonstrated their potential as scaffold for advanced skin models. These dECM hydrogels effectively reproduce the complex fibrillar structure of other common scaffolds, exhibiting similar mechanical properties, while preserving the molecular composition of the native dermis. It is worth noting that fibroblasts embedded within human dECM hydrogels exhibit a behavior more representative of natural skin compared to commercial collagen hydrogels, where uncontrolled cell proliferation leads to material shrinkage. The described human dECM hydrogel is able to be used as scaffold for dermal fibroblasts in a skin aging-on-a-chip model. These results demonstrate that dECM hydrogels preserve essential components of the native human dermis making them a suitable option for the development of 3D skin aging models that accurately represent the cellular microenvironment, improving existing in vitro skin models and allowing for more reliable results in dermatopathological studies.

Optimization of Enzymatic and Chemical Decellularization of Native Porcine Heart Valves for the Generation of Decellularized Xenografts.

One of the most important medical interventions for individuals with heart valvular disease is heart valve replacement, which is not without substantial challenges, particularly for pediatric patients. Due to their biological properties and biocompatibility, natural tissue-originated scaffolds derived from human or animal sources are one type of scaffold that is widely used in tissue engineering. However, they are known for their high potential for immunogenicity. Being free of cells and genetic material, decellularized xenografts, consequently, have low immunogenicity and, thus, are expected to be tolerated by the recipient's immune system. The scaffold ultrastructure and ECM composition can be affected by cell removal agents. Therefore, applying an appropriate method that preserves intact the structure of the ECM plays a critical role in the final result. So far, there has not been an effective decellularization technique that preserves the integrity of the heart valve's ultrastructure while securing the least amount of genetic material left. This study demonstrates a new protocol with untraceable cells and residual DNA, thereby maximally reducing any chance of immunogenicity. The mechanical and biochemical properties of the ECM resemble those of native heart valves. Results from this study strongly indicate that different critical factors, such as ionic detergent omission, the substitution of Triton X-100 with Tergitol, and using a lower concentration of trypsin and a higher concentration of DNase and RNase, play a significant role in maintaining intact the ultrastructure and function of the ECM.

Influence of extracellular matrix scaffolds on histological outcomes of regenerative endodontics in experimental animal models: a systematic review.

BACKGROUND: Decellularized extracellular matrix (dECM) from several tissue sources has been proposed as a promising alternative to conventional scaffolds used in regenerative endodontic procedures (REPs). This systematic review aimed to evaluate the histological outcomes of studies utilizing dECM-derived scaffolds for REPs and to analyse the contributing factors that might influence the nature of regenerated tissues. METHODS: The PRISMA 2020 guidelines were used. A search of articles published until April 2024 was conducted in Google Scholar, Scopus, PubMed and Web of Science databases. Additional records were manually searched in major endodontic journals. Original articles including histological results of dECM in REPs and in-vivo studies were included while reviews, in-vitro studies and clinical trials were excluded. The quality assessment of the included studies was analysed using the ARRIVE guidelines. Risk of Bias assessment was done using the (SYRCLE) risk of bias tool. RESULTS: Out of the 387 studies obtained, 17 studies were included for analysis. In most studies, when used as scaffolds with or without exogenous cells, dECM showed the potential to enhance angiogenesis, dentinogenesis and to regenerate pulp-like and dentin-like tissues. However, the included studies showed heterogeneity of decellularization methods, animal models, scaffold source, form and delivery, as well as high risk of bias and average quality of evidence. DISCUSSION: Decellularized ECM-derived scaffolds could offer a potential off-the-shelf scaffold for dentin-pulp regeneration in REPs. However, due to the methodological heterogeneity and the average quality of the studies included in this review, the overall effectiveness of decellularized ECM-derived scaffolds is still unclear. More standardized preclinical research is needed as well as well-constructed clinical trials to prove the efficacy of these scaffolds for clinical translation. OTHER: The protocol was registered in PROSPERO database #CRD42023433026. This review was funded by the Science, Technology and Innovation Funding Authority (STDF) under grant number (44426).