[First description of Schilder's disease : Paul Ferdinand Schilder and his struggle for the delimitation of a new entity]. / Die Erstbeschreibung der Schilder-Krankheit : Paul Ferdinand Schilder und sein Ringen um die Abgrenzung einer neuen Entität.

Paul Ferdinand Schilder was born in Vienna in 1886 and died in New York in 1940. He is nowadays remembered predominantly for his contributions to modern psychiatry and psychotherapy; however, he was also a neurologist and neuroscientist and in particular in his early years, he researched and published on neuropathological topics. This paper focuses on his scientific work during his years in Middle Germany (1909-1914), where he worked with Gabriel Anton in Halle and Paul Flechsig in Leipzig. During those years, he laid the foundations for his definition, clinical classification and differentiation of encephalitis periaxialis diffusa. Today, this inflammatory brain disease is known as Schilder's disease and is of some importance as a rare differential diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (MS), especially in children. Schilder's reflections and findings were based on his scrupulous and detailed analysis of only a few medical histories, which also comprised histological neuropathological examinations, as well as on his extensive and critical review of the relevant literature of the time. His aim was to differentiate encephalitis periaxialis diffusa from brain tumors, MS and Heubner's diffuse sclerosis. Schilder's scientific achievement, made in relatively young years, is still impressive even to the present day due do its thoroughness and accuracy as well as the enormous workload and ambition it required. Even though ambitious, Schilder was always prepared to critically review his own ideas.

Ludwig Merzbacher (1875-1942): the man behind the disease.

Ludwig Merzbacher (1875-1942) is widely known for his seminal work on the pathology of the dysmyelinating CNS disease named for the clinician Friedrich Pelizaeus and himself. Yet his training, his scientific achievements and his list of publications suggest a scientist with broad interests in neuropathology, neuroscience, neurology and psychiatry. Among several studies in experimental and clinical neuropathology, Merzbacher's work on scavenger cells is the most outstanding. While working in Alois Alzheimer's laboratory in Munich in 1906/1907, Ludwig Merzbacher analyzed in great detail the reaction patterns of these cells, which are nowadays known as reactive microglia, and already attempted to elucidate their function in brain pathology.

The nature of multiple sclerosis.

Multiple sclerosis (MS) has recently been classified according to its clinical course. Despite relapses and remissions, its course is invariably progressive, and the observed progression from the remitting-relapsing to the secondary progressive form represents the accumulation of permanent damage to the nervous system. Discussions of the nomenclatural position of Schilder's, Marburg's, and Baló's diseases, ignore the fact that the unique, pathognomonic, sharp-edged plaque of MS, is also the pathologic end-result in the three variants. Devic's disease or neuromyelitis optica (NMO) is quite different and with some exceptions, is a particular form of disseminated encephalomyelitis (DEM). There is no evidence that the 'oriental form of MS' is anything but NMO. The suggestion that MS and DEM are variants of the same condition is contradicted by the fact that the pathological characteristics of the two are quite different. While it is probable that the two share aspects of pathogenesis, the patients differ because of their genetic endowment. This was dramatically demonstrated in a group of Japanese patients who died after anti-rabies vaccination and were found to have the typical sharp-edged lesions of MS. The genetic determinant was also crucial in the marmoset in which EAE uniquely resulted in a chronic relapsing-remitting (RR) disease characterized by the classic sharp-edged lesions of MS. The question 'ADEM: distinct disease or part of the MS spectrum?' can be answered with a resounding no. A new classification is proposed separating the different forms of MS from the various types of DEM.