Assessment of energy expenditure: are calories measured differently for different diets?

ABSTRACT

PURPOSE OF REVIEW The prevalence and burden of obesity has reached alarming levels. The assessment of human energy expenditure enables the identification of obesity-prone and obesity-resistant individuals and helps to explain the short and long-term success of weight loss treatments. In this review, we describe the state-of-the-art methods used in the assessment of human energy expenditure and the impact of dietary intake on the interpretation of the data. RECENT FINDINGS: The reference techniques to assess energy expenditure in humans have not significantly changed during the last century. Today, indirect calorimetry, either using a metabolic chamber or a metabolic cart, is the favored method to assess human energy expenditure and is the only method enabling the assessment of macronutrient oxidation. The doubly labeled water method however provides accurate assessment of human energy expenditure under free living conditions. SUMMARY: Although energy expenditure and macronutrient oxidation can be assessed by simple calculations from oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide production, these calculations can provide erroneous results or require corrections and/or more complex interpretation when several biochemical pathways are simultaneously engaged. Such physiological mechanisms are often elicited by dietary interventions including, among other, gluconeogenesis, lipogenesis, ketogenesis, alcohol oxidation and under or overfeeding.