Intraoperative Frozen Section Biopsy of Uterine Smooth Muscle Tumors: A Clinicopathologic Analysis of 112 Cases With Emphasis on Potential Diagnostic Pitfalls.

ABSTRACT

Frozen sections of uterine smooth muscle tumors are infrequently required, and related diagnostic difficulties are seldom discussed. We analyzed the clinicopathologic features of 112 frozen sections of uterine smooth muscle tumors and determined the accuracy, reasons for deferrals, and causes of interpretational errors. Most patients (median age, 45 y) presented with pelvic mass symptoms (53%). The main reasons for a frozen section examination were an abnormal gross appearance including loss of the usual whorled pattern of leiomyoma (36 cases, 32.1%), and intraoperative discovery of an abnormal growth pattern and extrauterine extension of a uterine tumor (28 cases, 25%). There were 9 leiomyosarcomas and 103 leiomyomas, including 18 benign histologic variants. An accurate diagnosis of malignancy was achieved in all leiomyosarcomas, with the exception of a myxoid leiomyosarcoma. In 99 cases (88%), the frozen section diagnosis concurred with the permanent section diagnosis (false positives, 0.9%; false negatives, 0%). Misinterpretation of stromal hyalinization as tumor cell necrosis in a leiomyoma with amianthoid-like fibers was a major discrepancy. Two minor discrepancies did not lead to a change in management. The diagnosis was deferred in 10 cases (8.9%) because of stromal alterations, unusual cellular morphology, uncertain type of necrosis, and abnormal growth patterns. Thus, although various stromal and cellular alterations can cause diagnostic uncertainty, leading to deferrals, frozen section diagnosis of uterine smooth muscle tumors has a high accuracy rate. While a definitive frozen section diagnosis of malignancy may be made when there is unequivocal atypia, indisputable mitotic figures, and tumor cell necrosis, it is important to remember that nonmyogenic mesenchymal tumors may also mimic uterine smooth muscle tumors. In a frozen section setting, it would be sufficient to issue a diagnosis of "malignant mesenchymal tumor." For tumors that do not meet the criteria for malignancy, issuing a frozen section diagnosis of "atypical mesenchymal tumor and defer the histologic subtyping to the permanent sections" is appropriate.