The role of chest X-ray in the diagnosis of neonatal respiratory distress syndrome: a systematic review concerning low-resource birth scenarios.

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND: Access to diagnostic tools like chest radiography (CXR) is challenging in resource-limited areas. Despite reduced reliance on CXR due to the need for quick clinical decisions, its usage remains prevalent in the approach to neonatal respiratory distress syndrome (NRDS). OBJECTIVES: To assess CXR's role in diagnosing and grading NRDS severity compared to current clinical features and laboratory standards. METHODS: A review of studies with NRDS diagnostic criteria was conducted across six databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, BVS, Scopus-Elsevier, Web of Science, Cochrane) up to 3 March 2023. Independent reviewers selected studies, with discrepancies resolved by a senior reviewer. Data were organised into descriptive tables to highlight the use of CXR and clinical indicators of NRDS. RESULTS: Out of 1,686 studies screened, 23 were selected, involving a total of 2,245 newborns. All selected studies used CXR to diagnose NRDS, and 21 (91%) applied it to assess disease severity. While seven reports (30%) indicated that CXR is irreplaceable by other diagnostic tools for NRDS diagnosis, 10 studies (43%) found that alternative methods surpassed CXR in several respects, such as severity assessment, monitoring progress, predicting the need for surfactant therapy, foreseeing Continuous Positive Airway Pressure failure, anticipating intubation requirements, and aiding in differential diagnosis. CONCLUSION: CXR remains an important diagnostic tool for NRDS. Despite its continued use in scientific reports, the findings suggest that the study's outcomes may not fully reflect the current global clinical practices, especially in low-resource settings where the early NRDS approach remains a challenge for neonatal survival.Trial registration PROSPERO number CRD42022336480.

Main findings: Access to diagnostic tools like chest radiography is challenging in resource-limited areas, yet its usage persists in the management of neonatal respiratory distress syndrome despite a decreased dependency due to the imperative for swift clinical decisions.Added knowledge Despite its continued significance in scientific literature, the usage of chest radiography as a diagnostic tool for neonatal respiratory distress syndrome may not entirely reflect current global clinical practices, particularly in low-resource settings where early management of neonatal respiratory distress syndrome poses a challenge for neonatal survival.Global health impact for policy and action The results underscore the necessity of guidelines for the utilisation of chest radiography to minimise unnecessary ionising radiation exposure while ensuring timely access to critical clinical information for appropriate newborn care.