Wastewater treatment in lagoons: A systematic review and a meta-analysis.

ABSTRACT

This study has carried out a systematic review of 36 scientific papers (reporting 63 case studies) published in the last 15 years about the treatment of industrial, agri-food and municipal wastewater in lagoons. A concentration of studies from a few countries (Italy, Algeria and Iran) and about municipal wastewater (70% of papers) was revealed by the bibliographic analysis. Aeration was supplied in more than 50% of case studies; the storage capacity of lagoons (adopted as a measure of size) was extremely variable (over seven orders of magnitude), while their depth was generally lower than a few metres. The efficiency of lagoon treatments at removing COD was in a wide range (25-98%). Very few studies analysed the energy intensity of treatments in lagoons. The meta-analysis applied to a further selection of 10 papers with 29 case studies revealed significant differences in pH and dissolved oxygen concentration, due to aeration or type of treated wastewater. Treatment efficiency was higher in aerated lagoons compared to non-aerated systems, and did not depend on the type of treated wastewater. Based on the analysis of the reviewed papers, an urgent research need on this topic arises, mainly due to the oldness of most analysed studies. Practical suggestions are given to optimise the depuration performances of lagoons (i) application of intermittent and night aeration; (ii) reduced air flow rates; (iii) adaptation of microbial biomass to high contents of inhibiting compounds in wastewater; (iv) construction of baffles to keep the planned hydraulic retention time avoiding short-circuit; (v) integration of lagoons with other treatments (e.g., constructed wetlands); (vi) ferti-irrigation of crops with lagoon effluents rather than disposal into water bodies.