Safety effects of bypass lanes at unsignalized three-leg junctions.

ABSTRACT

Bypass lanes are a low-cost measure to increase capacity at unsignalized T-junctions without left-turn lanes that allow through-traffic to pass left-turning vehicles on the right. There is very limited knowledge about the safety effects of bypass lanes. We found six previous studies that could be summarized by means of meta-analysis, and the results show an average accident reduction of 10 percent. However, the results from previous studies are inconsistent and may be biased. Therefore, the present study has estimated safety effects of by-pass lanes in Norway, based on a sample of 2,227 T-junctions (incl. 94 with bypass-lanes) for which relevant data was available for a period of up to 10 years. We developed accident prediction models and conducted before-after analyses. The accident prediction models show that junctions with bypass lanes have 82 percent more accidents than junctions without bypass lanes, when controlling for endogeneity. Endogeneity occurs when the implementation of a measure is conditional on the frequency of crashes, as has been the case with bypass lanes. The before-after analysis shows that average accident numbers decrease after the installation of bypass lanes. However, when controlling for regression-to-the-mean (RTM), average accident numbers increase. RTM means that accident numbers would have been likely to decrease even without any measure because they had been exceptionally high in the before period. The control for potential biases in our study is likely to contribute to the discrepancy between results from our study and previous studies, most of which have not controlled for the same potential biases. We conclude therefore that bypass lanes, although favorable for capacity, are likely to be unfavorable for safety when compared to other unsignalized T-junctions without left-turn lanes. Unfavorable safety effects may partly be due to site specific conditions, such as road alignment and sight conditions, that contribute to rear-end collision risk or inappropriate driver behavior. However, this does not necessarily mean that bypass lanes never should be used. For example, at junctions where a bypass lane may solve capacity problems, and where site-specific conditions are favorable, bypass lanes may still be an acceptable solution.