Fingerprints of Chalcogen Bonding Revealed Through 77Se-NMR.

77Se-NMR is used to characterise several chalcogen bonded complexes of derivatives of the organoselenium drug ebselen, exploring a range of electron demand. NMR titration experiments support the intuitive understanding that chalcogen bond donors bearing more electron withdrawing substituents give rise stronger chalcogen bonds. The chemical shift of the selenium nucleus is also shown to move upfield as it participates in a chalcogen bond. Solid-state NMR is used to explore chalcogen bonding in co-crystals. Due to the lack of molecular reorientation on the NMR timescale in the solid state, the shape of the chemical shift tensor can be determined using this technique. A range of co-crystals are shown to have extremely large chemical shift anisotropy, which suggests a strongly anisotropic electron density distribution around the selenium atom. A single crystal NMR experiment was conducted using one of the co-crystals, affording the absolute orientation of the chemical shift tensor within the crystal. This showed that the selenium nucleus is strongly shielded in the direction of the chalcogen bond (due to the approach of the lone pair of the Lewis base), and strongly deshielded in the perpendicular direction. The orientation of the deshielded axis is consistent with the presence of a second σ-hole which is not participating in a chalcogen bond, showing the profound effect of electron density anisotropy on the chemical shift.

--Steric Activation in the Nazarov Cyclization of Fully Substituted Divinyl Ketones.

Fully substituted divinyl ketones (fsDVKs) have long been regarded as resistant to Nazarov cyclization (NC) unless they contain strategically positioned electronically-activating substituents. Here, however, we show that fsDVKs bearing only electronically neutral alkyl or aryl groups actually undergo facile NC due to steric-crowding in the pentadienyl cation intermediate, which raises its energy and reduces the barrier height to cyclization. Strongly ionizing and suitably bulky acid moieties further increase the energy of this intermediate cation, favoring cyclization. These features enable NCs of fsDVKs to be employed in the ready construction of multiple contiguous all-carbon quaternary stereocenters under mild conditions, in the absence  of electronically activating groups.

Chemical and Antiplasmodial Investigations on Eremophila-Derived Alkaloids and Semisynthetic Ether Analogues.

Microthecaline A (1), the known antiplasmodial quinoline serrulatane alkaloid from the roots of Eremophila microtheca F. Muell. ex Benth. (Scrophulariaceae), was targeted for isolation and subsequent use in the generation of a semisynthetic ether library. A large-scale extraction and isolation yielded the previously undescribed quinoline serrulatane microthecaline B (2), along with crystalline 1 that enabled the first X-ray crystallographic analysis to be undertaken on this rare alkaloid structure class. The X-ray diffraction analysis of 1 supported the absolute configuration assignment of microthecaline A, which was originally assigned by ECD data analysis. Microthecaline A (1) was converted into 10 new semisynthetic ether derivatives (3-12) using a diverse series of commercially available alkyl halides. Chemical structures of the new serrulatane alkaloid and semisynthetic ether analogues were assigned by spectroscopic and spectrometric analyses. Antiplasmodial evaluations of 1-12 showed that the semisynthetic derivative 5 elicited the most potent activity with an IC50 value of 7.2 µM against Plasmodium falciparum 3D7 (drug-sensitive) strain.

Belgian Patients of the European Registry for Hidradenitis Suppurativa (ERHS-Be): Data, Scores, and Phenotypes since 2015.

INTRODUCTION: Hidradenitis suppurativa (HS) is a chronic inflammatory skin disease, characterized by painful and recurrent lesions in apocrine gland-bearing skin areas. It is a heterogeneous disease, which makes assessment and data collection difficult. Questionnaires with detailed items, such as the Belgian European Registry for Hidradenitis Suppurativa (ERHS-Be), are useful to study HS and its associated comorbidities. The aim of this registry was to uncover new factors associated with HS and understand HS patients' clinical profiles and efficacy of treatments. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The ERHS-Be registry is based on questionnaires, with sections for sociodemographic data, medical and HS history, clinical examination, and treatment plan. It allows identification of different clinical phenotypes and automatic calculation of severity scores. RESULTS: At present, 606 patients are included in the ERHS-Be (67% women, 33% men). The mean age at the first visit is 38.5 years. Tobacco use is present in 72.6% of patients. A family history of HS is noted in 42% of patients. Comorbidities are documented in this cohort: depression is present in 43.8% of patients, arthritis in 27.8%, obesity in 31.5%, hypertension in 10.6%, diabetes mellitus in 6.4%, and dyslipidemia in 12.4%. Moreover, 7.7% of patients suffer from IBD and 27.4% have a pilonidal sinus. History of severe acne is found in 32.1% of patients and psoriasis in 9.3%. Thirteen percent of women in our cohort suffer from polycystic ovarian syndrome. Severity of disease is quantified in 533 patients: for instance, Hurley I, II, and III scores proportions are, respectively, 32.3%, 52.7%, and 15%, while the mean IHS4 score is 5.2. This registry also enables determination of relative phenotype proportions in our cohort, according to different classifications. CONCLUSION: The ERHS-Be questionnaires allow systematic and larger data collection, including detailed comorbidities, phenotypes, and severity of disease. Analysis of this large database will contribute to a better understanding and management of HS, at a time where new therapeutic options are becoming available.

Factors Associated with Severe Hidradenitis Suppurativa, Using Hurley Staging and Metascore.

INTRODUCTION: Hidradenitis suppurativa (HS) is a chronic inflammatory skin disease for which certain risk factors are well known: obesity and smoking (in particular). However, the factors associated with more severe conditions, and therefore potential aggravators of the disease, remain a matter of debate. Our study aims to determine the clinical factors associated with severe HS using several severity scores. METHODS: The data were obtained via the ERHS questionnaire from patients exclusively recruited at Erasme Hospital in Brussels. The severity of HS was firstly estimated by the Hurley score, and secondly by a metascore, a system combining the iHS4, HS-PGA, SAHS, and DLQI. Univariable and multivariable analyses were performed. RESULTS: Six hundred and forty-seven patients were included in the Hurley analysis, and 456 patients in the metascore analysis. In multivariable analysis, men have a more severe metascore than women (odds ratio [OR] = 1.89, p = 0.022), smoking was associated with a more severe disease according to metascore, especially in mild cases (OR = 0.76, p = 0.043), and an elevated body mass index was associated with having Hurley stage III disease compared to Hurley I or II disease (OR = 1.09, p = 0.001). A significant association is also shown between blood pressure and Hurley stage (OR = 0.97, p = 0.025). Self-reports of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs aggravating the disease is also a factor associated with greater severity according to the metascore (OR = 0.12, p = 0.008). Finally, several locations of HS lesions were associated with greater severity, in particular the armpits according to the metascore (OR = 0.29, p < 0.001), and the perianal area according to the Hurley score (OR = 0.15, p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: HS seems to be more severe in men; smoking seems to aggravate mild cases of HS, while increased body mass index plays a major role in the transition from Hurley II to Hurley III.

Semisynthesis and Cytotoxic Evaluation of an Ether Analogue Library Based on a Polyhalogenated Diphenyl Ether Scaffold Isolated from a Lamellodysidea Sponge.

The known oxygenated polyhalogenated diphenyl ether, 2-(2',4'-dibromophenoxy)-3,5-dibromophenol (1), with previously reported activity in multiple cytotoxicity assays was isolated from the sponge Lamellodysidea sp. and proved to be an amenable scaffold for semisynthetic library generation. The phenol group of 1 was targeted to generate 12 ether analogues in low-to-excellent yields, and the new library was fully characterized by NMR, UV, and MS analyses. The chemical structures for 2, 8, and 9 were additionally determined via single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis. All natural and semisynthetic compounds were evaluated for their ability to inhibit the growth of DU145, LNCaP, MCF-7, and MDA-MB-231 cancer cell lines. Compound 3 was shown to have near-equivalent activity compared to scaffold 1 in two in vitro assays, and the activity of the compounds with an additional benzyl ring appeared to be reliant on the presence and position of additional halogens.

Effect of breed, obturator type and surgical experience on tenoscopic portal creation into the digital flexor tendon sheath in horses.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the influence of breed (cob [CB] and non-cob [NC]), obturator type and surgical experience on the number of attempts, time taken and iatrogenic damage (ID) created when entering the digital flexor tendon sheath (DFTS) tenoscopically. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective experimental cadaveric study. ANIMALS: A total of 104 cadaver limbs. METHODS: An equal number of randomly selected CB and NC limbs were operated using a conical obturator (OB) or a switching stick (SS) by one boarded (BS) and one resident surgeon (RS). Skin measurements, number of attempts and time taken to enter the DFTS were recorded. The DFTS was endoscopically examined and then dissected to record ID and cumulative ID calculated. RESULTS: Mean CB skin thickness (8.4 mm) was nearly twice that of NC limbs (4.5 mm) (p < .001). Mean DFTS entry took longer in CB limbs (133 s) compared to NC limbs (112 s) (p = .02). BS mean entry time in CB limbs was 115 s compared to 46 s in NC limbs (p < .001). Cumulative ID was greater in CB limbs (25 of 52 limbs with ID) compared to NC limbs (14 of 52 limbs with ID) (p = .04). No difference was noted between obturators. Surgical experience reduced attempts and time entering the DFTS. CONCLUSION: Surgeons take longer to enter DFTS in CB limbs and more cumulative ID is created, regardless of obturator type used. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Skin thickness is a major determinant of time taken to enter the DFTS and increases the risk of ID. Awareness of the challenges in CB limbs is important.

Hoof wall masses removal in 30 standing sedated horses: Surgical technique, postoperative complications and long-term outcome.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the surgical technique for removal of hoof wall masses in horses under standing sedation (SS) and local anesthesia (LA), and to report complications and long-term outcome following surgery. STUDY DESIGN: Observational retrospective study. ANIMALS: Client-owned horses (n = 30). METHODS: Horses undergoing keratoma removal under SS and LA in a single equine hospital between August 2016 and July 2023 were included in the study. Signalment, affected foot, history of lameness and/or foot abscesses, degree of lameness on admission, imaging findings (radiography and magnetic resonance imaging [MRI] when available), location of the mass, surgical technique, remedial farriery, postoperative care, complications and outcome were recorded. Long-term follow-up information was obtained by telephone questionnaire. RESULTS: A total of 30 horses met the inclusion criteria. Duration of lameness ranged from 1 to 289 days (mean 90 days). The degree of lameness varied from absent to grade 4/5 (AAEP) (mean grade 3/5). All horses underwent preoperative radiographic examination and 14/30 underwent MRI. All horses underwent partial hoof wall resection. The surgery was performed safely in all cases. Postoperative complications included marked lameness in the early postoperative period in 3/30 horses and exuberant granulation tissue formation in 2/30 horses. Long-term (>6 months) follow-up information was available for 28 horses, and 26/28 horses returned to previous levels of exercise. Recurrence was suspected in 1/30 horses. CONCLUSIONS: The complication rate was lower than previously reported for keratoma removal under general anesthesia (GA). CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Removal of hoof wall masses under SS and LA can be considered as an alternative to removal under GA.

Electronic and Steric Effects on the Reactivity of Seleniranium Ions with Alkenes in the Gas Phase.

Gas phase ion-molecule reactions between seleniranium ions, R-c-SeCH2CH2+, and cis-cyclooctene were used to probe electronic and steric effects of substituents on kinetics and branching ratios. The second-order rate coefficients increased in the order p-OMeC6H4 < C6H5 < p-BrC6H4 < p-CF3C6H4 < m-NO2C6H4, giving a Hammett plot with R2 = 0.98 and ρ = +1.66. The two main pathways include direct transfer of the selenium moiety to the incoming alkene (π-ligand exchange) and the less favored ring-opening by attack at an iranium carbon to give a cis-bicyclic selenonium ion as supported by density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Branching ratios of each pathway indicated that electron-withdrawing groups directed more attack at carbon than selenium in agreement with previous solution-phase results. Increased steric bulk on selenium was investigated by changing the R group from a methyl to t-butyl, which not only shut down π-ligand exchange but also significantly reduced the overall reactivity. Finally, the reactivity of the iranium ion derived from Se-methylselenocysteine was investigated and shown to react faster and favor π-ligand exchange as the leaving group was changed from ethene to acrylic acid.

Protection of Boronic Acids Using a Tridentate Aminophenol ONO Ligand for Selective Suzuki-Miyaura Coupling.

Boronic acid protecting group chemistry powerfully enhances the versatility of Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling. Prominent examples include trifluoroborate salts, N-methyliminodiacetic acid (MIDA) boronates, and 1,8-diaminonaphthalene boronamides. In this work, we present a bis(2-hydroxybenzyl)methylamine (BOMA) ligand that forms tridentate complexes with boronic acids much like the MIDA ligand but the deprotection is facilitated by organic acids. The BOMA boronates showed considerable stability in both aqueous base and acid, and a variety of chemoselective reactions were performed on these boronates, including selective Suzuki-Miyaura coupling, palladium-catalyzed borylation, ester hydrolysis, alkylation, lithiation-borylation, and oxidative hydroxydeboronation.

Copper(II) Complexes of 2,2'-Bisdipyrrins: Synthesis, Characterization, Cell Uptake, and Radiolabeling with Copper-64.

Complexes prepared with positron-emitting copper-64 are of interest as imaging agents for positron emission tomography (PET). This work investigates the potential of using acyclic tetrapyrrolic 2,2'-bisdipyrrins as ligands to prepare charge-neutral, lipophilic, cell-permeable, redox active complexes with positron-emitting copper-64. The synthesis and characterization of a series of tetrapyrrolic 2,2'-bisdipyrrin copper(II) complexes are reported. Four 2,2'-bisdipyrrin copper(II) complexes were prepared with different functional groups in the meso-position of the ligands. Two of the new copper(II) complexes, one palladium(II) complex, and one nickel(II) complex were characterized by X-ray crystallography, which demonstrated that the copper(II) is in a distorted square planar environment. An investigation of the electrochemical properties of the complexes by cyclic voltammetry revealed that the complexes undergo multiple quasi-reversible processes. A comparison of the cyclic voltammetry of the copper complexes with their palladium(II) analogues suggests that these redox processes are ligand-based and not metal-based. The copper(II) complexes are cell-permeable in A431 mammalian cells and are nontoxic at concentrations of 50 µM. The ligands can be radiolabeled with copper-64 at room temperature.

A cis-ß-iron(III) SALPN catalyst for hydrogen atom transfer reductions and olefin cross couplings.

An inexpensive Fe(III) SALPN catalyst for MHAT reactions such as reductions of α,ß-unsaturated carbonyl compounds and olefin cross couplings is reported. The majority of these reactions proceeded in good yields and high stereoselectivities with low catalyst loadings at room temperature.

Pyrimidine-morpholine hybrids as potent druggable therapeutics for Alzheimer's disease: Synthesis, biochemical and in silico analyses.

The identification of effective and druggable cholinesterase inhibitors to treat progressive neurodegenerative Alzheimer's disorder remains a continuous drug discovery hunt. In this perspective, the present study investigates the design and discovery of pyrimidine-morpholine hybrids (5a-l) as potent cholinesterase inhibitors. Palladium-catalyzed Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling reaction was employed to introduce the structural diversity on the pyrimidine heterocyclic core. A range of commercially available boronic acids was successfully coupled showing a high functional group tolerance. In vitro cholinesterase inhibitory potential using Ellman's method revealed significantly strong potency. Compound 5h bearing a meta-tolyl substituent at 2-position of pyrimidine ring emerged as a lead candidate against AChE with an inhibitory potency of 0.43 ± 0.42 µM, ∼38-fold stronger value than neostigmine (IC50 = 16.3 ± 1.12 µM). Compound 5h also showed the lead inhibition against BuChE with an IC50 value of 2.5 ± 0.04 µM. The kinetics analysis of 5h revealed the non-competitive mode of inhibition against AChE whereas computational modelling results of potent leads depicted diverse contacts with the binding site amino acid residues. Molecular dynamics simulations revealed the stability of biomolecular system, while, ADME analysis demonstrated druglikeness behaviour of potent compounds. Overall, the investigated pyrimidine-morpholine scaffold presented a remarkable potential to be developed as efficacious anti-Alzheimer's drugs.

Treatment of Acne with Isotretinoin Should Be Avoided in Patients with Hidradenitis Suppurativa "Conglobata Phenotype".

BACKGROUND: Acne conglobata (AC) and nodulocystic acne have long been confused clinically, despite the presentation and the response to treatment being different. AC and hidradenitis suppurativa (HS) resemble each other; a subtype of HS called "conglobata phenotype" has recently been reported in a large Dutch cohort. Acne vulgaris and HS are often associated. Isotretinoin is typically ineffective in treating HS and may even aggravate it, but it is often indispensable in treating acne vulgaris. OBJECTIVE: The aim of the study was to assess whether isotretinoin may be used safely in adults with both HS and acne vulgaris and when it might be contraindicated. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Belgian HS patients from the European Registry for Hidradenitis Suppurativa Registry (ERHS) reporting a history of severe acne of the face and/or the back, and who have ever used isotretinoin for their acne, were all selected. Patients whose acne worsened on isotretinoin were compared to patients whose acne did not worsen (improvement or no change). RESULTS: Among the 82 selected patients, 10 (12.2%) report that their acne was aggravated while taking isotretinoin, while 72 (87.8%) report that their acne was not aggravated on isotretinoin. Of the 10 HS patients whose acne worsened with isotretinoin, 9 (90%) were men (p = 0.04) and 8 (80%) were HS "conglobata phenotype" (p < 0.001). In contrast, 47 (65.3%) of the 72 patients whose acne did not worsen on isotretinoin belonged to the HS "regular phenotype" (p = 0.01). On multivariate analysis, the item most strongly associated with poor response to isotretinoin was the HS "conglobata phenotype," followed by body mass index (BMI) (worse response to isotretinoin if BMI >25 kg/m2). Additionally, of 26 patients who received isotretinoin while their HS had already started, only 6 (23.1%) reported isotretinoin effectiveness on their HS. CONCLUSION: Subject to confirmation by larger studies, our study suggests that isotretinoin should be avoided in the treatment of acne in HS patients with the HS "conglobata phenotype," as it may worsen the acne, likewise being male or having a BMI above 25 seems to increase this risk of a bad therapeutic outcome. Patients with an HS "regular phenotype" appear to be at a reduced risk of isotretinoin treatment worsening their acne.

Synthesis and characterisation of new antimalarial fluorinated triazolopyrazine compounds.

Nine new fluorinated analogues were synthesised by late-stage functionalisation using Diversinate™ chemistry on the Open Source Malaria (OSM) triazolopyrazine scaffold (Series 4). The structures of all analogues were fully characterised by NMR, UV and MS data analysis; three triazolopyrazines were confirmed by X-ray crystal structure analysis. The inhibitory activity of all compounds against the growth of the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum (3D7 and Dd2 strains) and the cytotoxicity against a human embryonic kidney (HEK293) cell line were tested. Some of the compounds demonstrated moderate antimalarial activity with IC50 values ranging from 0.2 to >80 µM; none of the compounds displayed any cytotoxicity against HEK293 cells at 80 µM. Antimalarial activity was significantly reduced when C-8 of the triazolopyrazine scaffold was substituted with CF3 and CF2H moieties, whereas incorporation of a CF2Me group at the same position completely abolished antiplasmodial effects.

Inflammation as a chemoprevention target in asbestos-induced malignant mesothelioma.

Malignant mesothelioma (MM) is an incurable cancer of the serosal lining that is often caused by exposure to asbestos. Therefore, novel agents for the prevention and treatment of this disease are urgently needed. Asbestos induces the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines such as IL-1ß and IL-6, which play a role in MM development. IL-6 is a component of the JAK-STAT3 pathway that contributes to inflammation-associated tumorigenesis. Glycoprotein 130 (gp130), the signal transducer of this signaling axis, is an attractive drug target because of its role in promoting neoplasia via the activation of downstream STAT3 signaling. The anticancer drug, SC144, inhibits the interaction of gp130 with the IL-6 receptor (IL6R), effectively blunting signaling from this inflammatory axis. To test whether the inflammation-related release of IL-6 plays a role in the formation of MM, we evaluated the ability of SC144 to inhibit asbestos-induced carcinogenesis in a mouse model. The ability of sulindac and anakinra, an IL6R antagonist/positive control, to inhibit MM formation in this model was tested in parallel. Asbestos-exposed Nf2+/-;Cdkn2a+/- mice treated with SC144, sulindac or anakinra showed significantly prolonged survival compared to asbestos-exposed vehicle-treated mice. STAT3 activity was markedly decreased in MM specimens from SC144-treated mice. Furthermore, SC144 inhibited STAT3 activation by IL-6 in cultured normal mesothelial cells, and in vitro treatment of MM cells with SC144 markedly decreased the expression of STAT3 target genes. The emerging availability of newer, more potent SC144 analogs showing improved pharmacokinetic properties holds promise for future trials, benefitting individuals at high risk of this disease.

Synthesis of the Alkylsulfonate Metabolites Cysteinolic Acid, 3-Amino-2-hydroxypropanesulfonate, and 2,3-Dihydroxypropanesulfonate.

Chiral hydroxy- and aminohydroxysulfonic acids are widespread in the marine and terrestrial environment. Here we report simple methods for the synthesis of d- and l-cysteinolic acid (from (Boc-d-Cys-OH)2 and (Boc-l-Cys-OH)2, respectively), R- and S-3-amino-2-hydroxypropanesulfonate (from S- and R-epichlorohydrin, respectively), and R- and S-2,3-dihydroxypropanesulfonate (from S- and R-epichlorohydrin, respectively). d-Cysteinolate bile salts were generated by coupling with cholic and chenodeoxycholic acids. A series of single-crystal 3D X-ray structures confirmed the absolute configurations of the aminosulfonates. By comparison of optical rotation, we assign naturally occurring 3-amino-2-hydroxypropanesulfonate from Gateloupia livida as possessing the R-configuration. This simple synthetic approach will support future studies of the occurrence, chemotaxonomic distribution, and metabolism of these alkylsulfonates.

Synthesis of acyloin natural products by Mukaiyama hydration.

The acyloin natural products are a family of bioactive compounds isolated from fungi and myxobacteria. The total synthesis of 7 members of the acyloin family was achieved via a HWE reaction followed by Mukaiyama-Isayama hydration, using novel Co(II) and Co(III) Schiff base SALPN complexes as catalysts for the key enone hydration step. Furthermore, we have shown that a mild acyloin rearrangement is possible under Mukaiyama hydration conditions, which was crucial in the success of this approach.

Identification of Anthelmintic Bishomoscalarane Sesterterpenes from the Australian Marine Sponge Phyllospongia bergquistae and Structure Revision of Phyllolactones A-D.

High-throughput screening of the NatureBank marine extract library (7616 samples) identified an extract derived from the Australian marine sponge Phyllospongia bergquistae with activity against Hemonchus contortus (barber's pole worm), an economically important parasitic nematode. Bioassay-guided fractionation of the CH2Cl2/MeOH extract from P. bergquistae led to the purification of four known bishomoscalarane sesterterpenes, phyllolactones A-D (1-4). The absolute configurations of phyllolactones B (2) and C (3) were determined by single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis; literature and data analyses revealed the need for these chemical structures to be revised. Compounds 2-4 induced a lethal, skinny (Ski) phenotype in larvae of H. contortus at concentrations between 5.3 and 10.1 µM. These data indicate that the bishomoscalarane sesterterpene structure class warrants further investigation for nematocidal or nematostatic activity.

Computational Study of the Donor-Acceptor Interactions Underlying the Variable Oxygen Probe.

The variable oxygen probe (VOP) is a crystallographic technique that has been used to explore the relative donor abilities of various filled orbitals ranging from vicinal lone pairs to polarized heteroatom-carbon bonds, remote π functionalities, and strained carbon-carbon (CC) bonds. In this study, the donor-acceptor interactions which underlie the VOP have been explored in the gas phase using density functional theory on the model systems 1-13 with natural bond orbital analysis of the various donor-acceptor interactions involving both neutral and charged σ* antibonding orbitals as the acceptor probes. Updated values for the VOP slopes of 1-13 were shown to relate qualitatively with the sum of all significant donor-acceptor interactions present in these derivatives. Application of the VOP to calculated structures of 1-13 with various -OR substituents revealed a similar relationship between the C-OR bond distance to pKa (ROH). However, the VOP slopes in the gas phase were significantly smaller in magnitude than those obtained from crystal structural data, likely due to the valence form (C+-OR) being disfavored in the former, highlighting the advantage of the VOP as an experimental technique to discriminate donor ability more effectively than calculated structures.