Molecular Crowding: The History and Development of a Scientific Paradigm.

It is now generally accepted that macromolecules do not act in isolation but "live" in a crowded environment, that is, an environment populated by numerous different molecules. The field of molecular crowding has its origins in the far 80s but became accepted only by the end of the 90s. In the present issue, we discuss various aspects that are influenced by crowding and need to consider its effects. This Review is meant as an introduction to the theme and an analysis of the evolution of the crowding concept through time from colloidal and polymer physics to a more biological perspective. We introduce themes that will be more thoroughly treated in other Reviews of the present issue. In our intentions, each Review may stand by itself, but the complete collection has the aspiration to provide different but complementary perspectives to propose a more holistic view of molecular crowding.

A biosensor of protein foldedness identifies increased "holdase" activity of chaperones in the nucleus following increased cytosolic protein aggregation.

Chaperones and other quality control machinery guard proteins from inappropriate aggregation, which is a hallmark of neurodegenerative diseases. However, how the systems that regulate the "foldedness" of the proteome remain buffered under stress conditions and in different cellular compartments remains incompletely understood. In this study, we applied a FRET-based strategy to explore how well quality control machinery protects against the misfolding and aggregation of "bait" biosensor proteins, made from the prokaryotic ribonuclease barnase, in the nucleus and cytosol of human embryonic kidney 293T cells. We found that those barnase biosensors were prone to misfolding, were less engaged by quality control machinery, and more prone to inappropriate aggregation in the nucleus as compared with the cytosol, and that these effects could be regulated by chaperone Hsp70-related machinery. Furthermore, aggregation of mutant huntingtin exon 1 protein (Httex1) in the cytosol appeared to outcompete and thus prevented the engagement of quality control machinery with the biosensor in the cytosol. This effect correlated with reduced levels of DNAJB1 and HSPA1A chaperones in the cell outside those sequestered to the aggregates, particularly in the nucleus. Unexpectedly, we found Httex1 aggregation also increased the apparent engagement of the barnase biosensor with quality control machinery in the nucleus suggesting an independent implementation of "holdase" activity of chaperones other than DNAJB1 and HSPA1A. Collectively, these results suggest that proteostasis stress can trigger a rebalancing of chaperone abundance in different subcellular compartments through a dynamic network involving different chaperone-client interactions.

CAG-Repeat RNA Hairpin Folding and Recruitment to Nuclear Speckles with a Pivotal Role of ATP as a Cosolute.

A hallmark of Huntington's disease (HD) is a prolonged polyglutamine sequence in the huntingtin protein and, correspondingly, an expanded cytosine, adenine, and guanine (CAG) triplet repeat region in the mRNA. A majority of studies investigating disease pathology were concerned with toxic huntingtin protein, but the mRNA moved into focus due to its recruitment to RNA foci and emerging novel therapeutic approaches targeting the mRNA. A hallmark of CAG-RNA is that it forms a stable hairpin in vitro which seems to be crucial for specific protein interactions. Using in-cell folding experiments, we show that the CAG-RNA is largely destabilized in cells compared to dilute buffer solutions but remains folded in the cytoplasm and nucleus. Surprisingly, we found the same folding stability in the nucleoplasm and in nuclear speckles under physiological conditions suggesting that CAG-RNA does not undergo a conformational transition upon recruitment to the nuclear speckles. We found that the metabolite adenosine triphosphate (ATP) plays a crucial role in promoting unfolding, enabling its recruitment to nuclear speckles and preserving its mobility. Using in vitro experiments and molecular dynamics simulations, we found that the ATP effects can be attributed to a direct interaction of ATP with the nucleobases of the CAG-RNA rather than ATP acting as "a fuel" for helicase activity. ATP-driven changes in CAG-RNA homeostasis could be disease-relevant since mitochondrial function is affected in HD disease progression leading to a decline in cellular ATP levels.

The emerging role of ATP as a cosolute for biomolecular processes.

ATP is an important small molecule that appears at outstandingly high concentration within the cellular medium. Apart from its use as a source of energy and a metabolite, there is increasing evidence for important functions as a cosolute for biomolecular processes. Owned to its solubilizing kosmotropic triphosphate and hydrophobic adenine moieties, ATP is a versatile cosolute that can interact with biomolecules in various ways. We here use three models to categorize these interactions and apply them to review recent studies. We focus on the impact of ATP on biomolecular solubility, folding stability and phase transitions. This leads us to possible implications and therapeutic interventions in neurodegenerative diseases.

Intracellular spatially-targeted chemical chaperones increase native state stability of mutant SOD1 barrel.

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a progressive neurological disorder with currently no cure. Central to the cellular dysfunction associated with this fatal proteinopathy is the accumulation of unfolded/misfolded superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) in various subcellular locations. The molecular mechanism driving the formation of SOD1 aggregates is not fully understood but numerous studies suggest that aberrant aggregation escalates with folding instability of mutant apoSOD1. Recent advances on combining organelle-targeting therapies with the anti-aggregation capacity of chemical chaperones have successfully reduce the subcellular load of misfolded/aggregated SOD1 as well as their downstream anomalous cellular processes at low concentrations (micromolar range). Nevertheless, if such local aggregate reduction directly correlates with increased folding stability remains to be explored. To fill this gap, we synthesized and tested here the effect of 9 ER-, mitochondria- and lysosome-targeted chemical chaperones on the folding stability of truncated monomeric SOD1 (SOD1bar) mutants directed to those organelles. We found that compound ER-15 specifically increased the native state stability of ER-SOD1bar-A4V, while scaffold compound FDA-approved 4-phenylbutyric acid (PBA) decreased it. Furthermore, our results suggested that ER15 mechanism of action is distinct from that of PBA, opening new therapeutic perspectives of this novel chemical chaperone on ALS treatment.

Ethylene glycol energetically disfavours oligomerization of pseudoisocyanine dyestuffs at crowded concentrations.

The intriguing role of the intracellular crowded environment in regulating protein aggregation remains elusive. The convolution of several factors such as the protein sequence-dependence, crowder's shape and size and diverse intermolecular interactions makes it complex to identify systematic trends. One of the ways to simplify the problem is to study a synthetic model for self-assembling proteins. In this study, we examine the aggregation behaviour of the cationic pseudoisocyanine chloride (PIC) dyestuff which is known to self-assemble and form fibril-like J-aggregates in aqueous solutions, similar to those formed by amyloid-forming proteins. Prior experimental studies have shown that polyethylene glycol impedes and Ficoll-400 promotes the self-assembly of PIC dyes. To achieve molecular insights, we examine the effect of crowding by ethylene glycol on the solvation thermodynamics of oligomerization of dyes into H-type and J-type oligomers using extensive molecular dynamics simulations. The binding free energy calculations show that the formation of J-oligomers is more favourable than that of H-oligomers in water. The stability of H- and J- tetramers and pentamers decreases in crowded solutions. The formation of oligomers is supported by the favourable change in dye-solvent interaction energy in both pure water and aqueous ethylene glycol solution although it is opposed by the reduced dye-solvent entropy. Ethylene glycol, as a molecular crowder, disfavours the H- as well as J-oligomerization via preferential binding to the dye oligomers. An unfavourable change in dye-crowder and dye-dye interaction energy on dye association makes the H-oligomer formation less favourable in crowded solution than in pure water solution. In the case of J-oligomers, however, the unfavourable change in dye-crowder interaction energy primarily contributes to making total dye-solvent energy unfavourable. The results are supported by isothermal titration calorimetry measurements where the binding of ethylene glycol to PIC molecules is found to be endothermic. The results provide an emerging view that a crowded environment can disfavour self-assembly of PIC dyes by interactions with the oligomeric states. The findings have implications in understanding the role of a crowded environment in shaping the free energy landscapes of proteins.

Superoxide Dismutase 1 Folding Stability as a Target for Molecular Tweezers in SOD1-Related Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis.

Protein misfolding and aggregation are hallmarks of many severe neurodegenerative diseases including Alzheimer's, Parkinson's and Huntington's disease. As a supramolecular ligand that binds to lysine and arginine residues, the molecular tweezer CLR01 was found to modify the aggregation pathway of disease-relevant proteins in vitro and in vivo with beneficial effects on toxicity. However, the molecular mechanisms of how tweezers exert these effects remain mainly unknown, hampering further drug development. Here, we investigate the modulation mechanism of unfolding and aggregation pathways of SOD1, which are involved in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), by CLR01. Using a truncated version of the wildtype SOD1 protein, SOD1bar , we show that CLR01 acts on the first step of the aggregation pathway, the unfolding of the SOD1 monomer. CLR01 increases, by ∼10 °C, the melting temperatures of the A4V and G41D SOD1 mutants, which are commonly observed mutations in familial ALS. Molecular dynamics simulations and binding free energy calculations as well as native mass spectrometry and mutational studies allowed us to identify K61 and K92 as binding sites for the tweezers to mediate the stability increase. The data suggest that the modulation of SOD1 conformational stability is a promising target for future developments of supramolecular ligands against neurodegenerative diseases.

4-Phenylbutyric Acid (4-PBA) Derivatives Prevent SOD1 Amyloid Aggregation In Vitro with No Effect on Disease Progression in SOD1-ALS Mice.

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a fatal neurodegenerative disease characterized by the degeneration of motor neurons. Mutations in the superoxide dismutase (SOD1) gene, causing protein misfolding and aggregation, were suggested as the pathogenic mechanisms involved in familial ALS cases. In the present study, we investigated the potential therapeutic effect of C4 and C5, two derivatives of the chemical chaperone 4-phenylbutyric acid (4-PBA). By combining in vivo and in vitro techniques, we show that, although C4 and C5 successfully inhibited amyloid aggregation of recombinant mutant SOD1 in a dose-dependent manner, they failed to suppress the accumulation of misfolded SOD1. Moreover, C4 or C5 daily injections to SOD1G93A mice following onset had no effect on either the accumulation of misfolded SOD1 or the neuroinflammatory response in the spinal cord and, consequently, failed to extend the survival of SOD1G93A mice or to improve their motor symptoms. Finally, pharmacokinetic (PK) studies demonstrated that high concentrations of C4 and C5 reached the brain and spinal cord but only for a short period of time. Thus, our findings suggest that use of such chemical chaperones for ALS drug development may need to be optimized for more effective results.

Sequestration of Proteins in Stress Granules Relies on the In-Cell but Not the In Vitro Folding Stability.

Stress granules (SGs) are among the most studied membraneless organelles that form upon heat stress (HS) to sequester unfolded, misfolded, or aggregated protein, supporting protein quality control (PQC) clearance. The folding states that are primarily associated with SGs, as well as the function of the phase separated environment in adjusting the energy landscapes, remain unknown. Here, we investigate the association of superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) proteins with different folding stabilities and aggregation propensities with condensates in cells, in vitro and by simulation. We find that irrespective of aggregation the folding stability determines the association of SOD1 with SGs in cells. In vitro and in silico experiments however suggest that the increased flexibility of the unfolded state constitutes only a minor driving force to associate with the dynamic biomolecular network of the condensate. Specific protein-protein interactions in the cytoplasm in comparison to SGs determine the partitioning of folding states between the respective phases during HS.

GlycoBODIPYs: Sugars Serving as a Natural Stock for Water-soluble Fluorescent Probes of Complex Chiral Morphology.

A range of unprocessed, reducing sugar substrates (mono-, di-, and trisaccharides) is shown to take part in a straightforward four-step synthetic route to water-soluble, uncharged BODIPY derivatives with unimpaired chiral integrity and high fluorescence efficiency. A wide compatibility with several postfunctionalizations is demonstrated, thus suggesting a universal utility of the multifunctional glycoconjugates, which we call GlycoBODIPYs. Knoevenagel condensations are able to promote a red-shift in the spectra, thereby furnishing strongly fluorescent red and far-red glycoconjugates of high hydrophilicity. The synthetic outcome was studied by X-ray crystallography and by comprehensive photophysical investigations in several solvent systems. Furthermore, cell experiments illustrate efficient cell uptake and demonstrate differential cell targeting as a function of the integrated chiral information.

Self-Assembly of Pseudo-Isocyanine Chloride as a Sensor for Macromolecular Crowding In Vitro and In Vivo.

Pseudo-isocyanine chloride (PIC) is a cationic dyestuff that exhibits self-assembly in aqueous solution, promoted either by increasing the PIC concentration or by decreasing the temperature. PIC-aggregates exhibit a characteristic and sharp absorption band as well as a fluorescence band at a wavelength of 573 nm making PIC an interesting candidate to analyze the self-assembly process in various environments. The present work developed PIC-based, synthetic model systems, suitable to investigate how macromolecular crowding influences self-assembly processes. Four synthetic additives were used as potential crowders: Triethylene glycol (TEG), polyethylene glycol (PEG), Ficoll 400 as a highly branched polysaccharide, and sucrose corresponding to the monomeric unit of Ficoll. Combined UV/Vis spectroscopy and time-resolved light scattering revealed a strong impact of crowding based on excluded volume effects only for Ficoll 400. Sucrose had hardly any influence on the self-assembly of PIC and PEG and TEG impeded the PIC self-assembly. Development of such a PIC based model system led over to in-cell experiments. HeLa cells were infiltrated with PIC solutions well below the aggregation threshold in the infiltrating solution. In the cellular environment, PIC was exposed to a significant crowding and immediately started to aggregate. As was demonstrated by fluorescence imaging, the extent of aggregation can be modulated by exposing the cells to salt-induced osmotic stress. The results suggest future use of such a system as a sensor for the analysis of in vitro and in vivo crowding effects on self-assembly processes.

Effects of in vivo conditions on amyloid aggregation.

One of the grand challenges of biophysical chemistry is to understand the principles that govern protein misfolding and aggregation, which is a highly complex process that is sensitive to initial conditions, operates on a huge range of length- and timescales, and has products that range from protein dimers to macroscopic amyloid fibrils. Aberrant aggregation is associated with more than 25 diseases, which include Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, Huntington's, and type II diabetes. Amyloid aggregation has been extensively studied in the test tube, therefore under conditions that are far from physiological relevance. Hence, there is dire need to extend these investigations to in vivo conditions where amyloid formation is affected by a myriad of biochemical interactions. As a hallmark of neurodegenerative diseases, these interactions need to be understood in detail to develop novel therapeutic interventions, as millions of people globally suffer from neurodegenerative disorders and type II diabetes. The aim of this review is to document the progress in the research on amyloid formation from a physicochemical perspective with a special focus on the physiological factors influencing the aggregation of the amyloid-ß peptide, the islet amyloid polypeptide, α-synuclein, and the hungingtin protein.

Stability Effect of Quinary Interactions Reversed by Single Point Mutations.

In cells, proteins are embedded in a crowded environment that controls their properties via manifold avenues including weak protein-macromolecule interactions. A molecular level understanding of these quinary interactions and their contribution to protein stability, function, and localization in the cell is central to modern structural biology. Using a mutational analysis to quantify the energetic contributions of single amino acids to the stability of the ALS related protein superoxide dismutase I (SOD1) in mammalian cells, we show that quinary interactions destabilize SOD1 by a similar energetic offset for most of the mutants, but there are notable exceptions: Mutants that alter its surface properties can even lead to a stabilization of the protein in the cell as compared to the test tube. In conclusion, quinary interactions can amplify and even reverse the mutational response of proteins, being a key aspect in pathogenic protein misfolding and aggregation.

Thermal stability modulation of the native and chemically-unfolded state of bovine serum albumin by amino acids.

Cells are crowded with various cosolutes including salts, osmolytes, nucleic acids, peptides and proteins. These cosolutes modulate the protein folding equilibrium in different ways, however, a unifying concept remains elusive. To elucidate the cosolute size-effect, macromolecular crowders are commonly compared to their monomeric building blocks (e.g. dextran vs. glucose or polyethylene glycol with different degrees of polymerization). To the best of our knowledge, such studies do not exist for protein crowders, raising the question of how single amino acids modulate the folding equilibrium. Therefore, we investigate the effect of glycine, alanine, proline and arginine on the stability of a model globular protein bovine serum albumin (BSA) upon thermal and urea-induced unfolding. We use three complementary techniques, fluorescence spectroscopy (as a local site-specific probe), circular dichroism (as a global probe for α-helical structure) and differential scanning calorimetry (to probe the energetics of unfolding). We find that the amino acids modulate BSA stability and unfolding, however, without following a particular trend with either the hydrophobicity scale or the solvent accessible surface area (SASA) of the added amino acids. Our data rather suggest that solvation effects play a role in understanding the cosolute effect.

A Multiperspective Approach to Solvent Regulation of Enzymatic Activity: HMG-CoA Reductase.

3-Hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl-coenzyme A (HMG-CoA) reductase was investigated in different organic cosolvents by means of kinetic and calorimetric measurements, molecular dynamics simulations, and small-angle X-ray scattering. The combined experimental and theoretical techniques were essential to complement each other's limitations in the investigation of the complex interaction pattern between the enzyme, different solvent types, and concentrations. In this way, the underlying mechanisms for the loss of enzyme activity in different water-miscible solvents could be elucidated. These include direct inhibitory effects onto the active center and structural distortions.

Inhibition of Huntingtin Exon-1 Aggregation by the Molecular Tweezer CLR01.

Huntington's disease is a neurodegenerative disorder associated with the expansion of the polyglutamine tract in the exon-1 domain of the huntingtin protein (htte1). Above a threshold of 37 glutamine residues, htte1 starts to aggregate in a nucleation-dependent manner. A 17-residue N-terminal fragment of htte1 (N17) has been suggested to play a crucial role in modulating the aggregation propensity and toxicity of htte1. Here we identify N17 as a potential target for novel therapeutic intervention using the molecular tweezer CLR01. A combination of biochemical experiments and computer simulations shows that binding of CLR01 induces structural rearrangements within the htte1 monomer and inhibits htte1 aggregation, underpinning the key role of N17 in modulating htte1 toxicity.

Conformational dynamics and self-association of intrinsically disordered Huntingtin exon 1 in cells.

Huntington's disease is caused by a CAG trinucleotide expansion mutation in the Huntingtin gene that leads to an artificially long polyglutamine sequence in the Huntingtin protein. A key feature of the disease is the intracellular aggregation of the Huntingtin exon 1 protein (Httex1) into micrometer sized inclusion bodies. The aggregation process of Httex1 has been extensively studied in vitro, however, the crucial early events of nucleation and aggregation in the cell remain elusive. Here, we studied the conformational dynamics and self-association of Httex1 by in-cell experiments using laser-induced temperature jumps and analytical ultracentrifugation. Both short and long polyglutamine variants of Httex1 underwent an apparent temperature-induced conformational collapse. The temperature jumps generated a population of kinetically trapped species selectively for the longer polyglutamine variants of Httex1 proteins. Their occurrence correlated with the formation of inclusion bodies suggesting that such species trigger further self-association.

The macromolecular crowding effect--from in vitro into the cell.

The influence of the cellular milieu, a complex and crowded solvent, is often neglected when biomolecular structure and function are studied in vitro. To mimic the cellular environment, crowding effects are commonly induced in vitro using artificial crowding agents like Ficoll or dextran. However, it is unclear if such effects are also observed in cellulo. Diverging results on protein stability in living cells point out the need for new quantitative methods to investigate the contributions of excluded volume and nonspecific interactions to the cellular crowding effect. We show how new crowding sensitive probes may be utilized to directly investigate crowding effects in living cells. Moreover, we discuss processes where crowding effects could play a crucial role in molecular cell biology.

The temperature dependence of the Hofmeister series: thermodynamic fingerprints of cosolute-protein interactions.

The Hofmeister series is a universal homologous series to rank ion-specific effects on biomolecular properties such as protein stability or aggregation propensity. Although this ranking is widely used, outliers and exceptions are discussed controversially and a molecular level understanding is still lacking. Studying the thermal unfolding equilibrium of RNase A, we here show that this ambiguity arises from the oversimplified approach to determine the ion rankings. Instead of measuring salt effects on a single point of the protein folding stability curve (e.g. the melting point Tm), we here consider the salt induced shifts of the entire protein 'stability curve' (the temperature dependence of the unfolding free energy change, ΔGu(T)). We found multiple intersections of these curves, pinpointing a widely ignored fact: the Hofmeister cation and anion rankings are temperature dependent. We further developed a novel classification scheme of cosolute effects based on their thermodynamic fingerprints, reaching beyond salt effects to non-electrolytes.

Long-range protein-water dynamics in hyperactive insect antifreeze proteins.

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) are specific proteins that are able to lower the freezing point of aqueous solutions relative to the melting point. Hyperactive AFPs, identified in insects, have an especially high ability to depress the freezing point by far exceeding the abilities of other AFPs. In previous studies, we postulated that the activity of AFPs can be attributed to two distinct molecular mechanisms: (i) short-range direct interaction of the protein surface with the growing ice face and (ii) long-range interaction by protein-induced water dynamics extending up to 20 Å from the protein surface. In the present paper, we combine terahertz spectroscopy and molecular simulations to prove that long-range protein-water interactions make essential contributions to the high antifreeze activity of insect AFPs from the beetle Dendroides canadensis. We also support our hypothesis by studying the effect of the addition of the osmolyte sodium citrate.