ABSTRACT
Objetivo: Este estudio tuvo como objetivo principal validar el Voice Handicap Index (VHI) y su versión abreviada (VHI-10) adaptados al español rioplatense de Argentina, con objetivos específicos centrados en evaluar su fiabilidad y validez. Metodología: La adaptación cultural incluyó técnicas de traducción directa, síntesis y retrotraducción, evaluación de la equivalencia semántica y aplicación a un grupo piloto. Para la validación se evaluó la fiabilidad de ambos índices adaptados mediante la consistencia interna (coeficiente alfa de Cronbach) y la estabilidad test-retest (prueba de Bland-Altman, CCI y r de Spearman). Además, se examinó la validez de criterio y de constructo. 213 sujetos participaron en la validación del índice adaptado de 30 ítems (123 disfónicos; 90 de control); 113, en la del índice abreviado (63 disfónicos; 50 de control). Resultados: Se constituyó el Índice de Desventaja Vocal (IDV) como la versión adaptada del VHI al español rioplatense de Argentina. Ambos índices demostraron excelente consistencia interna (IDV-30 α = 0,96; IDV-10 α = 0,92) y estabilidad y concordancia (IDV-30 CCI = 0,95; IDV-10 CCI = 0,96). Se halló alta correlación entre los puntajes de ambos índices y la autoevaluación de la severidad de la disfonía de los participantes (r = 0,85). Ambos índices demostraron capacidad de diferenciar entre individuos con disfonía y sujetos sanos (p< 0,001). El análisis factorial reveló tres factores para el IDV-30 y un factor para el IDV-10. Conclusiones: El IDV-30 e IDV-10 presentan grados adecuados de fiabilidad y validez. Ambos pueden ser incluidos en protocolos de valoración de la función vocal por profesionales de Argentina.
Aim: This study aimed to validate the Voice Handicap Index (VHI) and its abbreviated version (VHI-10) adapted into Rioplatense Spanish from Argentina, with specific goals centered on assessing their reliability and validity. Methods: Cultural adaptation involved direct translation, synthesis and back-translation techniques, followed by an assessment of semantic equivalence and application to a pilot group. For the validation process, the reliability of both adapted indices was assessed through measures of internal consistency (Cronbach's alpha coefficient) and test-retest stability (Bland-Altman test, ICC and Spearman's correlation coefficient). Additionally, we conducted analyses to asses criterion and construct validity. 213 subjects participated in the validation of the adapted 30-items index, (123 with dysphonia; 90 from control group); 113, in the abbreviated version (63 with dysphonia; 50 from control group). Results: The "Índice de Desventaja Vocal" (IDV) was established as the adapted version of the VHI into Rioplatense Spanish from Argentina. Both indeces exhibited excellent internal consistency (IDV-30 α = 0,96; IDV-10 α = 0,92) and satisfactory stability and agreement (IDV-30 CCI = 0,95; IDV-10 CCI = 0,96). Regarding validity, a strong correlation was observed between the scores of both indeces and the participant's self-assessment of dysphonia degree (r = 0,85). Both indices effectively differentiated between individuals with dysphonia and healthy subjects (p< 0,001). Factor analysis revealed three factors for the IDV-30 and one factor for the IDV-10. Conclusion: The IDV-30 and IDV-10 demonstrate satisfactory levels of reliability and validity. Both indices can be incorporated into the assessment protocols for evaluating the vocal function by professionals in Argentina.
ABSTRACT
La distonía laríngea (DL), también conocida como disfonía espasmódica, es un desorden focal tarea-específico del movimiento, que afecta primariamente la producción de la voz. Los movimientos distónicos de las cuerdas vocales producen fenómenos diferentes, especialmente quiebres o interrupciones vocales y tensión en el tipo de distonía laríngea aductora (DLAD), e interrupciones y soplo o segmentos áfonos en el tipo abductor (DLAB). Más del 80% de pacientes sufren de DLAD o DEAD (disfonía espasmódica aductora). Dos pacientes de sexo femenino desarrollaron DL un mes después de haber contraído una infección del tracto respiratorio superior causada por COVID-19. Ambas presentaron distonía laríngea de tipo aductor. En el análisis acústico de la vocal /a/ sostenida se han observado quiebres o interrupciones, cambios frecuenciales y aperiodicidad. El rango de habla fue estudiado en ambas pacientes mediante el fonetograma, dando un resultado alterado. Posiblemente la inflamación de los nervios periféricos de la laringe, causada por COVID-19, produjo una alteración sensitiva con una respuesta mal adaptativa en estas pacientes con una base genética quizás predisponente. O la activación inmunológica, o la invasión del germen a través de la vía retrógrada alteraron las redes neuronales involucradas en la génesis de la DL.
Laryngeal dystonia (LD), also known as spasmodic dysphonia, is a task-specific focal movement disorder, primarily affecting voice production. The dystonic movements of the vocal folds result in a varied phenomenology, typically hard vocal breaks and strain in the adductor-type laryngeal dystonia (ADLD), and breathy breaks or aphonia in the abductor-type laryngeal dystonia (ABLD). More than 80% of patients have suffered from ADLD. Two female patients developed LD a month after presenting an upper respiratory tract infection by COVID-19. They had the adductor-type laryngeal dystonia. Through the acoustic study of the vowel /a/ breaks, frequency changes and aperiodicity were observed. Speech was studied using the phonetogram, and the range of speech is altered in both patients. The inflammation of the peripheral nerves of the larynx by COVID-19 produced a sensory alteration, with a maladaptive response in these patients, who perhaps had predisposing genetic basis, or the immunological activation or the invasion of the germ by retrograde pathway altered the neuronal networks involved in the genesis of LD.
ABSTRACT
Purpose: To describe the acoustic characteristics of a classroom, voice quality, fatigue, and vocal load of university professors. Methods: Exploratory, observational, longitudinal, and descriptive study with a single group of participants, including vocal monitoring data over two weeks. Acoustic characterization of the classroom, perceptual-auditory evaluation, and acoustic analysis of voice samples were conducted before and after classes. Vocal dosimetry was performed during classes, and the Vocal Fatigue Index (VFI) was assessed at the beginning of each week. Descriptive analysis of the findings was conducted, and randomization test was performed to verify the internal reliability of the judge. Results: All participants reported speaking loudly in the classroom, with the majority reporting vocal changes in the past six months, and only one participant reported a current vocal change. The classroom had acoustical measures and estimations that deviated from established standards. The professors used high vocal intensities during classes. After the classes, an increase in the absolute values of the aggregated data for CAPE-V, jitter, and fundamental frequency was found, varying within the range of normality. Furthermore, there was an observed increase in both post-lesson intensity and VFI when comparing the two-week period. Conclusions: Vocal intensities and VFI were possibly impacted by the acoustics of the classroom. The increase in average VFI between the weeks may be attributed to a cumulative fatigue sensation. Further research with a larger number of participants and in acoustically conditioned classrooms is suggested in order to evaluate collective intervention proposals aimed at reducing the vocal load on teachers.
Objetivo: Describir las características acústicas, calidad vocal, fatiga y carga vocal de profesores universitarios. Métodos: Estudio exploratorio, observacional, longitudinal, descriptivo con un solo grupo de participantes y datos de monitoreo vocal durante dos semanas. Se realizó caracterización acústica de la sala, evaluación auditiva-perceptiva y acústica de muestras de voz antes y después de las clases. Se realizó dosimetría vocal durante las clases y se verificó el Índice de Fatiga Vocal (IFV) en dos semanas. Se realizó un análisis descriptivo de los hallazgos y una prueba de aleatorización para verificar la confiabilidad interna del juez. Resultados: Todos los participantes informaron hablar en voz alta en clase, la mayoría informó cambios vocales en los últimos seis meses y solo uno informó cambios vocales actuales. La sala presentó mediciones y estimaciones acústicas fuera de las normas establecidas. Los profesores utilizaron intensidades vocales altas durante las clases. Hubo un aumento en los valores absolutos de los datos agrupados para CAPE-V, jitter y frecuencia fundamental, variando dentro de los límites normales, después de las clases. La intensidad después de las clases y el IFV, en la comparación entre las dos semanas, mostraron un aumento. Conclusiones: La dosis vocal y el IFV posiblemente se vieron afectados por la acústica del aula. El aumento del IFV medio entre semanas pudo deberse a la sensación de cansancio acumulada. Se sugieren nuevas investigaciones con un mayor número de participantes y que se realicen en la sala acondicionada acústicamente para evaluar propuestas de intervención colectiva, con el objetivo de reducir la carga vocal de los docentes.
ABSTRACT
José Martí, el más universal de los cubanos, el hombre que unió a sus compatriotas en el exilio y organizó la Guerra Necesaria, padeció varias entidades patológicas, entre ellas algunas de tipo otorrinolaringológico; pero estas no lograron detenerlo en su labor por alcanzar una patria libre. En el presente trabajo se precisan algunos deslices encontrados en una publicación donde se exponen las enfermedades otorrinolaringológicas que aquejaban al Apóstol.
José Martí, the most universal of Cubans, the man who united his compatriots in exile and organized The Necessary War, suffered from several pathological entities, including some of the otorhinolaryngological type; but these illnesses did not stop him in his work to achieve a free homeland. In the present work, some errors found in a publication that exposes the otorhinolaryngological diseases that afflicted the Apostle are specified.
ABSTRACT
Introducción: las medidas auditivo-perceptuales subjetivas GRABS (Grade [grado de gravedad], Roughness [aspereza], Asthenia [astenia], Breathiness [soplosidad] y Strain [tensión] y CAPE-V (Consensus Auditory-Perceptual Evaluation of Voice) han sido el estándar de oro en evaluar la voz. La prominencia del pico cepstral suavizado (CPPS) se impone como la medida acústica objetiva más robusta para evaluar la gravedad de la disfonía. Se evaluó el análisis cepstral del programa PRAAT en pacientes con voz patológica y no patológica en hablantes de español colombiano y los valores estándar para el CPPS en lenguaje conectado (CPPSc), comparado con el análisis perceptual de la voz (GRBAS). Métodos: estudio observacional y analítico de prueba diagnóstica, de corte transversal y multicéntrico, con 120 individuos. Se grabó la voz y se analizó el CPPSc con el programa PRAAT. Se aplicó la valoración auditiva-perceptual por dos evaluadores expertos para la escala GRBAS. Resultados: el promedio de edad fue 43,3 años, 64,2 % mujeres. La media del CPPSc en el grupo disfónico fue de 6,40 dB y en el grupo de normofónicos fue 8,54 dB con p=0,000. Sensibilidad de 83,6% y especificidad de 96,2 % para la voz patológica en los pacientes con valores de CPPSc menores a 7,38 dB. Hubo alta correlación del valor de CPPSc con la gravedad de la disfonía. Conclusiones: el valor del CPPSc mediante el programa PRAAT es una medida eficiente por su alta validez, bajo costo y fácil aplicación para evaluar objetivamente la disfonía y su gravedad.
Introduction: Subjective auditory-perceptual measurements, GRABS (Grade, Roughness, Asthenia, Breathiness y Strain) and CAPE-V (Consensus Auditory Perceptual Evaluation of Voice) have been the gold standard in voice evaluation. Recently, the smoothed cepstral peak prominence (CPPS) has been imposed as the acoustic measurement, objective and more robust for dysphonia severity. Objectives: The cepstral analysis of the PRAAT program was evaluated in patients with a patho-logical and non-pathological voice in Colombian Spanish speakers and the standard values for the CPPS in connected language (CPPSc), compared with the perceptual analysis of the voice (GRBAS). Methods: An observational, analytical, cross-sec-tional, multicenter diagnostic test was performed with 120 individuals. The voice was recorded and the CPPSc was analyzed with the PRAAT program. The auditory-perceptual assessment was applied by two expert evaluators for the GRBAS scale. Results: The average age was 43.3 ± 18.1 years, 64.2% were women. The mean CPPSc in the dysphonic group was 6.40 dB, while in the group of normophonic indi-viduals it was 8.54 dB, with significant differences between both groups (p=0.000). Sensitivity of 83.6% and specificity of 96.2%; for pathological voice was established in patients with CPPSc values less than 7.38 dB. A high correlation was found in the CPPSc value with the severity of dysphonia. Conclusions: The value of CPPSc through the Praat program is an efficient measure, due to its high validity, low cost and easy application to objectively evaluate dysphonia and its severity.
Subject(s)
Humans , Male , FemaleABSTRACT
RESUMO Objetivo Identificar evidências científicas sobre o distúrbio de voz relacionado ao trabalho e fatores de risco, além de apontar os sintomas vocais, instrumentos e métodos de avaliação em profissionais da voz falada. Estratégia de pesquisa Revisão integrativa da literatura, realizada nas bases de dados LILACS, SciELO, MEDLINE/PubMed e Scopus. Critérios de seleção Artigos com profissionais da voz falada, que abordassem os fatores de riscos individuais, organizacionais e/ou ambientais vinculados aos sintomas e/ou distúrbios de voz, estudos observacionais, disponíveis na íntegra, sem restrição ao idioma e ano de publicação. Resultados Foram incluídos 58 estudos, maior publicação entre os anos de 2014 e 2022, predominantemente no Brasil, em destaque, o professor. O método de avaliação mais utilizado foi autoavaliação com o uso dos protocolos, seguido da avaliação perceptivo-auditiva e do exame laringológico. Os fatores de risco mais identificados foram os individuais, seguidos dos organizacionais e ambientais, além de terem sido relatados os sintomas vocais sensoriais e auditivos. Conclusão Os fatores mais autorreferidos são ruído, uso intenso da voz, alterações respiratórias, ser do gênero feminino e práticas vocais inadequadas. Quanto aos sintomas vocais sensoriais, destacam-se garganta seca, pigarro e fadiga vocal, e quanto aos auditivos, rouquidão.
ABSTRACT Purpose To identify scientific evidence about (Work-Related Voice Disorder) and risk factors, as well as to point out vocal symptoms, instruments and evaluation methods in spoken voice professionals. Research strategy Integrative literature review carried out in LILACS, SciELO, MEDLINE/PubMed and Scopus databases. Selection criteria Articles with spoken voice professionals, which addressed individual, organizational and/or environmental risk factors linked to symptoms and/or voice disorders, observational studies, fully available, without restriction to language and year of publication. Results 58 papers were included, the largest publication between the years 2014 and 2022, predominantly in Brazil, with emphasis on the teacher. The most used evaluation method was vocal assessment using self-assessment protocols, followed by auditory-perceptual assessment and laryngological examination. The mostly identified risk factors were individual ones, followed by organizational and environmental ones, in addition to sensory and auditory vocal symptoms having been reported. Conclusion The most often self-reported factors were noise, intense voice use, respiratory changes, being female and inappropriate vocal practices. For sensory vocal symptoms, dry throat, throat clearing and vocal fatigue stand out, and for auditory symptoms, hoarseness.
Subject(s)
Humans , Auditory Perception , Voice Disorders/diagnosis , Risk Factors , Occupational Health , Faculty , Dysphonia/diagnosis , BrazilABSTRACT
RESUMO Objetivo Realizar a adaptação transcultural do Instrumento de Rastreio para a Disfonia (IRD-Br) para o Português Europeu (PE). Métodos Foi realizada a adaptação transcultural do IRD-Br para o PE de acordo com as seguintes etapas: tradução, retrotradução, análise de um comitê de especialistas e pré-teste. Na etapa de pré-teste, participaram 30 indivíduos disfônicos com idades entre os 18 e 87 anos, sendo 24 do sexo feminino e 6 do sexo masculino. Resultados Foi necessária a inserção de um enunciado na versão em PE do instrumento. Houve divergência na retrotradução do título, sendo resolvida na análise do comitê de especialistas. Um item apresentou divergência na tradução e na retrotradução, sendo definida a versão final na análise do comitê de especialistas. Um item e a chave de resposta apresentaram consenso em todas as etapas. No pré-teste, todos os itens receberam 100% de respostas sim ou não, e nenhum recebeu resposta não aplicável. Conclusão A adaptação do IRD-Br para o PE foi bem sucedida. A versão para o português europeu do instrumento foi denominada de Instrumento de Rastreio para a Disfonia em português europeu - IRD-PT.
ABSTRACT Purpose To perform a cross-cultural adaptation of the Brazilian Dysphonia Screening Tool (DST-Br) for European Portuguese (EP). Methods The cross-cultural adaptation of the DST-Br for EP was carried out in four stages: translation, back-translation, expert committee review, and pre-testing. The pre-testing involved 30 dysphonic individuals (24 women and 6 men) aged between 18 and 87 years old. Results An additional statement was required in the EP version of the instrument. Disagreement in the back-translation of the title was resolved through an expert committee review. One item presented discrepancies in the translation and back-translation, with the final version determined through an expert committee review. One item and the answer key reached a consensus in all stages. During pre-testing, all items received 100% "yes" or "no" responses, and none were marked as "not applicable". Conclusion The cross-cultural adaptation of DST-Br for use in EP was successfully carried out. The European Portuguese version of the instrument was named the Instrumento de Rastreio para a Disfonia em português europeu (IRD-PT) / Dysphonia Screening Tool in European Portuguese.
ABSTRACT
ABSTRACT Purpose: to determine the structure of treatment goals set by expert voice-specialized speech-language pathologists in treatment plans for patients with vocal needs. Methods: a cross-sectional documentary research was conducted to analyze 129 treatment goals proposed in treatment plans by 30 expert voice-specialized speech-language pathologists. These goals were thematically analyzed and organized according to the therapeutic content addressed. The goals including the notion of patient in their wording, the statement of a specific purpose, the method for achieving it, and the presence of outcome criteria, were evaluated. Results: most treatment goals analyzed correspond to those aimed at modifying vocal parameters (67.4%). The contents referring to muscle tone (13.8%), vocal hygiene and education (10%), breathing (7.75%), and posture (1.55%) are represented to a lesser extent. From the total number of treatment goals analyzed, 82.17% include the notion of patient, 88.37% indicate the method, 100% indicate the purpose, 52.71% state the outcome criteria used, and 17.05% include other components in their structure. Conclusions: diversity in goal setting shows different visions by the professionals involved in the therapeutic process.
RESUMEN Objetivo: determinar la estructura de los objetivos operacionales formulados por los/las fonoaudiólogos/as en las planificaciones terapéuticas para usuarios con necesidades vocales. Métodos: investigación documental transversal en que se analizaron 129 objetivos operacionales propuestos en las planificaciones terapéuticas de 30 fonoaudiólogos/as. Estos objetivos se sometieron a un proceso de análisis temático y se organizaron según el contenido terapéutico abordado. Se examinó la inclusión de la noción de usuario en la redacción, la declaración de una finalidad específica, el método para alcanzarla y la presencia de criterios de logro. Resultados: de la totalidad de objetivos analizados, la mayoría corresponde a aquellos que están orientados a la modificación de parámetros vocales (67.4%). En menor medida, están representados los contenidos referentes a tonicidad muscular (13.8%), educación e higiene vocal (10%), respiración (7.75%) y postura (1.55%). Del total, un 82.17% incluye la noción de usuario, un 88.37% señala el método, el 100% indica la finalidad y un 52.71% declara los criterios de logro utilizados. Un 17.05% incluye otros componentes en su estructura. Conclusiones: la diversidad en la formulación de los objetivos evidencia distintas visiones acerca del proceso terapéutico por parte de los profesionales involucrados.
ABSTRACT
El término "presbifonía" se refiere a la sintomatología generada por cambios fisiológicos del sistema de producción vocal en personas mayores saludables. Existen diversos enfoques terapéuticos para su abordaje, sin embargo, no existe suficiente investigación que permita documentarlos y, a partir de ellos, conocer las técnicas disponibles y eficaces para la terapia vocal, lo que se traduce en un desafío para la fonoaudiología, considerando el acelerado proceso de envejecimiento poblacional actual y la necesidad de atender, cada vez más, a personas mayores con esta condición, desde una perspectiva gerontológica y situada. Esta revisión analizó la evidencia científica disponible sobre los enfoques terapéuticos y las estrategias metodológicas utilizadas para el abordaje terapéutico de la presbifonía, con el fin de caracterizar las herramientas que se están utilizando actualmente. Se realizó una revisión exploratoria de literatura según las orientaciones del método PRISMA y se seleccionaron 6 publicaciones científicas. En las investigaciones, ninguna en habla castellana, se observa tendencia al uso de propuestas basadas en el modelo biomédico, con intervenciones individuales y fundamentadas en un enfoque fisiológico. Se encuentra evidencia que respalda una intervención integradora, de tipo grupal, situada en lo comunitario, con enfoque ecléctico y que dialoga con los lineamientos internacionales para el trabajo en vejez. Se concluye la urgencia de contar con nuevas investigaciones que den cuenta rigurosamente de nuevos enfoques eficientes para intervención conductual en presbifonía, sobre todo aquellos que se adapten al proceso de envejecer saludablemente
The term "presbyphonia" refers to the symptomatology caused by physiological changes in the vocal production system in healthy older adults. There are various therapeutic approaches for its management, however, there is not enough research to document these and, from there, to understand the available and effective techniques for vocal therapy, which poses a challenge for speechlanguage pathology. This is especially pertinent considering the rapid process of population aging currently underway and the growing need to address older individuals with this condition from a gerontological and situated perspective. This review analyzed the available scientific evidence on therapeutic approaches and methodological strategies used for the therapeutic management of presbyphonia, in order to characterize the tools that are currently being used. An exploratory literature review was conducted following the PRISMA method guidelines, and 6 scientific publications were selected. In the research, none of which were in Spanish, there is a trend towards the use of proposals based on the biomedical model, with individual interventions and grounded on a physiological approach. Evidence supports an integrative, group-based intervention, situated in the community, with an eclectic approach that aligns with international guidelines for working with the elderly. It concludes the urgent need for new research that rigorously accounts for new efficient approaches to behavioral intervention in presbyphonia, especially those that adapt to the process of aging healthily.
ABSTRACT
ABSTRACT Purpose: to characterize the actions of vocal health promotion and/or prevention of vocal disorders applied to voice professionals. Methods: a scoping review following the PRISMA-ScR guidelines in SciELO and PubMed databases was conducted. Articles that had as participants voice professionals without concomitant vocal treatment, that described proposals for health promotion or vocal disorders prevention, published between 2010 and 2023, were included. They were grouped into categories and data were presented descriptively. Literature Review: eighteen articles with artistic and non-artistic voice professionals, mostly teachers, were included. Most of the studies focused on healthy voices, aiming at primary prevention. Many articles presented guidance on vocal hygiene and health and used resources such as vocal enhancement, voice workshop, voice amplifiers and apps. All the articles positively mentioned their results, especially with regard to self-perception in relation to voice, vocal quality and quality of life, awareness of positive and harmful practices to the voice. Conclusion: the proposals contemplated different levels of prevention, but most focused on primary prevention, including vocally healthy participants; all articles indicated positive results in voice self-perception, voice quality and quality of life, and awareness of positive and harmful voice practices.
RESUMO Objetivo: caracterizar as ações de promoção de saúde vocal e/ou prevenção de distúrbios vocais aplicadas em profissionais da voz. Métodos: foi conduzida uma revisão de escopo seguindo as diretrizes do PRISMA-ScR nas bases de dados SciELO e PubMed. Foram incluídos artigos que tivessem como participantes profissionais da voz sem tratamento vocal concomitante, que descrevessem propostas de promoção da saúde ou prevenção de distúrbios vocais, publicados entre 2010 e 2023. Os artigos foram agrupados em categorias e os dados apresentados de forma descritiva. Revisão da Literatura: foram incluídos 18 artigos com profissionais da voz artística e não-artística, em sua maioria professores. A maior parte dos estudos tinha como foco vozes saudáveis, visando a prevenção primária. Muitos artigos apresentaram orientações sobre higiene e saúde vocal e utilizaram recursos como aprimoramento vocal, oficina de voz, amplificadores de voz e aplicativos. Todos os artigos mencionam resultados benéficos, principalmente no que se refere à autopercepção em relação a voz, qualidade vocal e de vida, conscientização de práticas positivas e prejudiciais à voz. Conclusão: as propostas contemplaram diferentes níveis de prevenção, mas a maioria tinha como foco a prevenção primária, incluindo participantes vocalmente saudáveis; todos os artigos indicaram resultados favoráveis na autopercepção em relação à voz, qualidade vocal e de vida e conscientização de práticas benéficas e prejudiciais à voz.
ABSTRACT
RESUMO Objetivo Traduzir e adaptar de forma transcultural o Iranian Voice Quality of Life Profile (IVQLP) para o português brasileiro (PB). Método O processo de adaptação transcultural foi realizado por meio de cinco etapas: tradução do IVQLP para o PB por três especialistas nativos do PB e fluentes no inglês americano; elaboração de uma versão de consenso; retrotradução por um especialista nativo do inglês americano e fluente no PB; análise por um comitê de cinco especialistas e elaboração da versão final do instrumento em PB, denominado IVQLP-Br; e pré-teste. O IVQLP-Br tem o objetivo de avaliar os impactos da voz de uma forma mais abrangente, englobando vários domínios da vida dos indivíduos, apresenta 43 itens e uma chave de respostas de cinco pontos. Para o pré-teste foi acrescida como opção para o respondente a alternativa "não aplicável". Participaram do pré-teste 36 indivíduos adultos com risco autorrelatado para disfonia. Resultados Na etapa de tradução 10 itens foram modificados e na retrotradução, 15 itens necessitaram de ajustes. Nenhum item precisou ser reformulado após a aplicação na população-alvo, pois a opção "não aplicável" apareceu em doze respostas, porém, sem significância estatística. Conclusão Conclui-se que a versão traduzida do IVQLP para o PB, denominado IVQLP-Br, apresentou equivalência transcultural e pode ser utilizada para uma análise mais detalhada do impacto da voz nos diferentes domínios da vida dos indivíduos. Após a validação, o IVQLP-Br poderá contribuir tanto para a prática clínica, quanto para pesquisas com falantes do PB.
ABSTRACT Purpose To cross-culturally adapt the Voice Quality of Life Profile (IVQLP) into Brazilian Portuguese (BP). Methods The cross-cultural adaptation process was performed in five stages: translation of the IVQLP into BP by three native BP experts fluent in American English; preparation of a consensus version; back-translation by a native American English expert fluent in BP; analysis by a committee of five experts and preparation of the final version of the instrument in BP, which was named IVQLP-Br; and pre-testing. The IVQLP-Br aims to assess the impacts of the voice more comprehensively, encompassing various areas of an individual's life. It has 43 items and a five-level response key. For the pre-test, the alternative "not applicable" was added as a response option. Thirty-six adults with self-reported risk of dysphonia participated in the pre-test. Results In the translation stage, ten items were modified, and during the back-translation, 15 items required adjustments. No questions required reformulation after the application of the IVQLP-Br in the target population, because the option "not applicable" appeared in 12 responses without statistical significance. Conclusion The version of the IVQLP translated into BP, named the IVQLP-Br, exhibited cross-cultural equivalence and was administrable for a more detailed analysis of the impact of the voice in different domains of an individual's life. After validation, the IVQLP-Br will be able to contribute both to clinical practice and to research with BP speakers.
ABSTRACT
Objetivo: Adaptar lingüística y culturalmente el cuestionario Singing Voice Handicap Index (SVHI) al español chileno. Metodología: Se realizó la traducción directa al español chileno del SVHI y posteriormente la retrotraducción al idioma original inglés; ambas traducciones fueron revisadas por un juicio de expertos bilingües, quienes definieron qué ítems conformarían la primera versión de la herramienta traducida. Esta versión fue respondida por 15 cantantes chilenos con diagnóstico de disfonía, con el objetivo de identificar discrepancias, las que fueron revisadas y consensuadas por el comité de expertos; una segunda versión modificada fue aplicada a 5 cantantes más con diagnóstico de disfonía, no encontrándose en esta fase preguntas incomprendidas o inapropiadas para la cultura chilena. Resultados: Se modificaron 5 de los 9 ítems cuestionados para llegar la versión final que refleja la versión original del inglés, tanto en la cantidad de ítems como en los dominios de la encuesta. Limitaciones: Por la cantidad de personas participantes, se pudo realizar solamente la adaptación cultural y no la validación del instrumento que considere puntajes de corte para la población estudiada. Por lo tanto, la herramienta puede ser usada para realizar un análisis cualitativo y no cuantitativo. Valor: Contar con esta encuesta traducida, siguiendo un proceso metodológico riguroso, permite que cantantes chilenos manifiesten su desventaja vocal relacionada con el canto, además de identificar los dominios más afectados y, de esa forma, planificar de manera más específica la intervención vocal. Conclusión: Se cuenta con el cuestionario Índice de desventaja en voz cantada para el español chileno para su aplicación al idioma y cultura chilena.
Purpose: To adapt the Singing Voice Handicap Index (SVHI) questionnaire linguistically and culturally to Chilean Spanish. Methodology: The SVHI was directly translated into Chilean Spanish and later back-translated into the original English language; both translations were reviewed by a judgment of bilingual experts, who defined which items would make up the first version of the translated tool. This version was answered by 15 Chilean singers with a diagnosis of dysphonia, with the aim of identifying discrepancies, which were reviewed and agreed upon by the committee of experts; a second modified version was applied to 5 more singers with a diagnosis of dysphonia, not finding misunderstood or inappropriate questions for Chilean culture at this stage. Results: 5 of the 9 items questioned were modified to reach the final version that reflects the original English version, both in the number of items and in the domains of the survey. Limitations: Due to the number of participating people, only the cultural adaptation could be carried out and not the validation of the instrument that considers cut-off scores for the population studied. Therefore, the tool can be used to carry out a qualitative and not quantitative analysis. Value: Having this survey translated, following a rigorous methodological process, allows Chilean singers to express their singing-related vocal disadvantage and identify the most affected domains and, thus, plan the vocal intervention more specifically. Conclusion: The Singing Voice Disadvantage Index questionnaire for Chilean Spanish is available for its application to the Chilean language and culture.
ABSTRACT
Introducción: El hiatus glótico longitudinal es un signo descrito en la práctica clínica a partir de las fibrolaringoscopias de pacientes con patologías laríngeas. Objetivo: Describir la prevalencia de patologías laríngeas orgánicas y funcionales mediante videolaringoestroboscopia, y evaluar la frecuencia de hiatus longitudinal y su asociación con patología orgánica en pacientes adultos disfónicos. Material y Método: Se realizó un estudio retrospectivo y descriptivo durante 2018-2019 en un hospital de alta complejidad. Se incluyeron las videolaringoestroboscopia de pacientes mayores de 14 años que consultaron por disfonía. Las patologías laríngeas se categorizaron en orgánicas o funcionales. La asociación entre patología orgánica y el hiatus longitudinal se analizó mediante un análisis multivariado ajustado por confundidores. Resultados: Se incluyeron 310 pacientes de los cuales se analizaron 269. La media de edad fue 43,9 ± 7,09 años y el porcentaje de sexo femenino 65,8% (n: 177). La prevalencia de disfonía orgánica fue del 84,01% y de disfonía funcional, del 13,38%. La prevalencia de hiatus longitudinal fue del 23,79% (n: 64). Se observó una asociación, estadísticamente significativa entre la presencia de hiatus longitudinal y la presencia de patología orgánica con OR de12,64 (1,60-99,42; p: 0,01) ajustada por edad, sexo, tabaquismo y antigüedad de la disfonía. Conclusión: La prevalencia de patologías laríngeas orgánicas es mayor a la de funcionales y el hiatus longitudinal se asocia a patología orgánica ajustada por confundidores.
Introduction: Spindle-shaped glottic chink is a sign described in clinical practice from fibrolaryngoscopy of patients with laryngeal pathologies. Aim: to describe the prevalence of organic and functional laryngeal pathologies by videolaringostroboscopy, and to evaluate the frequency of spindle-shaped glottic chink and its association with organic pathology in dysphonic adult patients. Material and Method: A retrospective and descriptive study was conducted during 2018-2019 in a high complexity hospital. Patient's videostroboscopy older than 14 years old who consulted for dysphonia were included. Laryngeal pathologies were categorized into organic or functional diseases. The association between organic pathology and spindle-shaped glottic chink was analyzed using a multivariate analysis adjusted for confounders. Results: 310 patients were included of whom 269 patients were analyzed. The mean age was 43.9 ± 7.09 years and the percentage of female sex was 65.8 % (n: 177). The prevalence of organic dysphonia was 84.01% and of functional dysphonia, 13.38%. The prevalence of spindle-shaped glottic chink was 23.79% (n:64) (18.67-28.91%). A statistically significant association was observed between the presence of spindle-shaped glottic chink and the presence of organic pathology with OR of 12.64 (1.60- 99.42; p: 0.01) adjusted for age, sex, smoking status and history of dysphonia. Conclusion: The prevalence of organic laryngeal pathology is higher than functional and spindle-shaped glottic chink is associated with organic pathology adjusted for confounders.
Subject(s)
Humans , Male , Female , Adolescent , Adult , Laryngeal Diseases/epidemiology , Dysphonia/epidemiology , Chi-Square Distribution , Laryngeal Diseases/diagnosis , Epidemiology, Descriptive , Prevalence , Sex Distribution , Age Distribution , Dysphonia/diagnosis , Laryngoscopy/methodsABSTRACT
Objetivo: Los trastornos de la voz son muy frecuentes en la población pediátrica, entre el 6% y el 23% de todos los niños presentan alguna forma de disfonía. La evaluación de la voz abarca los aspectos perceptuales, análisis acústico, métodos de diagnóstico visual, y cuestionarios que orientan al impacto sobre la calidad de vida. El objetivo de nuestro estudio es realizar la traducción, transculturalización y validación del cuestionario Children Voice Handicap Index (CVHI) a hispanohablantes latinoamericanos. Material y Método: El estudio se realizó en el Hospital Italiano de Buenos Aires, Argentina y en el Hospital de Niños Dr. Luis Calvo Mackenna de Santiago de Chile. Se incluyeron pacientes entre 8 y 15 años de edad. Se tradujo, transculturalizó y validó el CVHI para dicha población. Se realizó el cuestionario en dos grupos de pacientes: un grupo de niños con antecedentes de disfonías, n = 48 y el otro grupo pacientes de control, sin patología de la voz, n = 86. El cuestionario se aplicó a los niños, en presencia de sus cuidadores o padres, con la correspondiente conformidad. Resultados: Se encontró una diferencia significativa entre ambos grupos (p < 0,05) con una confianza interna óptima de 0,98 obtenida mediante alfa de Cronbach y una alta fiabilidad test-retest (correlación de Pearson = 0,96). Conclusión: La validación y transculturalización del CVHI para la población hispanohablante de latinoamérica presentó una adecuada validez y fiabilidad. Complementar la evaluación de la patología vocal con un sencillo cuestionario de auto-rrealización en población pediátrica, constituye una valiosa herramienta que completa el diagnóstico del impacto de la alteración de la voz en la calidad de vida.
Aim: Voice disorders are very common in the pediatric population, since between 6% and 23% of all children present some type of dysphonia. Voice evaluation includes perceptual aspects, acoustic analysis, visual diagnostic methods, and questionnaires that guide the impact on quality of life. The objective of this study is to carry out the translation, transculturalization and validation of the Children Voice Handicap Index (CVHI) questionnaire for Latin American Spanish speakers. Material and Method: The study was conducted at the Italian Hospital in Buenos Aires, Argentina and at the Dr. Luis Calvo Mackenna Children's Hospital in Santiago de Chile, Chile. Patients between 8 and 15 years of age were included. The CVHI was translated, transculturalized, and validated for said population. The questionnaire was carried out in two groups of patients: a group of children with a history of dysphonia, n = 48, and the other group, control patients, without voice pathology, n = 86. The questionnaire was applied to the children, in the presence of their caregivers or parents, with the corresponding consent. Results: A significant difference was found between both groups (p < 0.05) with an optimal internal confidence of 0.98 obtained using Cronbach's alpha and high test-retest reliability (Pearson's correlation = 0.96). Conclusion: The validation and transculturalization of the CVHI for the Spanish-speaking population of Latin America presented adequate validity and reliability. Complementing the evaluation of vocal pathology with a simple self-administration questionnaire in the pediatric population constitutes a valuable tool that completes the diagnosis of the impact of voice alteration on quality of life.
Subject(s)
Humans , Male , Female , Child , Adolescent , Voice Disorders/diagnosis , Voice Disorders/epidemiology , Dysphonia/diagnosis , Dysphonia/epidemiology , Argentina/epidemiology , Chile/epidemiology , Surveys and Questionnaires , Self-TestingABSTRACT
Introdução: Materiais educativos sobre cuidados com a voz dão apoio no atendimento clínico e prevenção de disfonia, entretanto, são escassos. Portanto, este estudo objetivou elaborar e avaliar um guia sobre saúde vocal infantil para pais e crianças. Descrição: A elaboração do guia abrangeu: Levantamento Bibliográfico nas bases de dados Biblioteca Virtual em Saúde (BVS) e Público/editora MEDLINE (PubMed); Escrita dos temas; Organização/escrita dos conteúdos/referências; Seleção de imagens. Estruturação do guia: Produção da voz; Sinais/sintomas mais comuns de alterações vocais; Causas dos distúrbios vocais infantis; Consequências do distúrbio vocal infantil; Profissionais envolvidos no diagnóstico e tratamento; Mito e Verdade sobre voz; Como prevenir o distúrbio vocal infantil; Atividades amigas da voz. A avaliação foi em grupo focal, via Google Meet, com três juízes mestrandos em Fonoaudiologia, que discutiram qualitativamente estética, conteúdo e organização. A discussão foi coordenada pela coorientadora e as indicações, realizadas por consenso entre os juízes: Estética - ajustar local das referências, elaborar jogo de trilha, uniformizar desenhos/cores e criar mascote; Conteúdo - material relevante, diminuir textos, adequar a linguagem para crianças, usar links/QR-Code para informações extras e acrescentar orientações para professores; Organização - tópicos em ordem hierárquica, conteúdo relacionado ao tema e separar assuntos por capítulos. Considerações Finais: Foram apontadas mudanças, porém, os juízes ressaltaram a importância deste material na clínica fonoaudiológica e na promoção de saúde vocal. O grupo focal foi importante para a primeira avaliação do guia. (AU)
Introduction: Educational materials on voice care support in clinical care and dysphonia prevention, however, are scarce. Therefore, this study aimed to elaborate and evaluate a guide on child vocal health for parents and children. Description: The elaboration of the guide covered: Bibliographic Survey in the databases Biblioteca Virtual em Saúde (BVS) and MEDLINE Public/Publisher (Pubmed); Themes writing; Organization/writing of the contents/references; Selection of images. Structure of the guide: Voice production; Most common signs/symptoms of vocal disorders; Causes of voice disorders in childhood; Consequences of voice disorders in childhood; Professionals involved in diagnosis and treatment; Myth and Truth about voice; How to prevent vocal disorder in childhood; Voice-friendly activities. The evaluation was in a focus group, via Google Meet, with three Master Judges in Speech Therapy, who discussed qualitatively aesthetics, content and organization. The discussion was coordinated by the co-supervisor and the following recommendations were consensus among the judges: Aesthetics - adjust location of references, elaborate track game, standardize drawings/colors and, create mascot; Content -relevant material, decrease texts, tailor language for children, use/QR-Code links for extra information and, add guidance for teachers; Organization - topics in hierarchical order, content according to theme and separate subjects by chapters. Final Considerations: Improvements were pointed out, however, the judges emphasized the importance of this material in the speech therapy clinic and vocal health promotion. The focus group was important for the guide's first evaluation. (AU)
Introducción: Los materiales educativos sobre cuidados con la voz dan apoyo en la atención clínica y prevención de la disfonía, sin embargo, son escasos. Por lo tanto, este estudio tuvo como objetivo elaborar y evaluar una guía sobre salud vocal infantil para padres e hijos. Descripción: La elaboración de la guía abarcó: Levantamiento Bibliográfico en las bases de datos Biblioteca Virtual en Salud (BVS)/MEDLINE Público/Editor (PubMed); Escritura de los temas; Organización/escritura de los contenidos/referencias; Selección de imágenes. Estructuración de la guía: Producción de la voz; Signos/síntomas más comunes de alteraciones vocales; Causas de los trastornos vocales infantiles; Consecuencias del trastorno vocal infantil; Profesionales involucrados en el diagnóstico y tratamiento; Mito y Verdad sobre voz; Cómo prevenir el trastorno vocal infantil; Actividades amigas de la voz. La evaluación fue en grupo focal, vía Google Meet, con tres jueces maestres en Fonoaudiología, que discutieron cualitativamente estética, contenido y organización. La discusión fue conducida por la coordinadora y las indicaciones, realizadas por consenso entre los jueces: Estética - ajustar lugar de las referencias, elaborar juego de pista, uniformizar dibujos/colores y crear mascota; Contenido - material relevante, disminuir textos, adecuar el lenguaje para niños, usar links/QR-Code para informaciones extras y añadir orientaciones para profesores; Organización - tópicos en orden jerárquico, contenido relacionado al tema y separar asuntos por capítulos. Consideraciones Finales: Se señalaron cambios, sin embargo, los jueces resaltaron la importancia de este material en la clínica fonoaudiológica y en la promoción de salud vocal. El grupo focal fue importante para la primera evaluación de la guía. (AU)
Subject(s)
Humans , Child , Voice , Child Health , Practice Guidelines as Topic/standards , Health Education , Focus Groups , Dysphonia/prevention & control , Dysphonia/therapy , Health Promotion/methodsABSTRACT
Introducción: la infección por COVID-19 afecta el tracto aerodigestivo superior a través de la enzima convertidora de angiotensina 2 (ECA2) y/o la proteasa transmembrana serina 2 (TMPRSS2). Sus manifestaciones agudas y secuelas han sido muy variadas y no todas están relacionadas con la intubación orotraqueal. El objetivo es describir las características sociodemográficas, clínicas y los hallazgos endoscópicos de los pacientes con síntomas laringofaríngeos posteriores a una infección por SARS-CoV-2 evaluados en el Hospital Militar Central y Hospital Universitario Clínica San Rafael entre marzo de 2020 y marzo de 2022. Materiales y métodos: estudio observacional de corte transversal con datos sociodemográficos, comorbilidades, necesidad de intubación orotraqueal, variedad de síntomas y sus hallazgos endoscópicos. Resultados: se recolectaron datos de 118 pacientes; la edad media fue de 51 años ± 14,4. El síntoma más frecuente fue la disfonía (69,5 %), seguido de la disnea (39,8 %). El 58,9 % requirió intubación orotraqueal y, de estos, la manifestación más frecuente fue disfonía por tensión muscular (DTM) y estenosis subglótica-traqueal. En el 41,1 % restante su hallazgo más frecuente fue la laringitis irritativa. Conclusiones: la COVID-19 tiene múltiples manifestaciones laringofaríngeas en relación con su mecanismo de infección e invasión en los tejidos de esta zona, de tipo inflamatorio y estructural, y no todos están relacionados con la intubación.
Introduction: COVID 19 infection affects the upper aerodigestive tract through angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) and/or Transmembrane serine protease 2 (TMPRSS2). Its acute manifestations and sequelae have been very varied, and not all of them are related to orotracheal intubation. The objective is to describe the sociodemographic and clinical characteristics and the endoscopic findings of patients with laryngopharyngeal symptoms after SARS-CoV-2 infection evaluated at the Hospital Militar Central and Hospital Universitario Clínica San Rafael between March 2020 and March 2022. Methods: Cross-sectional observational study, obtaining sociodemographic data, comorbidities, need for orotracheal intubation, variety of symptoms and their endoscopic findings. Results: 118 patients were collected; the mean age was 51 years ± 14.4. The most frequent symptom was dysphonia (69.5%), followed by dyspnea (39.8%). 58.9% required orotracheal intubation and of these the most frequent manifestation was muscular tension dysphonia (MTD) and subglottictracheal stenosis. In the remaining 41.1%, the most frequent finding was irritative laryngitis. Conclusions: COVID-19 has multiple laryngopharyngeal manifestations in relation to its mechanism of infection and invasion in the tissues of this area, as an inflammatory and structural type, and not all of them are related to intubation.
Subject(s)
Humans , Male , Female , COVID-19 , Larynx , Tracheal Stenosis , Deglutition Disorders , Laryngitis , Laryngostenosis , DysphoniaABSTRACT
Abstract Introduction Dysphonia and lower pitch after surgery of Reinke edema are common. They are caused especially due to chronic smoking but, probably, other factors should be associated. Objectives To evaluate the results of laryngeal microsurgery in patients with Reinke edema, following a standardized postoperative guidance protocol in our service. Methods Retrospective study. Thirty patients (3 males; 27 females) were included, 70% between 41 and 60 years old. The parameters analyzed in the pre- and postoperative (between 4 and 6 months) of patients undergoing laryngeal microsurgery for Reinke edema were: smoking, vocal symptoms, videolaryngostroboscopy, voice therapy, perceptual and acoustic vocal evaluation, histopathological report. Results Smoking was reported by 100% of the patients and maintained in the postoperative period by 80%. Complete improvement of symptoms in the postoperative period was reported by 43% of them, partial improvement by 40%, and maintenance by 17%. There was low adherence to voice therapy in the pre- and postsurgery. Postoperative videolaryngoscopy indicated congestion (19), atrophy and bowed vocal fold (1), subepithelial edema (2), and normal findings (8). The histological findings were subepithelial edema, enlargement of vessels, inflammation, epithelial hyperplasia, and thickening of the basement membrane. The perceptual and acoustic vocal analyzes indicated improvement of the analyzed parameters. Conclusions The maintenance of some vocal symptoms and laryngeal alterations in videolaryngoscopy after microsurgery of Reinke edema is frequent, even in patients who follow the recommendations of vocal rest and control of gastroesophageal reflux. Vocal symptoms are attributed to changes in the laryngeal mucosa caused by chronic smoking, aggravated by the maintenance of addiction in the postoperative period.
ABSTRACT
Involvement of larynx is a uncommon manifestation but could be the first time when the patient may be reporting to a specialist. This is the case report of a 65-year-old man who presented with dysphonia, was evaluated and was diagnosed as lepromatous leprosy with laryngeal involvement. On clinical examination the patient was found to have signs of leprosy – leonine face, nodular involvement of ears, madarosis, oedema of hands and feet, trophic ulcer on right foot. Bilateral greater auricular nerves were found to be enlarged. Video laryngoscopy revealed pale edematous epiglottis, arytenoid and aryepiglottic folds, with nodules on epiglottis. Biopsy from aryepiglottic fold and skin both was done. The diagnosis of lepromatous leprosy was confirmed with histopathology of biopsy from both skin and epiglottic fold. MRI imaging of the neck with contrast showed diffuse hyperintensity in the glottic-supraglottic larynx with asymmetry in the aryepiglottic fold and vocal cord. This experience shows that clinical suspicion is most critical element in reaching the diagnosis of leprosy
ABSTRACT
RESUMO Objetivo comparar as tarefas de emissão de vogal e de contagem de números na diferenciação perceptivo-auditiva de crianças com e sem lesão laríngea. Método Estudo observacional, analítico, transversal. Utilizou-se banco de dados de uma pesquisa de doutorado, com resultados de avaliações laringológicas e gravação de amostras vocais de 44 crianças que se dividiram em: Grupo sem lesão laríngea (GSLL), com 33 crianças; e grupo com lesão laríngea (GCLL), com 11 crianças. Para a avaliação perceptivo-auditiva, as amostras vocais foram separadas de acordo com o tipo de tarefa e analisadas separadamente por uma juíza, que analisou o grau geral do desvio vocal e informou se, diante de uma situação de triagem, a criança passaria ou falharia. Resultados Houve diferença entre os grupos GSLL e GCLL quanto ao grau geral do desvio vocal para tarefa de emissão de números, com predomínio de desvios discretos no GSLL e moderados no GCLL. Quanto à triagem, houve diferença entre os grupos para a tarefa de contagem, com mais falhas no GCLL. Os grupos foram semelhantes na tarefa de vogal, tanto no que se refere à intensidade do desvio quanto ao resultado da triagem. A maior parte das crianças do GCLL falhou em ambas as tarefas na situação de triagem vocal, com diferença em relação às crianças do GSLL que, em geral, falharam em apenas uma tarefa. Conclusão A tarefa de contagem de números contribui para a diferenciação auditiva de crianças com e sem lesão laríngea, por identificar desvios de maior intensidade em crianças com lesão.
ABSTRACT Purpose To compare the vowel emission and number counting tasks in perceptual-auditory differentiation among children with and without laryngeal lesions. Methods Observational, analytical, and cross-sectional methods were used. Medical records of 44 children were selected from a database of an otorhinolaryngology service at a University Hospital and they were divided into groups: without laryngeal lesion (WOLL), and with laryngeal lesion (WLL), with 33 and 11 children. For the auditory-perceptual evaluation, the vocal samples were separated according to the type of task. They were analyzed separately by a judge who analyzed the general degree of vocal deviation and assessed whether the child would pass or fail in the face of a screening situation. Results There was a difference between the WOLL and WLL groups in terms of the overall degree of vocal deviation for the task of number counting, with a predominance of mild deviations in WOLL and moderate in WLL. In the screening, there was a difference between the groups during the number counting task, with more failures in the WLL. The groups were similar in the sustained vowel task, both in terms of the overall degree of vocal deviation and the vocal screening. Most children in the WLL failed in both tasks during vocal screening compared to the children in the WOLL who, in general, failed in only one task. Conclusion The task of number counting contributes to the auditory differentiation in children with and without laryngeal lesion, by identifying deviations of greater intensity in children with laryngeal lesion.
ABSTRACT
RESUMO Objetivo Comparar a eficiência de diferentes instrumentos de autoavaliação vocal para o rastreio da disfonia. Método Participaram 262 indivíduos disfônicos e não disfônicos, com média de idade de 41,3 (±14,5) anos. O diagnóstico da disfonia foi dado a partir da análise perceptivo-auditiva da vogal sustentada "é" e do diagnóstico laringológico. Foram coletadas as respostas dos instrumentos: Questionário de Qualidade de Vida em Voz (QVV), Índice de Desvantagem Vocal (IDV), IDV-10, Escala de Sintomas Vocais (ESV) e do Br-DST (Brazilian Dysphonia Screening Tool), denominado no português brasileiro como Instrumento de Rastreio da Disfonia (IRDBR). Para análise da assertividade destes em relação à presença da disfonia, foram utilizados os pontos de corte de cada instrumento e a regra de decisão preconizada pelo IRDBR. Foi realizada uma análise exploratória para comparação das médias dos escores dos instrumentos e verificação de associações entre as variáveis. Resultados Os instrumentos avaliados foram sensíveis para captar o impacto da disfonia de forma semelhante independentemente do uso profissional da voz e tipo de disfonia. Foi observada diferença apenas nos escores da ESV para a variável sexo, com maior pontuação observada no sexo feminino. Em relação à assertividade global, os instrumentos apresentaram elevados índices de acerto na classificação, com destaque para a ESV que apresentou maior índice (86,3%), seguida do IRDBR (84,0%), QVV (80,9%), IDV (78,2%) e IDV-10 (75,2%). Conclusão A ESV apresenta maior índice de assertividade na identificação da disfonia, seguida do IRDBR. O IRDBR é uma ferramenta curta, simples e de fácil aplicação para procedimentos de rastreio.
ABSTRACT Purpose To compare the efficiency of different vocal self-assessment instruments for dysphonia screening. Methods 262 dysphonic and non-dysphonic individuals participated in the research. The mean age was 41.3 (±14.5) years. The diagnosis of dysphonia was based on the auditory-perceptual analysis of the sustained vowel "é" and on laryngological diagnosis. The responses of the instruments were collected: Voice-Related Quality of Life (V-RQOL), Voice Handicap Index (VHI), VHI-10, Voice Symptoms Scale (VoiSS), and the Brazilian Dysphonia Screening Tool, (Br-DST) called in Brazilian Portuguese Instrumento de Rastreio da Disfonia (IRDBR). To analyze assertiveness in relation to the presence of dysphonia, the cutoff points of each instrument and the decision rule recommended by the IRDBR were used. An exploratory analysis was performed to compare mean scores of instruments and verify associations between variables. Results The instruments evaluated were sensitive to capture the impact of dysphonia in a similar way regardless of professional voice use and type of dysphonia. There was a difference only in VoiSS scores for the variable gender, with a higher score for females. Regarding global assertiveness, the instruments showed high rates of success in classification, with emphasis on the VoiSS, which had the highest rate (86.3%), followed by the IRDBR (84.0%), VQL (80.9%), VHI (78.2%), and VHI-10 (75.2%). Conclusion The VoiSS has the highest assertiveness index in the identification of dysphonia, followed by the IRDBR. The IRDBR is a short, simple, and easy-to-apply tool for screening procedures.