Repeatability and Reproducibility of a New Ocular Biometer Based on Partial Coherence Interferometry and Its Agreement with IOL Master 500 / 中山大学学报(医学科学版)

ABSTRACT

ObjectiveTo assess the repeatability （intra-operator variability） and reproducibility （inter-operator variability） of a new partial coherence interferometry （PCI）-based ocular biometer， Myopia Master， and its agreement with IOL Master 500 for measuring axial length （AL） and corneal curvature （K） in children aged 8-12 years. MethodsThe same operator measured school children with the Myopia Master and the IOL Master 500 in random order to assess agreement. Additionally， some of these children received measurements from another operator using the Myopia Master to assess repeatability and reproducibility. AL， flat keratometry （Kf）， steep keratometry （Ks）， mean keratometry （Km）， J0 and J45 were analyzed. The repeatability and reproducibility were assessed by the within-subject standard deviation （Sw）， test-retest repeatability （TRT）， coefficient of variation （CoV） and intra-class correlation coefficient （ICC）. The agreement between the Myopia Master and the IOL Master 500 was assessed by Bland-Altman plots and 95% limits of agreement （LoA）. ResultsBoth repeatability and reproducibility of the Myopia Master were high for AL measurements （Sw=0.02 mm， ICC=0.999； Sw=0.04 mm， ICC=0.998）， but moderate for K measurements （Sw range， 0.04 to 0.12 D， ICC range， 0.861 to 0.991； Sw range， 0.06 to 0.20 D， ICC range， 0.835 to 0.992）. There were significant mean differences between the Myopia Master and the IOL Master 500 in measurements of AL （-0.01±0.04） mm， Kf （-0.09 ± 0.15） D， Ks （-0.47±0.40） D， and Km （-0.28±0.23） D， J0 （0.18±0.20） D and J45 （-0.01±0.12） D. ConclusionsThe Myopia Master provided high repeatability and reproducibility for AL measurements in schoolchildren with myopia， but the Myopia Master and the IOL Master 500 cannot be used interchangeably in measuring AL and K.