Meta-analysis of long-term survival of standard and extended pancreaticoduodenectomy for carcinoma of the head of pancreas / 中华普通外科杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To compare the complication and long-term efficacy of standard and extended pancreaticoduodenectomy for carcinoma of the head of pancreas by meta-analysis.Methods A literature search was performed of PubMed,Web of Science,Springer,WanFang,CNKI and CBMDisc databases from January 1990 to August 2014.Qualitative analysis of these literatures was conducted using Jadad evaluation.Patients with pancreatic head carcinoma undergoing extended radical resection and standard radical resection were divided into treatment group (extended pancreaticoduodenectomy group,EPD) and control group (standard pancreaticoduodenectomy group,SPD),respectively.Based on the heterogeneity test,meta-analysis of a fixed-or random-effect model were used.Results A total of 5 studies suitable for the selection criteria were chosen,involving 597 patients (299 in EPDs and 298 in SPDs).The results of meta-analysis showed that the EPDs have significantly longer operative time (MD =64.36,95％ CI =23.88-104.85,P =0.002) and more dissected lymph nodes (MD =16.45,95％ CI =9.61-23.29,P ＜ 0.000 01) than SPDs.There was no statistical difference (OR =1.76,95 ％ CI =0.66-4.65,P =0.26) in postoperative complications (46.3％ vs 36.0％) mortality (OR =1.31,95％ CI =0.47-3.69,P =0.61),1-year survival rate (OR =0.70,95 ％ CI =0.49-0.99,P =0.05),3-year survival rate (OR =0.79,95％ CI =0.55-1.15,P =0.22),and 5-year survival rate (OR =-0.02,95％ CI =-0.17-0.12,P =0.77).Conclusions Compared with standard radical resection,extended radical resection for pancreatic head carcinoma does not prolong the postoperative 1-,3-,and 5-year survival rates with comparable postoperative mortality and morbidity and prolonged operative time.