Efficacy comparison of buttress plating and cannulated screw fixation of Regan-Morrey type II ulnar coronoid fractures / 中华创伤杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective:To compare the clinical effect of buttress plate fixation and cannulated screw fixation of Regan-Morrey type II ulnar coronoid fractures.Methods:A retrospective case control study was made on 53 patients with Regan-Morrey type II ulnar coronoid fractures admitted to Wuxi No.9 People 's Hospital from April 2015 to January 2018，including 36 males and 17 females，aged from 21 to 63 years［（36.3±7.1）years］. Among them，24 patients were treated using buttress plates（plate group），and 29 patients using cannulated screws（screw group）. The operation time and fracture healing time were documented. The visual analogue score（VAS），range of motion of elbow flexion and extension and forearm rotation and Mayo elbow performance score（MEPS）were assessed at postoperative 1，3，6 months and at the last follow-up. The incidence of complications was observed as well. Results:All patients were followed up for 15-18 months［（15.9±1.3）months］. The operation time in plate group［（150.6±24.2）minutes］was longer than that in screw group［（126.8±18.3）minutes］（ P<0.05）. There was no significant difference in fracture healing time or VAS between the two groups（ P>0.05）. After 1，3，6 months and during the last follow-up，the range of motion of elbow joint flexion and extension in plate group［（87.2±5.8）°，（109.2±7.1）°，（121.3±6.2）°，（127.3±5.4）°］was higher than that in screw group［（70.5±9.1）°，（90.2±4.5）°，（108.3±5.1）°，（116.2±4.6）°］，the range of motion of forearm rotation in plate group［（78.3±9.1）°，（98.7±8.6）°，（130.2±7.1）°，（139.2±6.7）°］was higher than that in screw group［（60.1±5.1）°，（80.6±8.7）°，（116.1±5.5）°，（127.3±4.1）°］，and the MEPS in plate group［（30.6±7.6）points，（68.1±6.1）points，（90.2±4.3）points，（95.2±2.1）points］was higher than that in screw group［（27.2±8.1）points，（54.1±7.1）points，（82.1±5.3）points，（88.2±5.2）points］（all P<0.05）. In plate group，one patient sustained superficial wound infection at postoperative 1 week，which was healed uneventfully after surgical debridement and antibiotic therapy；two patients had heterotopic ossification without addition surgery. In screw group，three patients presented screw loosening and fracture redisplacement during early movement，which was healed by reducing the intensity of elbow functional exercise and prolonging the protection time of brace；four patients had heterotopic ossification，among which one combined with elbow stiffness showed improved range of motion of the elbow after elbow release at postoperative 12 months. The incidence of complications in plate group［13%（3/24）］was lower than that in screw group［26%（7/29）］（ P<0.05）. Conclusion:For Regan-Morrey type II ulnar coronoid fractures，the buttress plate fixation is superior to the cannulated screw fixation in fixation strength，recovery of elbow function and incidence of complications in regardless of longer operation time.