A public health approach for leprosy detection based on a very short term-training of primary health care workers in basic dermatology.

INTRODUCTION: In countries where leprosy control is integrated to general heath services, health workers, at primary health care level, often manage a large number of patients with skin diseases including leprosy. The distinction of leprosy from others skin diseases requires more skill and attention. Basic dermatological knowledge will help these staff to provide a better quality of care. A few years ago, a short term training programme focussed on leprosy and some common skin diseases was set up in Mali through a pilot project. This study will evaluate the impact of this training on the detection of leprosy at primary health care level. METHODS: health care workers from two health districts were invited to participate in the training. Trainee was submitted to an anonymous written test before training, immediately after and 12-18 months post-training using a standardized scoring system. The suspected or referred leprosy cases before and after training were compared. Data were recorded and analysed with the software Epi info version 6.04. RESULTS: Overall, 495 HCW attended the three anonymous written tests (before training, just after and 12-18 months later). The proportion of participants who gave correct answers before training, just after were respectively: 33 and 57% for correct diagnosis, 5 and 39% for test of sensation and 28 and 47% for referral. Eight patients suspected of leprosy were referred for further examination; in these, five cases of leprosy were detected. DISCUSSION: The training showed a huge improvement in the skill of the participants in managing leprosy patients. This study addresses how leprosy control can be improved by involving primary health care staff and by the implementation of only a single day's training on basic dermatology. CONCLUSION: The role of the dermatologist in this post-elimination era of leprosy needs to be reconsidered and adapted to the increasing need to take multiple programmes, inclusive of dermatology and leprosy, into primary health care services and those interested in leprosy control should fund these programmes.

High prevalence of non-leprotic hypochromic patches among children in a rural area of Mali, West Africa.

The identification of one or several hypochromic patches (HP) on the skin is a key stage in the diagnosis of leprosy on dark skin. However, HP are often caused by other disorder than leprosy. A study to determine the prevalence and causes of HP among children was carried out in a rural area of Mali in November 2001. All children under 15 years of age in two villages in an endemic area were screened by two dermatologists. Among the 1729 children seen, HP were identified in 71 patients, with a prevalence of 4.1%. The most common cause of HP was tinea versicolor, which was present in 39.4% of children with HP, followed by pityriasis alba in 31%, naevus achromicus in 24% and vitiligo in 5.6%. No case of leprosy was detected. Our study raises several points with practical consequences for the detection of leprosy cases: the high prevalence of non-leprous HP compared to leprosy, the reliability of the clinical diagnosis of leprosy, and the role of general health care workers in the detection of leprosy cases. Helping those who should be involved in that detection in distinguishing true cases from other hypochromic disorders appears to be a priority.

Definition of an algorithm for the management of common skin diseases at primary health care level in sub-Saharan Africa.

In order to help primary health care (PHC) workers in developing countries in the care of common skin diseases, an algorithm for the management of pyoderma, scabies, superficial mycoses, contact dermatitis and referral of early leprosy cases (based on the identification of diseases through the presence of objective key signs, and on treatments by generic drugs) was elaborated. One thousand patients were seen by trained dermatologists, who established diagnoses and treatments; in addition, there was systematic recording of each key sign, according to the successive algorithm steps. We compared the diagnostics and treatments obtained for several combinations of diagnostic signs, with those of the dermatologists. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value of defined combinations were high for pyoderma, scabies and superficial mycoses. Values were less exact for dermatitis and leprosy, but were considered sufficient for the level of health care targeted. The apportionment of treatments between the algorithm and the dermatological approaches was considered appropriate in more than 80% of cases; mismanagement was possible in 7% of cases, with few predictable harmful consequences. The algorithm was found satisfactory for the management of the dermatological priorities according to the standards required at the PHC level.

[Evaluation of the clinical classification of new cases of leprosy. Study conducted at the Marchoux Institute in Bamako, Mali]. / Evaluation de la classification clinique des nouveaux cas de lèpre. Etude réalisée á l'Institut Marchoux (Bamako, Mali).

INTRODUCTION: The difficulties related to the bacilloscopic diagnosis of leprosy, providing a more reliable classification of cases, in 1995 led the WHO to recommend the use of a new classification, in endemic countries, based on clinical criteria alone, in order to simplify the poly-chemotherapeutic regimens. According to our experience in the Marchoux Institute, this classification may lead to errors in diagnosis through overzealous or mis-interpretation of the two forms of leprosy. The aim of our study was to evaluate the concordance between this clinical classification and that based on a bacilloscopic examination. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We conducted a descriptive study of new cases of leprosy seen at the Marchoux Institute, without distinction in gender or age, from January to December 2000. All the patients included underwent clinical examination and a bacilloscopic exploration to provide a double classification. The concordance between the two classifications was assessed using the Kappa test. RESULTS: Two hundred new cases of leprosy were included. Out of 126 clinically multi-bacillary cases, 61 were confirmed bacteriologically, and 65 were false positives. Out of 74 clinical cases with few bacilli, 2 were bacteriologically multi-bacilli. The concordance between the two classifications was average (Kappa=0.40). There was a significant difference between the percentages of multi-bacilli observed in both classifications (p<10(-8)). DISCUSSION: The clinical classification may well overestimate the multi-bacillary form. In the absence of a reliable bacilloscopic apparatus, a more detailed clinical classification of leprosy forms must be developed.

Evaluation de la classification clinique des nouveaux cas de lèpre. Etude réalisée à lInstitut Marchoux (Bamako, Mali) / Evaluation of the clinical classification of new cases of leprosy. Study conducted at the Marchoux Institute in Bamako, Mali

INTRODUCTION: The difficulties related to the bacilloscopic diagnosis of leprosy, providing a more reliable classification of cases, in 1995 led the WHO to recommend the use of a new classification, in endemic countries, based on clinical criteria alone, in order to simplify the poly-chemotherapeutic regimens. According to our experience in the Marchoux Institute, this classification may lead to errors in diagnosis through overzealous or mis-interpretation of the two forms of leprosy. The aim of our study was to evaluate the concordance between this clinical classification and that based on a bacilloscopic examination. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We conducted a descriptive study of new cases of leprosy seen at the Marchoux Institute, without distinction in gender or age, from January to December 2000. All the patients included underwent clinical examination and a bacilloscopic exploration to provide a double classification. The concordance between the two classifications was assessed using the Kappa test.RESULTS: Two hundred new cases of leprosy were included. Out of 126 clinically multi-bacillary cases, 61 were confirmed bacteriologically, and 65 were false positives. Out of 74 clinical cases with few bacilli, 2 were bacteriologically multi-bacilli. The concordance between the two classifications was average (Kappa=0.40). There was a significant difference between the percentages of multi-bacilli observed in both classifications (p<10(-8)). DISCUSSION: The clinical classification may well overestimate the multi-bacillary form. In the absence of a reliable bacilloscopic apparatus, a more detailed clinical classification of leprosy forms must be developed.

[Predictive value of consultation reasons in the diagnosis of leprosy in Bamako (Mali)]. / Valeur prédictive des motifs de consultation pour le diagnostic de lèpre à Bamako (Mali).

INTRODUCTION: One of the weak points in the strategy for eliminating leprosy is the poor quality of screening. To overcome this, the World Health Organization (WHO) encourages endemic countries to run campaigns for the elimination of leprosy by circulating educational messages and mobilizing the medical community for early screening of cases. The aim of our study was to identify the motives for consultation with high predictive value for the diagnosis of leprosy and to determine the late diagnosis factors and hence assist the staff on site to improve the results of their leprosy elimination campaigns. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The study consisted, during the second trimester of 1999, in interviewing all the patients consulting for the first time the Marchoux Institute or the units screening for leprosy in the Bamako area. The interview recorded the motives for consultation, the delay before consulting and the reasons for late consulting. To assess their positive predictive value, the motives for consultation were related to the diagnosis retained (leprosy or not). RESULTS: One thousand one hundred and seventy seven patients were interviewed. The motive for consulting, "suspected leprosy", scored the highest positive predictive value (PPV) (80 p. 100): 12 cases of leprosy were diagnosed by 15 consultants having suspected leprosy. Neurological problems were the second motive for consultation (PPV=61.9 p. 100). The most frequent motive for consultation was spots or "macules" (20 p. 100 of consultations), but only provided a positive predictive value of 19 p. 100. Prior consultations and non-specialized treatments were identified as factors of delay in diagnosing leprosy (P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Diagnosis of leprosy cannot be based on the motives for dermatological consultation alone. The macules are the most apparent signs, but of low predictive value. Nevertheless, they are an early but non-specific sign of leprosy and are often neglected by the patient. Other than macules, attention must be paid to the neurological signs (dysesthesia, motor disorders) when screening for leprosy. These signs may appear early on, or be observed at a late stage in the progression of the disease.

[Systematic search for parasites among leprosy patients in Mali]. / Recherche systématique de parasites chez les lépreux au Mali.

Practice of multidrug therapy in leprosy (combination Dapsone + Rifampicine + Clofazimine) established since 1981, has significantly reduced the incidence of the disease. However, immunosuppression due to treatment of multi-drugs therapy induced adverse reactions with glucocorticoid and the change in host immune response due to the leprosy itself, might increase the risk of parasitic infections. To test this hypothesis, we carried out a case-control study at the "Institut Marchoux" in Bamako. Stool and urine samples from all patients included in the study were examined for parasites identification. In addition, we performed thick and thin blood film to identify malaria infection and skin biopsy (snip) to detect onchocerciasis. A total of 121 cases of leprosy and 219 controls aged 10-84 years old were included in the study from March 1999 to February 2000. Sixty two percent (n = 121) of cases were treated with glucocorticoid. The prevalence of infection due to Entamoeba coli and Entamoeba histolytica were higher in cases than in controls (p = 0.02). The prevalence of infection due to hookworms was higher in cases than in controls. There was no difference of the infections to the other intestinal parasites. Three cases of cryptosporidiosis and one case of isosporosis were observed in leprosy group vs none in the control group. There was no significant difference between cases and controls with regard to prevalence of Schistosoma haematobium, Trichomonas vaginalis and Onchocera volvulus. The prevalence of Plasmodium falciparum was 4.9% (6/121) in the leprosy case and 7.8% (17/219) in the control group. In conclusion, despite the corticotherapy and immunosuppression due to leprosy, there was no difference in prevalence of pathogenic parasites. Entomoeba coli, Entamoeba histolytica which have significantly higher prevalence among the cases were not pathogen therefore there was no higher risk of severe intestinal parasitosis among the cases of leprosy. Treatment with glycocorticoid in patients with leprosy did not suggest any impact on the prevalence of this parasitic infections. In addition, multidrug therapy did not show any effect on the carriage of Plasmodium falciparum.

Valeur prédictive des motifs de consultation pour le diagnostic de lèpre à Bamako (Mali) / Predictive value of medical reasons in the diagnosis of leprosy in Bamako (Mali)

INTRODUCTION: One of the weak points in the strategy for eliminating leprosy is the poor quality of screening. To overcome this, the World Health Organization (WHO) encourages endemic countries to run campaigns for the elimination of leprosy by circulating educational messages and mobilizing the medical community for early screening of cases. The aim of our study was to identify the motives for consultation with high predictive value for the diagnosis of leprosy and to determine the late diagnosis factors and hence assist the staff on site to improve the results of their leprosy elimination campaigns. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The study consisted, during the second trimester of 1999, in interviewing all the patients consulting for the first time the Marchoux Institute or the units screening for leprosy in the Bamako area. The interview recorded the motives for consultation, the delay before consulting and the reasons for late consulting. To assess their positive predictive value, the motives for consultation were related to the diagnosis retained (leprosy or not). RESULTS: One thousand one hundred and seventy seven patients were interviewed. The motive for consulting, "suspected leprosy", scored the highest positive predictive value (PPV) (80 p. 100): 12 cases of leprosy were diagnosed by 15 consultants having suspected leprosy. Neurological problems were the second motive for consultation (PPV=61.9 p. 100). The most frequent motive for consultation was spots or "macules" (20 p. 100 of consultations), but only provided a positive predictive value of 19 p. 100. Prior consultations and non-specialized treatments were identified as factors of delay in diagnosing leprosy (P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Diagnosis of leprosy cannot be based on the motives for dermatological consultation alone. The macules are the most apparent signs, but of low predictive value. Nevertheless, they are an early but non-specific sign of leprosy and are often neglected by the patient. Other than macules, attention must be paid to the neurological signs (dysesthesia, motor disorders) when screening for leprosy. These signs may appear early on, or be observed at a late stage in the progression of the disease.

Recherche systematique de parasites chez les lepreux au Mali / Systematic search for parasites among patients with leprosy in Mali

Practice of multidrug therapy in leprosy (combination Dapsone + Rifampicine + Clofazimine) established since 1981, has significantly reduced the incidence of the disease. However, immunosuppression due to treatment of multi-drugs therapy induced adverse reactions with glucocorticoid and the change in host immune response due to the leprosy itself, might increase the risk of parasitic infections. To test this hypothesis, we carried out a case-control study at the "Institut Marchoux" in Bamako. Stool and urine samples from all patients included in the study were examined for parasites identification. In addition, we performed thick and thin blood film to identify malaria infection and skin biopsy (snip) to detect onchocerciasis. A total of 121 cases of leprosy and 219 controls aged 10-84 years old were included in the study from March 1999 to February 2000. Sixty two percent (n = 121) of cases were treated with glucocorticoid. The prevalence of infection due to Entamoeba coli and Entamoeba histolytica were higher in cases than in controls (p = 0.02). The prevalence of infection due to hookworms was higher in cases than in controls. There was no difference of the infections to the other intestinal parasites. Three cases of cryptosporidiosis and one case of isosporosis were observed in leprosy group vs none in the control group. There was no significant difference between cases and controls with regard to prevalence of Schistosoma haematobium, Trichomonas vaginalis and Onchocera volvulus. The prevalence of Plasmodium falciparum was 4.9% (6/121) in the leprosy case and 7.8% (17/219) in the control group. In conclusion, despite the corticotherapy and immunosuppression due to leprosy, there was no difference in prevalence of pathogenic parasites. Entomoeba coli, Entamoeba histolytica which have significantly higher prevalence among the cases were not pathogen therefore there was no higher risk of severe intestinal parasitosis among the cases of leprosy. Treatment with glycocorticoid in patients with leprosy did not suggest any impact on the prevalence of this parasitic infections. In addition, multidrug therapy did not show any effect on the carriage of Plasmodium falciparum.

[New cases of leprosy at the Marchoux Institute: a comparative study 1988-1997]. / Nouveaux cas de lèpre à l'Institut Marchoux (Bamako, Mali).

BACKGROUND: The prevalence of leprosy had declined greatly over the last decade. The purpose of this work was to determine whether changes in the epidemiology, clinical and bacteriological patterns occurred among patients with leprosy treated at the Marchoux Institute in 1988 and in 1997. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We conducted a descriptive cross-sectional study, reviewing retrospectively all files of patients with leprosy seen in 1988 in comparison with a prospective series of leprosy patients seen in 1997. Only new cases of leprosy, prior to treatment and with skin and/or nervous lesions irrespective of the bacilloscopy results, were included in the two series. RESULTS: We included 93 patients among 246 patient files in 1988. There were 119 new cases in 1997. The following variables showed changes: mean delay to consultation (41.2 months in 1988 versus 26.1 months in 1997; patient's suspicion of having leprosy (93 patients in 1988 versus 22 in 1997); notion of contact (35 cases in 1988 versus 45 in 1997). Multibacilli leprosy predominated over paucibacilli leprosy in 1988 (51 versus 42 cases). This trend was inverted in 1997 (44 versus 75) (p<0.009). Patients with grade 2 handicap were more numerous in 1988 (20 cases versus 2 cases, p<0.001). CONCLUSION: These findings demonstrate a change in the epidemiology, clinical and bacilloscopic pattern of patients with leprosy from 1988 to 1997.

Epidemiologic aspects of scabies in Mali, Malawi, and Cambodia.

BACKGROUND: The prevalence rates of scabies are compared in Bamako, Mali, Karonga District, Malawi, and Battambang Province, Cambodia. METHODS: In Mali, children attending three different urban schools catering for different socio-economic levels were examined specifically for scabies. In Malawi, data were collected during a total population survey for leprosy. In Cambodia, a sample survey was carried out in a rural area to determine the prevalence of leprosy and other skin diseases. RESULTS: In Mali, the prevalence rate of scabies among all the children examined was 4% (44/1103), but only 1.8% (7/388) in the higher socio-economic group. In Malawi, the overall prevalence rate of scabies was 0.7% (408/61,735). The highest rate (1.1%) was found among children 0-9 years of age. In Cambodia, the overall prevalence in the 13 villages screened was 4.3% (645/14,843). The highest rate (6.5%) was found among children 0-9 years of age. CONCLUSIONS: Scabies was most prevalent among children in Cambodia and Malawi, but there were considerable differences in the overall rates between the two areas studied. The data from all three countries indicate that poor socio-economic conditions, in particular crowding and public water supplies, are risk factors for scabies.

[Leprosy. Developmental modalities]. / Lèpre. Modalités évolutives.

The very broad clinical spectrum of the Mycobacterium leprae infection is due to the diversity of the underlying immunological and genetic factors. The evolutive modalities of leprosy are mainly determined by a dual pathogenesis: An infectious disease due to a bacillus of low virulence which, even when dead, persists in the body for several years, independently of the antibiotic therapy prescribed. A dysimmune disease maintained by a chronic discharge of antigens. Neuropathies and leprous reactions are still the most troublesome episodes in the course of the disease. They constitute the principal prognostic factor in both pauci- and multibacillary forms of leprosy.