Audiogram Estimation Performance Using Auditory Evoked Potentials and Gaussian Processes.

OBJECTIVES: Auditory evoked potentials (AEPs) play an important role in evaluating hearing in infants and others who are unable to participate reliably in behavioral testing. Discriminating the AEP from the much larger background activity, however, can be challenging and time-consuming, especially when several AEP measurements are needed, as is the case for audiogram estimation. This task is usually entrusted to clinicians, who visually inspect the AEP waveforms to determine if a response is present or absent. The drawback is that this introduces a subjective element to the test, compromising quality control of the examination. Various objective methods have therefore been developed to aid clinicians with response detection. In recent work, the authors introduced Gaussian processes (GPs) with active learning for hearing threshold estimation using auditory brainstem responses (ABRs). The GP is attractive for this task, as it can exploit the correlation structure underlying AEP waveforms across different stimulus levels and frequencies, which is often overlooked by conventional detection methods. GPs with active learning previously proved effective for ABR hearing threshold estimation in simulations, but have not yet been evaluated for audiogram estimation in subject data. The present work evaluates GPs with active learning for ABR audiogram estimation in a sample of normal-hearing and hearing-impaired adults. This involves introducing an additional dimension to the GP (i.e., stimulus frequency) along with real-time implementations and active learning rules for automated stimulus selection. METHODS: The GP's accuracy was evaluated using the "hearing threshold estimation error," defined as the difference between the GP-estimated hearing threshold and the behavioral hearing threshold to the same stimuli. Test time was evaluated using the number of preprocessed and artifact-free epochs (i.e., the sample size) required for locating hearing threshold at each frequency. Comparisons were drawn with visual inspection by examiners who followed strict guidelines provided by the British Society of Audiology. Twenty-two normal hearing and nine hearing-impaired adults were tested (one ear per subject). For each subject, the audiogram was estimated three times: once using the GP approach, once using visual inspection by examiners, and once using a standard behavioral hearing test. RESULTS: The GP's median estimation error was approximately 0 dB hearing level (dB HL), demonstrating an unbiased test performance relative to the behavioral hearing thresholds. The GP additionally reduced test time by approximately 50% relative to the examiners. The hearing thresholds estimated by the examiners were 5 to 15 dB HL higher than the behavioral thresholds, which was consistent with the literature. Further testing is still needed to determine the extent to which these results generalize to the clinic. CONCLUSIONS: GPs with active learning enable automatic, real-time ABR audiogram estimation with relatively low test time and high accuracy. The GP could be used to automate ABR audiogram estimation or to guide clinicians with this task, who may choose to override the GP's decisions if deemed necessary. Results suggest that GPs hold potential for next-generation ABR hearing threshold and audiogram-seeking devices.

Efficient Detection of Cortical Auditory Evoked Potentials in Adults Using Bootstrapped Methods.

BACKGROUND: Statistical detection methods are useful tools for assisting clinicians with cortical auditory evoked potential (CAEP) detection, and can help improve the overall efficiency and reliability of the test. However, many of these detection methods rely on parametric distributions when evaluating test significance, and thus make various assumptions regarding the electroencephalogram (EEG) data. When these assumptions are violated, reduced test sensitivities and/or increased or decreased false-positive rates can be expected. As an alternative to the parametric approach, test significance can be evaluated using a bootstrap, which does not require some of the aforementioned assumptions. Bootstrapping also permits a large amount of freedom when choosing or designing the statistical test for response detection, as the distributions underlying the test statistic no longer need to be known prior to the test. OBJECTIVES: To improve the reliability and efficiency of CAEP-related applications by improving the specificity and sensitivity of objective CAEP detection methods. DESIGN: The methods included in the assessment were Hotelling's T2 test, the Fmp, four modified q-sample statistics, and various template-based detection methods (calculated between the ensemble coherent average and some predefined template), including the correlation coefficient, covariance, and dynamic time-warping (DTW). The assessment was carried out using both simulations and a CAEP threshold series collected from 23 adults with normal hearing. RESULTS: The most sensitive method was DTW, evaluated using the bootstrap, with maximum increases in test sensitivity (relative to the conventional Hotelling's T2 test) of up to 30%. An important factor underlying the performance of DTW is that the template adopted for the analysis correlates well with the subjects' CAEP. CONCLUSION: When subjects' CAEP morphology is approximately known before the test, then the DTW algorithm provides a highly sensitive method for CAEP detection.

A study of the relationship between the video head impulse test and air calorics.

The video head impulse test (vHIT) has been proposed as an objective approach to detect peripheral vestibular disorder in a clinical setting. Data from several studies indicate that the vHIT is a useful addition to the vestibular test battery and can give complementary information to caloric testing. This study explores the relationship between lateral canal vestibular occular reflex gain measured using the vHIT system and canal paresis indicated using air calorics in a sample of patients attending a clinic for balance disorder. Sensitivity and specificity of the vHIT test relative to calorics was studied for a clinical sample of 51 patients (20 male, 31 female) who attended a private clinic for balance disorders. vHIT gains were compared to the manufacturer's normative range and to data from a normative study using 30 young volunteers. Of 14 patients in the clinical sample that had significant canal paresis indicated by air calorics, only 4 showed a significant abnormality in either canal using a measurement of vHIT gain. vHIT gain does not correlate with canal paresis as indicated by air caloric testing. vHIT gain appears relatively insensitive to peripheral vestibular disorder as indicated by air caloric testing, although patients that had no caloric response on one side showed abnormal vHIT gain. vHIT testing may be a useful addition to the existing vestibular test battery, but it does not appear to be an alternative to it.

Modified T2 Statistics for Improved Detection of Aided Cortical Auditory Evoked Potentials in Hearing-Impaired Infants.

The cortical auditory evoked potential (CAEP) is a change in neural activity in response to sound, and is of interest for audiological assessment of infants, especially those who use hearing aids. Within this population, CAEP waveforms are known to vary substantially across individuals, which makes detecting the CAEP through visual inspection a challenging task. It also means that some of the best automated CAEP detection methods used in adults are probably not suitable for this population. This study therefore evaluates and optimizes the performance of new and existing methods for aided (i.e., the stimuli are presented through subjects' hearing aid(s)) CAEP detection in infants with hearing loss. Methods include the conventional Hotellings T2 test, various modified q-sample statistics, and two novel variants of T2 statistics, which were designed to exploit the correlation structure underlying the data. Various additional methods from the literature were also evaluated, including the previously best-performing methods for adult CAEP detection. Data for the assessment consisted of aided CAEPs recorded from 59 infant hearing aid users with mild to profound bilateral hearing loss, and simulated signals. The highest test sensitivities were observed for the modified T2 statistics, followed by the modified q-sample statistics, and lastly by the conventional Hotelling's T2 test, which showed low detection rates for ensemble sizes <80 epochs. The high test sensitivities at small ensemble sizes observed for the modified T2 and q-sample statistics are especially relevant for infant testing, as the time available for data collection tends to be limited in this population.