The Evidence for Selective Loss of Otolithic Function.

Recent advances in vestibular testing now permit functional testing of all peripheral vestibular sense organs (all three semicircular canals, utricle, and saccule). This makes it possible to identify patients with isolated dysfunction of the utricle or saccule, even though parallel pathways for vestibular information are ultimately integrated centrally. Selective, isolated unilateral loss of utricular function as measured by ocular vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs) has been observed in patients with normal semicircular canal function as measured by the video head impulse test of all six semicircular canals, and normal bilateral saccular function as determined by symmetrical cervical VEMPs. How these patients present clinically and how they recover is discussed and contrasted with acute vestibular neuritis. In some patients, the unilateral loss of otolith organ (utricle or saccule) function persists and yet the patient recovers functionally to their usual lifestyle. Until the testing of all peripheral vestibular sense organs is routine, the frequency of isolated loss of otolith function cannot be gauged.

A review of mechanical and synaptic processes in otolith transduction of sound and vibration for clinical VEMP testing.

Older studies of mammalian otolith physiology have focused mainly on sustained responses to low-frequency (<50 Hz) or maintained linear acceleration. So the otoliths have been regarded as accelerometers. Thus evidence of otolithic activation and high-precision phase locking to high-frequency sound and vibration appears to be very unusual. However, those results are exactly in accord with a substantial body of knowledge of otolith function in fish and frogs. It is likely that phase locking of otolith afferents to vibration is a general property of all vertebrates. This review examines the literature about the activation and phase locking of single otolithic neurons to air-conducted sound and bone-conducted vibration, in particular the high precision of phase locking shown by mammalian irregular afferents that synapse on striolar type I hair cells by calyx endings. Potassium in the synaptic cleft between the type I hair cell receptor and the calyx afferent ending may be responsible for the tight phase locking of these afferents even at very high discharge rates. Since frogs and fish do not possess full calyx endings, it is unlikely that they show phase locking with such high precision and to such high frequencies as has been found in mammals. The high-frequency responses have been modeled as the otoliths operating in a seismometer mode rather than an accelerometer mode. These high-frequency otolithic responses constitute the neural basis for clinical vestibular-evoked myogenic potential tests of otolith function.

Neural basis of new clinical vestibular tests: otolithic neural responses to sound and vibration.

Extracellular single neuron recording and labelling studies of primary vestibular afferents in Scarpa's ganglion have shown that guinea-pig otolithic afferents with irregular resting discharge are preferentially activated by 500 Hz bone-conducted vibration (BCV) and many also by 500 Hz air-conducted sound (ACS) at low threshold and high sensitivity. Very few afferent neurons from any semicircular canal are activated by these stimuli and then only at high intensity. Tracing the origin of the activated neurons shows that these sensitive otolithic afferents originate mainly from a specialized region, the striola, of both the utricular and saccular maculae. This same 500 Hz BCV elicits vestibular-dependent eye movements in alert guinea-pigs and in healthy humans. These stimuli evoke myogenic potentials, vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs), which are used to test the function of the utricular and saccular maculae in human patients. Although utricular and saccular afferents can both be activated by BCV and ACS, the differential projection of utricular and saccular afferents to different muscle groups allows for differentiation of the function of these two sensory regions. The basic neural data support the conclusion that in human patients in response to brief 500 Hz BCV delivered to Fz (the midline of the forehead at the hairline), the cervical VEMP indicates predominantly saccular function and the ocular VEMP indicates predominantly utricular function. The neural, anatomical and behavioural evidence underpins clinical tests of otolith function in humans using sound and vibration.

Effect of stimulus rise-time on the ocular vestibular-evoked myogenic potential to bone-conducted vibration.

OBJECTIVES: The negative potential at 10 msec (called n10) of the ocular vestibular-evoked myogenic potential (oVEMP) recorded beneath the eyes in response to bone-conducted vibration (BCV) delivered to the skull at the midline in the hairline (Fz) is a new indicator of otolithic, and in particular utricular, function. Our aim is to find the optimum combination of frequency and rise-time for BCV stimulation, to improve the sensitivity of oVEMP testing in the clinic. DESIGN: We tested 10 healthy subjects with 6 msec tone bursts of BCV at three stimulus frequencies, 250, 500, and 750 Hz, at rise-times ranging between 0 and 2 msec. The BCV was delivered at Fz. RESULTS: The n10 response was significantly larger at the shorter rise-times, being largest at zero rise-time. In addition, we examined the effect of stimulus frequency in these same subjects by delivering 6 msec tone bursts at zero rise-time at a range of frequencies from 50 to 1200 Hz. The main effect of rise-time was significant with shorter rise-times leading to larger n10 responses and the Rise-Time × Frequency interaction was significant so that at low frequencies (100 Hz) shorter rise-times had a modest effect on n10 whereas at high frequencies (750 Hz) shorter rise-times increased n10 amplitude substantially. The main effect of frequency was also significant: The n10 response tended to be larger at lower frequency, being largest between 250 and 500 Hz. CONCLUSIONS: In summary, in this sample of healthy subjects, the most effective stimulus for eliciting oVEMP n10 to BCV at Fz was found to be a tone burst with a rise-time of 0 msec at low stimulus frequency (250 or 500 Hz).

A Review of Neural Data and Modelling to Explain How a Semicircular Canal Dehiscence (SCD) Causes Enhanced VEMPs, Skull Vibration Induced Nystagmus (SVIN), and the Tullio Phenomenon.

Angular acceleration stimulation of a semicircular canal causes an increased firing rate in primary canal afferent neurons that result in nystagmus in healthy adult animals. However, increased firing rate in canal afferent neurons can also be caused by sound or vibration in patients after a semicircular canal dehiscence, and so these unusual stimuli will also cause nystagmus. The recent data and model by Iversen and Rabbitt show that sound or vibration may increase firing rate either by neural activation locked to the individual cycles of the stimulus or by slow changes in firing rate due to fluid pumping ("acoustic streaming"), which causes cupula deflection. Both mechanisms will act to increase the primary afferent firing rate and so trigger nystagmus. The primary afferent data in guinea pigs indicate that in some situations, these two mechanisms may oppose each other. This review has shown how these three clinical phenomena-skull vibration-induced nystagmus, enhanced vestibular evoked myogenic potentials, and the Tullio phenomenon-have a common tie: they are caused by the new response of semicircular canal afferent neurons to sound and vibration after a semicircular canal dehiscence.

A review of the geometrical basis and the principles underlying the use and interpretation of the video head impulse test (vHIT) in clinical vestibular testing.

This paper is concerned mainly with the assumptions underpinning the actual testing procedure, measurement, and interpretation of the video head impulse test-vHIT. Other papers have reported in detail the artifacts which can interfere with obtaining accurate eye movement results, but here we focus not on artifacts, but on the basic questions about the assumptions and geometrical considerations by which vHIT works. These matters are crucial in understanding and appropriately interpreting the results obtained, especially as vHIT is now being applied to central disorders. The interpretation of the eye velocity responses relies on thorough knowledge of the factors which can affect the response-for example the orientation of the goggles on the head, the head pitch, and the contribution of vertical canals to the horizontal canal response. We highlight some of these issues and point to future developments and improvements. The paper assumes knowledge of how vHIT testing is conducted.

Ocular and cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potentials to 500 Hz fz bone-conducted vibration in superior semicircular canal dehiscence.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of superior semicircular canal dehiscence (SSCD) on the n10 component of the ocular vestibular evoked myogenic potential (oVEMP n10) and the p13-n23 component of the cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potential (cVEMP p13-n23) evoked by 500 Hz bone-conducted vibration (BCV) at the midline forehead at the hairline (Fz) in 26 patients with computed tomography-verified SSCD. Previous evidence has led to the proposal that the oVEMP n10 is of utricular origin whereas the cVEMP p13-n23 is of saccular origin. The question is can the oVEMP n10 to 500 Hz BCV indicate SSCD? DESIGN: A hand-held Bruel & Kjaer 4810 Minishaker was used to provide BCV stimulation using surface electromyography electrodes to record oVEMP n10 and cVEMP p13-n23. The stimulus was 7 msec bursts of 500 Hz BCV at either Fz or at the vertex of the skull (Cz). Twenty-seven healthy subjects were tested in the same paradigm. RESULTS: In response to 500 Hz Fz BCV in SSCD patients the oVEMP n10 amplitude beneath the contraSSCD eye was substantially and significantly larger than the oVEMP n10 beneath the ipsiSSCD eye, whereas in these same patients the cVEMP p13-n23 amplitude over the ipsiSSCD sternocleidomastoid muscle to Fz BCV was slightly but significantly larger than the cVEMP p13-n23 amplitude over the contraSSCD sternocleidomastoid muscle. In SSCD patients there was a significant relationship between the size of the dehiscence and the amplitude of the contralateral oVEMP n10 potential. The oVEMP n10 to Cz stimulation was still present in SSCD patients, but small or absent in healthy subjects. CONCLUSIONS: In response to 500 Hz Fz BCV an asymmetrical oVEMP n10 with a significantly increased amplitude of contralesional oVEMP n10 (compared with population values of healthy subjects) is a simple useful indicator of SSCD, confirmed by the Cz response. oVEMP testing with 500 Hz Fz BCV allows very simple, very fast identification of a probable unilateral SSCD.

Vestibular function in Lermoyez syndrome at attack.

Lermoyez syndrome (LS) has been regarded as a variant of Ménière's disease (MD), but so far there have been very few cases of LS reported in the literature, so such a conclusion is debatable. Specifying the pattern of auditory and vestibular changes at attack using objective quantitative measures is important for understanding the mechanism responsible for MD and LS. Here we report the first objective measures of dynamic otolith function and dynamic semicircular canal function in an LS patient at the time of the attack as well as at quiescence, documenting the fluctuation in otolith and semicircular canal function in the patient. The very rapid changes in dynamic vestibular function at the time of the LS attack appear to complement some of the rapid changes in auditory and vestibular function at the attack in Ménière's disease, supporting the contention that LS is a variant of MD.

A Single Fast Test for Semicircular Canal Dehiscence-oVEMP n10 to 4000 Hz-Depends on Stimulus Rise Time.

As previously reported, a single test measuring oVEMP n10 to 4000 Hz stimuli (bone-conducted vibration (BCV) or air-conducted sound (ACS)) provides a definitive diagnosis of semicircular canal dehiscence (SCD) in 22 CT-verified patients, with a sensitivity of 1.0 and specificity of 1.0. This single short screening test has great advantages of speed, minimizing testing time, and the exposure of patients to stimulation. However, a few studies of the 4000 Hz test for SCD have reported sensitivity and specificity values which are slightly less than reported previously. We hypothesized that the rise time of the stimulus is important for detecting the oVEMP n10 to 4000 Hz, similarly to what we had shown for 500 and 750 Hz BCV. We measured oVEMP n10 in 15 patients with CT-verified SCD in response to 4000 Hz ACS or BCV stimuli with rise times of 0, 1, and 2 ms. As a result, increasing the rise time of the stimulus reduced the oVEMP n10 amplitude. This outcome is expected from the physiological evidence of guinea pig primary vestibular afferents, which are activated by sound or vibration. Therefore, for clinical VEMP testing, short rise times are optimal (preferably 0 ms).

Vestibular semicircular canal function as detected by video Head Impulse Test (vHIT) is essentially unchanged in people with Parkinson's disease compared to healthy controls.

BACKGROUND: Parkinson's disease (PD) is a common multi-system neurodegenerative disorder with possible vestibular system dysfunction, but prior vestibular function test findings are equivocal. OBJECTIVE: To report and compare vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) gain as measured by the video head impulse test (vHIT) in participants with PD, including tremor dominant and postural instability/gait dysfunction phenotypes, with healthy controls (HC). METHODS: Forty participants with PD and 40 age- and gender-matched HC had their vestibular function assessed. Lateral and vertical semicircular canal VOR gains were measured with vHIT. VOR canal gains between PD participants and HC were compared with independent samples t-tests. Two distinct PD phenotypes were compared to HC using Tukey's ANOVA. The relationship of VOR gain with PD duration, phenotype, severity and age were investigated using logistic regression. RESULTS: There were no significant differences between groups in vHIT VOR gain for lateral or vertical canals. There was no evidence of an effect of PD severity, phenotype or age on VOR gains in the PD group. CONCLUSION: The impulsive angular VOR pathways are not significantly affected by the pathophysiological changes associated with mild to moderate PD.

Enhanced Eye Velocity in Head Impulse Testing-A Possible Indicator of Endolymphatic Hydrops.

Introduction: On video head impulse testing (vHIT) of semicircular canal function, some patients reliably show enhanced eye velocity and so VOR gains >1.0. Modeling and imaging indicate this could be due to endolymphatic hydrops. Oral glycerol reduces membranous labyrinth volume and reduces cochlear symptoms of hydrops, so we tested whether oral glycerol reduced the enhanced vHIT eye velocity. Study Design: Prospective clinical study and retrospective analysis of patient data. Methods: Patients with enhanced eye velocity during horizontal vHIT were enrolled (n = 9, 17 ears) and given orally 86% glycerol, 1.5 mL/kg of body weight, dissolved 1:1 in physiological saline. Horizontal vHIT testing was performed before glycerol intake (time 0), then at intervals of 1, 2, and 3 h after the oral glycerol intake. Control patients with enhanced eye velocity (n = 4, 6 ears) received water and were tested at the same intervals. To provide an objective index of enhanced eye velocity we used a measure of VOR gain which captures the enhanced eye velocity which is so clear on inspecting the eye velocity records. We call this measure the initial VOR gain and it is defined as: (the ratio of peak eye velocity to the value of head velocity at the time of peak eye velocity). The responses of other patients who showed enhanced eye velocity during routine clinical testing were analyzed to try to identify how the enhancement occurred. Results: We found that oral glycerol caused, on average, a significant reduction in the enhanced eye velocity response, whereas water caused no systematic change. The enhanced eye velocity during the head impulses is due in some patients to a compensatory saccade-like response during the increasing head velocity. Conclusion: The significant reduction in enhanced eye velocity during head impulse testing following oral glycerol is consistent with the hypothesis that the enhanced eye velocity in vHIT may be caused by endolymphatic hydrops.

Activation of Guinea Pig Irregular Semicircular Canal Afferents by 100 Hz Vibration: Clinical Implications for Vibration-induced Nystagmus and Vestibular-evoked Myogenic Potentials.

HYPOTHESIS: Bone-conducted vibration (BCV) at 100 Hz causes endolymph displacement at hair cell stereocilia in semicircular canal (SCC) ducts of the intact bony labyrinth resulting in activation of irregularly discharging afferent neurons. BACKGROUND: Suprathreshold 100 Hz BCV is employed in the clinic to evoke skull vibration-induced nystagmus, an indicator for peripheral vestibular asymmetry. Recently, this stimulus has also been used in vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials, a selective test for otolithic function. METHODS: We performed extracellular recordings from utricular and SCC afferents in guinea pigs during application of suprathreshold BCV stimuli (100-500 Hz) to the animal's skull. Vibration was administered in a way that the animal, the vibrator, and the recording electrode moved as one. RESULTS: In summary, 19 of 43 recorded SCC afferents displayed a stimulus- and phase-locked increase in firing during stimulation at 100 Hz BCV with no perstimulatory adaptation and no poststimulatory silencing. All of the 19 activated SCC afferents had an irregular resting discharge. Neuronal activation of SCC afferents was less pronounced at 200 Hz and largely absent at 500 Hz. On the contrary, a stimulus- and phase-locked increase in firing was observed for irregularly discharging utricular neurons at all frequencies tested. CONCLUSIONS: At intensities usually applied in the clinic, 500 Hz BCV is a largely selective otolithic stimulus, while 100 Hz BCV can activate both otolith and SCC afferents. Therefore, while 100 Hz BCV is ideally suited for evoking skull vibration-induced nystagmus in peripheral vestibular asymmetry, it is not recommended for vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials, as it lacks otolithic specificity.

Computing Endolymph Hydrodynamics During Head Impulse Test on Normal and Hydropic Vestibular Labyrinth Models.

Hypothesis: Build a biologic geometry based computational model to test the hypothesis that, in some circumstances, endolymphatic hydrops can mechanically cause enhanced eye velocity responses during clinical conditions of the head impulse test. Background: Some recent clinical and experimental findings had suggested that enhanced eye velocity responses measured with the video head impulse test could not only be caused by recording artifacts or central disfunction but also could be directly caused by the mechanical effect of endolymphatic hydrops on horizontal semicircular canal receptor. Methods: Data from clinical video head impulse test was computed in three biologic-based geometry models governed by Navier-Stokes equations; six head impulses of incrementally increasing peak head velocity were computed in each one of the three different geometric models, depending on absence, canal or utricular hydrops. Results: For all computed head impulses an increased endolymphatic pressure was measured at the ampullar region of the horizontal semicircular canal on both canal and utricular hydrops models. The mean of aVOR gain was 1.01 ± 0.008 for the no-hydrops model, 1.14 ± 0.010 for the canal hydrops model was, and 1.10 ± 0.007 for the utricular hydrops model. Conclusion: The results of the physical computation models support-the hypothesis that in endolymphatic hydrops conditions, which are affecting horizontal semicircular canal and utricular region on moderate dilatations, the eye velocity responses output-by the aVOR will be enhanced by a 1.14 factor and aVOR gain values will be enhanced by over 1.1 for impulses to the right side.

Phase-locking of irregular guinea pig primary vestibular afferents to high frequency (>250 Hz) sound and vibration.

Phase-locking of cochlear neurons to sound has been of great value in understanding cochlear transduction. Phase-locking has also been reported previously in irregular vestibular afferents, but detailed information about it is sparse. We measured the phase-locking of guinea pig irregular otolithic neurons and canal neurons (after a semicircular canal dehiscence allowed them to respond) to both sound and vibration stimuli. Irregular vestibular afferents from both otoliths and canals have a range of preferred phase angles which systematically increase as frequency is increased from 250 Hz to above 1000 Hz. Surprisingly vestibular afferents show more precise phase-locking than comparable auditory afferents as reported by Palmer and Russell (1986), and they do so up to higher frequencies. This high precision implies a very sharp, fast threshold for evoking an action potential with minimal variability, and so has implications for the current controversy about hair-cell-afferent transmission in the vestibular system. Following recent evidence, we suggest that potassium in the unique type I-calyx synapse may be a major factor in generating this very precise phase-locking.

Superior Canal Dehiscence Syndrome: Relating Clinical Findings With Vestibular Neural Responses From a Guinea Pig Model.

HYPOTHESIS: In superior canal dehiscence (SCD), fluid displacement of the endolymph activates type I vestibular hair cells in the crista of the affected canal and thus irregular superior canal (SC) neurons in Scarpa's ganglion, which provides the neurophysiological basis for the clinical presentation of SCD. BACKGROUND: Patients with SCD display sound- and vibration-induced vertigo/nystagmus and increased amplitudes of vestibular evoked myogenic potentials. METHODS: Extracellular recordings from n = 25 primary vestibular neurons of 16 female guinea pigs were analyzed. We recorded from the same vestibular neuron before, during and after creating the dehiscence and after closing the dehiscence. Neurobiotin labeling was employed in n = 11 neurons. RESULTS: After SCD, previously unresponsive irregular SC neurons displayed a stimulus-locked increase in discharge during application of air-conducted sound (ACS) or bone-conducted vibration (BCV) for a broad range of frequencies (ACS: 200-4000 Hz; BCV: 500-1500 Hz). This typical response was only observed for irregular SC neurons (n = 19), but not regular SC neurons, or irregular/regular horizontal canal neurons (n = 2 each), and was abolished after closing the dehiscence. Eleven irregular SC neurons responsive to ACS and/or BCV were traced back to calyx synapses in the central crista of the affected superior canal by neurobiotin labeling. CONCLUSIONS: Stimulus-locked activation of irregular SC neurons by ACS and BCV is the neurophysiological basis for sound- and vibration-induced vertigo/nystagmus and increased VEMP amplitudes in SCD. The results of the present study help to improve vestibular diagnostics in patients with suspected SCD.

On the relation between ocular torsion and visual perception of line orientation.

A recent study by Poljac et al. [Poljac, E., Lankheet, M. J. M., & van den Berg, A. (2005). Perceptual compensation for eye torsion. Vision Research, 45(4), 485-496] concluded that there was complete perceptual compensation for ocular torsion, although they did not directly measure ocular torsion. Using a similar eccentric-gaze paradigm to induce changes in torsion, which were directly measured, we found inconsistent torsional eye movements at eccentric fixation, and also failed to detect a significant relationship between ocular torsion and the perception of line orientation. We then used a stimulus known to induce large changes in ocular torsion: on-centre yaw rotation. This stimulus induced a consistent change in the torsional position of the eye which positively correlated to subjects' visual perception of horizontal.

Enhanced Vestibulo-Ocular Reflex Responses on vHIT. Is It a Casual Finding or a Sign of Vestibular Dysfunction?

In current clinical practice, when in response to vHIT testing the observed slow-phase eye-velocity responses are significantly higher than head velocity, the most probable cause is considered to be an inadequate collection method or a recording artifact. We present two cases with clinical diagnoses of Menière's Disease: for both cases, enhanced eye velocity responses were measured with a rigorous vHIT testing protocol. In the first case we measured these enhanced responses on each test performed during a 5 year time series; in the second case multiple measurements were obtained from a patient after the radiologic diagnosis of vestibulo-cochlear hydrops. The two cases presented and the new evidence reported by other researchers suggest that owing to the low probability of artifact and the high consistency of the vHIT measurements, we should consider the hypothesis of a physio-pathologic cause for the enhanced eye responses to vHIT testing of some patients with vestibular dysfunction.

Otolithic Receptor Mechanisms for Vestibular-Evoked Myogenic Potentials: A Review.

Air-conducted sound and bone-conduced vibration activate otolithic receptors and afferent neurons in both the utricular and saccular maculae, and trigger small electromyographic (EMG) responses [called vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs)] in various muscle groups throughout the body. The use of these VEMPs for clinical assessment of human otolithic function is built on the following logical steps: (1) that high-frequency sound and vibration at clinically effective stimulus levels activate otolithic receptors and afferents, rather than semicircular canal afferents, (2) that there is differential anatomical projection of otolith afferents to eye muscles and neck muscles, and (3) that isolated stimulation of the utricular macula induces short latency responses in eye muscles, and that isolated stimulation of the saccular macula induces short latency responses in neck motoneurons. Evidence supports these logical steps, and so VEMPs are increasingly being used for clinical assessment of otolith function, even differential evaluation of utricular and saccular function. The proposal, originally put forward by Curthoys in 2010, is now accepted: that the ocular vestibular-evoked myogenic potential reflects predominantly contralateral utricular function and the cervical vestibular-evoked myogenic potential reflects predominantly ipsilateral saccular function. So VEMPs can provide differential tests of utricular and saccular function, not because of stimulus selectivity for either of the two maculae, but by measuring responses which are predominantly determined by the differential neural projection of utricular as opposed to saccular neural information to various muscle groups. The major question which this review addresses is how the otolithic sensory system, with such a high density otoconial layer, can be activated by individual cycles of sound and vibration and show such tight locking of the timing of action potentials of single primary otolithic afferents to a particular phase angle of the stimulus cycle even at frequencies far above 1,000 Hz. The new explanation is that it is due to the otoliths acting as seismometers at high frequencies and accelerometers at low frequencies. VEMPs are an otolith-dominated response, but in a particular clinical condition, semicircular canal dehiscence, semicircular canal receptors are also activated by sound and vibration, and act to enhance the otolith-dominated VEMP responses.