Comment on "Amphibian fungal panzootic causes catastrophic and ongoing loss of biodiversity".

Scheele et al (Reports, 29 March 2019, p. 1459) bring needed attention to the effects of amphibian infectious disease. However, the data and methods implicating the disease chytridiomycosis in 501 amphibian species declines are deficient. Which species are affected, and how many, remains a critical unanswered question. Amphibians are imperiled; protective actions require public support and robust science.

Breeding Guild Determines Frog Distributions in Response to Edge Effects and Habitat Conversion in the Brazil's Atlantic Forest.

Understanding the response of species with differing life-history traits to habitat edges and habitat conversion helps predict their likelihood of persistence across changing landscape. In Brazil's Atlantic Forest, we evaluated frog richness and abundance by breeding guild at four distances from the edge of a reserve: i) 200 m inside the forest, ii) 50 m inside the forest, iii) at the forest edge, and iv) 50 m inside three different converted habitats (coffee plantation, non-native Eucalyptus plantation, and abandoned pastures, hereafter matrix types). By sampling a dry and a wet season, we recorded 622 individual frogs representing 29 species, of which three were undescribed. Breeding guild (i.e. bromeliad, leaf-litter, and water-body breeders) was the most important variable explaining frog distributions in relation to edge effects and matrix types. Leaf-litter and bromeliad breeders decreased in richness and abundance from the forest interior toward the matrix habitats. Water-body breeders increased in richness toward the matrix and remained relatively stable in abundance across distances. Number of large trees (i.e. DBH > 15 cm) and bromeliads best explained frog richness and abundance across distances. Twenty species found in the interior of the forest were not found in any matrix habitat. Richness and abundance across breeding guilds were higher in the rainy season but frog distributions were similar across the four distances in the two seasons. Across matrix types, leaf-litter species primarily used Eucalyptus plantations, whereas water-body species primarily used coffee plantations. Bromeliad breeders were not found inside any matrix habitat. Our study highlights the importance of primary forest for bromeliad and leaf-litter breeders. We propose that water-body breeders use edge and matrix habitats to reach breeding habitats along the valleys. Including life-history characteristics, such as breeding guild, can improve predictions of frog distributions in response to edge effect and matrix types, and can guide more effective management and conservation actions.

Energy accumulation and amphibian metamorphosis.

Timing of metamorphosis and size at metamorphosis were examined for Hyla crucifer under two densities in the laboratory. Results agree with previously known relationships for ranids and bufonids: at higher densities developmental time is longer, mean size at metamorphosis is smaller, and both parameters have greater variance than at lower densities. Density also affects energy accumulation: under ad libitum feeding conditions, an average individual raised at a higher density is able to accumulate less energy before metamorphosis than an average individual raised at a lower density. The suggestion is made that, in addition to growth and differentiation rates, energy accumulation may be important in determining when amphibian metamorphosis occurs.

Morphological correlates of male mating success in Triprion petasatus and Hyla marmorata (Anura: Hylidae).

Multivariate analyses of 18 morphological variables recorded for amplectant males and females and non-amplectant males of Hyla marmorata and Triprion petasatus reveal that in both of these explosive breeding species, mating is significantly non-random. Females of H. marmorata from the relatively aseasonal environment of the Upper Amazon Basin average larger than males, and amplectant males average larger than non-amplectant males. Females of Triprion petasatus from the seasonal environment of the Yucatan Peninsula average larger than males, the sizes of males are significantly correlated with the sizes of the females with which they are paired in amplexus, and amplectant males have shorter internarial distances than non-amplectant males. For both species, non-random mating is interpretable in terms of sexual selection, but the relative importance of male-male competition and female choice cannot be assessed.