Echocardiography in nonclinical studies: Where are we?

Echocardiography is a powerful, noninvasive tool used both in clinical and nonclinical settings, including in drug development. When used appropriately, it can provide valuable translational information about pharmacodynamics, safety pharmacology, or toxicology, helping to define no-observed-adverse-effect levels and providing guidance for clinical monitoring and dose selection. Echocardiography is advantageous in conducting longitudinal studies and reducing the number of animals used in safety assessments. To this end, there has been no clear enunciation of what constitutes appropriate use of this imaging technology in a nonclinical drug development setting. In this review, we describe the use of echocardiography in nonclinical studies in regulatory submissions to the US Food and Drug Administration Center for Drug Evaluation and Research. In addition, we discuss three main areas: the operator, image acquisition, and image analysis, where variability may affect the reliability of information generated in an echocardiography study. As a path forward, our recommendation is for a multi-disciplinary expert working group to establish guidelines for education and credentialing of nonclinical echocardiographers as well as quality assurance standards for nonclinical echocardiography labs.

Overview of the Components of Cardiac Metabolism.

Metabolism in organs other than the liver and kidneys may play a significant role in how a specific organ responds to chemicals. The heart has metabolic capability for energy production and homeostasis. This homeostatic machinery can also process xenobiotics. Cardiac metabolism includes the expression of numerous organic anion transporters, organic cation transporters, organic carnitine (zwitterion) transporters, and ATP-binding cassette transporters. Expression and distribution of the transporters within the heart may vary, depending on the patient's age, disease, endocrine status, and various other factors. Several cytochrome P450 (P450) enzyme classes have been identified within the heart. The P450 hydroxylases and epoxygenases within the heart produce hydroxyeicosatetraneoic acids and epoxyeicosatrienoic acids, metabolites of arachidonic acid, which are critical in regulating homeostatic processes of the heart. The susceptibility of the cardiac P450 system to induction and inhibition from exogenous materials is an area of expanding knowledge, as are the metabolic processes of glucuronidation and sulfation in the heart. The susceptibility of various transcription factors and signaling pathways of the heart to disruption by xenobiotics is not fully characterized but is an area with implications for disruption of normal postnatal development, as well as modulation of adult cardiac health. There are knowledge gaps in the timelines of physiologic maturation and deterioration of cardiac metabolism. Cross-species characterization of cardiac-specific metabolism is needed for nonclinical work of optimum translational value to predict possible adverse effects, identify sensitive developmental windows for the design and conduct of informative nonclinical and clinical studies, and explore the possibilities of organ-specific therapeutics.

Pediatric cardiovascular safety: challenges in drug and device development and clinical application.

Development of pediatric medications and devices is complicated by differences in pediatric physiology and pathophysiology (both compared with adults and within the pediatric age range), small patient populations, and practical and ethical challenges to designing clinical trials. This article summarizes the discussions that occurred at a Cardiac Safety Research Consortium-sponsored Think Tank convened on December 10, 2010, where members from academia, industry, and regulatory agencies discussed important issues regarding pediatric cardiovascular safety of medications and cardiovascular devices. Pediatric drug and device development may use adult data but often requires additional preclinical and clinical testing to characterize effects on cardiac function and development. Challenges in preclinical trials include identifying appropriate animal models, clinically relevant efficacy end points, and methods to monitor cardiovascular safety. Pediatric clinical trials have different ethical concerns from adult trials, including consideration of the subjects' families. Clinical trial design in pediatrics should assess risks and benefits as well as incorporate input from families. Postmarketing surveillance, mandated by federal law, plays an important role in both drug and device safety assessment and becomes crucial in the pediatric population because of the limitations of premarketing pediatric studies. Solutions for this wide array of issues will require collaboration between academia, industry, and government as well as creativity in pediatric study design. Formation of various epidemiologic tools including registries to describe outcomes of pediatric cardiac disease and its treatment as well as cardiac effects of noncardiovascular medications, should inform preclinical and clinical development and improve benefit-risk assessments for the patients. The discussions in this article summarize areas of emerging consensus and other areas in which consensus remains elusive and provide suggestions for additional research to further our knowledge and understanding of this topic.

Troponin measurements during drug development--considerations for monitoring and management of potential cardiotoxicity: an educational collaboration among the Cardiac Safety Research Consortium, the Duke Clinical Research Institute, and the US Food and Drug Administration.

Drug-induced cardiac toxicity is a recognized challenge in development and implementation of pharmacotherapy. Appropriate biomarkers are needed to detect these abnormalities early in development and to manage the risk of potentially cardiotoxic drugs or biologic agents. Circulating cardiac troponin (cTn) is the most widely used biomarker for detection of myocardial injury. Although most commonly used to detect myonecrosis in the setting of ischemia, cTns are also elevated with other acute and chronic disease processes, including heart failure, renal failure, sepsis, pulmonary embolic disease, and many others. High-sensitivity assays for both cTnI and cTnT are now available that achieve acceptable imprecision (coefficient of variation <10%) at the 99th percentile of a normal reference population. Even more sensitive assays are being developed that detect cTn in ranges that are near the level of normal cellular turnover (apoptosis). These properties of cTn and the continuing evolution of highly sensitive assays position cTn as a potentially uniquely informative marker for early detection of cardiac toxicity. This article summarizes collaborative discussions among key stakeholders in the Cardiac Safety Research Consortium about the use of cTn monitoring in drug development.

Long-term consequences of drugs on the paediatric cardiovascular system.

Many pharmacological and toxicological actions of drugs in children cannot be fully predicted from adult clinical experience or from standard non-clinical toxicology studies. Numerous drugs have direct or indirect pharmacological effects on the heart and are prescribed for children of all ages. Toxicity or secondary effects may be immediate or delayed for years after drug exposure has ceased. Originally, the aim of this review was to compile information on the effect of specific drugs on the post-natal development of the cardiovascular system and to examine long-term follow-up of the use of cardio-active drugs in children. The limited database of published information caused the original question to evolve into an examination of the medical literature for three areas of information: (i) whether vulnerable developmental windows have been identified that reflect the substantial functional development that the cardiovascular system undergoes after birth; (ii) what is known about pharmacological perturbation of development; and (iii) what the likelihood is of drug exposure during childhood. We examined different scenarios for exposure including random, isolated exposure, conditions historically associated with adults, primary or secondary cardiac disease, psychiatric and neurological conditions, asthma, cancer and HIV. Except for random, isolated drug exposures, each category of possible exposure contained numerous drugs known to have either primary or secondary effects on the cardiovascular system or to influence factors associated with atherosclerosis. It is likely that a significant number of children will be prescribed drugs having either direct or indirect effects upon the immature cardiovascular system. A confounding factor is the simultaneous use of over-the-counter medications and herbal or nutraceutical preparations that a patient, parent or guardian does not mention to a prescribing physician. Metabolism is also important in assessing drug effects in children. Differences in body water : body fat ratio, age-related gastrointestinal absorption, distribution, excretion, renal function and drug metabolizing capabilities make it possible for children to have a different metabolite profile for a drug compared with adults. There is little examination of drug effects on the interdependent processes of cardiac maturation and less examination of metabolite effects. It is difficult to identify delayed toxicities in children as these adverse events may take years to manifest with many patients lost to follow-up. Clearly this is an area of study where intermediate endpoints and surrogate markers would be of great benefit. Pharmacogenomics may be useful in providing markers of increased risk or susceptibility. A perspective must be kept in balancing the possibility of a problem with the very real benefits that many children experience from the use of these pharmaceuticals.

Biomarkers of drug-induced acute kidney injury: a regulatory perspective.

INTRODUCTION: Biomarkers are one of the drug development tools that are being developed through collaborative efforts among multiple stakeholder communities to enhance the drug development process. Biomarkers of acute drug-induced renal injury as used in drug development are more commonly referred to as renal safety biomarkers, the focus of this manuscript. Areas covered: This manuscript provides an overview of the history and evolution of the United States Food and Drug Administration's Center for Drug Evaluation and Research's Biomarker Qualification Program. In addition, a regulatory perspective on the potential for renal safety biomarkers to accelerate medical and pharmaceutical research is presented. The first qualification submissions (acute kidney injury biomarkers) are discussed, including how the FDA review process affected the evolution of the biomarker qualification process and the future of biomarker discovery, development, and use. This manuscript also discusses a new repository for data on novel translational safety biomarkers from drug development programs. Expert opinion: In addition to the qualification of novel biomarkers, a key achievement of the first submission for qualification was the bringing together of multiple stakeholder communities to optimize the process. Early qualification reviews provided valuable lessons that informed an overarching approach of how to develop a biomarker for regulatory use.

Renal biomarker qualification submission: a dialog between the FDA-EMEA and Predictive Safety Testing Consortium.

The first formal qualification of safety biomarkers for regulatory decision making marks a milestone in the application of biomarkers to drug development. Following submission of drug toxicity studies and analyses of biomarker performance to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and European Medicines Agency (EMEA) by the Predictive Safety Testing Consortium's (PSTC) Nephrotoxicity Working Group, seven renal safety biomarkers have been qualified for limited use in nonclinical and clinical drug development to help guide safety assessments. This was a pilot process, and the experience gained will both facilitate better understanding of how the qualification process will probably evolve and clarify the minimal requirements necessary to evaluate the performance of biomarkers of organ injury within specific contexts.

Regulatory toxicology perspectives on the development of botanical drug products in the United States.

Toxicological studies constitute an essential part of the effort in developing a botanical supplement into a drug product. The US Food and Drug Administration recently published a draft guidance and established a special botanical review team to assist academic and industry sponsors to manage this and other regulatory considerations related to this unique group of drug products. In this article, the current state of regulatory viewpoints on issues related to requirements and recommendations of various types of nonclinical toxicity studies in support of advanced phases clinical trials and filing a New Drug Application of a botanical are discussed. Topics include nonclinical pharmacology/toxicology view of previous human experience and initial clinical trial, regulatory perspectives on acute toxicity studies, chronic toxicity studies, mutagenicity studies, reproductive toxicity studies, and carcinogenicity studies on botanicals. Certain regulatory review-related issues are also presented. It is anticipated that through a proactive 2-way communication between the Agency and the sponsor, toxicological development of botanical drug product can be significantly facilitated.