Novel expression of Haemonchus contortus vaccine candidate aminopeptidase H11 using the free-living nematode Caenorhabditis elegans.

With the problem of parasitic nematode drug resistance increasing, vaccine development offers an alternative sustainable control approach. For some parasitic nematodes, native extracts enriched for specific proteins are highly protective. However, recombinant forms of these proteins have failed to replicate this protection. This is thought to be due to differences in glycosylation and/or conformation between native and recombinant proteins. We have exploited the free-living nematode Caenorhabditis elegans to examine its suitability as an alternative system for recombinant expression of parasitic nematode vaccine candidates. We focussed on Haemonchus contortus aminopeptidase H11 glycoprotein, which is enriched in a gut membrane fraction capable of inducing significant protection against this important ovine gastrointestinal nematode. We show that H. contortus H11 expressed in C. elegans is enzymatically active and MALDI mass spectrometry identifies similar di- and tri-fucosylated structures to those on native H11, with fucose at the 3- and/or 6-positions of the proximal GlcNAc. Some glycan structural differences were observed, such as lack of LDNF. Serum antibody to native H11 binds to C. elegans recombinant H11 and most of the antibody to rH11 or native H11 is directed to glycan moieties. Despite these similarities, no reduction in worm burden or faecal egg count was observed following immunisation of sheep with C. elegans-expressed recombinant H11 protein. The findings suggest that the di- and tri-fucosylated N-glycans expressed on rH11 do not contribute to the protective effect of H11 and that additional components present in native H11-enriched extract are likely required for enhancing the antibody response necessary for protection.

Effects of duration of exposure, co-supplementation with iron and Nippostrongylus brasiliensis infection on accumulation of trichloroacetic acid-insoluble copper in rats given molybdate in drinking water.

Thiolation can convert molybdate (MoO4) into a series of thiomolybdates (MoSxO4-x) in the rumen, terminating in tetrathiomolybdate (MoS4), a potent antagonist of copper absorption and, if absorbed, donor of reactive sulphide in tissues. Systemic exposure to MoS4 increases trichloroacetic acid-insoluble copper (TCAI Cu) concentrations in the plasma of ruminants and induction of TCAI Cu in rats given MoO4 in drinking water would support the hypothesis that rats, like ruminants, can thiolate MoO4. Data on TCAI Cu are presented from two experiments involving MoO4 supplementation that had broader objectives. In experiment 1, plasma Cu concentrations (P Cu) tripled in female rats infected with Nippostrongylus brasiliensis after only 5 days exposure to drinking water containing 70 mg Mo L-1, due largely to an increase in TCAI Cu; activities of erythrocyte superoxide dismutase and plasma caeruloplasmin oxidase (CpOA) were unaffected. Exposure for 45-51 days did not raise P Cu further but TCA-soluble (TCAS) Cu concentrations increased temporarily 5 days post infection (dpi) and weakened the linear relationship between CpOA and TCAS Cu. In experiment 2, infected rats were given less MoO4 (10 mg Mo L-1), with or without iron (Fe, 300 mg L-1), for 67 days and killed 7 or 9 dpi. P Cu was again tripled by MoO4 but co-supplementation with Fe reduced TCAI Cu from 65 ± 8.9 to 36 ± 3.8 µmol L-l. Alone, Fe and MoO4 each reduced TCAS Cu in females and males when values were higher (7 and 9 dpi, respectively). Thiolation probably occurred in the large intestine but was inhibited by precipitation of sulphide as ferrous sulphide. Fe alone may have inhibited caeruloplasmin synthesis during the acute phase response to infection, which impacts thiomolybdate metabolism.

The development of RNA interference (RNAi) in gastrointestinal nematodes.

Despite the utility of RNAi for defining gene function in Caenorhabditis elegans and early successes reported in parasitic nematodes, RNAi has proven to be stubbornly inconsistent or ineffective in the animal parasitic nematodes examined to date. Here, we summarise some of our experiences with RNAi in parasitic nematodes affecting animals and discuss the available data in the context of our own unpublished work, taking account of mode of delivery, larval activation, site of gene transcription and the presence/absence of essential RNAi pathway genes as defined by comparisons to C. elegans. We discuss future directions briefly including the evaluation of nanoparticles as a means to enhance delivery of interfering RNA to the target worm tissue.

Ups and downs of RNA interference in parasitic nematodes.

RNA interference (RNAi) is widely used in Caenorhabiditis elegans to identify essential gene function. In parasitic nematodes RNAi has been reported to result in transcript knockdown of some target genes, but not others, thus limiting its use as a potential functional genomics tool. We recently extended work in Haemonchus contortus to examine why only some genes seem to be susceptible to RNAi and to test RNAi effects in vivo. Here we review our findings, which suggest that site of gene expression influences silencing. This most likely reflects limited uptake of dsRNA from the environment, a phenomenon also observed in other free-living nematodes. We discuss new technologies to improve dsRNA delivery, such as nanoparticles being developed for therapeutic siRNA delivery, and methods to monitor RNAi effects. Alternative approaches will be important in progressing the application of RNAi to identify essential gene function in parasitic nematodes.

Effects of Raising or Lowering Molybdenum Status on Outcome of Acute Infection with Nippostrongylus brasiliensis in Mature Rats.

Molybdate (Mo+) supplements can suppress or enhance nematode infections in ruminants, depending on exposure level, but there have been no investigations in non-ruminants. Three groups of 16 mature rats were each fed a commercial diet and given Mo+ (10 mg Mo/l), tungstate (a molybdenum [Mo] antagonist) (MoO4, 350 mg W/l) or no supplement (C) via drinking water for 40 days before acute infection with 3,600 Nippostrongylus brasiliensis larvae. Group Mo- also received allopurinol (1 g/l), a molybdenoenzyme inhibitor, from 4 days post infection (dpi). Subgroups of four rats from each group were killed at 7-14 dpi. A group of six rats was left untreated and uninfected and subgroups killed 10 or 12 dpi. Infection reduced intakes of food and water but impacts were greatest in group Mo-. Median worm counts in groups C, Mo- and Mo+ were 900, 941 and 510, respectively, at 7 dpi and 9, 40 and 0 (P = 0.05) at 10 dpi. Median faecal egg counts were consistently lowest in group Mo+. Worm weight was reduced (P <0.05), worm tissue protease increased and superoxide dismutase activities increased in worm (P < 0.01) and host duodenal homogenates (P < 0.01) from group Mo+. In group Mo-, liver Mo concentration decreased, duodenal xanthine oxidoreductase activity (DXOR) became totally inhibited and plasma uric acid was barely detectable at 10 dpi. Plasma mast cell protease activity and duodenal malonyldialdehyde concentrations, markers of inflammation, were increased by nematode infection (P <0.001) but unaffected by water treatments. Liver Mo, liver copper (Cu) and plasma Cu concentrations were increased in group Mo+ and plasma Cu concentration was increased in group Mo- suggesting systemic exposure to partially thiolated MoO4 and WO4. Supplementary MoO4 impaired larval establishment and changed parasite biochemistry without affecting the inflammatory response to infection but may have required partial thiolation to do so. Rats did not rely on DXOR activity to expel N. brasiliensis.

Effects of Chronic Exposure to Molybdate and Tetrathiomolybdate Supplementation of Water on Immature Rats Acutely Infected with Nippostrongylus brasiliensis. 1. Effects on Outcome of Infection and Host Health.

Low molybdate (MoO4) exposure via drinking water in mature rats infected with Nippostrongylus brasiliensis raised liver and plasma copper (Cu) concentrations. The possibility that anthelmintic effects were attributable to conversion of MoO4 to tetrathiomolybdate (MoS4) in a non-ruminant species was investigated by giving three groups of 18 immature rats drinking water containing 70 mg Mo l-1 as MoO4 (group A), 5 mg Mo l-1 as MoS4 (group B) or no supplement (group C), while receiving a commercial cubed diet. After 41 days, 12 rats from each group were inoculated subcutaneously with 2,000 L3-stage N. brasiliensis larvae. Subgroups were killed 7, 8 or 9 days post infection (dpi), when adult worms are normally expelled, and enzyme markers for the inflammatory response to infection were measured in plasma or liver. Male rats given MoS4 prior to infection grew more slowly than those given MoO4. Eight dpi, females given MoS4 had lost more bodyweight than those in group C, while those given MoO4 had gained weight. Mean worm counts at 7 dpi were 160, 65 and 250 ± 30.6 (SE), respectively, in groups C, A and B, and differed significantly from each other (P <0.05) but only rats given MoO4 remained infected 9 dpi (mean worm count 52 ± 16.4): Faecal egg counts followed a broadly similar pattern. Both Mo sources pre-empted increases in liver and duodenal superoxide dismutase activity, induced by infection 7 and 9 dpi, respectively, in group C and enlarged the femur: neither source prevented hypertrophy of the small intestine and a rise in serum mast cell protease concentration caused by infection. Since data for plasma Cu concentration and caeruloplasmin oxidase activity, reported separately, indicated MoO4 was thiolated in vivo, differences between Mo sources may be attributable to differences in the degree of thiolation, extent of thiomolybdate exposure and rates of thiomolybdate degradation at critical times in host or parasite development.

Effects of Molybdate and Tetrathiomolybdate Supplementation of Drinking Water on Immature Rats Infected with Nippostrongylus brasiliensis. 2. Copper Status and Tissue Molybdenum Accretion.

Molybdate (MoO4) and tetrathiomolybdate (MoS4) supplementation of rats via drinking water had opposite effects on the establishment of Nippostrongylus brasiliensis larvae but both induced hypercupraemia, temporarily inhibited activities of superoxide dismutase in liver and duodenum after infection and enlarged the femoral head. Effects of MoO4 and MoS4 on activities of caeruloplasmin oxidase (CpO) in plasma, erythrocyte superoxide dismutase (ESOD) and tissue copper (Cu) and molybdenum (Mo) were compared to test the hypothesis that species lacking a rumen can thiolate MoO4. Three groups of 18 immature Wistar rats were given Mo (70 mg/L as MoO4) or MoS4 (5 mg/L) via drinking water or remained untreated; all received a commercial, cubed diet and 12 from each group were infected with larvae of N. brasiliensis. Rats were killed 7-9 days later and liver, kidney, spleen, heart, muscle (quadriceps), brain and bone (femur) removed for Cu and Mo analysis. Plasma Cu was greatly increased by MoO4 and MoS4, without changing CpO activity, but the effect was more variable with MoO4 and accompanied by a smaller decrease in ESOD. Tissue Cu and Mo were increased by MoS4 in all tissues examined except brain and bone, correlating with plasma Cu and with each other; relationships were strongest in spleen, followed by kidney. MoO4 also increased soft tissue Cu and Mo but increases were generally smaller than those induced by MoS4 and correlations between the two elements and with plasma Cu generally weaker. Since hypercupraemia and correlated increases in liver and kidney Cu and Mo are characteristic of systemic thiomolybdate (TM) exposure, we conclude that MoO4 was partially thiolated to give a different TM profile from that produced by MoS4. The pathophysiological significance of systemic exposure to di- and tri-TM merits investigation in non-ruminants as agents of chelation therapy and in ruminants as agents of short-lived TM toxicity on Mo-rich pastures.

Stage-specific gene expression in Teladorsagia circumcincta (Nematoda: Strongylida) infective larvae and early parasitic stages.

Suppression subtractive hybridisation was used to enrich genes expressed in a stage-specific manner in infective, exsheathed L3s (xL3) versus early L4s of the ovine nematode, Teladorsagia circumcincta prior to gene expression profiling by microarray. The 769 cDNA sequences obtained from the xL3-enriched library contained 361 unique sequences, with 292 expressed sequence tags (ESTs) being represented once ("singletons") and 69 sequences which were represented more than once (overlapping and non-overlapping "contigs"). The L4-enriched EST dataset contained 472 unique sequences, with 314 singletons and 158 contigs. Of these 833 sequences, 85% of the xL3 sequences and 86% of the L4 sequences exhibited homology to known genes or ESTs derived from other species of nematode. Quantitative differential expression (P<0.05) was demonstrated for 563 (68%) of the ESTs by microarray. Within the L3-specific dataset, more than 30% of the transcripts represented the enzyme, guanosine-5'-triphosphate (GTP)-cyclohydrolase, which is the first and rate-limiting enzyme of the tetrahydrobiopterin synthesis pathway and may be involved in critical elements of larval development. In L4s, proteolytic enzymes were highly up-regulated, as were collagens and a number of previously characterised secretory proteins, reflecting the rapid growth of these larvae in abomasal glands. Nucleotide sequence data reported in this paper are available in the EMBL, GenBank and DDJB databases under accession numbers AM 743198-AM 744942.

Psoroptes ovis: identification of vaccine candidates by immunoscreening.

Serum from successful vaccine trials against the sheep scab mite, Psoroptes ovis, was used to immunoscreen a cDNA library constructed from mixed-stage and gender P. ovis to identify potential recombinant vaccine candidates. Immunodominant recombinant proteins recognised by IgG in these sera were selected for further analysis. Two candidates were identified in this way; a catchin-like protein (CLP) and a novel mu class glutathione S-transferase (GST). Both candidates were expressed in bacteria as recombinant proteins, the GST as an active enzyme, and combined with four other recombinant allergens in a multi-component recombinant vaccine. Strong serum IgG responses were induced in sheep against each of the components of the recombinant vaccine, however, the protective efficacy of the vaccine could not be determined because of variability in the establishment of a challenge infection.

RNA interference in parasitic nematodes of animals: a reality check?

RNA interference (RNAi) is widely used in Caenorhabditis elegans to identify gene function and has been adapted as a high-throughput screening method to identify genes involved in essential processes. The technique has been applied to parasitic nematodes with variable success and we believe that inconsistent outcomes preclude its use as a robust screen with which to identify potential control targets. In this article, key issues that require clarification are discussed, including the mode of delivery of double-stranded RNA to the parasite, the developmental stage targeted and, perhaps of most importance, whether the RNAi pathway (as defined by studies in C. elegans) is fully functional in some parasitic nematodes.

Expression and purification of an active cysteine protease of Haemonchus contortus using Caenorhabditis elegans.

Many proteolytic enzymes of parasitic nematodes have been identified as possible targets of control. Testing these as vaccine or drug targets is often difficult due to the problems of expressing proteases in a correctly folded, active form in standard expression systems. In an effort to overcome these difficulties we have tested Caenorhabditis elegans as an expression system for a Haemonchus contortus cathepsin L cysteine protease, Hc-CPL-1. Recombinant Hc-CPL-1 with a polyhistidine tag added to the C-terminal was expressed in an active and glycosylated form in C. elegans. Optimal expression was obtained expressing Hc-cpl-1 under control of the promoter of the homologous C. elegans cpl-1 gene. The recombinant protein was purified from liquid cultures by nickel chelation chromatography in sufficient amounts for vaccination studies to be carried out. This study provides proof of principle that active, post-translationally modified parasitic nematode proteases can be expressed in C. elegans and this approach can be extended for expression of known protective antigens.

Testing the efficacy of RNA interference in Haemonchus contortus.

RNA interference (RNAi) is widely used in Caenorhabditis elegans to identify gene function and has been adapted as a high throughput screening method to identify genes involved in essential processes. We have been examining whether RNAi could also be used on the strongylid parasitic nematode Haemonchus contortus to study gene function. Eleven genes were targeted in L1 and exsheathed L3 H. contortus larvae with RNAi methodologies which have been shown to be effective in C. elegans and parasitic nematodes-feeding, soaking and electroporation. Reverse transcriptase-PCR and, where possible, protein assays were carried out to examine decreases in mRNA and protein levels. RNAi soaking in dsRNA to beta-tubulin and sec-23, a gene involved in vesicle transport, resulted in specific decreases in mRNA levels in exsheathed L3 larvae. No signs of specific decreases in expression levels were observed for the other nine genes tested. Following electroporation of dsRNA in L1 stage larvae, significant decreases were observed for two out of four genes tested. These findings suggest that the RNAi pathway is functional in H. contortus and that, under certain conditions, it is possible to suppress gene expression by RNAi. However, it only works on a limited number of genes and in some cases the effect is small and difficult to reproduce. This indicates that the RNAi approaches established for C. elegans and other nematodes have limited efficacy in H. contortus. This may reflect differences between nematode species in dsRNA uptake and transport into cells and between cells.

A preliminary proteomic characterisation of extracellular vesicles released by the ovine parasitic nematode, Teladorsagia circumcincta.

Teladorsagia circumcincta is a major cause of ovine parasitic gastroenteritis in temperate climatic regions. The development of high levels of anthelmintic resistance in this nematode species challenges its future control. Recent research indicates that many parasite species release extracellular vesicles into their environment, many of which have been classified as endocytic in origin, termed exosomes. These vesicles are considered to play important roles in the intercellular communication between parasites and their hosts, and thus represent potentially useful targets for novel control strategies. Here, we demonstrate that exosome-like extracellular vesicles can be isolated from excretory-secretory (ES) products released by T. circumcincta fourth stage larvae (Tci-L4ES). Furthermore, we perform a comparative proteomic analysis of vesicle-enriched and vesicle-free Tci-L4ES. Approximately 73% of the proteins identified in the vesicle-enriched fraction were unique to this fraction, whilst the remaining 27% were present in both vesicle-enriched and vesicle-free fraction. These unique proteins included structural proteins, nuclear proteins, metabolic proteins, proteolytic enzymes and activation-associated secreted proteins. Finally, we demonstrate that molecules present within the vesicles-enriched material are targets of the IgA and IgG response in T. circumcincta infected sheep, and could potentially represent useful targets for future vaccine intervention studies.

SAGE and the quantitative analysis of gene expression in parasites.

The nature of an organism is defined by the genes that it expresses. Genome- and expressed-sequence-tag (EST) sequencing projects are underway for many of the major parasites of humans and animals. These provide essential datasets that delineate the genes present in an organism and, in the case of ESTs, some quantitative information on gene expression. The temporal and quantitative analysis of gene expression is essential to fully exploit these datasets and define the biology of the parasite at the molecular level. Here, we discuss the application of serial analysis of gene expression (SAGE) for this purpose. SAGE is a technique that allows the rapid, quantitative analysis of thousands of transcripts. It complements microarray analysis with the advantage that it is affordable for standard laboratories. It provides a platform to define complete metabolic pathways and has been applied to study responses to drug treatment and the molecular events that are associated with arrested larval development.

Veterinary parasitic vaccines: pitfalls and future directions.

Most available antiparasitic drugs are safe, cheap and highly effective against a broad spectrum of parasites. However, the alarming increase in the number of parasite species that are resistant to these drugs, the issue of residues in the food chain and the lack of new drugs stimulate development of alternative control methods in which vaccines would have a central role. Parasite vaccines are still rare, but there are encouraging signs that their number will increase in the next decade. The modern paradigm is that an understanding of parasite genes will lead to the identification of useful antigens, which can then be produced in recombinant systems developed as a result of the huge investment in biotechnology. However, we should also continue to devote efforts to basic research on the host-parasite interface.

Digestive proteases of blood-feeding nematodes.

Blood-feeding parasites employ a battery of proteolytic enzymes to digest the contents of their bloodmeal. Host haemoglobin is a major substrate for these proteases and, therefore, a driving force in the evolution of parasite-derived proteolytic enzymes. This review will focus on the digestive proteases of the major blood-feeding nematodes - hookworms (Ancylostoma spp. and Necator americanus) and the ruminant parasite, Haemonchus contortus - but also compares and contrasts these proteases with recent findings from schistosomes and malaria parasites. Haematophagous nematodes express proteases of different mechanistic classes in their intestines, many of which have proven or putative roles in degradation of haemoglobin and other proteins involved in nutrition. Moreover, the fine specificity of the relationships between digestive proteases and their substrate proteins provides a new molecular paradigm for understanding host-parasite co-evolution. Numerous laboratories are actively investigating these molecules as antiparasite vaccine targets.

Evaluation of Caenorhabditis elegans glycoproteins as protective immunogens against Haemonchus contortus challenge in sheep.

High levels of protection can be attained against Haemonchus contortus challenge infection in sheep using native antigens isolated from the gut of the adult parasite. However, vaccination with recombinant forms of these antigens, or components thereof, has disappointingly failed to generate similar levels of protection, suggesting that appropriate nematode glycosylation may be a prerequisite for protection. The free-living nematode, Caenorhabditis elegans is closely related to H. contortus and has been shown to share similar glycan moieties. In order to investigate the potentially protective role of these glycan moieties, a complex set of glycoproteins was isolated from C. elegans using ConA-lectin chromatography and their efficacy as immunogens against H. contortus challenge infection evaluated in sheep. Despite the generation of a high titre systemic IgG antibody response to the C. elegans glycoproteins and the ability of these antibodies to bind to the microvillar surface of the gut of H. contortus, no protection against challenge infection was observed. Serum antibodies to the C. elegans glycoproteins cross-reacted with the H. contortus host-protective antigen, H-gal-GP, by ELISA, although the level of cross-reactivity was not of a magnitude considered protective. Qualitative differences were also determined between the glycan epitopes of the C. elegans ConA-binding proteins and those of H-gal-GP, suggesting the presence of H. contortus-specific patterns of glycosylation.

The nature and prospects for gut membrane proteins as vaccine candidates for Haemonchus contortus and other ruminant trichostrongyloids.

Substantial progress has been made in the last decade in identifying several antigens from Haemonchus contortus which, in their native form, stimulate useful levels of protective immunity (70-95% reductions in faecal egg output) in the ovine host. Much work has focussed on proteins/protein complexes expressed on the surface of the worm gut which are exposed to the blood meal, and, hence, antibody ingested with it. The antigens generally, but not in all cases, show protease activity and antibody is thought to mediate protective immunity by blocking the activity of enzymes involved in digestion within the worm. This review summarises the protective efficacy, as well as the biochemical and molecular properties, of the principal candidate antigens which are expressed in the gut of these parasites. Of course, such antigens will have to be expressed as recombinant proteins to be sufficiently cost-effective for use in a commercial vaccine and the current status of recombinant antigen expression is discussed with particular reference to conformation and glycosylation. There is a need for continued antigen definition even in the confines of gut antigens and potential targets can be selected from the rapidly expanding genome/EST datasets on the basis of predicted functional homology. Gene knockout technologies such as RNA interference have the potential to provide high throughput, rapid and inexpensive methods to define whether the protein product of a particular gene would be a suitable vaccine candidate.

Current research and future prospects in the development of vaccines against gastrointestinal nematodes in cattle.

Vaccination is being considered as the most feasible alternative for anthelmintic drugs to control gastrointestinal nematode infections in cattle. However, despite the identification of several candidate protective antigens, no vaccines against gastrointestinal nematode parasites are currently available. The main problems that hamper the development of nematode vaccines in ruminants are that vaccination with recombinant nematode proteins produced in bacterial or eukaryotic expression systems did not induce a protective immune response and no suitable antigen delivery system is available for presentation of protective worm antigens to the bovine mucosal immune system. The present review will focus on recent advances and remaining obstacles in vaccine development against gastrointestinal nematodes in cattle, in particular against the abomasal parasite Ostertagia ostertagi.