Using routinely recorded data in a UK RCT: a comparison to standard prospective data collection methods.

BACKGROUND: Routinely recorded data held in electronic health records can be used to inform the conduct of randomised controlled trials (RCTs). However, limitations with access and accuracy have been identified. OBJECTIVE: Using epilepsy as an exemplar condition, we assessed the attributes and agreement of routinely recorded data compared to data collected using case report forms in a UK RCT assessing antiepileptic drug treatments for individuals newly diagnosed with epilepsy. METHODS: The case study RCT is the Standard and New Antiepileptic Drugs II (SANAD II) trial, a pragmatic, UK multicentre RCT assessing the clinical and cost-effectiveness of antiepileptic drugs as treatments for epilepsy. Ninety-eight of 470 eligible participants provided consent for access to routinely recorded secondary care data that were retrieved from NHS Digital Hospital Episode Statistics (N=71) and primary and secondary care data from The Secure Anonymised Information Linkage Databank (N=27). We assessed data items relevant to the identification of individuals eligible for inclusion in SANAD II, baseline and follow-up visits. The attributes of routinely recorded data were assessed including the degree of missing data. The agreement between routinely recorded data and data collected on case report forms in SANAD II was assessed using calculation of Cohen's kappa for categorical data and construction of Bland-Altman plots for continuous data. RESULTS: There was a significant degree of missing data in the routine record for 15 of the 20 variables assessed, including all clinical variables. Agreement was poor for the majority of comparisons, including the assessments of seizure occurrence and adverse events. For example, only 23/62 (37%) participants had a date of first-ever seizure identified in routine datasets. Agreement was satisfactory for the date of prescription of antiepileptic drugs and episodes of healthcare resource use. CONCLUSIONS: There are currently significant limitations preventing the use of routinely recorded data for participant identification and assessment of clinical outcomes in epilepsy, and potentially other chronic conditions. Further research is urgently required to assess the attributes, agreement, additional benefits, cost-effectiveness and 'optimal mix' of routinely recorded data compared to data collected using standard methods such as case report forms at clinic visits for people with epilepsy. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Standard and New Antiepileptic Drugs II (SANAD II (EudraCT No: 2012-001884-64, registered 05/09/2012; ISRCTN Number: ISRCTN30294119 , registered 03/07/2012)).

Risk of a seizure recurrence after a breakthrough seizure and the implications for driving: further analysis of the standard versus new antiepileptic drugs (SANAD) randomised controlled trial.

OBJECTIVES: A breakthrough seizure is one occurring after at least 12 months seizure freedom while on treatment. The Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA) allows an individual to return to driving once they have been seizure free for 12 months following a breakthrough seizure. This is based on the assumption that the risk of a further seizure in the next 12 months has dropped <20%. This analysis considers whether the prescribed 1 year off driving following a breakthrough seizure is sufficient for this and stratifies risk according to clinical characteristics. DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, INTERVENTIONS AND MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The multicentre UK-based Standard versus New Antiepileptic Drugs (SANAD) study was a randomised controlled trial assessing standard and new antiepileptic drugs for patients with newly diagnosed epilepsy. For participants aged at least 16 with a breakthrough seizure, data have been analysed to estimate the annual seizure recurrence risk following a period of 6, 9 and 12 months seizure freedom. Regression modelling was used to investigate how antiepileptic drug treatment and a number of clinical factors influence the risk of seizure recurrence. RESULTS: At 12 months following a breakthrough seizure, the overall unadjusted risk of a recurrence over the next 12 months is lower than 20%, risk 17% (95% CI 15% to 19%). However, some patient subgroups have been identified which have an annual recurrence risk significantly greater than 20% after an initial 12-month seizure-free period following a breakthrough seizure. CONCLUSIONS: This reanalysis of SANAD provides estimates of seizure recurrence risks following a breakthrough seizure that will inform policy and guidance about regaining an ordinary driving licence. Further guidance is needed as to how such data should be used. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: SANAD is registered with the International Standard Randomised Controlled Trial Number Register ISRCTN38354748.

Using routinely recorded data in the UK to assess outcomes in a randomised controlled trial: The Trials of Access.

BACKGROUND: In the UK, routinely recorded data may benefit prospective studies including randomised controlled trials (RCTs). In an on-going study, we aim to assess the feasibility of access and agreement of routinely recorded clinical and non-clinical data compared to data collected during a RCT using standard prospective methods. This paper will summarise available UK routinely recorded data sources and discuss our experience with the feasibility of accessing routinely recorded data for participants of a RCT before finally proposing recommendations for improving the access and implementation of routinely recorded data in RCTs. METHODS: Setting: the case study RCT is the Standard and New Antiepileptic Drugs II (SANAD II) trial, a pragmatic, UK, multicentre, phase IV RCT assessing the clinical and cost-effectiveness of antiepileptic drug treatments for newly diagnosed epilepsy. PARTICIPANTS: 98 participants have provided written consent to permit the request of routinely recorded data. Study procedures: routinely recorded clinical and non-clinical data were identified and data requested through formal applications from available data holders for the duration that participants have been recruited into SANAD II. The feasibility of accessing routinely recorded data during a RCT is assessed and recommendations for improving access proposed. RESULTS: Secondary-care clinical and socioeconomic data is recorded on a national basis and can be accessed, although there are limitations in the application process. Primary-care data are recorded by a number of organisations on a de-identified basis but access for specific individuals has not been feasible. Access to data recorded by non-clinical sources, including The Department for Work and Pensions and The Driving and Vehicle Licensing Agency, was not successful. CONCLUSIONS: Recommendations discussed include further research to assess the attributes of routinely recorded data, an assessment of public perceptions and the development of strategies to collaboratively improve access to routinely recorded data for research. TRIAL REGISTRATION: International Standard Randomised Controlled Trials, ISRCTN30294119 . Registered on 3 July 2012. EudraCT No: 2012-001884-64. Registered on 9 May 2012.

Primary central nervous system lymphoma: a single-centre experience of 55 unselected cases.

AIMS: Current treatment for primary central nervous system lymphoma (PCNSL) involves high-dose methotrexate (HDMTX) with or without radiotherapy. Many published studies describing this approach include a highly selected group of patients. We report a single-centre experience of unselected cases of PCNSL. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed the case notes of 55 consecutive patients diagnosed with biopsy-proven PCNSL between 1995 and 2003 at Addenbrooke's Hospital Cambridge, UK. We describe the treatment and outcome, including survival, treatment-related toxicity and long-term functional disability. RESULTS: At diagnosis, 45% of patients were considered unfit to receive treatment with HDMTX, owing to poor performance status or comorbidity. These patients had a median survival of 46 days and may not have been included in other published studies. The remaining patients were treated with a chemotherapy regimen, which included HDMTX. Patients who received at least one cycle of a chemotherapy containing HDMTX had a median survival of 31 months. Forty per cent did not complete planned chemotherapy owing to toxicity, disease progression or death. The median survival of patients treated with HDMTX aged 60 years compared with patients aged under 60 years was 26 months vs 41 months (P = 0.07), respectively. Younger patients treated with HDMTX, who achieved complete remission with chemotherapy, had a median survival of 56 months. We identified a high incidence of functional disability among survivors, resulting from a combination of the tumour itself, the neurosurgical procedure required for diagnosis and the late neurotoxicity of combined chemoradiotherapy. CONCLUSION: The treatment of PCNSL is associated with significant early and late toxicity. Further attempts to improve treatment should address mechanisms to reduce this toxicity. In particular, the benefit of radiotherapy in patients who achieve complete remission with HDMTX will remain uncertain until it is addressed in a multicentre, randomised trial.

Enhanced secretion of immune-modulating cytokines by human lung fibroblasts during in vitro infection with Mycoplasma fermentans.

Fibroblasts may play an important role in the modulation of immune and inflammatory responses through elaboration of cytokines. To test this hypothesis, human lung fibroblasts were isolated from transbronchial biopsy specimens and assayed for production of interleukin-6 (IL-6) and granulocyte/macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF). The sources of fibroblasts included lung allografts, recipient lungs obtained at time of transplant, and normal lung tissue removed during tumor resection. During the course of these studies, several early-passage fibroblasts from transplant recipients were observed to contain mycoplasma (MP)-like organisms as detected by extranuclear fluorescent staining with Hoechst 33258. Positive staining cultures were associated with isolation of Mycoplasma fermentans. IL-6 and GM-GSF as measured by ELISA were found to be elevated over 50-fold in conditioned medium from MP-infected fibroblasts as compared with noninfected lines. Treatment of cells with mycoplasma removal agent (MRA) eliminated extranuclear Hoechst fluorescence and significantly reduced the production of these cytokines. Tumor necrosis factor-beta (TNF-beta) induction of IL-6 and GM-CSF was amplified synergistically in infected cultures. No additional production of IL-6 or GM-CSF was observed in infected cultures treated with interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) despite the ability of IFN-gamma to modestly induce IL-6 in uninfected cultures. Thus, in vitro infection of lung fibroblasts with MP represents a potent stimulus for the production of inflammatory cytokines and, therefore, necessitates rigorous control for these organisms in cell culture studies.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)