Communication in Drug Development: "Translating" Scientific Discovery.

The discovery and development of new medicines that promote human health and potentially extend natural life remains a remarkably challenging endeavor. In this Commentary, we identify key elements of communication required to successfully translate promising biological findings to novel approved drug therapies and discuss the attendant challenges and opportunities.

From cancer genomics to precision oncology--tissue's still an issue.

Rapidly evolving genome technology has enabled extensive molecular analysis of limited tumor biopsy material, thereby facilitating the broader implementation of personalized cancer medicine. However, genomics-based patient stratification across diverse tumor types is unlikely to supplant tissue-of-origin considerations in addressing clinical needs, including the development and application of novel "rationally targeted" cancer therapies.

TAK1 inhibition promotes apoptosis in KRAS-dependent colon cancers.

Colon cancers frequently harbor KRAS mutations, yet only a subset of KRAS mutant colon cancer cell lines are dependent upon KRAS signaling for survival. In a screen for kinases that promote survival of KRAS-dependent colon cancer cells, we found that the TAK1 kinase (MAP3K7) is required for tumor cell viability. The induction of apoptosis by RNAi-mediated depletion or pharmacologic inhibition of TAK1 is linked to its suppression of hyperactivated Wnt signaling, evident in both endogenous and genetically reconstituted cells. In APC mutant/KRAS-dependent cells, KRAS stimulates BMP-7 secretion and BMP signaling, leading to TAK1 activation and enhancement of Wnt-dependent transcription. An in vitro-derived "TAK1 dependency signature" is enriched in primary human colon cancers with mutations in both APC and KRAS, suggesting potential clinical utility in stratifying patient populations. Together, these findings identify TAK1 inhibition as a potential therapeutic strategy for a treatment-refractory subset of colon cancers exhibiting aberrant KRAS and Wnt pathway activation.

A chromatin-mediated reversible drug-tolerant state in cancer cell subpopulations.

Accumulating evidence implicates heterogeneity within cancer cell populations in the response to stressful exposures, including drug treatments. While modeling the acute response to various anticancer agents in drug-sensitive human tumor cell lines, we consistently detected a small subpopulation of reversibly "drug-tolerant" cells. These cells demonstrate >100-fold reduced drug sensitivity and maintain viability via engagement of IGF-1 receptor signaling and an altered chromatin state that requires the histone demethylase RBP2/KDM5A/Jarid1A. This drug-tolerant phenotype is transiently acquired and relinquished at low frequency by individual cells within the population, implicating the dynamic regulation of phenotypic heterogeneity in drug tolerance. The drug-tolerant subpopulation can be selectively ablated by treatment with IGF-1 receptor inhibitors or chromatin-modifying agents, potentially yielding a therapeutic opportunity. Together, these findings suggest that cancer cell populations employ a dynamic survival strategy in which individual cells transiently assume a reversibly drug-tolerant state to protect the population from eradication by potentially lethal exposures.

Reproducible pharmacogenomic profiling of cancer cell line panels.

The use of large-scale genomic and drug response screening of cancer cell lines depends crucially on the reproducibility of results. Here we consider two previously published screens, plus a later critique of these studies. Using independent data, we show that consistency is achievable, and provide a systematic description of the best laboratory and analysis practices for future studies.

Transcriptional control of autophagy-lysosome function drives pancreatic cancer metabolism.

Activation of cellular stress response pathways to maintain metabolic homeostasis is emerging as a critical growth and survival mechanism in many cancers. The pathogenesis of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDA) requires high levels of autophagy, a conserved self-degradative process. However, the regulatory circuits that activate autophagy and reprogram PDA cell metabolism are unknown. Here we show that autophagy induction in PDA occurs as part of a broader transcriptional program that coordinates activation of lysosome biogenesis and function, and nutrient scavenging, mediated by the MiT/TFE family of transcription factors. In human PDA cells, the MiT/TFE proteins--MITF, TFE3 and TFEB--are decoupled from regulatory mechanisms that control their cytoplasmic retention. Increased nuclear import in turn drives the expression of a coherent network of genes that induce high levels of lysosomal catabolic function essential for PDA growth. Unbiased global metabolite profiling reveals that MiT/TFE-dependent autophagy-lysosome activation is specifically required to maintain intracellular amino acid pools. These results identify the MiT/TFE proteins as master regulators of metabolic reprogramming in pancreatic cancer and demonstrate that transcriptional activation of clearance pathways converging on the lysosome is a novel hallmark of aggressive malignancy.

Widespread potential for growth-factor-driven resistance to anticancer kinase inhibitors.

Mutationally activated kinases define a clinically validated class of targets for cancer drug therapy. However, the efficacy of kinase inhibitors in patients whose tumours harbour such alleles is invariably limited by innate or acquired drug resistance. The identification of resistance mechanisms has revealed a recurrent theme­the engagement of survival signals redundant to those transduced by the targeted kinase. Cancer cells typically express multiple receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) that mediate signals that converge on common critical downstream cell-survival effectors­most notably, phosphatidylinositol-3-OH kinase (PI(3)K) and mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK). Consequently, an increase in RTK-ligand levels, through autocrine tumour-cell production, paracrine contribution from tumour stroma or systemic production, could confer resistance to inhibitors of an oncogenic kinase with a similar signalling output. Here, using a panel of kinase-'addicted' human cancer cell lines, we found that most cells can be rescued from drug sensitivity by simply exposing them to one or more RTK ligands. Among the findings with clinical implications was the observation that hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) confers resistance to the BRAF inhibitor PLX4032 (vemurafenib) in BRAF-mutant melanoma cells. These observations highlight the extensive redundancy of RTK-transduced signalling in cancer cells and the potentially broad role of widely expressed RTK ligands in innate and acquired resistance to drugs targeting oncogenic kinases.

Genome and transcriptome sequencing of lung cancers reveal diverse mutational and splicing events.

Lung cancer is a highly heterogeneous disease in terms of both underlying genetic lesions and response to therapeutic treatments. We performed deep whole-genome sequencing and transcriptome sequencing on 19 lung cancer cell lines and three lung tumor/normal pairs. Overall, our data show that cell line models exhibit similar mutation spectra to human tumor samples. Smoker and never-smoker cancer samples exhibit distinguishable patterns of mutations. A number of epigenetic regulators, including KDM6A, ASH1L, SMARCA4, and ATAD2, are frequently altered by mutations or copy number changes. A systematic survey of splice-site mutations identified 106 splice site mutations associated with cancer specific aberrant splicing, including mutations in several known cancer-related genes. RAC1b, an isoform of the RAC1 GTPase that includes one additional exon, was found to be preferentially up-regulated in lung cancer. We further show that its expression is significantly associated with sensitivity to a MAP2K (MEK) inhibitor PD-0325901. Taken together, these data present a comprehensive genomic landscape of a large number of lung cancer samples and further demonstrate that cancer-specific alternative splicing is a widespread phenomenon that has potential utility as therapeutic biomarkers. The detailed characterizations of the lung cancer cell lines also provide genomic context to the vast amount of experimental data gathered for these lines over the decades, and represent highly valuable resources for cancer biology.

Inherited susceptibility to lung cancer may be associated with the T790M drug resistance mutation in EGFR.

Somatic activating mutations in EGFR identify a subset of non-small cell lung cancer that respond to tyrosine kinase inhibitors. Acquisition of drug resistance is linked to a specific secondary somatic mutation, EGFR T790M. Here we describe a family with multiple cases of non-small cell lung cancer associated with germline transmission of this mutation. Four of six tumors analyzed showed a secondary somatic activating EGFR mutation, arising in cis with the germline EGFR mutation T790M. These observations implicate altered EGFR signaling in genetic susceptibility to lung cancer.

Mechanisms of acquired resistance to targeted cancer therapies.

Drugs that target genomically defined vulnerabilities in human tumors have now been clinically validated as effective cancer therapies. However, the relatively rapid acquisition of resistance to such treatments that is observed in virtually all cases significantly limits their utility and remains a substantial challenge to the clinical management of advanced cancers. As molecular mechanisms of resistance have begun to be elucidated, new strategies to overcome or prevent the development of resistance have begun to emerge. In some cases, specific mutational mechanisms contribute directly to acquired drug resistance, and in other cases it appears that nonmutational and possibly epigenetic mechanisms play a significant role. This article discusses the various genetic and nongenetic mechanisms of acquired drug resistance that have been reported in the context of 'rationally targeted' drug therapies.

Emerging Trends in Cancer Drug Discovery-From Drugging the "Undruggable" to Overcoming Resistance.

Technology advancement and the courage to challenge dogma have been key elements that have continuously shifted druggability limits. We illustrate this notion with several recent cancer drug-discovery examples, while also giving an outlook on the opportunities offered by newer modalities such as chemically induced proximity and direct targeting of RNA. Treatment resistance is a major impediment to the goal of durable efficacy and cure, but the confluence of new biological insights, novel drug modalities, and drug combinations is predicted to enable transformative progress in this decade and beyond.

Thinking Differently about Cancer Treatment Regimens.

Most experimental cancer drugs ultimately fail during the course of clinical development, contributing to the high cost of the few that are granted regulatory approval. Moreover, approved drugs often deliver only modest clinical benefit to patients with advanced disease due to the development of resistance. Here, we discuss opportunities we consider promising to overcome drug resistance associated with interactions between signaling pathways and the presence of multiple coexisting cell states within tumors with distinct vulnerabilities. We highlight how understanding drug-resistance mechanisms can enable innovative treatment regimens that deliver longer-lasting benefit to patients.

A Single-Step, High-Dose Selection Scheme Reveals Distinct Mechanisms of Acquired Resistance to Oncogenic Kinase Inhibition in Cancer Cells.

Despite the remarkable clinical efficacy demonstrated by molecularly targeted cancer therapeutics, the benefits are typically temporary due to the emergence of acquired drug resistance. This has spurred a massive effort by the cancer research community to identify mechanisms used by cancer cells to evade treatment. Among the various methodologies developed and employed to identify such mechanisms, the most commonly used approach has been to model acquired resistance by exposing cancer cells in culture to gradually increasing concentrations of drug over an extended period of time. Here, we employed a less commonly used variation on this approach, wherein resistant cells are selected by immediately exposing cancer cells to a continuous, high concentration of drug. Using this approach, we isolated clones representing three distinct mechanisms of resistance to inhibition of MET kinase activity from a single clonally derived cancer cell line. The emergent clones had acquired resistance through engagement of alternative receptor tyrosine kinases either through upregulation of FGF3 or HBEGF or increased MAPK signaling through an activating V600E mutation in BRAF. Importantly, these mechanisms were not identified using the conventional "ramp-up" approach in previous studies that employed the same cell line. These results suggest that the particular nature of the selection scheme employed in cell culture modeling studies can determine which potential resistance mechanisms are identified and which ones may be missed, highlighting the need for careful consideration of the specific approach used to model resistance in cultured cells. SIGNIFICANCE: Through modeling resistance to MET kinase inhibition in cultured cancer cells using single-step, high-dose selection, these findings highlight that the specific nature of the selection protocol impacts which resistance mechanisms are identified.See related commentary by Floros et al., p. 25.

Unprovoked Stabilization and Nuclear Accumulation of the Naked Mole-Rat p53 Protein.

The naked mole-rat is a subterranean rodent, approximately the size of a mouse, renowned for its exceptional longevity (>30 years) and remarkable resistance to cancer. To explore putative mechanisms underlying the cancer resistance of the naked mole-rat, we investigated the regulation and function of the most commonly mutated tumor suppressor, TP53, in the naked mole-rat. We found that the p53 protein in naked mole-rat embryonic fibroblasts (NEFs) exhibits a half-life more than ten times in excess of the protein's characterized half-life in mouse and human embryonic fibroblasts. We determined that the long half-life of the naked mole-rat p53 protein reflects protein-extrinsic regulation. Relative to mouse and human p53, a larger proportion of naked mole-rat p53 protein is constitutively localized in the nucleus prior to DNA damage. Nevertheless, DNA damage is sufficient to induce activation of canonical p53 target genes in NEFs. Despite the uniquely long half-life and unprecedented basal nuclear localization of p53 in NEFs, naked mole-rat p53 retains its canonical tumor suppressive activity. Together, these findings suggest that the unique stabilization and regulation of the p53 protein may contribute to the naked mole-rat's remarkable resistance to cancer.

Targeting microtubules sensitizes drug resistant lung cancer cells to lysosomal pathway inhibitors.

Oncogene-addicted cancers are predominantly driven by specific oncogenic pathways and display initial exquisite sensitivity to designer therapies, but eventually become refractory to treatments. Clear understanding of lung tumorigenic mechanisms is essential for improved therapies. Methods: Lysosomes were analyzed in EGFR-WT and mutant cells and corresponding patient samples using immunofluorescence or immunohistochemistry and immunoblotting. Microtubule organization and dynamics were studied using immunofluorescence analyses. Also, we have validated our findings in a transgenic mouse model that contain EGFR-TKI resistant mutations. Results: We herein describe a novel mechanism that a mutated kinase disrupts the microtubule organization and results in a defective endosomal/lysosomal pathway. This prevents the efficient degradation of phosphorylated proteins that become trapped within the endosomes and continue to signal, therefore amplifying downstream proliferative and survival pathways. Phenotypically, a distinctive subcellular appearance of LAMP1 secondary to microtubule dysfunction in cells expressing EGFR kinase mutants is seen, and this may have potential diagnostic applications for the detection of such mutants. We demonstrate that lysosomal-inhibitors re-sensitize resistant cells to EGFR tyrosine-kinase inhibitors (TKIs). Identifying the endosome-lysosome pathway and microtubule dysfunction as a mechanism of resistance allows to pharmacologically intervene on this pathway. Conclusions: We find that the combination of microtubule stabilizing agent and lysosome inhibitor could reduce the tumor progression in EGFR TKI resistant mouse models of lung cancer.

Integrating complex genomic datasets and tumour cell sensitivity profiles to address a 'simple' question: which patients should get this drug?

It is becoming increasingly apparent that cancer drug therapies can only reach their full potential through appropriate patient selection. Matching drugs and cancer patients has proven to be a complex challenge, due in large part to the substantial molecular heterogeneity inherent to human cancers. This is not only a major hurdle to the improvement of the use of current treatments but also for the development of novel therapies and the ability to steer them to the relevant clinical indications. In this commentary we discuss recent studies from Kuo et al., published this month in BMC Medicine, in which they used a panel of cancer cell lines as a model for capturing patient heterogeneity at the genomic and proteomic level in order to identify potential biomarkers for predicting the clinical activity of a novel candidate chemotherapeutic across a patient population. The findings highlight the ability of a 'systems approach' to develop a better understanding of the properties of novel candidate therapeutics and to guide clinical testing and application.See the associated research paper by Kuo et al: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-7015/7/77.

Cell culture modeling of genotype-directed sensitivity to selective kinase inhibitors: targeting the anaplastic lymphoma kinase (ALK).

Selective kinase inhibitors have emerged as an important class of cancer therapeutics. The clinical success of drugs such as imatinib, erlotinib, and lapatinib, together with findings demonstrating the important relationship between specific tumor genotypes and clinical response to these agents, also has brought to the forefront the concept of "personalized cancer medicine." The potential broader significance of this relationship has been further highlighted in preclinical studies using tumor-derived cell lines as a model system that can faithfully recapitulate the association of specific genotypes with drug sensitivity, suggesting the utility of cancer cell lines to identify novel candidate biomarkers for predicting clinically responsive patient subsets for newly developed anticancer agents. The case of the anaplastic lymphoma kinase (ALK) nicely exemplifies this, and cell line profiling has revealed that ALK mutations present in a subset of anaplastic large cell lymphomas (ALCLs), non-small cell lung cancers (NSCLCs), and neuroblastomas appear to sensitize cancer cells to treatment with selective ALK kinase inhibitors. Such findings suggest that genotype-based stratification of cancer patients for treatment with selective kinase inhibitors, even across multiple diseases of distinct tissue origin, may be essential for maximizing their clinical benefit.

Increased prevalence of EGFR-mutant lung cancer in women and in East Asian populations: analysis of estrogen-related polymorphisms.

PURPOSE: Somatic mutations in the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) gene occur in a subset of non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) and are highly predictive of the clinical response to selective EGFR kinase inhibitors. The prevalence of EGFR-mutant NSCLC is appreciably higher in females than in males and in East Asian than in Caucasian populations. We hypothesized that these disparate frequencies may be attributable to underlying genetic modifiers. Given the coincident differences in sex and ethnic origin, we tested allozymatic variants of enzymes involved in estrogen biosynthesis and metabolism, encoded by polymorphic alleles known to differ in frequency between Caucasian and Asian populations, as modifying alleles. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: We genotyped nine polymorphisms in the CYP1A1, CYP17A1, CYP19, HSD17B1, COMT, GSTM1, and GSTT1 genes, in a series of 100 Japanese NSCLCs, selected for equal representation of EGFR wild-type (wt) and EGFR-mutant cases, as well as male and female cases. Associations between polymorphic variants and the EGFR genotype and sex of NSCLC cases were examined using Fisher's exact test of significance. RESULTS: Only CYP1A1 2C showed a difference in allele frequency that approached statistical significance. Heterozygotes were underrepresented among EGFR-mutant cases compared with EGFR-wt cases (27% versus 47%, P = 0.08), with a concurrent trend toward overrepresentation of CYP1A1 2C(Ile/Ile) homozygotes among EGFR-mutant cases as compared with EGFR-wt cases (69% versus 51%, P = 0.13). CONCLUSION: Within the power of this study, our findings suggest that the selected polymorphic variants in the estrogen biosynthesis and metabolism pathways are unlikely to be major genetic modifiers of the prevalence of EGFR-mutant NSCLC.

Adaptive Resistance to Dual BRAF/MEK Inhibition in BRAF-Driven Tumors through Autocrine FGFR Pathway Activation.

PURPOSE: Combined MAPK pathway inhibition using dual BRAF and MEK inhibitors has prolonged the duration of clinical response in patients with BRAFV600E-driven tumors compared with either agent alone. However, resistance frequently arises. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: We generated cell lines resistant to dual BRAF/MEK inhibition and utilized a pharmacologic synthetic lethal approach to identify a novel, adaptive resistance mechanism mediated through the fibroblast growth factor receptor (FGFR) pathway. RESULTS: In response to drug treatment, transcriptional upregulation of FGF1 results in autocrine activation of FGFR, which potentiates extracellular signal-regulated kinases (ERK) activation. FGFR inhibition overcomes resistance to dual BRAF/MEK inhibitors in both cell lines and patient-derived xenograft (PDX) models. Abrogation of this bypass mechanism in the first-line setting enhances tumor killing and prevents the emergence of drug-resistant cells. Moreover, clinical data implicate serum FGF1 levels in disease prognosis. CONCLUSIONS: Taken together, these results describe a new, adaptive resistance mechanism that is more commonly observed in the context of dual BRAF/MEK blockade as opposed to single-agent treatment and reveal the potential clinical utility of FGFR-targeting agents in combination with BRAF and MEK inhibitors as a promising strategy to forestall resistance in a subset of BRAF-driven cancers.