RESUMEN
Studies on Ebola virus disease (EVD) survivors and clinical studies on Ebola virus (EBOV) vaccine candidates have pinpointed the importance of a strong antibody response in protection and survival from EBOV infection. However, little is known about the T cell responses to EBOV or EBOV vaccines. We used HLA-A*02:01 (HLA-A2) transgenic mice to study HLA-A2-specific T cell responses elicited following vaccination with EBOV glycoprotein (EBOV-GP) presented with three different systems: (i) recombinant protein (rEBOV-GP), (ii) vesicular stomatitis replication-competent recombinant virus (VSV-EBOV-GP), and (iii) modified vaccinia Ankara virus recombinant (MVA-EBOV-GP). T cells from immunized animals were analyzed using peptide pools representing the entire GP region and individual peptides. Regardless of the vaccine formulation, we identified a minimal 9mer epitope containing an HLA-A2 motif (FLDPATTS), which was confirmed through HLA-A2 binding affinity and immunization studies. Using binding prediction software, we identified substitutions surrounding position 9 (S9V, P10V, and Q11V) that predicted enhanced binding to the HLA-A2 molecule. This enhanced binding was confirmed through in vitro binding studies and enhanced potency was shown with in vivo immunization studies using the enhanced sequences and the wild-type sequence. Of note, in silico studies predicted the enhanced 9mer epitope carrying the S9V substitution as the best overall HLA-A2 epitope for the full-length EBOV-GP. These results suggest that EBOV-GP-S9V and EBOV-GP-P10V represent more potent in vivo immunogens. Identification and enhancement of EBOV-specific human HLA epitopes could lead to the development of tools and reagents to induce more robust T cell responses in human subjects. IMPORTANCE Vaccine efficacy and immunity to viral infection are often measured by neutralizing antibody titers. T cells are specialized subsets of immune cells with antiviral activity, but this response is variable and difficult to track. We showed that the HLA-A2-specific T cell response to the Ebola virus glycoprotein can be enhanced significantly by a single residue substitution designed to improve an epitope binding affinity to one of the most frequent MHC alleles in the human population. This strategy could be applied to improve T cell responses to Ebola vaccines designed to elicit antibodies and adapted to target MHC alleles of populations in regions where endemic infections, like Ebola virus disease, are still causing outbreaks with concerning pandemic potential.
Asunto(s)
Aminoácidos , Ebolavirus , Epítopos de Linfocito T , Glicoproteínas , Fiebre Hemorrágica Ebola , Aminoácidos/metabolismo , Animales , Anticuerpos Neutralizantes , Anticuerpos Antivirales , Vacunas contra el Virus del Ébola/genética , Ebolavirus/genética , Epítopos de Linfocito T/metabolismo , Antígeno HLA-A2/genética , Antígeno HLA-A2/metabolismo , Humanos , Ratones , Proteínas Recombinantes , Virus Vaccinia , VesiculovirusRESUMEN
To evaluate the risk of residual cellular DNA in vaccines manufactured in tumorigenic cell lines, we have been establishing in vivo assays to quantify the oncogenic activity of DNA. We had generated three oncogene-expression plasmids: pMSV-T24-H-ras, which expresses activated H-ras; pMSV-c-myc, which expresses c-myc; and pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc, which expresses both oncogenes. Tumors were induced in mice by pMSV-T24-H-ras plus pMSV-c-myc or by pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc. Because newborn hamsters and newborn rats have been recommended for oncogenicity testing of the DNA from tumorigenic mammalian cell-substrates used for vaccine production, we evaluated their sensitivity. Newborn hamsters and rats were inoculated with different doses of pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc to determine their sensitivity to tumor induction and with the single-oncogene-expression plasmids to determine whether single oncogenes could induce tumors. Newborn rats were more sensitive than newborn hamsters, and activated H-ras but not c-myc induced tumors in newborns of both rodent species. DNA from four cell lines established from tumors induced by pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc was inoculated into newborn rats. Because no tumors were induced by this cellular DNA, which should be optimal as it contains both oncogenes linked and present in several copies, we conclude that available in vivo models are not sensitive enough to detect the oncogenicity of cellular DNA.
Asunto(s)
ADN , Neoplasias , Cricetinae , Ratas , Ratones , Animales , Animales Recién Nacidos , ADN/genética , ADN/metabolismo , Oncogenes , Plásmidos/genética , Neoplasias/metabolismo , Transformación Celular Neoplásica , Transfección , Mamíferos/metabolismoRESUMEN
All viral vaccines contain contaminating residual DNA derived from the production cell substrate. The potential risk of this DNA, particularly when derived from tumorigenic cells, has been debated for over 40 years. While the major risk has been considered to be the oncogenicity of the DNA, another potential risk is that a genome of an infectious virus is present in this DNA. Such a genome might generate an infectious agent that could establish an infection in vaccine recipients. To determine the quantity of a retroviral provirus in cellular DNA that can establish a productive infection in vitro, we developed a transfection/co-culture system capable of recovering infectious virus from 1 pg of cloned HIV DNA and from 2 microg of cellular DNA from HIV-infected cells. We demonstrate that infectivity can be reduced to below detectable levels either by lowering the median size of the DNA to 350 base pairs or by treatment with beta-propiolactone. From the amount of reduction of infectivity, we calculate that clearance values in excess of 10(7) are attainable with respect to the infectivity associated with residual cell-substrate DNA. Thus, the potential risk associated with DNA can be substantially reduced by degradation or by chemical inactivation.
Asunto(s)
ADN Viral/análisis , ADN Viral/fisiología , Retroviridae/genética , Retroviridae/patogenicidad , Inactivación de Virus , Vacunas contra el SIDA/genética , Células Cultivadas , Clonación Molecular , ADN Superhelicoidal/fisiología , ADN Viral/aislamiento & purificación , ADN Viral/metabolismo , Desinfectantes/farmacología , Endodesoxirribonucleasas/metabolismo , Endorribonucleasas/metabolismo , Infecciones por VIH/genética , VIH-1/genética , VIH-1/patogenicidad , Humanos , Células Jurkat , Propiolactona/farmacología , Infecciones por Retroviridae/prevención & controlRESUMEN
The presence of some residual cellular DNA derived from the production-cell substrate in viral vaccines is inevitable. Whether this DNA represents a safety concern, particularly if the cell substrate is derived from a tumor or is tumorigenic, is unknown. DNA has two biological activities that need to be considered. First, DNA can be oncogenic; second, DNA can be infectious. As part of our studies to assess the risk of residual cell-substrate DNA in viral vaccines, we have established assays that can quantify the biological activities of DNA. From data obtained using these assays, we have estimated the risk of an oncogenic or an infectious event from DNA. Because these estimates were derived from the most sensitive assays identified so far, they likely represent worst-case estimates. In addition, methods that inactivate the biological activities of DNA can be assessed and estimations of risk reduction by these treatments can be made. In this paper, we discuss our approaches to address potential safety issues associated with residual cellular DNA from neoplastic cell substrates in viral vaccines, summarize the development of assays to quantify the oncogenic and infectivity activities of DNA, and discuss methods to reduce the biological activities of DNA.
Asunto(s)
ADN/fisiología , Vacunas Virales , AlgoritmosRESUMEN
Development of vaccines against highly pathogenic viruses that could also be used as agents of bioterrorism is both a public health issue and a national security priority. Methods that can quantify neutralizing antibodies will likely be crucial in demonstrating vaccine effectiveness, as most licensed viral vaccines are effective due to their capacity to elicit neutralizing antibodies. Assays to determine whether antibodies are neutralizing traditionally involve infectious virus, and the assay most commonly used is the plaque-reduction neutralization test (PRNT). However, when the virus is highly pathogenic, this assay must be done under the appropriate level of containment; for tier one select agents, such as Ebola virus (EBOV), it is performed under Biological Safety Level 4 (BSL-4) conditions. Developing high-throughput neutralization assays for these viruses that can be done in standard BSL-2 laboratories should facilitate vaccine development. Our approach is to use a replication-competent hybrid virus whose genome carries the envelope gene from the pathogenic virus on the genetic backbone of a non-pathogenic virus, such as vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV). We have generated hybrid VSVs carrying the envelope genes for several species of ebolavirus. The readout for infectivity is a one-step reverse transcriptase quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR), an approach that we have used for other viruses that allows robustness and adaptability to automation. Using this method, we have shown that neutralization can be assessed within 6-16h after infection. Importantly, the titers obtained in our assay with two characterized antibodies were in agreement with titers obtained in other assays. Finally, although in this paper we describe the VSV platform to quantify neutralizing antibodies to ebolaviruses, the platform should be directly applicable to any virus whose envelope is compatible with VSV biology.
Asunto(s)
Anticuerpos Neutralizantes/inmunología , Vacunas contra el Virus del Ébola/inmunología , Ebolavirus/inmunología , Estomatitis Vesicular/inmunología , Virus de la Estomatitis Vesicular Indiana/inmunología , Animales , Anticuerpos Antivirales/inmunología , Línea Celular , Chlorocebus aethiops , Células HEK293 , Humanos , Pruebas de Neutralización/métodos , Reacción en Cadena en Tiempo Real de la Polimerasa/métodos , Células Vero , Estomatitis Vesicular/prevención & control , Proteínas del Envoltorio Viral/inmunología , Vacunas Virales/inmunologíaRESUMEN
As part of safety studies to evaluate the risk of residual cellular DNA in vaccines manufactured in tumorigenic cells, we have been developing in vivo assays to detect and quantify the oncogenic activity of DNA. We generated a plasmid expressing both an activated human H-ras gene and murine c-myc gene and showed that 1 µg of this plasmid, pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc, was capable of inducing tumors in newborn NIH Swiss mice. However, to be able to detect the oncogenicity of dominant activated oncogenes in cellular DNA, a more sensitive system was needed. In this paper, we demonstrate that the newborn CD3 epsilon transgenic mouse, which is defective in both T-cell and NK-cell functions, can detect the oncogenic activity of 25 ng of the circular form of pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc. When this plasmid was inoculated as linear DNA, amounts of DNA as low as 800 pg were capable of inducing tumors. Animals were found that had multiple tumors, and these tumors were independent and likely clonal. These results demonstrate that the newborn CD3 epsilon mouse is highly sensitive for the detection of oncogenic activity of DNA. To determine whether it can detect the oncogenic activity of cellular DNA derived from four human tumor-cell lines (HeLa, A549, HT-1080, and CEM), DNA (100 µg) was inoculated into newborn CD3 epsilon mice both in the presence of 1 µg of linear pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc as positive control and in its absence. While tumors were induced in 100% of mice with the positive-control plasmid, no tumors were induced in mice receiving any of the tumor DNAs alone. These results demonstrate that detection of oncogenes in cellular DNA derived from four human tumor-derived cell lines in this mouse system was not possible; the results also show the importance of including a positive-control plasmid to detect inhibitory effects of the cellular DNA.
Asunto(s)
Genes myc , Genes ras , Células Asesinas Naturales/patología , Ratones/genética , Neoplasias/genética , Plásmidos/genética , Linfocitos T/patología , Animales , Línea Celular Tumoral , ADN Circular/genética , ADN de Neoplasias/genética , Humanos , Células Asesinas Naturales/metabolismo , Ratones/fisiología , Ratones Transgénicos , Neoplasias/patología , Linfocitos T/metabolismoRESUMEN
Vaccines contain residual DNA derived from the cells used to produce them. As part of our investigation to assess the risk of this cellular DNA, we are developing a quantitative in vivo assay to assess the oncogenicity of DNA. In an earlier study, we had generated expression plasmids for two oncogenes--human activated T24-H-ras and murine c-myc--and had shown that these two plasmids, pMSV-T24-H-ras and pMSV-c-myc, could act in concert to induce tumors in mice, although the efficiency was low. In this study, we took two approaches to increase the oncogenic efficiency: 1) both oncogene-expression cassettes were placed on the same plasmid; 2) transfection facilitators, which increase DNA uptake and expression in vitro, were tested. The dual-expression plasmid, pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc, is about 20-fold more efficient at tumor induction in newborn NIH Swiss mice than the separate expression plasmids, with tumors being induced with 1 microg of the dual-expression plasmid DNA. However, none of the transfection facilitators tested increased the efficiency of tumor induction. Based on these data, the dual-expression plasmid pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc will be used as the positive control to develop a sensitive and quantitative animal assay that can be used to assess the oncogenic activity of DNA.