Probing Microbiome Genotoxicity: A Stable Colibactin Provides Insight into Structure-Activity Relationships and Facilitates Mechanism of Action Studies.

Colibactin is a genotoxic metabolite produced by commensal-pathogenic members of the human microbiome that possess the clb (aka pks) biosynthetic gene cluster. clb+ bacteria induce tumorigenesis in models of intestinal inflammation and have been causally linked to oncogenesis in humans. While colibactin is believed underlie these effects, it has not been possible to study the molecule directly due to its instability. Herein, we report the synthesis and biological studies of colibactin 742 (4), a stable colibactin derivative. We show that colibactin 742 (4) induces DNA interstrand-cross-links, activation of the Fanconi Anemia DNA repair pathway, and G2/M arrest in a manner similar to clb+E. coli. The linear precursor 9, which mimics the biosynthetic precursor to colibactin, also recapitulates the bacterial phenotype. In the course of this work, we discovered a novel cyclization pathway that was previously undetected in MS-based studies of colibactin, suggesting a refinement to the natural product structure and its mode of DNA binding. Colibactin 742 (4) and its precursor 9 will allow researchers to study colibactin's genotoxic effects independent of the producing organism for the first time.

Structure Revision of the Lomaiviticins.

The lomaiviticins are dimeric genotoxic metabolites that contain unusual diazocyclopentadiene functional groups and 2-4 deoxyglycoside residues. Because only 6 of 19 carbon atoms in the monomeric aglycon unit are proton-attached, their structure determination by NMR spectroscopic analysis is difficult. Prior structure elucidation efforts established that the two halves of the lomaiviticins are joined by a single carbon-carbon bond appended to an oxidized cyclohexenone ring. This ring was believed to comprise a 4,5-dihydroxycyclohex-2-ene-1-one. The bridging bond was positioned at C6. This structure proposal has not been tested because no lomaiviticin has been prepared by total chemical synthesis or successfully analyzed by X-ray crystallography. Here, we disclose microED studies which establish that (-)-lomaiviticin C contains a 4,6-dihydroxy-cyclohex-2-ene-1-one residue, that the bridging carbon-carbon bond is located at C5, and that the orientation of the cyclohexenone ring and configuration of the secondary glycoside are reversed, relative to their original assignment. High-field (800 MHz) NMR analysis supports the revised assignment and suggests earlier efforts were misled by a combination of a near-zero 3JH4,H5 coupling constant and a 4JC,H coupling interpreted as a 3JC,H coupling. DFT calculations of the expected 13C chemical shifts and C-H coupling constants provide further robust support for the structure revision. Because the interconversion of lomaiviticins A, B, and C has been demonstrated, these findings apply to each isolate. These studies clarify the structures of this family of metabolites and underscore the power of microED analysis in natural product structure determination.

Depurination of Colibactin-Derived Interstrand Cross-Links.

Colibactin is a genotoxic gut microbiome metabolite long suspected of playing an etiological role in colorectal cancer. Evidence suggests that colibactin forms DNA interstrand cross-links (ICLs) in eukaryotic cells and activates ICL repair pathways, leading to the production of ICL-dependent DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). Here we show that colibactin ICLs can evolve directly to DNA DSBs. Using the topology of supercoiled plasmid DNA as a proxy for alkylation adduct stability, we find that colibactin-derived ICLs are unstable toward depurination and elimination of the 3' phosphate. This ICL degradation pathway leads progressively to single strand breaks (SSBs) and subsequently DSBs. The spontaneous conversion of ICLs to DSBs is consistent with the finding that nonhomologous end joining repair-deficient cells are sensitized to colibactin-producing bacteria. The results herein refine our understanding of colibactin-derived DNA damage and underscore the complexities underlying the DSB phenotype.

Development of a Convergent Enantioselective Synthetic Route to (-)-Myrocin G.

Myrocins are a family of antiproliferative antibiotic fungal metabolites possessing a masked electrophilic cyclopropane. Preliminary chemical reactivity studies imputed the bioactivity of these natural products to a DNA cross-linking mechanism, but this hypothesis was not confirmed by studies with native DNA. We recently reported a total synthesis of (-)-myrocin G (4), the putative active form of the metabolite myrocin C (1), that featured a carefully orchestrated tandem fragment coupling-annulation cascade. Herein, we describe the evolution of our synthetic strategy toward 4 and report the series of discoveries that prompted the design of this cascade coupling. Efforts to convert the diosphenol (-)-myrocin G (4) to the corresponding 5-hydroxy-γ-lactone isomer myrocin C (1) are also detailed. We present a preliminary evaluation of the antiproliferative activities of (-)-myrocin G (4) and related structures, as well as DNA cross-linking studies. These studies indicate that myrocins do not cross-link DNA, suggesting an alternative mode of action potentially involving a protein target.

Structure and bioactivity of colibactin.

Colibactin is a secondary metabolite produced by certain strains of bacteria found in the human gut. The presence of colibactin-producing bacteria has been correlated to colorectal cancer in humans. Colibactin was first discovered in 2006, but because it is produced in small quantities and is unstable, it has yet to be isolated from bacterial cultures. Here we summarize advances in the field since ~2017 that have led to the identification of the structure of colibactin as a heterodimer containing two DNA-reactive electrophilic cyclopropane residues. Colibactin has been shown to form interstrand cross-links by alkylation of adenine residues on opposing strands of DNA. The structure of colibactin contains two thiazole rings separated by a two-carbon linker that is thought to exist as an α-aminoketone following completion of the biosynthetic pathway. However, synthetic studies have now established that this α-aminoketone is unstable toward aerobic oxidation; the resulting oxidation products are in turn unstable toward nucleophilic cleavage under mild conditions. These data provide a simple molecular-level explanation for colibactin's instability and potentially also explain the observation that cell-to-cell contact is required for genotoxic effects.

Characterization of Natural Colibactin-Nucleobase Adducts by Tandem Mass Spectrometry and Isotopic Labeling. Support for DNA Alkylation by Cyclopropane Ring Opening.

Colibactins are genotoxic secondary metabolites whose biosynthesis is encoded in the clb gene cluster harbored by certain strains of gut commensal Escherichia coli. Using synthetic colibactin analogues, we previously provided evidence that colibactins alkylate DNA by addition of a nucleotide to an electrophilic cyclopropane intermediate. However, natural colibactin-nucleobase adducts have not been identified, to the best of our knowledge. Here we present the first identification of such adducts, derived from treatment of pUC19 DNA with clb + E. coli. Previous biosynthetic studies established cysteine and methionine as building blocks in colibactin biosynthesis; accordingly, we used cysteine (Δ cysE) and methionine (Δ metA) auxotrophic strains cultured in media supplemented with l-[U-13C]Cys or l-[U-13C]Met to facilitate the identification of nucleobases bound to colibactins. Using MS2 and MS3 analysis, in conjunction with the known oxidative instability of colibactin cyclopropane-opened products, we were able to characterize adenine adducts derived from cyclopropane ring opening. This study provides the first reported detection of nucleobase adducts derived from clb + E. coli and lends support to our earlier model suggesting DNA alkylation by addition of a nucleotide to an electrophilic cyclopropane.

Mechanism of Nucleophilic Activation of (-)-Lomaiviticin A.

(-)-Lomaiviticin A (1) is a C2-symmetric cytotoxin that contains two diazofluorene functional groups and which induces double-strand breaks (DSBs) in DNA. Evidence suggests DNA cleavage is initiated by hydrogen atom abstraction from the deoxyribose backbone. Here we demonstrate the formation of the vinyl radicals 1· and 2· from 1 by 1,7-addition of thiols to the diazofluorenes. These radicals can affect hydrogen atom abstraction from methanol and acetone. The first addition of thiol to 1 proceeds at a much greater rate than the second. The diazosulfide 5 formed en route to 1· has been detected at -50 °C and undergoes decomposition to 1· with a half-life of 110 min at -20 °C under air. These data, which constitute the first direct evidence for the generation of 1· and 2· from 1, provide insights into the mechanism of DNA cleavage by 1.

Commensal microbiota from patients with inflammatory bowel disease produce genotoxic metabolites.

Microbiota-derived metabolites that elicit DNA damage can contribute to colorectal cancer (CRC). However, the full spectrum of genotoxic chemicals produced by indigenous gut microbes remains to be defined. We established a pipeline to systematically evaluate the genotoxicity of an extensive collection of gut commensals from inflammatory bowel disease patients. We identified isolates from divergent phylogenies whose metabolites caused DNA damage and discovered a distinctive family of genotoxins-termed the indolimines-produced by the CRC-associated species Morganella morganii. A non-indolimine-producing M. morganii mutant lacked genotoxicity and failed to exacerbate colon tumorigenesis in mice. These studies reveal the existence of a previously unexplored universe of genotoxic small molecules from the microbiome that may affect host biology in homeostasis and disease.

Structure elucidation of colibactin and its DNA cross-links.

Colibactin is a complex secondary metabolite produced by some genotoxic gut Escherichia coli strains. The presence of colibactin-producing bacteria correlates with the frequency and severity of colorectal cancer in humans. However, because colibactin has not been isolated or structurally characterized, studying the physiological effects of colibactin-producing bacteria in the human gut has been difficult. We used a combination of genetics, isotope labeling, tandem mass spectrometry, and chemical synthesis to deduce the structure of colibactin. Our structural assignment accounts for all known biosynthetic and cell biology data and suggests roles for the final unaccounted enzymes in the colibactin gene cluster.

Model Colibactins Exhibit Human Cell Genotoxicity in the Absence of Host Bacteria.

Colibactins are genotoxic secondary metabolites produced in select Enterobacteriaceae, which induce downstream DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) in human cell lines and are thought to promote the formation of colorectal tumors. Although key structural and functional features of colibactins have been elucidated, the full molecular mechanisms regulating these phenotypes remain unknown. Here, we demonstrate that free model colibactins induce DSBs in human cell cultures and do not require delivery by host bacteria. Through domain-targeted editing, we demonstrate that a subset of native colibactins generated from observed module skipping in the nonribosomal peptide synthetase-polyketide synthase (NRPS-PKS) biosynthetic assembly line share DNA alkylation phenotypes with the model colibactins in vitro. However, module skipping eliminates the strong DNA interstrand cross-links formed by the wild-type pathway in cell culture. This product diversification during the modular NRPS-PKS biosynthesis produces a family of metabolites with varying observed mechanisms of action (DNA alkylation versus cross-linking) in cell culture. The presence of membranes separating human cells from model colibactins attenuated genotoxicity, suggesting that membrane diffusion limits colibactin activity and could account for the reported bacterium-human cell-to-cell contact phenotype. Additionally, extracellular supplementation of the colibactin resistance protein ClbS was able to intercept colibactins in an Escherichia coli-human cell transient infection model. Our studies demonstrate that free model colibactins recapitulate cellular phenotypes associated with module-skipped products in the native colibactin pathway and define specific protein domains that are required for efficient DNA interstrand cross-linking in the native pathway.