RESUMEN
We describe and discuss the forensic mission after the terrorist attack on the Breitscheidplatz in Berlin on 19th December 2016, focusing on co-operation with police authorities, and the injury patterns of the deceased. Even after massive blunt trauma, severe injury patterns are often unrecognizable by visual inspection of the body ("Casper's sign"), which could instill false security among rescuers or, as happened on the Breitscheidplatz, may lead to distress or even trauma in rescue personnel when obviously primarily uninjured patients die suddenly.
Asunto(s)
Incidentes con Víctimas en Masa , Terrorismo , Berlin , Lesiones Traumáticas del Encéfalo/patología , Lesiones por Aplastamiento/patología , Femenino , Medicina Legal , Humanos , Masculino , Traumatismo Múltiple/patología , Choque Hemorrágico/etiologíaRESUMEN
Disaster victim identification (DVI) often occurs in remote locations with extremes of temperatures and humidities. Access to mortuary facilities and refrigeration are not always available. An effective and robust DNA sampling and preservation procedure would increase the probability of successful DNA profiling and allow faster repatriation of bodies and body parts. If the act of tissue preservation also released DNA into solution, ready for polymerase chain reaction (PCR), the DVI process could be further streamlined. In this study, we explored the possibility of obtaining DNA profiles without DNA extraction, by adding aliquots of preservative solutions surrounding fresh human muscle and decomposing human muscle and skin tissue samples directly to PCR. The preservatives consisted of two custom preparations and two proprietary solutions. The custom preparations were a salt-saturated solution of dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) with ethylenediaminetetraacetic (EDTA) and TENT buffer (Tris, EDTA, NaCl, Tween 20). The proprietary preservatives were DNAgard (Biomatrica(®)) and Tissue Stabilising Kit (DNA Genotek). We obtained full PowerPlex(®) 21 (Promega) and GlobalFiler(®) (Life Technologies) DNA profiles from fresh and decomposed tissue preserved at 35 °C for up to 28 days for all four preservatives. The preservative aliquots removed from the fresh muscle tissue samples had been stored at -80 °C for 4 years, indicating that long-term archival does not diminish the probability of successful DNA typing. Rather, storage at -80 °C seems to reduce PCR inhibition.
Asunto(s)
Dermatoglifia del ADN/métodos , ADN/análisis , Reacción en Cadena de la Polimerasa , Conservación de Tejido , Crioprotectores , Dimetilsulfóxido , Ácido Edético , Genotipo , Humanos , Repeticiones de Microsatélite , Músculo Esquelético/química , Piel/química , Manejo de Especímenes/métodosRESUMEN
Integrated approaches to disaster victim identification (DVI) management have led to a need for technologies to improve interaction among parties involved in post-mortem (PM) and ante-mortem (AM) data collection through better communication and coordination. Mobile Forensic Workspace© (MFW) is a collaborative mobile system that not only facilitates the systematic collection of high-quality data, but also allows DVI professionals to coordinate activities and exchange data through secure real-time communication at major disaster scenarios in accordance with security, privacy and legal protocols. MFW is adaptable to any communication format (text, voice calls, photographs, etc.) and is dynamically self-reconfigurable when connectivity problems arise. It also allows data integration and backup through secure communication channels between local and remote servers. The feasibility of the system has been demonstrated through implementation of MFW on the iOS platform for iPhone, iPod Touch and iPad terminals. A further strength of MFW is that it provides out-of-the-box support for INTERPOL DVI forms. The application of information and communication technologies for DVI was shown to be useful in improving DVI management by enhancing the quality of data collection and enabling non-Internet dependent real-time data sharing and communication.
Asunto(s)
Víctimas de Desastres , Desastres , Humanos , Medicina Legal , Autopsia , Odontología Forense/métodosRESUMEN
As an emerging technology, Rapid DNA has demonstrated its utility for law enforcement in the provision of DNA profiling data at the point of arrest, often not requiring analyst review of the profiles generated. Recently, efforts have centred on the evaluation of Rapid DNA (without analyst review) and modified Rapid DNA (requiring review by a trained analyst) for application to crime scene samples. In a broader forensic context, however, another application for Rapid DNA is its use to process post-mortem samples to assist with the identification of deceased persons; and while gaps in our knowledge remain as to how Rapid DNA instruments perform with these sample types (often compromised with regards to their yield and quality of DNA), they have been successfully deployed in the field to assist in the identification of disaster victims (as exemplified during the 2018 Californian wildfire). This review aims to provide the current research landscape for the forensic application of Rapid DNA as an emerging technology from a Disaster Victim Identification perspective.
Asunto(s)
Víctimas de Desastres , ADN/genética , Dermatoglifia del ADN , Humanos , Aplicación de la LeyRESUMEN
The ANDE 6C Rapid DNA system could offer a potential alternative for the processing of calcified and soft tissue samples, often encountered in mass disaster scenarios. While originally designed for single source buccal swabs, interest in the performance of these instruments when using other types of single source samples continues to grow. To enhance the recovery of otherwise lesser quality samples, the manufacturer developed the investigative biochip, an alternative to the NDIS approved Arrestee biochip for reference sample buccal swabs. This study explores the viability of using the ANDE 6C system and the investigative biochip to process soft and calcified tissue, and uses conventional sample processing to contrast the results. Though the success rate obtained using the instrument's expert system was lower than expected - 0% muscle, 11% ribs, and 50% teeth -, the ANDE 6C offers an advantage over conventional calcified tissue processing in terms of turn-around time and processing complexity. If robust analysis parameters can be established to allow the evaluation of the generated data by a qualified analyst on a third party software platform, the use of the ANDE 6C and investigative biochip could be a suitable alternative for currently employed procedures. However, as is the case with conventional DNA typing, the quantity, age, type of biological material and quality of the exemplars could all play a role in the success of the ANDE 6C typing process. In addition, it appears as if the calcified tissue pre-processing protocol that provides the better opportunity for the ANDE 6C success is not appropriate to be carried out in the field or by non-trained personnel as special equipment as well as a certain level of exe expertise and technique is necessary. Nevertheless, disaster victim and unidentified human remain samples could be processed in a laboratory setting using the Rapid DNA ANDE 6C platform provided sufficient material is available to conduct a second, 'rescue' sample processing if necessary.
Asunto(s)
Dermatoglifia del ADN/métodos , ADN/análisis , Manejo de Especímenes/instrumentación , Víctimas de Desastres , Humanos , Músculo Esquelético/química , Costillas/química , Diente/químicaRESUMEN
One of the important issues during the response to a mass disaster is the identification of victims. In this study, we verified the use of the occlusal morphology of molars for individual identification. The aim of this study was to establish a simple new method for identifying individuals from molar data. Using Python, we developed programming that included the perceptual Hash (pHash) function and the Hamming distance (HD) between antemortem data (AMD) and postmortem data (PMD). The AMD comprised 2,215 dental models. The PMD were selected from the AMD set and comprised 17 models from the same individual with changes over time. As a result, 16 PMD models (over 90%) were ranked in the top 5%. Although identification using only a single molar is difficult, there is the possibility of narrowing down victims' identity with high accuracy through verification using multiple teeth. This system is expected to be useful as a very simple method of identification.
Asunto(s)
Oclusión Dental , Odontología Forense/métodos , Procesamiento de Imagen Asistido por Computador , Modelos Dentales , Diente Molar/anatomía & histología , Programas Informáticos , Víctimas de Desastres , Humanos , Imagenología TridimensionalRESUMEN
OBJECTIVE: Although dentists are valuable assets in identification teams during disaster events, forensic dentistry is not used effectively in the identification studies conducted in Turkey, and the importance of dental data is ignored. The aim of this study was to determine the level of knowledge of dentists regarding their duties and responsibilities during major disasters. METHODS: This descriptive study was conducted between December 2015 and June 2016. Registered dentists (n=20.280) of the Turkish Dental Association were invited to complete the organization's online survey. A total of 539 dentists participated in the volunteer workshop. Data were analyzed using SPSS, version 22.0 (IBM Corp, Armonk, NY). The chi-square analysis was used to evaluate the knowledge level of dentists by group regarding disaster victim identification (DVI) - the process and procedure of recovering and identifying victims of major disasters (eg, earthquake, terrorist attack). RESULTS: The dentists included in the study consisted of 320 (59.4%) females and 219 (40.6%) males with a mean age of 37.4±12.6 years. The number of specialists and general dentists were 249 (45.6%) and 297 (54.4%), respectively; 249 (69.71%) dentists who had knowledge about forensic dentistry stated that they received this information during their formal training. The percentage of dentists who were aware of the existence of an organization of a disaster response operation in Turkey was 74.2%, but only 20.5% (n=110) had knowledge about DVI. We found that 92.9% (n=104) of these dentists believed that dentists should be included in the team for the identification of disaster victims. On the other hand, only half (52.3%) of the dentists with knowledge of DVI wanted to work on the identification teams. The majority (99.1%) considered DNA analysis to be the safest method for identification. CONCLUSION: Our findings show that, although dentists know about the identification process, they do not have enough relevant knowledge. (Disaster Med Public Health Preparedness. 2019;13:533-538).
Asunto(s)
Odontólogos/normas , Medicina de Desastres/métodos , Antropología Forense/métodos , Rol Profesional/psicología , Adulto , Odontólogos/psicología , Odontólogos/estadística & datos numéricos , Medicina de Desastres/estadística & datos numéricos , Víctimas de Desastres/estadística & datos numéricos , Femenino , Antropología Forense/estadística & datos numéricos , Humanos , Masculino , Persona de Mediana Edad , TurquíaRESUMEN
DNA profiling has emerged as the gold standard for the identification of victims in mass disaster events providing an ability to identify victims, reassociate remains and provide investigative leads at a relatively low cost, and with a high degree of discrimination. For the majority of samples, DNA-based identification can be achieved in a fast, streamlined and high-throughput manner. However, a large number of remains will be extremely compromised, characteristic of mass disasters. Advances in technology and in the field of forensic biology have increased the options for the collection, sampling, preservation and processing of samples for DNA profiling. Furthermore, recent developments now allow a vast array of new genetic markers and genotyping techniques to extract as much genetic information from a sample as possible, ensuring that identification is not only accurate but also possible where material is degraded, or limited. Where historically DNA profiling has involved comparison with ante mortem samples or relatives, now DNA profiling can direct investigators towards putative victims or relatives, for comparison through the determination of externally visible characteristics, or biogeographical ancestry. This paper reviews the current and emerging tools available for maximising the recovery of genetic information from post mortem samples in a disaster victim identification context.
Asunto(s)
Restos Mortales/química , Dermatoglifia del ADN , ADN/aislamiento & purificación , Víctimas de Desastres , Genética Forense/métodos , Cromosomas Humanos X , Cromosomas Humanos Y , Electroforesis Capilar , Marcadores Genéticos , Haplotipos , Humanos , Mutación INDEL , Soluciones Preservantes de Órganos , Polimorfismo de Nucleótido Simple , Manejo de Especímenes/métodosRESUMEN
DNA analysis was first applied to the identification of victims of armed conflicts and other situations of violence (ACOSV) in the mid-1990s, starting in South America and the Balkans. Argentina was the first country to establish a genetic database specifically developed to identify disappeared children. Following on from these programs the early 2000s marked major programs, using a largely DNA-led approach, identifying missing persons in the Balkans and following the attack on the World Trade Center in New York. These two identification programs significantly expanded the magnitude of events to which DNA analysis was used to help provide the identity of missing persons. Guidelines developed by Interpol (2014) [1] related to best practice for identification of human remains following DVI type scenarios have been widely disseminated around the forensic community; in numerous cases these guidelines have been adopted or incorporated into national guidelines/standards/practice. However, given the complexity of many humanitarian contexts in which forensic science is employed there is a lack of internationally accepted guidelines, related to these contexts, for authorities to reference. In response the Argentine government's Human Rights Division in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Worship (MREC) proposed that the United Nations (UN) should promote best practice in the use of forensic genetics in humanitarian forensic action: this was adopted by the UN in Resolutions A/HRC/RES/10/26 and A/HRC/RES/15/5. Following on from the adoption of the resolutions MREC has coordinated, with the support of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), the drafting of a set of guidelines (MREC, ICRC, 2014) [2], with input from national and international agencies. To date the guidelines have been presented to South America's MERCOSUR and the UN and have been disseminated to interested parties.
Asunto(s)
Dermatoglifia del ADN/normas , Genética Forense/normas , Guías como Asunto , Restos Mortales , ADN/aislamiento & purificación , Desastres , Humanos , Cooperación Internacional , Reacción en Cadena de la Polimerasa , Manejo de Especímenes/normas , Naciones UnidasRESUMEN
La valoración de la prueba de ADN en los casos de identificación masiva, exige el uso por los peritos del teorema de Bayes para estimar la probabilidad de identificación a partir de unos datos a priori a los que se suman las probabilidades proporcionadas por la prueba de ADN. Para aplicarlo hace falta, por una parte, especificar la probabilidad a priori de las hipótesis de identidad que se pueden plantear, de modo que un equipo multidisciplinario y la figura de un coordinador de identificaciones son clave. El abordaje estadístico puede ser complejo, pero existen programas validados no comerciales, como el software Familias que facilitan las estimaciones de las razones de verosimilitud de la prueba de ADN para las hipótesis que se establezcan. A continuación, la probabilidad a posteriori en eventos de identificación a gran escala se puede estimar a través de las aproximaciones one to one, PM-driven, AM-driven y Global approach publicadas recientemente por Kling et al. y que son descritas a detalle en este artículo. El papel del Coordinador de Identificación es clave en la formulación de las hipótesis del caso, en el establecimiento de las probabilidades a priori, del umbral de identificación y en consolidar el reporte integrado de identificación junto al equipo multidisciplinario, a través de la reconciliación del caso. (AU)
The evaluation of the DNA test in massive identification cases requires the use of Bayes' Theorem to estimate the probability of identification from a priori data together with probabilities obtained from the DNA test itself. To apply it, one needs to specify the prior probabilities of the hypotheses. An interdisciplinary team and an identification coordinator are key stakeholders in this process. The statistical approach can be complex, but there exists validated non-commercial software, such as Familias, which aid in estimating the likelihood ratios of the DNA test for the given hypotheses. Next, the posterior probabilities in massive identification events can be estimated using the one-to-one, PM-driven, AM-driven or Global approaches published recently by Kling et al. Which are discussed in this article. The Identification Coordinator has a key role in formulating the hypotheses of the case, in establishing the prior probabilities, the identification threshold and in consolidating the integrated identification report together with the multidisciplinary team through the reconciliation of the case. (AU)
Asunto(s)
Humanos , Antropología Forense , Estudios de Asociación Genética , Teorema de Bayes , ADN , Identificación de VíctimasRESUMEN
One of the key features to be considered in a mass disaster is victim identification. However, the recovery and identification of human remains are sometimes complicated by harsh environmental conditions, limited facilities, loss of electricity and lack of refrigeration. If human remains cannot be collected, stored, or identified immediately, bodies decompose and DNA degrades making genotyping more difficult and ultimately decreasing DNA profiling success. In order to prevent further DNA damage and degradation after collection, tissue preservatives may be used. The goal of this study was to evaluate three customized (modified TENT, DESS, LST) and two commercial DNA preservatives (RNAlater and DNAgard®) on fresh and decomposed human skin and muscle samples stored in hot (35°C) and humid (60-70% relative humidity) conditions for up to three months. Skin and muscle samples were harvested from the thigh of three human cadavers placed outdoors for up to two weeks. In addition, the possibility of purifying DNA directly from the preservative solutions ("free DNA") was investigated in order to eliminate lengthy tissue digestion processes and increase throughput. The efficiency of each preservative was evaluated based on the quantity of DNA recovered from both the "free DNA" in solution and the tissue sample itself in conjunction with the quality and completeness of downstream STR profiles. As expected, DNA quantity and STR success decreased with time of decomposition. However, a marked decrease in DNA quantity and STR quality was observed in all samples after the bodies entered the bloat stage (approximately six days of decomposition in this study). Similar amounts of DNA were retrieved from skin and muscle samples over time, but slightly more complete STR profiles were obtained from muscle tissue. Although higher amounts of DNA were recovered from tissue samples than from the surrounding preservative, the average number of reportable alleles from the "free DNA" was comparable. Overall, DNAgard® and the modified TENT buffer were the most successful tissue preservatives tested in this study based on STR profile success from "free DNA" in solution when decomposing tissues were stored for up to three months in hot, humid conditions.
Asunto(s)
Dermatoglifia del ADN , ADN/análisis , Fijadores/química , Cambios Post Mortem , Conservación de Tejido/métodos , Genotipo , Calor , Humanos , Humedad , Músculo Esquelético/patología , Reacción en Cadena de la Polimerasa , Piel/patología , Manejo de EspecímenesRESUMEN
The international disaster victim identification (DVI) response to the Boxing Day tsunami, led by the Royal Thai Police in Phuket, Thailand, was one of the largest and most complex in DVI history. Referred to as the Thai Tsunami Victim Identification operation, the group comprised a multi-national, multi-agency, and multi-disciplinary team. The traditional DVI approach proved successful in identifying a large number of victims quickly. However, the team struggled to identify certain victims due to incomplete or poor quality ante-mortem and post-mortem data. In response to these challenges, a new 'near-threshold' DVI management strategy was implemented to target presumptive identifications and improve operational efficiency. The strategy was implemented by the DNA Team, therefore DNA kinship matches that just failed to reach the reporting threshold of 99.9% were prioritized, however the same approach could be taken by targeting, for example, cases with partial fingerprint matches. The presumptive DNA identifications were progressively filtered through the Investigation, Dental and Fingerprint Teams to add additional information necessary to either strengthen or conclusively exclude the identification. Over a five-month period 111 victims from ten countries were identified using this targeted approach. The new identifications comprised 87 adults, 24 children and included 97 Thai locals. New data from the Fingerprint Team established nearly 60% of the total near-threshold identifications and the combined DNA/Physical method was responsible for over 30%. Implementing the new strategy, targeting near-threshold cases, had positive management implications. The process initiated additional ante-mortem information collections, and established a much-needed, distinct "end-point" for unresolved cases.