Healthcare Costs and Utilization among Patients Hospitalized for Malignant Pleural Effusion.

BACKGROUND: Malignant pleural effusion (MPE) poses a considerable healthcare burden, but little is known about trends in directly attributable hospital utilization. OBJECTIVE: We aimed to study national trends in healthcare utilization and outcomes among hospitalized MPE patients. METHODS: We analyzed adult hospitalizations attributable to MPE using the Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project - National Inpatient Sample (HCUP-NIS) databases from 2004, 2009, and 2014. Cases were included if MPE was coded as the principal admission diagnosis or if unspecified pleural effusion was coded as the principal admission diagnosis in the setting of metastatic cancer. Annual hospitalizations were estimated for the entire US hospital population using discharge weights. Length of stay (LOS), hospital charges, and hospital mortality were also estimated. RESULTS: We analyzed 92,034 hospital discharges spanning a decade (2004-2014). Yearly hospitalizations steadily decreased from 38,865 to 23,965 during this time frame, the mean LOS decreased from 7.7 to 6.3 days, and the adjusted hospital mortality decreased from 7.9 to 4.5% (p = 0.00 for all trend analyses). The number of pleurodesis procedures also decreased over time (p = 0.00). The mean inflation-adjusted charge per hospitalization rose from USD 41,252 to USD 56,951, but fewer hospitalizations drove the total annual charges down from USD 1.51 billion to USD 1.37 billion (p = 0.00 for both analyses). CONCLUSIONS: The burden of hospital-based resource utilization associated with MPE has decreased over time, with a reduction in attributable hospitalizations by one third in the span of 1 decade. Correspondingly, the number of inpatient pleurodesis procedures has decreased during this time frame.

Tube Thoracostomy Complications Increase Cost.

BACKGROUND: Tube thoracostomy (TT) can be an effective therapy for thoracic pathologies. Ineffective placement of TT is common and associated with significant complications. Complications require additional interventions to repair damaged tissues or replace dysfunctional TT. We hypothesize that complicated TT insertion increases cost to the hospital system. METHODS: Adult trauma patients requiring TT at a level 1 trauma center (2012-2013) were reviewed. Intraoperative or image-guided TT placements were excluded. Baseline demographics and TT insertion cost (normalized and assigned by hospital billing records) were recorded. Costs included initial TT equipment, radiographs, and subsequent operative or radiologic intervention to correct TT complications. Complications were categorized using previously validated method. Secondary outcomes included: number of TT inserted, number of chest radiographs performed, and TT dwell time utilizing a standardized TT discontinuation protocol. RESULTS: A total of 154 patients with 246 TT were included. Ninety TT (37%) had complication. Complication categories are postremoval (n = 15, 16.7%), insertional (n = 13, 14.4%), positional (n = 62, 68.9%). Overall median complicated TT cost was 9 times greater than uncomplicated TT insertion, p = 0.001. Insertional complications median cost 21 times greater than an uncomplicated, due to operative and radiologic interventions (p = 0.0001). Positional and postremoval complication rates increased median cost by 3 times compared to uncomplicated TT (p = 0.03). Operative or radiologic interventions (n = 10) were performed for organ injury or uncontrolled hemo-/pneumothorax. Increased dwell time median [IQR] was associated with complicated TT compared to uncomplicated 3 [1-5] versus 2 [1-3], p = 0.01. CONCLUSION: TT is a common procedure. TT complications are often considered benign. However, patients with a complicated TT insertion, especially related to insertional subtypes, have markedly increased hospitalization costs due to need for operative or radiologic repair. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level V-retrospective study. STUDY TYPE: This is a retrospective single-institution study.

Ultrasonography guidance reduces complications and costs associated with thoracentesis procedures.

PURPOSE.: We performed an analysis of hospitalizations involving thoracentesis procedures to determine whether the use of ultrasonographic (US) guidance is associated with differences in complications or hospital costs as compared with not using US guidance. METHODS.: We used the Premier hospital database to identify patients with ICD-9 coded thoracentesis in 2008. Use of US guidance was identified using CPT-4 codes. We performed univariate and multivariable analyses of cost data and adjusted for patient demographics, hospital characteristics, patient morbidity severity, and mortality. Logistic regression models were developed for pneumothorax and hemorrhage adverse events, controlling for patient demographics, morbidity severity, mortality, and hospital size. RESULTS.: Of 19,339 thoracentesis procedures, 46% were performed with US guidance. Mean total hospitalization costs were $11,786 (±$10,535) and $12,408 (±$13,157) for patients with and without US guidance, respectively (p < 0.001). Unadjusted risk of pneumothorax or hemorrhage was lower with US guidance (p = 0.019 and 0.078, respectively). Logistic regression analyses demonstrate that US is associated with a 16.3% reduction likelihood of pneumothorax (adjusted odds ratio 0.837, 95% CI: 0.73-0.96; p= 0.014), and 38.7% reduction in likelihood of hemorrhage (adjusted odds ratio 0.613, 95% CI: 0.36-1.04; p = 0.071). CONCLUSIONS.: US-guided thoracentesis is associated with lower total hospital stay costs and lower incidence of pneumothorax and hemorrhage. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Clin Ultrasound, 2011.

Can spontaneous pneumothorax patients be treated by ambulatory care management?

OBJECTIVE: In the Emergency Department, it would be worthwhile to treat pneumothorax patients on an outpatient basis by utilizing a small-calibre catheter and Heimlich valve insertion. We evaluated this treatment and compared it with the closed thoracostomy. METHODS: In this comparative study, the success rate, complications and recurrence rate of treating spontaneous pneumothorax patients by using a small-calibre catheter and Heimlch valve were compared with those of a similar-sized group treated by closed thoracostomy. RESULTS: Pneumothorax was successfully treated on an ambulatory basis by using the small-calibre catheter and Heimlch valve in 20 patients (47%); this was less than the 42 patients (89%) who were successfully treated by closed thoracostomy. While no complications were encountered in the group treated using the small-calibre catheter and Heimlich valve, 11 patients in the group treated by closed thoracostomy developed complications. The medical expenses for the treatment involving the small-calibre catheter and Heimlich valve were less than those for closed thoracostomy. CONCLUSION: Prior to the treatment, the patients should be fully informed of the success rate of this treatment and the possibility of requiring closed thoracostomy in the event of treatment failure.

Rational treatment of empyema in children.

HYPOTHESIS: Efficacious and cost-effective treatment of pediatric empyema can be accomplished following a protocol based on its radiographic appearance. Therapeutic modalities include thoracostomy tube drainage (TTD) with or without fibrinolytic therapy (FT) and video-assisted thoracoscopic debridement (VATD). DESIGN: Retrospective case series. SETTING: Tertiary referral center. RESULTS: From 1995 through 1999, 31 children were treated ranging in age from 11 months to 18 years (mean age, 5.1 years). Twenty-seven (87.1%) underwent TTD; of these, 22 (81.5%) received FT with urokinase. The TTD failed in 4 children (14.8%) who required salvage VATD. Primary VATD was performed in another 4 children (12.9%). The mean length of stay was 14.6 days (TTD, 14.1 days; salvage VATD, 20. 0 days; primary VATD, 11.5 days), ranging from 8.0 to 30.0 days. Complications included readmission for fever (2 patients [6.5%]) and gastrointestinal bleeding (1 patient [3.2%]). There were no anaphylactic reactions or bleeding episodes due to urokinase. Two patients (7.4%) treated with TTD and FT developed an air leak that resolved spontaneously. The mean hospital charges were $78,832 (TTD with or without FT, $75,450; salvage VATD, $107,476; primary VATD, $69,634). The procedural charges were highest for salvage VATD. CONCLUSIONS: Most cases of pediatric empyema can be treated by TTD with or without FT. This therapy is safe and effective for children with nascent disease. Primary VATD is preferred in children with advanced disease. Cost-effectiveness could be further improved through better prediction of those patients likely to fail TTD and require salvage VATD. An algorithmic approach based on findings from computed tomography or (better) ultrasonography of the chest may be the best way to make this distinction and rationalize care.

Evaluation of treatment modalities for thoracic empyema: a cost-effectiveness analysis.

BACKGROUND: Empyema thoracis is treated with a multitude of therapeutic options. Optimal therapy and cost-containment requires selection of the most appropriate initial intervention. METHODS: A retrospective review of treatment modalities was performed on 77 patients diagnosed with empyema thoracis from 1990 to 1997 at one institution. Mean age was 59 years (range, 21 to 90 years); 52 were men and 25 were women. RESULTS: Sixty-five percent (50/77) were parapneumonic and 68% (52/77) were multiloculated. Treatment modalities were as follows: group 1, antibiotics only (n = 4); group 2, primary intervention: image-directed catheter (n = 20) or tube thoracostomy (n = 24); and group 3, secondary intervention: decortication (n = 17), rib resection or muscle interposition (n = 12). Thirty-four percent (9/20 image-directed catheter and 8/24 tube thoracostomy) had failure of initial intervention. Patients undergoing decortication more often had multiloculated empyema thoracis (16 of 17) compared with those undergoing image-directed catheters (8 of 20) or tube thoracotomy (16 of 24). Length of stay was reduced for decortication patients (17 days) compared with those having image-directed catheters (21.8 days), failed image-directed catheters (29.7 days), or tube thoracostomies (19.6 days). Hospital charges per patient between decortication and image-directed catheter ($34,770.79 versus $37,869.41) were comparable, but charges were significantly decreased in decortication patients as compared with failed image-directed catheters ($55,609.32; p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Our series revealed that early decortication has charges similar to those of primary intervention (image-directed catheter or tube thoracostomy) but is more cost-effective than failed image-directed catheter. We advocate the use of early surgical intervention as the most optimal and cost-effective initial modality for the treatment of empyema thoracis.

Costs of treating children with complicated pneumonia: a comparison of primary video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery and chest tube placement.

OBJECTIVES: To describe charges associated with primary video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) and primary chest tube placement in a multicenter cohort of children with empyema and to determine whether pleural fluid drainage by primary VATS was associated with cost-savings compared with primary chest tube placement. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective cohort study. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: Administrative database containing inpatient resource utilization data from 27 tertiary care children's hospitals. Patients between 12 months and 18 years of age diagnosed with complicated pneumonia were eligible if they were discharged between 2001 and 2005 and underwent early (within 2 days of index hospitalization) pleural fluid drainage. MAIN EXPOSURE: Method of pleural fluid drainage, categorized as VATS or chest tube placement. RESULTS: Pleural drainage in the 764 patients was performed by VATS (n = 50) or chest tube placement (n = 714). There were 521 (54%) males. Median hospital charges were $36,320 [interquartile range (IQR), $24,814-$62,269]. The median pharmacy and radiologic imaging charges were $5,884 (IQR, $3,142-$11,357) and $2,875 (IQR, $1,703-$4,950), respectively. Adjusting for propensity score matching, patients undergoing primary VATS did not have higher charges than patients undergoing primary chest tube placement. CONCLUSIONS: In this multicenter study, we found that the charges incurred in caring for children with empyema were substantial. However, primary VATS was not associated with higher total or pharmacy charges than primary chest tube placement, suggesting that the additional costs of performing VATS are offset by reductions in length of stay (LOS) and requirement for additional procedures.

Omission of routine chest x-ray after chest tube removal is safe in selected trauma patients.

BACKGROUND: Definitive practice guidelines regarding the utility of chest x-ray (CXR) following chest tube removal in trauma patients have not been established. The authors hypothesized that the selective use of CXR following chest tube removal is safe and cost effective. METHODS: A retrospective review of chest tube insertions performed at a level I trauma center was conducted. RESULTS: Patients who underwent chest tube removal without subsequent CXR had a lower mean Injury Severity Score and were less likely to have suffered penetrating thoracic injuries. These patients received fewer total CXRs and had shorter durations of chest tube therapy and shorter lengths of stay following tube removal. Subsequent reinterventions were performed more frequently in the CXR group. The annual decrease in hospital charges by foregoing a CXR was $16,280. CONCLUSIONS: The selective omission of CXR following chest tube removal in less severely injured, nonventilated patients does not adversely affect outcomes or increase reintervention rates. Avoiding unnecessary routine CXR after chest tube removal could provide a significant reduction in total hospital charges.

In patients with first-episode primary spontaneous pneumothorax is video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery superior to tube thoracostomy alone in terms of time to resolution of pneumothorax and incidence of recurrence?

A best evidence topic in cardiac surgery was written according to a structured protocol. The question addressed whether video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) was justifiable for first-episode primary spontaneous pneumothorax (PSP). Altogether 183 papers were found using the reported search, of which nine represented the best evidence to answer the clinical question. The authors, journal, date and country of publication, patient group studied, study type, relevant outcomes and results of these papers are tabulated. We conclude that VATS has superior outcomes in terms of recurrence rates of pneumothorax (from 0 to 13% according to several studies for VATS vs. 22.8 to 42% for tube thoracostomy alone), duration of chest tube drainage (CTD) (4.56 vs.7.6 days) and mean hospital stay (from 2.4 to 7.8 days vs. 6 to 12 days for CTD) with first-episode PSP compared with conservative treatment. Additionally, even if VATS is associated with an average increased cost of $408, this is mitigated by the reduced length of stay and decreased pneumothorax recurrence, both resulting in a reduction of cost of 42% compared to conservative approach. These findings were not replicated in an article considering primary VATS (PV) vs. secondary VATS (SV) as the best treatment modality for PSP in children. Although the total treatment length of stay was significantly shorter for PV vs. SV (7.1+/-0.96 vs. 10.5+/-1.2, P=0.04), morbidity from recurrent pneumothorax after VATS occurred more frequently after PV than SV (4/14 vs. 0/20, P<0.05). In this article the observed recurrence rate was 54%. Performing PV on all patients with PSP would increase cost by $4010 per patient and require a recurrence rate of 72% or more to financially justify this approach, therefore, the increased morbidity and cost do not justify a strategy of PV blebectomy/pleurodesis in children with spontaneous pneumothorax (SP). Instead, secondary treatment is recommended. Lastly, two articles also examined the rate of recurrence of VATS compared to open thoracotomy (OT). The range was from 0 to 7.7% for OT vs. 10.3 to 13% for VATS, a non-statistical difference.

Sequential treatment of a simple pneumothorax.

In a prospective investigation of isolated simple pneumothorax, the treatment of 35 patients with a total of 37 pneumothoraces was studied. A standardized sequential treatment approach was followed for evacuation of the pneumothorax and maintenance of lung reexpansion. The protocol involved catheter placement using a Seldinger technique, aspirations, and documentation of reexpansion by chest radiography and observation. Reaccumulation of air was treated with Heimlich valve attachment to the catheter at intrapleural pressure and further observation. Continued air leak following Heimlich valve attachment was treated with chest catheter suction using a Pleurovac at -20 cm H2O pressure. Chest tube thoracostomy was performed for continued failure of reexpansion. In 22 of the 37 pneumothoraces (59%) simple catheter aspiration maintained lung reexpansion without complications. In the remaining 15 pneumothoraces (41%), seven (47%) responded to Heimlich valve attachment, and three (20%) maintained expansion with chest catheter suction. Chest tube thoracotomy was required to maintain expansion in 33% (five) of those who failed catheter suction (14% of all pneumothoraces studied). Patients treated successfully with simple catheter aspiration were sent home. Patients requiring a Heimlich valve, chest catheter suction, or chest tube thoracostomy were hospitalized. Use of these catheter techniques resulted in lower cost and was associated with shorter hospitalizations than in chest tube thoracostomy. Our study suggests that sequential treatment of simple pneumothorax should be considered as a cost-effective and therapeutically successful alternative to immediate chest thoracostomy in selected cases.

A cost-effective thoracoscopic treatment strategy for pediatric spontaneous pneumothorax.

BACKGROUND: Recent data suggest that children have a higher incidence of recurrence than adults after nonoperative treatment of primary spontaneous pneumothorax (PSP). Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) allows efficacious therapy with significantly less morbidity. We attempt to define the most cost-effective clinically efficacious strategy using VATS to manage pediatric PSP. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed all admissions to a tertiary care children's hospital for PSP between January 1, 1991 and June 30, 1996. RESULTS: Fifteen children had 29 primary or recurrent PSPs. Mean patient age was 14.8 +/- 1.1 years, boy-girl ratio 4:1, median body mass index 18 (normal, 20-25), and 67% of pneumothoraces left sided. All patients were managed initially nonoperatively: 14 with tube thoracostomy drainage and 1 with oxygen alone. Of the children initially managed nonoperatively, 57% had a recurrent pneumothorax, and 50% of these patients eventually developed contralateral pneumothoraces. Nonoperative treatment for recurrence resulted in a 75% second recurrence rate. In contrast, eight children who underwent operative management had a 9% incidence of recurrence. The total for charges accrued in treating 29 pneumothoraces in these 15 patients was approximately $315,000. In the same population, the estimated charges for initial nonoperative therapy followed by bilateral thoracoscopy after a single recurrence would be $230,000. CONCLUSIONS: A cost-effective treatment strategy for pediatric primary spontaneous pneumothorax is tube thoracostomy at first presentation, followed by VATS with thoracoscopic bleb resection and pleurodesis for patients who experience recurrent pneumothorax.