Surface Engineering of the Mechanical Properties of Molecular Crystals via an Atomistic Model for Computing the Facet Stress Response of Solids.

Invited for the cover of this issue are Mubarak Almehairbi, Vikram C. Joshi, Changquan Calvin Sun and Sharmarke Mohamed. The image depicts the digital exploration of the mechanical properties of crystals on specific facets that may be of interest for materials applications by "dialing-in" their stress response. Read the full text of the article at 10.1002/chem.202400779.

Efficient determination of critical water activity and classification of hydrate-anhydrate stability relationship.

For a pair of hydrated and anhydrous crystals, the hydrate is more stable than the anhydrate when the water activity is above the critical water activity (awc). Conventional methods to determine awc are based on either hydrate-anhydrate competitive slurries at different aw or solubilities measured at different temperatures. However, these methods are typically resource-intensive and time-consuming. Here, we present simple and complementary solution- and solid-based methods and illustrate them using carbamazepine and theophylline. In the solution-based method, awc can be predicted using intrinsic dissolution rate (IDR) ratio or solubility ratio of the hydrate-anhydrate pair measured at a known water activity. In the solid-based method, awc is predicted as a function of temperature from the dehydration temperature and enthalpy obtained by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) near a water activity of unity. For carbamazepine and theophylline, the methods yielded awc values in good agreement with those from the conventional methods. By incorporating awc as an additional variable, the hydrate-anhydrate relationship is categorized into four classes based on their dehydration temperature (Td) and enthalpy (ΔHd) in analogy with the monotropy/enantiotropy classification for crystal polymorphs. In Class 1 (ΔHd< 0 and Td ≥ 373 K), no awc exists. In Class 2 (ΔHd>0andTd≥373K), awc always exists under conventional crystallization conditions. In Class 3 (ΔHd<0andTd<373K), awc exists when T>Td. In Class 4 (ΔHd>0andTd<373K), awc exists only when T

Understanding the roles of compaction pressure and crystal hardness on powder tabletability through bonding area - Bonding strength interplay.

Bonding area (BA) and bonding strength (BS) interplay dictates tensile strength of a tablet and, hence, tabletability. Using a series of alkali halides with mechanical properties spanning more than one order of magnitude, the role of compaction pressure and mechanical properties on tabletability is systematically investigated and explained using the BA-BS interplay. Results reveal that BA dominates the BA-BS interplay at low pressures, where more plastic powders attain higher tensile strength due to larger BA. In contrast, BS dominates the interplay at high pressures, when difference in BA between powders is minimized. Under the typical compaction pressures of 100-300 MPa, tablet tensile strength is the highest for materials with intermediate hardness, or plasticity, due to an optimal BA-BS interplay.

Relative Bioavailability Assessment of Solid Forms by An Artificial Stomach and Duodenum Apparatus.

In this work, the ability of the artificial stomach and duodenum (ASD) model to predict bioavailability in rats was investigated using a poorly soluble model compound, BI-639667. A solution and four suspensions of different solid forms of BI-639667 were tested both in an ASD and rats. Rank order of the bioavailability estimated from an ASD apparatus is consistent with that of in vivo result in rats, i.e., solution > salicylic acid cocrystal > malate salt > maleate salt > monohydrate, which correlates with the ability of the different solid forms to maintain supersaturation with respect to the stable form in aqueous solution. The results support the use of an ASD for characterizing dissolution performance of solid forms to aid their selection for tablet formulation development.

Miscibility of Amorphous Solid Dispersions: A Rheological and Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy Study.

Miscibility is critical in the prediction of stability against crystallization of amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs) in the solid state. However, currently available approaches for its determination are limited by both theoretical and practical considerations. Recently, a rheological approach guided by the polymer overlap concentration (c*) has been proposed for miscibility quantification of ASDs [J. Pharm. Sci., 112 (2023) 204-212] and shown to be useful in predicting both accelerated and long term physical stability in the absence of moisture. However, this approach can only be performed at high temperatures (slightly above the melting temperature, Tm, of drugs), and little is known about the difference in miscibility between high and low temperatures (e.g., below the glass transition temperature, Tg). Here we compare the miscibility of nifedipine (NIF)/polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) ASDs as determined by the rheological approach at 175°C (∼3°C above Tm of NIF) and solid state NMR (ssNMR) 1H T1 and T1ρ relaxation times at -20°C (∼66°C below Tg of NIF). Our results indicate agreement between the two methods. For low molecular weight (Mw) PVP, T1ρ measurements are more consistent with the rheological approach, while T1 measurements are closer for relatively high Mw PVP. Our findings support the use of the c* based rheological approach for inferring miscibility of deeply cooled ASDs.

Delaying the First Nucleation Event of Amorphous Solid Dispersions Above the Polymer Overlap Concentration (c*): PVP and PVPVA in Posaconazole.

A thorough understanding of effects of polymers on crystallization of amorphous drugs is essential for rational design of robust amorphous solid dispersion (ASD), since crystallization of the amorphous drug negates their solubility advantage. In this work, we measured the first nucleation time (t0, time to form the first critical nucleus in fresh liquid/glass) in posaconazole (POS)/polyvinylpyrrolidone vinyl acetate (PVPVA) and POS/polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP K25) ASDs and showed that the polymer overlap concentration (c*, concentration above which adjacent polymer chains begin to contact) is critical in controlling crystallization of ASDs. When polymer concentration c < c*, t0 of POS ASDs is approximately equal to that of the neat amorphous POS, but it increases significantly when c > c*. This observation supports the view that the effective inhibitory effect of crystallization in ASDs above c* is primarily correlated with delay in the first nucleation event. Our finding is useful in efficient polymer selection and performance prediction of high drug loaded ASD formulations.

A new insight into the mechanism of the tabletability flip phenomenon.

Tabletability is an outcome of interparticulate bonding area (BA) - bonding strength (BS) interplay, influenced by the mechanical properties, size and shape, surface energetics of the constituent particles, and compaction parameters. Typically, a more plastic active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) exhibits a better tabletability than less plastic APIs due to the formation of a larger BA during tablet compression. Thus, solid forms of an API with greater plasticity are traditionally preferred if other critical pharmaceutical properties are comparable. However, the tabletability flip phenomenon (TFP) suggests that a solid form of an API with poorer tabletability may exhibit better tabletability when formulated with plastic excipients. In this study, we propose another possible mechanism of TFP, wherein softer excipient particles conform to the shape of harder API particles during compaction, leading to a larger BA under certain pressures and, hence, better tabletability. In this scenario, the BA-BS interplay is dominated by BA. Accordingly, TFP should tend to occur when API solid forms are formulated with a soft excipient. We tested this hypothesis by visualizing the deformation of particles in a model compressed tablet by nondestructive micro-computed tomography and by optical microscopy when the particles were separated from the tablet. The results confirmed that soft particles wrapped around hard particles at their interfaces, while an approximately flat contact was formed between two adjacent soft particles. In addition to the direct visual evidence, the BA-dominating mechanism was also supported by the observation that TFP occurred in the p-aminobenzoic acid polymorph system only when mixed with a soft excipient.

Cocrystallization improves the tabletability of ligustrazine despite a reduction in plasticity.

Cocrystallization is an effective method for altering the tableting performance of crystals by modifying their mechanical properties. In this study, cocrystals of ligustrazine (LIG) with malonic acid (MA) and salicylic acid (SA) were investigated to better understand how modifying crystal structure can affect tableting properties. LIG suffered from overcompression at high pressures despite its high plasticity. Both LIG-MA and LIG-SA displayed lower plasticity than LIG, which was confirmed by both an in-die Heckel and energy framework analyses. The LIG-MA cocrystal displayed slightly worse tabletability than LIG, as expected from its lower plasticity. However, LIG-SA surprisingly showed improved tabletability despite its lower plasticity. This was explained by the higher bonding strength of LIG-SA compared with LIG. This work not only provided new examples of tabletability modulation through crystal engineering but also highlighted the risk of failed tabletability predictions based on plasticity alone. Instead, more reliable tabletability predictions of different crystal forms must consider the bonding area - bonding strength interplay.

Crystallization Inhibition in Molecular Liquids by Polymers above the Overlap Concentration (c*): Delay of the First Nucleation Event.

Low concentration polymer additives can significantly alter crystal growth kinetics of molecular liquids and glasses. However, the effect of polymer concentration on nucleation kinetics remains poorly understood. Based on an experimentally determined first nucleation time (time to form the first critical nucleus, t0), we show that the polymer overlap concentration, c*, where polymer coils in the molecular liquid start to overlap with each other, is a critical polymer concentration for efficient inhibition of crystallization of a molecular liquid. The value of t0 is approximately equal to that of the neat molecular liquid when the polymer concentration, c, is below c*, but increases significantly when c > c*. This finding is relevant for effective polymer screening and performance prediction of engineered multicomponent amorphous materials, particularly pharmaceutical amorphous solid dispersions.

Development of direct compression Acetazolamide tablet with improved bioavailability in healthy human volunteers enabled by cocrystallization with p-Aminobenzoic acid.

Pharmaceutical cocrystallization has been widely used to improve physicochemical properties of APIs. However, developing cocrystal formulation with proven clinical success remains scarce. Successful translation of a cocrystal to suitable dosage forms requires simultaneously improvement of several deficient physicochemical properties over the parent API, without deteriorating other properties critical for successful product development. In the present work, we report the successful development of a direct compression tablet product of acetazolamide (ACZ), using a 1:1 cocrystal of acetazolamide with p-aminobenzoic acid (ACZ-PABA). The ACZ-PABA tablet exhibits superior biopharmaceutical performance against the commercial tablet, DIAMOX® (250 mg), in healthy human volunteers, leading to more than 50 % reduction in the required dose.

Tuning Caco-2 permeability by cocrystallization: Insights from molecular dynamics simulation.

Emerging evidence suggests that intestinal permeability can be potentially enhanced through cocrystallization. However, a mechanism for this effect remains to be established. In this study, we first demonstrate the enhancement in intestinal permeability, evaluated by the Caco-2 cell permeability assay, of acetazolamide (ACZ) in the presence of a conformer, p-aminobenzoic acid (PABA), delivered in the form of a 1:1 cocrystal. The binding strength of ACZ and PABA with the Pgp efflux transporter, either alone or as a mixture, was calculated using molecular dynamics simulation. Results show that PABA weakens the binding of ACZ with Pgp, which leads to a lower efflux ratio and elevated permeability of ACZ. This work provides molecular-level insights into a potentially effective strategy to improve the intestinal permeability of drugs. If the same cocrystal also exhibits higher solubility, oral bioavailability of BCS IV drugs can likely be improved by forming a cocrystal with a Pgp inhibitor.

Worsened punch sticking by external lubrication with magnesium stearate.

External lubrication of tooling with magnesium stearate (MgSt) is a common strategy to eliminate punch sticking when compressing powders with a high sticking propensity, such as many pure active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs). We found that it actually led to aggravated punch sticking at low compaction pressures. This counterintuitive phenomenon was explained based on interplay of forces among the punch tip, MgSt, and API. The explanation is supported by the observed effects of pressure and mechanical properties of APIs on this phenomenon.

Effect of drug loading and relative humidity on the mechanical properties and tableting performance of Celecoxib-PVP/VA 64 amorphous solid dispersions.

The mechanical properties of polymer-based amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs) are susceptible to changes in relative humidity (RH) conditions. The purpose of this study is to understand the impact of RH on both the mechanical properties and tableting performance of Celecoxib-polyvinyl pyrrolidone vinyl acetate co-polymer (PVP/VA 64) ASDs. The ASDs were prepared by solvent evaporation technique to obtain films for nanoindentation, which were also pulverized to obtain powder for compaction. Our results show that higher RH corresponds to lower Hardness, H, and Elastic Modulus, E. At a given RH, both the E and H increase with drug loading to a maximum and decrease with further drug loading. Using ASD powders with a narrow particle size range (d50 = 9-14 µm), we have demonstrated that increasing RH from 11% to 67% leads to improved tablet tensile strength for pure PVP/VA 64 and the ASDs. However, the extent of the increase in tablet tensile strength depends on their mechanical properties, H and E, and drug loading. At a higher compaction pressure and a higher RH, the effect of ASD mechanical properties on tabletability is less because the particles are nearly fully deformed so that bonding areas are approximately the same. Thus, difference in tablet strength is mainly contributed by the inter-particulate forces of attraction. Understanding the impact of these key processing conditions, i.e., RH and compaction pressure, will guide the design of an ASD tablet formulation with robust manufacturability.

The ubiquity of the tabletability flip phenomenon.

The plasticity of materials plays a critical role in adequate powder tabletability, which is required in developing a successful tablet product. Generally, a more plastic material can develop larger bonding areas when other factors are the same, leading to higher tabletability than less plastic materials. However, it was observed that, for a solid form of a compound with poorer tabletability, a mixture with microcrystalline cellulose (MCC) can actually exhibit better tabletability, a phenomenon termed tabletability flip. Hence, there is a chance that a solid form with poor tabletability could have been erroneously eliminated based on the expected tabletability challenges during tablet manufacturing. This study was conducted to investigate the generality of this phenomenon using two polymorph pairs, a salt and free acid pair, a crystalline and amorphous solid dispersion pair, and a pair of chemically distinct crystals. Results show that tabletability flip occurred in all six systems tested, including five pairs of binary mixtures with MCC and one pair in a realistic generic tablet formulation, suggesting the broad occurrence of the tabletability flip phenomenon, where both compaction pressure and the difference in plasticity between the pair of materials play important roles.

Modulating Pharmaceutical Properties of Berberine Chloride through Cocrystallization with Benzendiol Isomers.

PURPOSE: To synthesize and characterize new cocrystals of berberine chloride (BCl) for potential pharmaceutical tablet formulation. METHODS: Solutions of BCl with each of three selected cocrystal formers, catechol (CAT), resorcinol (RES), and hydroquinone (HYQ) were slowly evaporated at room temperature to obtain crystals. Crystal structures were solved using single crystal X-ray diffraction. Bulk powders were characterized by powder X-ray diffraction, thermogravimetric-differential scanning calorimetry, FTIR, dynamic moisture sorption, and dissolution (both intrinsic and powder). RESULTS: Single crystal structures confirmed the formation of cocrystals with all three coformers, which revealed various intermolecular interactions that stabilized crystal lattices, including O-H···Cl- hydrogen bonds. All three cocrystals exhibited better stability against high humidity (up to 95% relative humidity) at 25 ℃ and higher intrinsic and powder dissolution rates than BCl. CONCLUSION: The enhanced pharmaceutical properties of all three cocrystals, as compared to BCl, further contribute to the existing evidence that confirms the beneficial role of cocrystallization in facilitating drug development. These new cocrystals expand the structure landscape of BCl solid forms, which is important for future analysis to establish a reliable relationship between crystal structure and pharmaceutical properties.

Understanding the role of magnesium stearate in lowering punch sticking propensity of drugs during compression.

The sticking of active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) to the surfaces of compaction tooling, frequently referred to as punch sticking, causes costly downtime or product failures in commercial tablet manufacturing. Magnesium stearate (MgSt) is a common tablet lubricant known to ameliorate the sticking problem, even though there exist exceptions. The mechanism by which MgSt lowers punch sticking propensity (PSP) by covering API surface is sensible but not yet experimentally proven. This work was aimed at elucidating the link between PSP and surface area coverage (SAC) of tablets by MgSt, in relation to some key formulation properties and process parameters, namely MgSt concentration, API loading, API particle size, and mixing conditions. The study was conducted using two model APIs with known high PSPs, tafamidis (TAF) and ertugliflozin-pyroglutamic acid (ERT). Results showed that PSP decreases exponentially with increasing SAC by MgSt. The composition of material stuck to punch face was also explored to better understand the onset of punch sticking and the impact of possible MgSt-effected punch conditioning event.

Harmonizing Biopredictive Methodologies Through the Product Quality Research Institute (PQRI) Part I: Biopredictive Dissolution of Ibuprofen and Dipyridamole Tablets.

Assessing in vivo performance to inform formulation selection and development decisions is an important aspect of drug development. Biopredictive dissolution methodologies for oral dosage forms have been developed to understand in vivo performance, assist in formulation development/optimization, and forecast the outcome of bioequivalence studies by combining them with simulation tools to predict plasma profiles in humans. However, unlike compendial dissolution methodologies, the various biopredictive methodologies have not yet been harmonized or standardized. This manuscript presents the initial phases of an effort to develop best practices and move toward standardization of the biopredictive methodologies through the Product Quality Research Institute (PQRI, https://pqri.org ) entitled "The standardization of in vitro predictive dissolution methodologies and in silico bioequivalence study Working Group." This Working Group (WG) is comprised of participants from 10 pharmaceutical companies and academic institutes. The project will be accomplished in a total of five phases including assessing the performance of dissolution protocols designed by the individual WG members, and then building "best practice" protocols based on the initial dissolution profiles. After refining the "best practice" protocols to produce equivalent dissolution profiles, those will be combined with physiologically based biopharmaceutics models (PBBM) to predict plasma profiles. In this manuscript, the first two of the five phases are reported, namely generating biopredictive dissolution profiles for ibuprofen and dipyridamole and using those dissolution profiles with PBBM to match the clinical plasma profiles. Key experimental parameters are identified, and this knowledge will be applied to build the "best practice" protocol in the next phase.

Mechanical properties and peculiarities of molecular crystals.

In the last century, molecular crystals functioned predominantly as a means for determining the molecular structures via X-ray diffraction, albeit as the century came to a close the response of molecular crystals to electric, magnetic, and light fields revealed that the physical properties of molecular crystals were as rich as the diversity of molecules themselves. In this century, the mechanical properties of molecular crystals have continued to enhance our understanding of the colligative responses of weakly bound molecules to internal frustration and applied forces. Here, the authors review the main themes of research that have developed in recent decades, prefaced by an overview of the particular considerations that distinguish molecular crystals from traditional materials such as metals and ceramics. Many molecular crystals will deform themselves as they grow under some conditions. Whether they respond to intrinsic stress or external forces or interactions among the fields of growing crystals remains an open question. Photoreactivity in single crystals has been a leading theme in organic solid-state chemistry; however, the focus of research has been traditionally on reaction stereo- and regio-specificity. However, as light-induced chemistry builds stress in crystals anisotropically, all types of motions can be actuated. The correlation between photochemistry and the responses of single crystals-jumping, twisting, fracturing, delaminating, rocking, and rolling-has become a well-defined field of research in its own right: photomechanics. The advancement of our understanding requires theoretical and high-performance computations. Computational crystallography not only supports interpretations of mechanical responses, but predicts the responses itself. This requires the engagement of classical force-field based molecular dynamics simulations, density functional theory-based approaches, and the use of machine learning to divine patterns to which algorithms can be better suited than people. The integration of mechanics with the transport of electrons and photons is considered for practical applications in flexible organic electronics and photonics. Dynamic crystals that respond rapidly and reversibly to heat and light can function as switches and actuators. Progress in identifying efficient shape-shifting crystals is also discussed. Finally, the importance of mechanical properties to milling and tableting of pharmaceuticals in an industry still dominated by active ingredients composed of small molecule crystals is reviewed. A dearth of data on the strength, hardness, Young's modulus, and fracture toughness of molecular crystals underscores the need for refinement of measurement techniques and conceptual tools. The need for benchmark data is emphasized throughout.

An approach for predicting the true density of powders based on in-die compression data.

Helium pycnometry, a commonly used technique for measuring the true density of powders, is sensitive to the release of volatiles during measurement. This can lead to over-estimated true density, and as such, an accurate method for determining the true density of powders containing volatile components is needed. Here, a method based on in-die compression data obtained with a compaction simulator was assessed. Specifically, the stress transmission coefficient (STC), measured using an instrumented die, was used to predict the in-die Heckel mean yield pressure (Py). A true density was derived by repeatedly performing a Heckel analysis using iteratively estimated true density values until the predicted Py value from the measured STC value is obtained from in-die density - pressure data. This novel method was validated using a set of water-free powders. Using crystalline hydrates, we further showed that the calculated true densities were closer to values calculated from crystal structure than those from helium pycnometry. Hence, this method may be used for determining the true density of powders from their STC values.