Structural Expansion of Catalytic RNA Nanostructures through Oligomerization of a Cyclic Trimer of Engineered Ribozymes.

The multimolecular assembly of three-dimensionally structured proteins forms their quaternary structures, some of which have high geometric symmetry. The size and complexity of protein quaternary structures often increase in a hierarchical manner, with simpler, smaller structures serving as units for larger quaternary structures. In this study, we exploited oligomerization of a ribozyme cyclic trimer to achieve larger ribozyme-based RNA assembly. By installing kissing loop (KL) interacting units to one-, two-, or three-unit RNA molecules in the ribozyme trimer, we constructed dimers, open-chain oligomers, and branched oligomers of ribozyme trimer units. One type of open-chain oligomer preferentially formed a closed tetramer containing 12 component RNAs to provide 12 ribozyme units. We also observed large assembly of ribozyme trimers, which reached 1000 nm in size.

Pairwise Engineering of Tandemly Aligned Self-Splicing Group I Introns for Analysis and Control of Their Alternative Splicing.

Alternative splicing is an important mechanism in the process of eukaryotic nuclear mRNA precursors producing multiple protein products from a single gene. Although group I self-splicing introns usually perform regular splicing, limited examples of alternative splicing have also been reported. The exon-skipping type of splicing has been observed in genes containing two group I introns. To characterize splicing patterns (exon-skipping/exon-inclusion) of tandemly aligned group I introns, we constructed a reporter gene containing two Tetrahymena introns flanking a short exon. To control splicing patterns, we engineered the two introns in a pairwise manner to design pairs of introns that selectively perform either exon-skipping or exon-inclusion splicing. Through pairwise engineering and biochemical characterization, the structural elements important for the induction of exon-skipping splicing were elucidated.

Catalytic RNA Oligomers Formed by Co-Oligomerization of a Pair of Bimolecular RNase P Ribozymes.

Naturally occurring ribozymes with a modular architecture are promising platforms for construction of RNA nanostructures because modular redesign enables their oligomerization. The resulting RNA nanostructures can exhibit the catalytic function of the parent ribozyme in an assembly dependent manner. In this study, we designed and constructed open-form oligomers of a bimolecular form of an RNase P ribozyme. The ribozyme oligomers were analyzed biochemically and by atomic force microscopy (AFM).

Box-shaped ribozyme octamer formed by face-to-face dimerization of a pair of square-shaped ribozyme tetramers.

Naturally occurring ribozymes with defined three-dimensional (3D) structures serve as promising platforms for the design and construction of artificial RNA nanostructures. We constructed a hexameric ribozyme nanostructure by face-to-face dimerization of a pair of triangular ribozyme trimers, unit RNAs of which were derived from the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme. In this study, we have expanded the dimerization strategy to a square-shaped ribozyme tetramer by introducing four pillar units. The resulting box-shaped nanostructures, which contained eight ribozyme units, can be assembled from either four or two components of their unit RNAs.

A Hexameric Ribozyme Nanostructure Formed by Double-Decker Assembly of a Pair of Triangular Ribozyme Trimers.

The modular architecture of naturally occurring ribozymes makes them a promising class of structural platform for the design and assembly of three-dimensional (3D) RNA nanostructures, into which the catalytic ability of the platform ribozyme can be installed. We have constructed and analyzed RNA nanostructures with polygonal-shaped (closed) ribozyme oligomers by assembling unit RNAs derived from the Tetrahymena group I intron with a typical modular architecture. In this study, we dimerized ribozyme trimers with a triangular shape by introducing three pillar units. The resulting double-decker nanostructures containing six ribozyme units were characterized biochemically and their structures were observed by atomic force microscopy. The double-decker hexamers exhibited higher catalytic activity than the parent ribozyme trimers.

Effects of chain length of polyethylene glycol molecular crowders on a mutant Tetrahymena group I ribozyme lacking large peripheral module.

While current group I ribozymes use several distinct strategies to function under conditions of low Mg2+ concentration (≤ 3 mM), a deletion mutant of the Tetrahymena ribozyme (ΔP5 ribozyme) is virtually inactive with 3 mM Mg2+ due to removal of the large peripheral module, P5abc, supporting the active conformation of the core module. We investigated the molecular crowding effects of synthetic polyethylene glycols (PEGs) on the activity of the ΔP5 ribozyme. Among PEG molecules with different chain lengths, PEG600 improved the activity of the ΔP5 ribozyme most effectively in the presence of 3 mM Mg2+.

Flexible Assembly of Engineered Tetrahymena Ribozymes Forming Polygonal RNA Nanostructures with Catalytic Ability.

Ribozymes with modular architecture constitute an attractive class of structural platforms for design and construction of nucleic acid nanostructures with biological functions. Through modular engineering of the Tetrahymena ribozyme, we have designed unit RNAs (L-RNAs), assembly of which formed ribozyme-based closed trimers and closed tetramers. Their catalytic activity was dependent on oligomer formation. In this study, the structural variety of L-RNA oligomers was extended by tuning their structural elements, yielding closed pentamers and closed hexamers. Their assembly properties were analyzed by electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) and atomic force microscopy (AFM).

Catalytic RNA nano-objects formed by self-assembly of group I ribozyme dimers serving as unit structures.

Ribozymes with modular structures are attractive platforms for the construction of nanoscale RNA objects with biological functions. We designed group I ribozyme dimers as unit ribozyme dimers (Urds), which self-assembled to form their polymeric states and also oligomeric states with defined numbers of Urds. Assembly of Urds yielded catalytic ability of a pair of distinct ribozyme units to cleave two distinct substrates. The morphologies of the assembled ribozyme structures were observed directly by atomic force microscopy (AFM).

Polyethylene glycol molecular crowders enhance the catalytic ability of bimolecular bacterial RNase P ribozymes.

The modular structure of bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) ribozymes, which recognize tertiary structures of precursor tRNAs (pre-tRNAs) to cleave their 5' leader sequence, can be dissected physically into the two structured domain RNAs (S-domain and C-domain). Separately prepared S-domain RNA and C-domain RNA assemble to form bimolecular forms of RNase P ribozymes. We analyzed the effects of polyethylene glycols (PEGs) on pre-tRNA cleavage catalyzed by bimolecular RNase P ribozymes to examine the effects of molecular crowding on the reaction. PEG molecular crowders significantly enhanced the activities of bimolecular RNase P ribozymes, some of which were hardly active without PEGs.

Effects of external molecular factors on adaptation of bacterial RNase P ribozymes to thermophilic conditions.

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is an RNA processing enzyme essential for production of functional tRNAs. Bacterial RNase P is a ribozyme, i.e., an RNA-based enzyme, which functions in all bacteria including those growing at high temperatures (≥55 °C). We examined three bacterial RNase P ribozymes, one from a mesophilic bacterium and two from thermophilic bacteria, to understand the factor(s) providing efficient catalytic ability under conditions of high temperature. Thermophilic RNase P ribozymes show structural adaptations to allow correct folding at high temperature. The presence of a molecular crowder significantly enhanced the catalytic efficiency of thermophilic RNase P ribozyme reactions at 55 °C, while it modestly reduced the upper limit of the reaction temperature.

Rational Design of an Orthogonal Pair of Bimolecular RNase P Ribozymes through Heterologous Assembly of Their Modular Domains.

The modular structural domains of multidomain RNA enzymes can often be dissected into separate domain RNAs and their noncovalent assembly can often reconstitute active enzymes. These properties are important to understand their basic characteristics and are useful for their application to RNA-based nanostructures. Bimolecular forms of bacterial RNase P ribozymes consisting of S-domain and C-domain RNAs are attractive as platforms for catalytic RNA nanostructures, but their S-domain/C-domain assembly was not optimized for this purpose. Through analysis and engineering of bimolecular forms of the two bacterial RNase P ribozymes, we constructed a chimeric ribozyme with improved catalytic ability and S-domain/C-domain assembly and developed a pair of bimolecular RNase P ribozymes the assembly of which was considerably orthogonal to each other.

Oligomerization of a modular ribozyme assembly of which is controlled by a programmable RNA-RNA interface between two structural modules.

Bimolecular ribozymes derived by physical dissection of unimolecular ribozymes consisting of two structural modules are promising platforms for the design and construction of assembled RNA nanostructures. Unit RNAs to be assembled intermolecularly into one-dimensional (1D) oligomers are designed by reconnecting the two structural modules in a manner different from the parent ribozymes. This strategy was applied to the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme. We constructed 1D ribozyme oligomers the assembly of which was observed by atomic force microscopy (AFM) and also controlled rationally to design a heterooctamer by differentiating the interface between the two modules.

Effects of molecular crowding on a bimolecular group I ribozyme and its derivative that self-assembles to form ribozyme oligomers.

In the RNA world, enrichment of self-replicating RNAs would have been beneficial to their survival, amplification, and evolution. Self-assembly of RNAs may be a strategy by which they enrich themselves. We examined the effects of molecular crowding on the activity of a bimolecular group I ribozyme and its derivative that self-assembles to form ribozyme oligomers. In a comparative activity assay using PEG as a molecular crowder, PEG rescued mutations in the parent bimolecular ribozyme more effectively than those in the oligomeric form.

Distinct modulation of group I ribozyme activity among stereoisomers of a synthetic pentamine with structural constraints.

Among cationic molecules that can modulate ribozyme activities, polyamines act as both activator and inhibitor of ribozyme reactions partly due to their structural flexibility. Restriction of structural flexibility of polyamines may allow them to emphasize particular modulation effects. We examined eight stereoisomers of a synthetic pentamine bearing three cyclopentane rings. In the reaction of a structurally unstable group I ribozyme, three stereoisomers exhibited distinct effects as inhibitor, an additive with a neutral effect, and also as an activator.

Oligomerization of a Bimolecular Ribozyme Modestly Rescues its Structural Defects that Disturb Interdomain Assembly to Form the Catalytic Site.

The emergence of cellular compartmentalization was a crucial step in the hypothetical RNA world and its evolution because it would not only prevent the extinction of RNA self-replication systems due to dispersion/diffusion of their components but also facilitate ribozyme reactions by molecular crowding effects. Here, we proposed and examined self-assembly of RNA components as a primitive cellular-like environment, which may have the ability to mimic cellular compartmentalization and crowding effects. We engineered a bimolecular group I ribozyme to form a one-dimensional (1D)-ribozyme assembly. In the 1D assembly form, severe mutations that inactivated the parent bimolecular ribozyme were modestly rescued resulting in weak catalytic ability.

Comparative study of polyethylene polyamines as activator molecules for a structurally unstable group I ribozyme.

Polyamines are a promising class of molecules that can modulate RNA enzyme activities. To analyze the effects of the number of amine moieties systematically, we employed four polyamines sharing dimethylene units to connect amine moieties. As a model RNA enzyme, we used a structurally unstable group I ribozyme, which was activated most and least efficiently by tetraethylenepentamine and diethylenetriamine respectively.

Recognition of cyclic-di-GMP by a riboswitch conducts translational repression through masking the ribosome-binding site distant from the aptamer domain.

The riboswitch is a class of RNA-based gene regulatory machinery that is dependent on recognition of its target ligand by RNA tertiary structures. Ligand recognition is achieved by the aptamer domain, and ligand-dependent structural changes of the expression platform then usually mediate termination of transcription or translational initiation. Ligand-dependent structural changes of the aptamer domain and expression platform have been reported for several riboswitches with short (<40 nucleotides) expression platforms. In this study, we characterized structural changes of the Vc2 c-di-GMP riboswitch that represses translation of downstream open reading frames in a ligand-dependent manner. The Vc2 riboswitch has a long (97 nucleotides) expression platform, but its structure and function are largely unknown. Through mutational analysis and chemical probing, we identified its secondary structures that are possibly responsible for switch-OFF and switch-ON states of translational initiation.

Biogenic triamine and tetraamine activate core catalytic ability of Tetrahymena group I ribozyme in the absence of its large activator module.

Group I intron ribozymes share common core elements that form a three-dimensional structure responsible for their catalytic activity. This core structure is unstable without assistance from additional factors that stabilize its tertiary structure. We examined biogenic triamine and tetraamine and also their fragments for their abilities to stabilize a structurally unstable group I ribozyme, ΔP5 ribozyme, derived from the Tetrahymena group I intron ribozyme by deleting its large activator module. Biogenic triamine (spermidine) and tetraamine (spermine) efficiently activated the ΔP5 ribozyme under conditions where the ribozyme was virtually inactive. These observations suggested that polyamines are promising small molecule modulators to activate and possibly inhibit the core catalytic ability of group I ribozymes.

Modular Architecture of Bacterial RNase P Ribozymes as a Structural Platform for RNA Nanostructure Design.

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a class of enzymes involved in the processing of precursor tRNAs to remove their 5'-leader sequences. Ribonuclease P enzymes are classified into two completely distinct classes, i.e. an RNA-based enzyme and a protein-only enzyme. The RNA-based enzyme functions as a ribozyme in which the catalytic machinery is supported by its RNA component consisting of a single RNA molecule. Bacterial RNase P RNAs are a classical class of ribozymes and their structures and catalytic mechanisms have been studied extensively. The bacterial RNase P ribozyme has a modular tertiary structure consisting of two large domains, each of which can self-fold without the partner domain. Such modular architecture, identification of which provided important insight into the function of this ribozyme, is attractive as a structural platform to design functional RNA nanostructures. The first section of this article briefly summarizes the diversity of RNase P mainly focusing on RNA-based enzymes. The second section describes the structures of bacterial RNase P ribozymes from the viewpoint of their application as modular tools in RNA nanostructure design. The last section summarizes the current state and next steps in modular engineering of RNase P RNAs, including possible design of RNase P ribozyme-based nanostructures.

Artificial RNA Motifs Expand the Programmable Assembly between RNA Modules of a Bimolecular Ribozyme Leading to Application to RNA Nanostructure Design.

A bimolecular ribozyme consisting of a core ribozyme (ΔP5 RNA) and an activator module (P5abc RNA) has been used as a platform to design assembled RNA nanostructures. The tight and specific assembly between the P5abc and ΔP5 modules depends on two sets of intermodule interactions. The interface between P5abc and ΔP5 must be controlled when designing RNA nanostructures. To expand the repertoire of molecular recognition in the P5abc/ΔP5 interface, we modified the interface by replacing the parent tertiary interactions in the interface with artificial interactions. The engineered P5abc/ΔP5 interfaces were characterized biochemically to identify those suitable for nanostructure design. The new interfaces were used to construct 2D-square and 1D-array RNA nanostructures.