The immunogenicity of biopharmaceuticals. Lessons learned and consequences for protein drug development.

Most biopharmaceuticals, including those proteins that are more or less identical to native human proteins, induce antibodies in a significant fraction of patients. The main factors contributing to immunogenicity are impurities and the presence of aggregates. Sequence divergence from the native proteins only plays a minor role except in proteins from microbial, plant or distant vertebrate origin. In the majority of cases the antibodies have no biological or clinical effects. The most common clinical effect is the loss of efficacy of the biopharmaceutical. Serious complications of immunogenicity are rare. The best method to prevent immunogenicity is optimizing production, purification and formulation of the biopharmaceutical protein to generate soluble, non-aggregated, native protein free of contaminating adjuvants. The best way to predict immunogenicity in humans is evaluation in immune tolerant transgenic mice.

Advances in directed protein evolution by recursive genetic recombination: applications to therapeutic proteins.

Recent developments in directed evolution technologies combined with innovations in robotics and screening methods have revolutionized protein engineering. These methods are being applied broadly to many fields of biotechnology, including chemical engineering, agriculture and human therapeutics. More specifically, DNA shuffling and other methods of genetic recombination and mutation have resulted in the improvement of proteins of therapeutic interest. Optimizing genetic diversity and fitness through iterative directed evolution will accelerate improvements in engineered protein therapeutics.

Evolution of a cytokine using DNA family shuffling.

DNA shuffling of a family of over 20 human interferon-alpha (Hu-IFN-alpha) genes was used to derive variants with increased antiviral and antiproliferation activities in murine cells. A clone with 135,000-fold improved specific activity over Hu-IFN-alpha2a was obtained in the first cycle of shuffling. After a second cycle of selective shuffling, the most active clone was improved 285,000-fold relative to Hu-IFN-alpha2a and 185-fold relative to Hu-IFN-alpha1. Remarkably, the three most active clones were more active than the native murine IFN-alphas. These chimeras are derived from up to five parental genes but contained no random point mutations. These results demonstrate that diverse cytokine gene families can be used as starting material to rapidly evolve cytokines that are more active, or have superior selectivity profiles, than native cytokine genes.

Structural insights into the evolution of an antibody combining site.

The crystal structures of a germline antibody Fab fragment and its complex with hapten have been solved at 2.1 A resolution. These structures are compared with the corresponding crystal structures of the affinity-matured antibody, 48G7, which has a 30,000 times higher affinity for hapten as a result of nine replacement somatic mutations. Significant changes in the configuration of the combining site occur upon binding of hapten to the germline antibody, whereas hapten binds to the mature antibody by a lock-and-key fit mechanism. The reorganization of the combining site that was nucleated by hapten binding is further optimized by somatic mutations that occur up to 15 from bound hapten. These results suggest that the binding potential of the primary antibody repertoire may be significantly expanded by the ability of germline antibodies to adopt more than one combining-site configuration, with both antigen binding and somatic mutation stabilizing the configuration with optimal hapten complementarity.

Crystal structures of the free and liganded form of an esterolytic catalytic antibody.

The crystal structure of the esterase catalytic antibody 48G7 has been determined in the presence of hapten at 2.0 A resolution and in the absence of hapten at 2.7 A resolution. The root-mean-square difference between the two structures is 0.6 A for the variable domain and 0.7 A for the constant domain. Comparison of the active site shows that no significant changes occur upon hapten binding as main-chain and side-chain displacements are negligible. Complex formation occurs as hapten fits into a pre-formed pocket about 10 A deep. Although 151 water molecules were modeled into the 48G7-hapten structure, none are bound in the active site. Comparison of the 48G7 structures with those of other published ester hydrolysis antibodies illustrates an emerging theme used by esterolytic antibodies in binding their (nitro-)phenyl haptens and in hydrolysing their cognate esters and carbonates: hapten is bound with the aryl end buried deep in the binding pocket, and the phosphonate moiety is responsible for the majority of the binding energy to the antibody-hapten interaction.

Applications of DNA shuffling to pharmaceuticals and vaccines.

DNA shuffling is a practical process for directed molecular evolution which uses recombination to dramatically accelerate the rate at which one can evolve genes. Single and multigene traits that require many mutations for improved phenotypes can be evolved rapidly. DNA shuffling technology has been significantly enhanced in the past year, extending its range of applications to small molecule pharmaceuticals, pharmaceutical proteins, gene therapy vehicles and transgenes, vaccines and evolved viruses for vaccines, and laboratory animal models.

Directed evolution studies with combinatorial libraries of T4 lysozyme mutants.

Gene duplication with divergence to new functions has been an important mechanism in protein evolution. However, the questions of how many new functions can arise from a particular ancestral gene and how many mutational steps are typically required to generate new functions have been difficult to approach experimentally. We have addressed these questions using T4 lysozyme as a model system by synthesizing two combinatorial libraries of > 10(7) mutant T4 lysozyme genes: one library with an average of 14 missense mutations spread throughout the gene and one library in which 13 active site residues have been simultaneously randomized. These libraries were placed under selection in lacZ or pheA deficient strains of E. coli to investigate whether they sample sufficient diversity to contain mutants with acquired beta-galactosidase or prephenate dehydratase activities. Although neither selection yielded T4 lysozyme mutants with these new activities, a novel E. coli locus was cloned that weakly complements these mutants, allowing them to form 1 mm colonies in 4-6 weeks. This growth rate corresponds to a turnover number of approximately 1000 or 25 min-1 for the lacZ or pheA complementation systems, respectively, thus defining the limits of evolved enzymatic activity detectable in these selections. Thus, the strong selective pressure uncovered an unexpected solution to the biochemical blocks, a frequently observed phenomenon in selection experiments. The characterization of this locus will allow its elimination from future E. coli complementation schemes.

The immunological evolution of catalysis.

The germline genes used by the mouse to generate the esterolytic antibody 48G7 were cloned and expressed in an effort to increase our understanding of the detailed molecular mechanisms by which the immune system evolves catalytic function. The nine replacement mutations that were fixed during affinity maturation increased affinity for the transition state analogue by a factor of 10(4), primarily the result of a decrease in the dissociation rate of the hapten-antibody complex. There was a corresponding increase in the rate of reaction of antibody with substrate, k(cat)/k(m), from 1.7 x 10(2)M(-1) min(-1) to 1.4 x 10(4)M(-1) min(-1). The three-dimensional crystal structure of the 48G7-transition state analogue complex at 2.0 angstroms resolution indicates that one of the nine residues in which somatic mutations have been fixed directly contact the hapten. Thus, in the case of 48G7, affinity maturation appears to play a conformational role, either in reorganizing the active site geometry of limiting side-chain and backbone flexibility of the germline antibody. The crystal structure and analysis of somatic and directed active site mutants underscore the role of transition state stabilization in the evolution of this catalytic antibody.

Expression studies of catalytic antibodies.

We have examined the positive influence of human constant regions on the folding and bacterial expression of active soluble mouse immunoglobulin variable domains derived from a number of catalytic antibodies. Expression yields of eight hybridoma- and myeloma-derived chimeric Fab fragments are compared in both shake flasks and high density fermentations. In addition the usefulness of this system for the generation of in vivo expression libraries is examined by constructing and expressing combinations of heavy and light chain variable regions that were not selected as a pair during an immune response. A mutagenesis study of one of the recombinant catalytic Fab fragments reveals that single amino acid substitutions can have dramatic effects on the expression yield. This system should be generally applicable to the production of Fab fragments of catalytic and other hybridoma-derived antibodies for crystallographic and structure-function studies.

Transfer of putative complementarity-determining region loops of T cell receptor V domains confers toxin reactivity but not peptide/MHC specificity.

We have used multiple-amino acid replacement mutagenesis to examine the roles of the TCR homologues of Ig complementarity-determining regions (CDR) and framework sequences in Ag-MHC and Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxin reactivity. In the three cases examined, transplantation of Ig CDR3 homologues between I-Ek-restricted TCR that recognize distinct peptides did not result in transfer of peptide reactivity. Thus the structural context of the CDR3 loops, e.g., both neighboring CDR and the V beta structure, must play a crucial, albeit supporting, role in ligand recognition. The extreme lability of this context was also shown by the fact that transplantation of the CDR1, -2, and -3 loops from the beta chain of 5C.C7 onto a V beta 1 framework failed to transfer MHC-peptide specificity even when the TCR-alpha chains were identical. In contrast, superantigen reactivity was readily transferred in several cases, with CDR2 transplants conferring strong staphylococcal enterotoxin B and A reactivity and CDR1 transplants yielding weak reactivities. This suggests that bacterial (and perhaps other) superantigens bind to many of the same regions of the TCR V beta that are believed to interact with MHC molecules. These regions of V beta may be ideal targets for superantigen binding precisely because they interact with MHC molecules and thus may be relatively conserved.

A genetic approach to the generation of antibodies with enhanced catalytic activities.

A hydrolytic catalytic antibody, generated against a nitrophenyl phosphonate transition state analogue, has been cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli for use as a model system to demonstrate the feasibility of using genetic selections to enhance catalytic activity. Conditions were found that permit the secretion of active recombinant antibody into the periplasm of a strain of E. coli deficient in the biotin biosynthetic genes (delta bio-gal). A number of substrates were synthesized that, upon hydrolysis by the antibody, yield free biotin, which is required for cell growth. The substrates and selections can be used to identify mutants of the antibody with altered activities. This approach should be generalizable to a wide number of hydrolytic reactions including the selective cleavage of peptide, polysaccharide, phosphodiester, and ester bonds.

A possible basis for major histocompatibility complex-restricted T-cell recognition.

Four distinct T-cell antigen-receptor gene loci have now been identified and partly characterized: alpha, beta, gamma and delta. All of these loci can rearrange in an immunoglobulin-like fashion and express polypeptides that contribute to either alpha:beta or gamma:delta T-cell receptor-CD3 complexes. Surprisingly, the T-cell receptor (TCR) delta coding regions are located entirely, or almost entirely, within the TCR alpha locus and share at least some of the V region gene segments, thus at least partly linking the two different types of receptor heterodimers. Analysis of potential T-cell receptor diversity, particularly that of the delta chain, indicates a striking concentration of somatic polymorphism in the V-J junctional region of the two heterodimers, four to six orders of magnitude higher than similar calculations for immunoglobulin light- and heavy-chain combinations. In contrast, the number of possible V region combinations in T-cell receptors is one hundredth to one thousandth that of immunoglobulins. TCR alpha: beta heterodimers are known to recognize many possible fragments of antigens embedded in the peptide-binding clefts of a relatively small number of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. Thus it is attractive to speculate that the V-J junctional portions of both types of T-cell receptor contact peptide antigens, whereas the remaining diversity regions contact the MHC. This contention is supported by molecular modelling studies and has interesting implications for the evolution of antigen-receptor genes.

The adult T-cell receptor delta-chain is diverse and distinct from that of fetal thymocytes.

T lymphocytes recognize foreign molecules using the T-cell receptor (TCR), a disulphide-linked heterodimer closely associated with the CD3 polypeptide complex on the cell surface. The TCR alpha beta heterodimers seem largely responsible for the recognition properties of both helper (TH) and cytotoxic (TC) T cells. Recently, a second CD3-associated T-cell receptor heterodimer, gamma delta, has been described. Cells bearing the gamma delta receptor appear before those bearing alpha beta during thymic ontogeny and persist as a minor component (1-10%) of mature peripheral T cells. Their function is unknown. As there are a limited number of functional TCR V gamma gene segments, the size and potential diversity of the V delta repertoire is important for the number of different antigens that may be recognized by gamma delta heterodimers. The delta-chain locus is located 75 kilobases (kb) 5' to the TCR C alpha coding region, raising the possibility that the alpha and delta V-region repertoires may overlap. Also, analysis of rearrangements at the delta-chain locus in developing thymocytes shows distinct fetal and adult patterns indicating that there may be differences between the fetal and adult V delta repertoires. To address these questions, we have characterized a large number of delta-containing complementary DNA clones from adult double-negative thymocytes (CD4-8-), an immature population that is enriched for gamma delta-bearing cells. We find that a limited number of V delta sequences are used, showing little overlap with known adult V alpha s and differing significantly from fetal V delta s. But as two D elements may participate simultaneously in V delta gene assembly, and random nucleotides may be added at any one of three junctional points, the potential number of different delta chains that can be made in the adult thymus is very large (approximately 10(13)).