Reclassification of Genetic Testing Results: A Case Report Demonstrating the Need for Structured Re-Evaluation of Genetic Findings.

Rationale: Alport Syndrome (AS) is a progressive genetic condition characterized by chronic kidney disease (CKD), hearing loss, and eye abnormalities. It is caused by mutations in the genes COL4A3, COL4A4, and COL4A5. Heterozygous mutations in COL4A4 and COL4A3 cause autosomal dominant Alport Syndrome (ADAS), and a spectrum of phenotypes ranging from asymptomatic hematuria to CKD, with variable extra-renal features. In the past, heterozygous mutations in these genes were thought to be benign, however recent studies show that about 30% of patients can progress to CKD, and 15% can progress to end stage kidney disease (ESKD). Presenting Concerns: We present a case of a woman who was noted to have microscopic hematuria pre-living kidney donation. Genetic testing revealed a heterozygous variant of uncertain significance (VUS) in the COL4A4 gene. VUSs are medically nonactionable findings and data show that VUSs can be detected in 41% of all patients who undergo clinical genetic testing. VUSs frustrate clinicians and patients alike. Although they cannot be used in medical decision-making, data suggest that reanalysis can result in the reclassification of a VUS over time. Diagnosis: Post-donation, the index patient had a higher than anticipated rise in serum creatinine, raising a concern for possible intrinsic kidney disease. Kidney biopsy was deemed high risk in the setting of a unilateral kidney thereby limiting possible diagnostic intervention to determine the cause of disease. Intervention: Re-evaluation of prior genetic testing results and reassessment of the previously identified VUS in COL4A4 was performed 5-years post-donation. These analyses, along with the addition of new phenotypic data and extended pedigree data, resulted in the reclassification of the previously identified VUS to a likely pathogenic variant. Outcomes: This case demonstrates the importance of structured, periodic re-evaluation of genetic testing results. With the ever-changing landscape of genetics in medicine, the interpretation of a VUS can be dynamic and therefore warrant caution in living kidney donor evaluations. Studies have shown that about 10% of VUSs can be upgraded to a pathogenic classification after an 18- to 36-month interval. Structured re-evaluation of genomic testing results has not yet been integrated into clinical practice and poses a unique challenge in living kidney donation. Novel findings: This case report highlights the variability of the ADAS phenotype caused by pathogenic heterozygous variants in the type 4 collagen genes. It supports the nomenclature change from a benign hematuria phenotype to ADAS, particularly when additional risk factors such as proteinuria, focal segmental glomerulosclerosis or glomerular basement membrane changes on kidney biopsy are present, or as in this case, evidence of disease in other family members.

Justification: Le syndrome d'Alport (SA) est une maladie génétique progressive caractérisée par une insuffisance rénale chronique (IRC), une perte auditive et des anomalies oculaires. La maladie est causée par des mutations dans les gènes COL4A3, COL4A4 et COL4A5. Des mutations hétérozygotes dans les gènes COL4A4 et COL4A3 provoquent le syndrome d'Alport autosomique dominant (SAAD) et un specter de phénotypes allant de l'hématurie asymptomatique à l'IRC, avec des caractéristiques extrarénales variables. Dans le passé, les mutations hétérozygotes de ces gènes étaient considérées comme bénignes, mais des études récentes montrent qu'environ 30 % des patients peuvent progresser vers l'IRC et 15 % vers l'insuffisance rénale terminale (IRT). Présentation du cas: Nous présentons le cas d'une femme chez qui on avait observé une hématurie microscopique avant un don vivant de rein. Les tests génétiques ont révélé un variant hétérozygote de signification incertaine dans le gène COL4A4. Les variants de signification incertaine (VSI) sont des résultats qui ne peuvent être utilisés médicalement et les données montrent qu'ils peuvent être détectés chez 41 % des patients qui subissent des tests génétiques cliniques. Les VSI sont frustrants tant pour les cliniciens que pour les patients. Bien qu'ils ne puissent pas être utilisés dans la prise de décisions médicales, les données suggèrent que leur réanalyse pourrait entraîner leur reclassification au fil du temps. Diagnostic: Après le don, ce cas index a présenté une élévation de la créatinine sérique plus importante que prévu, ce qui a soulevé une préoccupation quant à la présence d'une néphropathie intrinsèque. La biopsie rénale a été jugée à haut risque dans le contexte de rein unilatéral, ce qui a limité la possible intervention diagnostique pour déterminer la cause de la maladie. Intervention: La réévaluation des résultats des tests génétiques antérieurs et du VSI précédemment identifié dans COL4A4 a été réalisée 5 ans après le don. Ces analyses, ainsi que l'ajout de nouvelles données phénotypiques et de données généalogiques étendues, ont abouti à la reclassification du VSI précédemment identifié en variant probablement pathogène. Résultats: Ce cas illustre l'importance de réévaluer de façon structurée et périodique les résultats des tests génétiques. La génétique étant en constante évolution en médecine, l'interprétation d'un VSI peut être dynamique et, ainsi, justifier la prudence dans les évaluations des donneurs de reins vivants. Des études ont montré qu'environ 10 % des VSI peuvent être reclassés comme pathogènes après 18 à 36 mois. La réévaluation structurée des résultats des tests génomiques, qui n'a pas encore été intégrée dans la pratique clinique, pose un défi unique dans le contexte d'un don vivant de reins. Principales observations: Ce rapport de cas met en évidence la variabilité du phénotype du SAAD causé par des variants hétérozygotes pathogènes dans les gènes du collagène de type 4. Il soutient un changement de nomenclature du phénotype d'hématurie bénigne en SAAD, en particulier en présence de facteurs de risque supplémentaires tels que la protéinurie et la glomérulosclérose segmentaire et focale, de modifications de la membrane basale glomérulaire sur la biopsie rénale ou, comme dans ce cas, de preuves de la maladie chez d'autres membres de la famille.

An uninformative NIPT as an early indicator of cri-du-chat due to a chromosomal 5;18 translocation-An atypical presentation of a rare cytogenetic phenomenon.

We present a patient with cri-du-chat syndrome secondary to a rare cytogenetic mechanism. Our patient was the product of a dichorionic diamniotic twin pregnancy initially flagged with soft markers on ultrasound and uninformative single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP)-based noninvasive prenatal testing (NIPT) for chromosome 18. Subsequent NIPT using proprietary-targeted amplification methodology returned low risk for chromosomal aneuploidies 13, 18, and 21. Due to postnatal clinical findings, a clinical microarray and chromosomal karyotype confirmed cri-du-chat syndrome due to a de novo psu dic(5;18) (p15.2, p11.32). In this report we focus on these cytogenetic changes and discuss some of the current guidelines for prenatal microarray indications.

Dual diagnosis of trisomy 21 and lethal perinatal Gaucher disease as a cause of non-immune hydrops fetalis in a twin pregnancy for a consanguineous couple.

Non-immune hydrops is a prenatal finding which can occur due to an underlying genetic diagnosis such as common chromosomal aneuploidy (Trisomy 21, Turner syndrome etc.). It is extremely rare to have more than one genetic cause of hydrops fetalis in a single pregnancy. This report describes a dichorionic diamniotic pregnancy for a consanguineous couple where noninvasive prenatal testing was "high risk" for Trisomy 21. Family declined amniocentesis and opted for postnatal genetic testing. The pregnancy was later complicated with severe hydrops fetalis leading to demise for one of the twins, and a premature delivery of the other twin who had remarkable collodion not in keeping with Trisomy 21. Postnatal genetic investigations confirmed both Trisomy 21 and prenatal lethal Gaucher disease in the survivor twin. This case report highlights some of the prenatal diagnostic challenges for a consanguineous couple where a rare cause of fetal hydrops was concealed in a setting of a common chromosomal aneuploidy. The prompt postnatal diagnosis of perinatal lethal Gaucher disease, confirmed with undetectable glucocerebrosidase enzyme activity, assisted the family in the decision of providing palliative care for their infant who was quickly deteriorating. The importance of postnatal genetic evaluation and its impact on immediate patient management in an NICU setting is emphasized. This dual diagnosis was significant for the couple as it explained pervious pregnancy losses and has important future recurrence risk implications.

Jansen-de Vries syndrome: Expansion of the PPM1D clinical and phenotypic spectrum in 34 families.

Jansen-de Vries syndrome (JdVS) is a neurodevelopmental condition attributed to pathogenic variants in Exons 5 and 6 of PPM1D. As the full phenotypic spectrum and natural history remain to be defined, we describe a large cohort of children and adults with JdVS. This is a retrospective cohort study of 37 individuals from 34 families with disease-causing variants in PPM1D leading to JdVS. Clinical data were provided by treating physicians and/or families. Of the 37 individuals, 27 were male and 10 female, with median age 8.75 years (range 8 months to 62 years). Four families document autosomal dominant transmission, and 32/34 probands were diagnosed via exome sequencing. The facial gestalt, including a broad forehead and broad mouth with a thin and tented upper lip, was most recognizable between 18 and 48 months of age. Common manifestations included global developmental delay (35/36, 97%), hypotonia (25/34, 74%), short stature (14/33, 42%), constipation (22/31, 71%), and cyclic vomiting (6/35, 17%). Distinctive personality traits include a hypersocial affect (21/31, 68%) and moderate-to-severe anxiety (18/28, 64%). In conclusion, JdVS is a clinically recognizable neurodevelopmental syndrome with a characteristic personality and distinctive facial features. The association of pathogenic variants in PPM1D with cyclic vomiting bears not only medical attention but also further pathogenic and mechanistic evaluation.

A novel MAP3K7 mutation in a child with cardiospondylocarpofacial syndrome and orofacial clefting.

Here we present the case of a patient with a novel de novo, likely pathogenic, heterozygous MAP3K7 variant (c.528dupT, p.G177WfsX5) causing cardiospondylocarpofacial syndrome (CSCFS). The variant, which falls in exon 6, is the first frameshift or non-sense mutation to be connected to CSCFS and presents with a phenotype that shares features with other MAP3K7-linked pathologies, including frontometaphyseal dysplasia 2 (FMD2) and the syndrome arising from an interstitial 6q15 deletions which envelop the gene. Other known mutations associated with CSCFS are plotted in black text (1,2,3).

Pitfalls in Genetic Testing for Consanguineous Pediatric Populations.

We describe the diagnostic odyssey of an eight-year-old female born to consanguineous parents. Our patient presented with global developmental delay, regression, microcephaly, spastic diplegia, and leukodystrophy confirmed on brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). She was found on whole exome sequencing (WES) to have dual genetic diagnoses. The first was a homozygous pathogenic HERC2 gene partial deletion of exons 43-45 that causes HERC2-related disorder. The second was a homozygous pathogenic variant (c.836 C > T, p.A279 V) in the SUMF1 gene responsible for multiple sulfatase deficiency. This case highlights some of the challenges in diagnosing consanguineous pediatric populations where standard genetic and metabolic testing may not provide answers. Our case further supports the recent American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) recommendation of WES as a first or second-tier test for patients with developmental delay, particularly in a population where the chances of dual diagnosis is high.

OTX2 mutation associated with severe myopia in a Canadian family.

PURPOSE: To describe a case of high myopia in a pediatric patient with a mutation in the OTX2 gene and further characterize the diverse ocular phenotypes of heterozygous OTX2 mutations. PATIENT AND METHODS: We describe a three-year-old girl who presented at two months old with abnormal eye movements and suspected retinal dystrophy. Clinical exam and electroretinography (ERG) were conducted, and molecular next generation sequencing (NGS) with the Inherited Retinal Dystrophies panel was completed in our patient and offered to the family. RESULTS: Further examination revealed progressive high myopia in our patient and her mother, alongside diffuse retinal thinning and normal ERG. NGS identified a likely pathogenic variant in the OTX2 gene (c.235 G > A) that was maternal in origin. There were no extra-ocular concerns in our patient, and brain MRI was normal. CONCLUSIONS: While OTX2 mutations are known to cause retinopathy, this case presents a unique phenotype through a heterozygous missense variant (c.235 G > A) underlying high myopia in a three-generation family. This case further supports the role of OTX2 in ocular development and demonstrates the variable expressivity of OTX2 mutations. Genetic testing in families with high myopia may be useful in future surveillance and preparation for ocular and extra-ocular complications associated with OTX2-syndrome presentations.

Aromatase deficiency in an Ontario Old Order Mennonite family.

OBJECTIVES: Aromatase deficiency is a rare autosomal recessive disease that results in the absence of aromatase. In females it presents with ambiguous genitalia and lack of secondary sexual characteristics during puberty. Aromatase deficiency is not attributed to any specific population, but it is more commonly seen in consanguineous parents. Herein, we report the first Old Order Mennonite family with that diagnosis. CASE PRESENTATION: Our proband is an Old Order Mennonite female born with ambiguous genitalia who was identified to carry novel homozygous variant in the CYP19A1 gene c.1304G>A (p. Arg435His). Her older brother was later confirmed with the same genetic diagnosis. CONCLUSIONS: Recognizing the cultural sensitivity, unrecognized affected cases, and late presentation of males affected with aromatase deficiency, this condition may be more prevalent than believed in that population.

The phenotypic spectrum of AMER1-related osteopathia striata with cranial sclerosis: The first Canadian cohort.

Osteopathia striata with cranial sclerosis (OSCS; OMIM# 300373) is a rare X-linked disorder caused by mutations of the AMER1 gene. OSCS is traditionally considered a skeletal dysplasia, characterized by cranial sclerosis and longitudinal striations in the long bone metaphyses. However, OSCS affects many body systems and varies significantly in phenotypic severity between individuals. This case series focuses on the phenotypic presentation and development of individuals with OSCS. We provide an account of 12 patients with OSCS, ranging from 5 months to 38 years of age. These patients were diagnosed with OSCS after genetic testing confirmed pathogenic mutations in AMER1. Patient consent was obtained for photos and participation. Data were collected regarding perinatal history, dysmorphic features, and review of systems. This case series documents common facial dysmorphology, as well as rare extraskeletal features of OSCS, including two patients with intestinal malrotation and two patients with pyloric stenosis. We share four apparently nonmosaic males with OSCS (one de novo and three maternal variants). We also provide a clinical update on a patient who was previously published by Chénier et al. (2012). American Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 158, 2946-2952. More research is needed to investigate the links between genotype and phenotype and assess the long-term comorbidities and overall quality of life of individuals with OSCS.

Clinical and technical assessment of MedExome vs. NGS panels in patients with suspected genetic disorders in Southwestern Ontario.

The adaptation of a broad genomic sequencing approach in the clinical setting has been accompanied by considerations regarding the clinical utility, technical performance, and diagnostic yield compared to targeted genetic approaches. We have developed MedExome, an integrated framework for sequencing, variant calling (SNVs, Indels, and CNVs), and clinical assessment of ~4600 medically relevant genes. We compared the technical performance of MedExome with the whole-exome and targeted gene-panel sequencing, assessed the reasons for discordance, and evaluated the added clinical yield of MedExome in a cohort of unresolved subjects suspected of genetic disease. Our analysis showed that despite a higher average read depth in panels (3058 vs. 855), MedExome yielded full coverage of the enriched regions (>20X) and 99% variant concordance rate with panels. The discordance rate was associated with low-complexity regions, high-GC content, and low allele fractions, observed in both platforms. MedExome yielded full sensitivity in detecting clinically actionable variants, and the assessment of 138 patients with suspected genetic conditions resulted in 76 clinical reports (31 full [22.1%], 3 partial, and 42 uncertain/possible molecular diagnoses). MedExome sequencing has comparable performance in variant detection to gene panels. Added diagnostic yield justifies expanded implementation of broad genomic approaches in unresolved patients; however, cost-benefit and health systems impact warrants assessment.

Further delineation of Basel-Vanagaite-Smirin-Yosef syndrome: Report of three patients.

Basel-Vanagaite-Smirin-Yosef syndrome is a recently described autosomal recessive intellectual disability syndrome caused by variants in the MED25 gene. While it was originally identified in Brazil, it was further described in Israel by authors who are now the namesake of the condition. A 2018 publication further contributed to its delineation, but the patient's phenotype was complicated by a dual diagnosis. More recently, an article describing a set of affected siblings was published. We describe three, previously unreported, patients showing clinical variability for this newly defined syndrome. The major features determined by "reverse phenotyping" include significant to profound developmental delays/intellectual disability with absent or delayed speech, epilepsy, ocular abnormalities, cleft lip and/or palate, congenital heart disease, urogenital anomalies, skeletal abnormalities, brain malformations and/or microcephaly, failure to thrive, and dysmorphic features. The authors suggest the delineation of an acronym using the gene name and common features seen across the majority of patients reported so far. This new nomination, MED-DOCS, may help clinicians to recognize, suspect, and remember this novel syndrome.

Diagnostic Utility of Genome-wide DNA Methylation Testing in Genetically Unsolved Individuals with Suspected Hereditary Conditions.

Conventional genetic testing of individuals with neurodevelopmental presentations and congenital anomalies (ND/CAs), i.e., the analysis of sequence and copy number variants, leaves a substantial proportion of them unexplained. Some of these cases have been shown to result from DNA methylation defects at a single locus (epi-variants), while others can exhibit syndrome-specific DNA methylation changes across multiple loci (epi-signatures). Here, we investigate the clinical diagnostic utility of genome-wide DNA methylation analysis of peripheral blood in unresolved ND/CAs. We generate a computational model enabling concurrent detection of 14 syndromes using DNA methylation data with full accuracy. We demonstrate the ability of this model in resolving 67 individuals with uncertain clinical diagnoses, some of whom had variants of unknown clinical significance (VUS) in the related genes. We show that the provisional diagnoses can be ruled out in many of the case subjects, some of whom are shown by our model to have other diseases initially not considered. By applying this model to a cohort of 965 ND/CA-affected subjects without a previous diagnostic assumption and a separate assessment of rare epi-variants in this cohort, we identify 15 case subjects with syndromic Mendelian disorders, 12 case subjects with imprinting and trinucleotide repeat expansion disorders, as well as 106 case subjects with rare epi-variants, a portion of which involved genes clinically or functionally linked to the subjects' phenotypes. This study demonstrates that genomic DNA methylation analysis can facilitate the molecular diagnosis of unresolved clinical cases and highlights the potential value of epigenomic testing in the routine clinical assessment of ND/CAs.