Randomized trial of a specialist genetic assessment service for familial breast cancer.

BACKGROUND: Because of the growing demand for genetic assessment, there is an urgent need for information about what services are appropriate for women with a family history of breast cancer. Our purpose was to compare the psychologic impact and costs of a multidisciplinary genetic and surgical assessment service with those of current service provisions. METHODS: We carried out a prospective randomized trial of surgical consultation with (the trial group) and without (the control group) genetic assessment in 1000 women with a family history of breast cancer. All P: values are from two-sided tests. RESULTS: Although statistically significantly greater improvement in knowledge about breast cancer was found in the trial group (P: =.05), differences between groups in other psychologic outcomes were not statistically significant. Women in both groups experienced statistically significant reductions in anxiety and found attending the clinics to be highly satisfying. An initial specialist genetic assessment cost pound 14.27 (U.S. $22.55) more than a consultation with a breast surgeon. Counseling and genetic testing of affected relatives, plus subsequent testing of family members of affected relatives identified as mutation carriers, raised the total extra direct and indirect costs per woman in the trial group to pound 60.98 (U.S. $96.35) over costs for the control subjects. CONCLUSIONS: There may be little benefit in providing specialist genetics services to all women with a family history of breast cancer. Further investigation of factors that may mediate the impact of genetic assessment is in progress and may reveal subgroups of women who would benefit from specialist genetics services.

BRCA1 and BRCA2 in breast cancer families from Wales: moderate mutation frequency and two recurrent mutations in BRCA1.

Mutations in the BRCA1/BRCA2 genes account for varying proportions of breast cancer families studied, and demonstrate considerable variation in mutational spectra coincident with ethnic and geographical diversity. We have screened for mutations in 17 families from Wales with two or more cases of breast cancer under age 50 and/or ovarian cancer. Eight out of 17 (47%) families had demonstrable mutations. Six out of 17 (35%) carried BRCA1 mutations and 2 out of 17 (12%) carried BRCA2 mutations. Two recurrent mutations in BRCA1 were identified, which appear to represent founder mutations in this population. These data support the existence of additional breast and ovarian cancer susceptibility genes.

PROMM: the expanding phenotype. A family with proximal myopathy, myotonia and deafness.

We describe a family with a proximal myopathy, subclinical EMG myotonia, cataracts and deafness. Transmission through two generations and down the male line confirms autosomal dominant inheritance. There was no abnormal expansion of the CTG triplet repeat in the last exon of the dystrophia myotonica protein kinase (DMPK) gene associated with myotonic dystrophy. Heteroduplex analysis of all but the promoter region of the DMPK gene has excluded point mutations in this gene as an underlying cause for this myotonic disorder. The family was not sufficiently informative to exclude linkage to the sodium channel gene SCN4A or the chloride channel gene CLC1. This family clearly fulfils the recently established diagnostic criteria for PROMM (proximal myotonic myopathy) and in addition shows consistent severe deafness as a hitherto undescribed feature of PROMM. We discuss the diagnostic criteria of PROMM in relation to this family and other recent papers, all of which would now fulfil the aforementioned diagnostic criteria for PROMM.

The GAP-related domain of tuberin, the product of the TSC2 gene, is a target for missense mutations in tuberous sclerosis.

Tuberous sclerosis is an autosomal dominant trait in which the dysregulation of cellular proliferation and differentiation results in the development of hamartomatous growths in many organs. The TSC2 gene is one of two genes determining tuberous sclerosis. Inactivating germline mutations of TSC2 in patients with tuberous sclerosis and somatic loss of heterozygosity at the TSC2 locus in the associated hamartomas indicate that TSC2 functions as a tumour suppressor gene and that loss of function is critical to expression of the tuberous sclerosis phenotype. The TSC2 product, tuberin, has a region of homology with the GTPase activating protein rap1GAP and stimulates the GTPase activity of rap1a and rab5a in vitro. Here we show that the region of homology between tuberin and human rap1GAP and the murine GAP mSpa1 is more extensive than previously reported and spans approximately 160 amino acid residues encoded within exons 34-38 of the TSC2 gene. Single strand conformation polymorphism analysis of these exons in 173 unrelated patients with tuberous sclerosis and direct sequencing of variant conformers together with study of additional family members enabled characterisation of disease associated mutations in 14 cases. Missense mutations, which occurred in exons 36, 37 and 38 were identified in eight cases, four of whom shared the same recurrent change P1675L. Each of the five different missense mutations identified was shown to occur de novo in at least one sporadic case of tuberous sclerosis. The high proportion of missense mutations detected in the region of the TSC2 gene encoding the GAP-related domain supports its key role in the regulation of cellular growth.

Cataract and myotonic dystrophy: the role of molecular diagnosis.

Myotonic dystrophy (dystrophia myotonica), the commonest and most variable of the muscular dystrophies of adult life, has long been known to be associated with cataract, while slit-lamp examination for specific lens opacities has been one of the principal methods of presymptomatic detection of gene carriers. The recent discovery that the myotonic dystrophy mutation is an unstable DNA sequence, composed of varying numbers of CTG triplet repeats, now allows a specific molecular test for this disorder, as well as explaining the phenomenon of anticipation. A series of case reports is presented to illustrate the important practical applications of this development in relation to ophthalmic aspects of the disorder. Reassessment of the specificity of the ophthalmic changes may be required and it will be important for molecular analysis to be used alongside ophthalmic studies, when determining whether family members carry the mutation for myotonic dystrophy.

Size of the unstable CTG repeat sequence in relation to phenotype and parental transmission in myotonic dystrophy.

A clinical and molecular analysis of 439 individuals affected with myotonic dystrophy, from 101 kindreds, has shown that the size of the unstable CTG repeat detected in nearly all cases of myotonic dystrophy is related both to age at onset of the disorder and to the severity of the phenotype. The largest repeat sizes (1.5-6.0 kb) are seen in patients with congenital myotonic dystrophy, while the minimally affected patients have repeat sizes of < 0.5 kb. Comparison of parent-child pairs has shown that most offspring have an earlier age at onset and a larger repeat size than their parents, with only 4 of 182 showing a definite decrease in repeat size, accompanied by a later age at onset or less severe phenotype. Increase in repeat size from parent to child is similar for both paternal and maternal transmissions when the increase is expressed as a proportion of the parental repeat size. Analysis of congenitally affected cases shows not only that they have, on average, the largest repeat sizes but also that their mothers have larger mean repeat sizes, supporting previous suggestions that a maternal effect is involved in the pathogenesis of this form of the disorder.

Huntington's disease: predictive testing and the molecular genetics laboratory.

We describe the laboratory-related aspects of a series of 40 completed presymptomatic tests for Huntington's disease, using linked DNA markers. Pedigree structure and marker heterozygosity are shown to be important factors, both in the number of laboratory analyses required to give an informative situation and the residual uncertainty of the final estimate. Specific problems encountered by the testing laboratory are described, with possible ways of avoiding them, and the close links required between laboratory and clinical staff are emphasised.

Specific molecular prenatal diagnosis for the CTG mutation in myotonic dystrophy.

The results of DNA analysis for the specific mutation of myotonic dystrophy are reported in eight pregnancies (two studied retrospectively) in six families. Four results were normal; in the other four, large DNA expansions were found, comparable to the range seen in severely affected children with congenital onset of the disorder. The results agreed with those obtained by linked DNA markers in the six cases where they were available. We conclude that specific molecular prenatal diagnosis of myotonic dystrophy is feasible, and that an abnormal result may also give a guide to possible severity, though this should be interpreted with caution until greater experience is available.

Presymptomatic testing for Huntington's disease in Wales 1987-90.

Between 1987 and 1990 a large series of at-risk individuals has been referred to our Huntington's disease (HD) presymptomatic testing programme. A detailed protocol for assessment and counselling has been followed. Out of 238 serious inquiries, 36% were potentially suitable for the testing programme, but 19% chose not to continue. Reasons for exclusion included the presence of clinical features of HD and being under the age of 18 years. Out of 40 final results given to 38 individuals, 23 indicated a lowered risk, 11 an increased risk, while five results were uninformative, two of these becoming informative on repeat testing. This series contained more women than men, and was disproportionately from the higher socio-economic groups. Motives for requesting a test principally related to child-bearing, informing existing children, and planning for the future. No significant psychiatric symptoms have been reported in the short term, but difficult counselling problems were presented by the high proportion of applicants who already showed clinical signs of HD. It is concluded that a detailed counselling protocol is essential in testing for HD, as many applicants are ill-prepared; this will assume even greater importance when the HD gene is identified and a test for specific mutations is available. The experience of presymptomatic testing for HD provides important general lessons which are likely to be applicable to other inherited neurological and psychiatric disorders.

Mutation analysis of 184 cystic fibrosis families in Wales.

We describe a molecular analysis of 184 cystic fibrosis (CF) families in Wales. To determine accurate frequency data for the CF mutations in the Welsh population, families with at least three Welsh grandparents were strictly regarded as Welsh. Of these 74 families, we have identified approximately 90% of mutations causing CF, with delta F508 accounting for 71.8% and 621 + 1G greater than T 6.7%. We observed a significant difference between the Welsh and Scottish frequencies of 621 + 1G greater than T. To allow the rapid and efficient screening for the more common mutations we modified a multiplex used by Watson et al enabling the detection of delta F508, G551D, and R553X simultaneously with 621 + 1G greater than T. In parallel to this system we ran the Cellmark Diagnostics ARMS multiplex kit, which detects delta F508, 621 + 1G greater than T, G551D, and G542X. RFLP analysis of the 184 families shows that the delta F508 chromosomes are almost exclusively found on the B haplotype (XV2c 1, KM19 2); the other CF mutations have more heterogeneous backgrounds. Strong haplotype correlations exist between the markers XV2c, KM19, D9, and G2 and the other CF mutations. Haplotype data suggest that there are at least seven mutations that remain to be identified in these families.

Five years experience of predictive testing for myotonic dystrophy using linked DNA markers.

We report on a 5 year experience in providing presymptomatic and prenatal molecular diagnostic services for myotonic dystrophy, using closely linked markers, representing 235 completed results in 161 families. Only 10 analyses (4.3%) proved uninformative, but a further 5 requests (1.9%) could not be reported because of uncertainty in clinical status. Seven of 81 (8.6%) patients considered to be at low risk on clinical grounds were found to be at high risk of carrying the gene. The importance of interpreting molecular results in conjunction with clinical findings is emphasised by the illustrative examples provided. Careful clinical examination and appropriate investigation remain a cornerstone of diagnosis in myotonic dystrophy and are crucial if errors in assigning genotype status by molecular means are to be minimised.

Unstable DNA sequence in myotonic dystrophy.

A variable DNA sequence has been detected in patients with myotonic dystrophy. We set out to determine whether identification of this specific molecular defect would improve clinical management of patients and families with myotonic dystrophy. 127 affected patients who were studied had an expanded DNA fragment not seen in 73 normal controls. The increase in length of the fragment correlated broadly with disease severity, and we noted expansion of the sequence in successive generations of the same family. Progressive expansion of the affected gene provides a molecular explanation for an apparently earlier onset in successive generations (anticipation) in myotonic dystrophy and supports the role of an unstable repeat sequence as the basis of the defect. The specificity of this finding will assist in accurate diagnosis of myotonic dystrophy and genetic counselling of affected families.

Molecular analysis for the myotonic dystrophy mutation in neuromuscular disorders.

A variable expansion of an unstable CTG repeat has been identified as the causal mutation for myotonic dystrophy. Standard molecular genetic techniques can now supplement traditional assessment protocols in a variety of clinical neurological situations where diagnostic uncertainty prevailed. Southern analysis using DNA probes which identify the expanded sequence, supplemented by direct PCR analysis for repeat number, provides a specific sensitive diagnostic test for myotonic dystrophy.