Validation of the influence of CT slice thickness on the quantitative accuracy and image quality of single photon emission computed tomography.

OBJECTIVES: Computed tomography (CT) images are used for precise anatomical location of lesions and for accurate attenuation correction in single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) image reconstruction in SPECT/CT examination. The aim of this study was to verify the effects of varying CT collimation width and slice thickness on CT images and on CT attenuation corrected SPECT images. METHODS: We acquired SPECT/CT images of a micro-coin phantom and the National Electrical Manufacturers Association body phantom filled with 99mTc-pertechnetate while varying the abovementioned CT parameters. The full width at half maximum of the slice sensitivity profile, the standard deviation of CT image background noise, and the radiation dose from CT scans were evaluated. Subsequently, the percentage contrast, background variability, and absolute recovery coefficient of the SPECT image were measured. Furthermore, we retrospectively reviewed the clinical bone SPECT images of 23 patients, and statistical testing of differences was performed. RESULTS: As the collimation width and reconstruction slice thickness of the CT image increased, z-axis resolution deteriorated, and background noise decreased. In addition, CT radiation dose decreased with increasing collimation width. Meanwhile, SPECT image quality and quantitative accuracy were unchanged with varying CT collimation width and slice thickness. There were no notable variations in clinical SPECT images and no statistically significant differences. CONCLUSION: When high-resolution CT slices on the z-axis are not required for clinical diagnosis, increasing collimation width or slice thickness can reduce the radiation dose and image noise with no influence on the quality of SPECT images .

Multicenter Study of Quantitative SPECT: Reproducibility of 99mTc Quantitation Using a Conjugated-Gradient Minimization Reconstruction Algorithm.

This multicenter study aimed to determine the reproducibility of quantitative SPECT images reconstructed using a commercially available method of ordered-subset conjugate-gradient minimization. Methods: A common cylindric phantom containing a 100 kBq/mL concentration of 99mTc-pertechnetate solution in a volume of 7 L was scanned under standard imaging conditions at 6 institutions using the local clinical protocol of each. Interinstitutional variation among the quantitative SPECT images was evaluated using the coefficient of variation. Dose calibrator accuracy was also investigated by measuring the same lot of commercially available 99mTc vials at each institution. Results: The respective radioactivity concentrations under standard and clinical conditions ranged from 95.71 ± 0.60 (mean ± SD) to 108.35 ± 0.36 kBq/mL and from 96.78 ± 0.64 to 108.49 ± 0.11 kBq/mL, respectively. Interinstitutional variation in radioactivity concentration was 4.20%. The bias in the radioactivity concentrations in SPECT images was associated with the accuracy of the dose calibrator at each institution. Conclusion: The reproducibility of the commercially available quantitative SPECT reconstruction method is high and comparable to that of PET, for comparatively large (∼7 L), homogeneous objects.

Phantom and clinical evaluation of bone SPECT/CT image reconstruction with xSPECT algorithm.

BACKGROUND: Two novel methods of image reconstruction, xSPECT Quant (xQ) and xSPECT Bone (xB), that use an ordered subset conjugate gradient minimizer (OSCGM) for SPECT/CT reconstruction have been proposed. The present study compares the performance characteristics of xQ, xB, and conventional Flash3D (F3D) reconstruction using images derived from phantoms and patients. METHODS: A custom-designed body phantom for bone SPECT was scanned using a Symbia Intevo (Siemens Healthineers), and reconstructed xSPECT images were evaluated. The phantom experiments proceeded twice with different activity concentrations and sphere sizes. A phantom with 28-mm spheres containing a 99mTc-background and tumor-to-normal bone ratios (TBR) of 1, 2, 4, and 10 were generated, and convergence property against various TBR was evaluated across 96 iterations. A phantom with four spheres (13-, 17-, 22-, and 28-mm diameters), containing a 99mTc-background at TBR4, was also generated. The full width at half maximum of an imaged spinous process (10 mm), coefficients of variance (CV), contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR), and recovery coefficients (RC) were evaluated after reconstructing images of a spine using Flash 3D (F3D), xQ, and xB. We retrospectively analyzed images from 20 patients with suspected bone metastases (male, n = 13) which were acquired using [99mTc]Tc-(H)MDP SPECT/CT, then CV and standardized uptake values (SUV) at the 4th vertebral body (L4) were compared after xQ and xB reconstruction in a clinical setup. RESULTS: Mean activity concentrations with various TBR converged according to increasing numbers of iterations. The spatial resolution of xB was considerably superior to xQ and F3D, and it approached almost the actual size regardless of the iteration numbers during reconstruction. The CV and RC were better for xQ and xB than for F3D. The CNR peaked at 24 iterations for xQ and 48 iterations for F3D and xB, respectively. The RC between xQ and xB significantly differed at lower numbers of iterations but were almost equivalent at higher numbers of iterations. The reconstructed xQ and xB images of the clinical patients showed a significant difference in the SUVmax and SUVpeak. CONCLUSIONS: The reconstructed xQ and xB images were more accurate than those reconstructed conventionally using F3D. The xB for bone SPECT imaging offered essentially unchanged spatial resolution even when the numbers of iterations did not converge. The xB reconstruction further enhanced SPECT image quality using CT data. Our findings provide important information for understanding the performance characteristics of the novel xQ and xB algorithms.

Impact of Novel Incorporation of CT-based Segment Mapping into a Conjugated Gradient Algorithm on Bone SPECT Imaging: Fundamental Characteristics of a Context-specific Reconstruction Method.

OBJECTIVES: The latest single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT)/computed tomography (CT) reconstruction system, referred to as xSPECT Bone™, is a context-specific reconstruction system utilizing tissue segmentation information from CT data, which is called a zone map. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of zone-map enhancement incorporated into the ordered-subset conjugated gradient minimization (OSCGM) reconstruction method on SPECT images. METHODS: Image quality with zone-map enhanced OSCGM (OSCGMz) and non-enhanced OSCGM methods was compared using various reconstruction parameters. The compartment phantom had 3 radioactive sections with CT values of about 1000, 250, and 0 HU. SPECT data were acquired using a low-energy high-resolution (LEHR) collimator, with a 256×256 matrix and 2.4-mm pixel size. The performances of the 2 reconstruction methods (OSCGM vs. OSCGMz) were evaluated on the basis of %error, coefficient of variation (%CV), and normalized mean squared error (NMSE), and adequate iterative update numbers were determined. The relative CV representing the ratio of smoothed images to non-smoothed images was calculated to evaluate the effects of the Gaussian filter on each section set with different CT values. RESULTS: On comparing the OSCGM and OSCGMz methods, it was found that the %error of the OSCGMz method tended to show convergence with fewer updates, especially in the high CT value section mimicking bone absorption. In the water section, the %CV of the OSCGMz method was lower than that of the OSCGM method. The NMSE minimum values for the OSCGM and OSCGMz methods were obtained at 30 and 20 updates, respectively. The relative CV for the OSCGMz method in the water section decreased remarkably according to the size of the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the Gaussian filter. CONCLUSION: The zone-map enhancement contributed to SPECT reconstruction for the reproduction of radioactive concentrations in bone tissues, using a low number of OSCGM updates. Our findings indicated that the incorporation of zone maps into SPECT reconstruction might improve image quality.

Characteristics of iodine-123 IQ-SPECT/CT imaging compared with conventional SPECT/CT.

OBJECTIVES: Although the utility of IQ-SPECT imaging using 99mTc and 201Tl myocardial perfusion SPECT has been reported, 123I-labeled myocardial SPECT has not been fully evaluated. We determined the characteristics and utility of 123I IQ-SPECT imaging compared with conventional SPECT (C-SPECT). METHODS: Two myocardial phantom patterns were used to simulate normal myocardium and myocardial infarction. SPECT acquisition was performed using a hybrid dual-head SPECT/CT system equipped with a SMARTZOOM collimator for IQ-SPECT or a low-medium energy general purpose collimator for C-SPECT. Projection data were reconstructed using ordered subset expectation maximization with depth-dependent 3-dimensional resolution recovery for C-SPECT and ordered subset conjugate gradient minimizer method for IQ-SPECT. Three types of myocardial image were created; namely, no correction (NC), with attenuation correction (AC), and with both attenuation and scatter corrections (ACSC). Five observers visually scored the homogeneity of normal myocardium and defect severity of the myocardium with inferior defects by a five-point scale: homogeneity scores (5 = homogeneous to 1 = inhomogeneous) and defect scores (5 = excellent to 1 = poor). We also created a 17-segment polar map and quantitatively assessed segmental %uptake using a myocardial phantom with normal findings and defects. RESULTS: The average visual homogeneity scores of the IQ-SPECT with NC and ACSC were significantly higher than that of C-SPECT, whereas the average visual defect scores of IQ-SPECT with AC and ACSC were significantly lower. The %uptake of all segments for IQ-SPECT with NC was significantly higher than that of C-SPECT. Furthermore, the subtraction of %uptake for C-SPECT and IQ-SPECT was the largest in inferior wall, which was approximately 10.1%, 14.7% and 14.4% for NC, AC and ACSC, respectively. The median % uptake values of the inferior wall with defect areas for C-SPECT and IQ-SPECT were 46.9% and 50.7% with NC, 59.8% and 69.2% with AC, and 54.7% and 66.5% with ACSC, respectively. CONCLUSION: 123I IQ-SPECT imaging significantly improved the attenuation artifact compared with C-SPECT imaging. Although the defect detectability of IQ-SPECT was inferior to that of C-SPECT, 123I IQ-SPECT images with NC and ACSC met the criteria for defect detectability. Use of 123I IQ-SPECT is suitable for routine examinations.

Characterization of Noise and Resolution for Quantitative 177Lu SPECT/CT with xSPECT Quant.

Quantitative SPECT/CT imaging forms the basis for internal dosimetry in molecular radiotherapies. While the conversion from counts to activity is typically based on conversion factors individually measured by each site, a recently introduced commercially available reconstruction (xSPECT Quant) offers a standardized and traceable calibration of SPECT/CT systems. The aim of this work was to assess the characteristics of xSPECT Quant in combination with 177Lu as one of the most important radionuclides used in molecular radiotherapies and to compare it to a widely used ordered-subset expectation-maximization reconstruction (Flash3D). Methods: In a series of 177Lu-filled phantom measurements, several important features were investigated for xSPECT Quant and Flash3D. Noise behavior and accuracy of the activity determination were evaluated in a large cylinder. Recovery coefficients were assessed in a hot-sphere phantom with and without background. Additionally, the resolutions were determined in a line source phantom as well as in a matched-filter resolution analysis of the hot-sphere-cold-background phantom. Results: Both reconstruction algorithms improve the spatial resolution at the cost of noise build-up. Despite its slower convergence, Flash3D features a more efficient recovery. Although resolution recovery methods are applied within both reconstructions, partial-volume errors-namely activity overestimation in the object center and spill-out of counts from the object edges-remain of relevance. In contrast to Flash3D, for which only the total number of updates (iterations × subsets) plays a role, the exact subdivision into iterations and subsets affected all characteristics of xSPECT Quant (optimum, 1 subset). The optimal trade-off between noise build-up and resolution improvement was found for 48 iterations and 1 subset, resulting in a quantitative accuracy of 1.2% in the Jaszczak cylinder (xSPECT Quant cross-calibrated to the dose calibrator). Conclusion: If the reconstruction parameters are chosen with care, both examined reconstructions can provide absolute quantitative SPECT images with high image quality (subcentimeter resolution at an acceptable noise build-up) as well as high quantitative accuracy (given a well-calibrated Flash3D conversion from counts to activity concentration). With its standardized (and traceable) activity determination, xSPECT Quant dispenses with site-specific calibration protocols, enabling a reliable activity determination comparable across sites, which is especially useful for multicentric molecular radiotherapy studies.