Automatic identification of physical activity types and sedentary behaviors from triaxial accelerometer: laboratory-based calibrations are not enough.

"Objective" methods to monitor physical activity and sedentary patterns in free-living conditions are necessary to further our understanding of their impacts on health. In recent years, many software solutions capable of automatically identifying activity types from portable accelerometry data have been developed, with promising results in controlled conditions, but virtually no reports on field tests. An automatic classification algorithm initially developed using laboratory-acquired data (59 subjects engaging in a set of 24 standardized activities) to discriminate between 8 activity classes (lying, slouching, sitting, standing, walking, running, and cycling) was applied to data collected in the field. Twenty volunteers equipped with a hip-worn triaxial accelerometer performed at their own pace an activity set that included, among others, activities such as walking the streets, running, cycling, and taking the bus. Performances of the laboratory-calibrated classification algorithm were compared with those of an alternative version of the same model including field-collected data in the learning set. Despite good results in laboratory conditions, the performances of the laboratory-calibrated algorithm (assessed by confusion matrices) decreased for several activities when applied to free-living data. Recalibrating the algorithm with data closer to real-life conditions and from an independent group of subjects proved useful, especially for the detection of sedentary behaviors while in transports, thereby improving the detection of overall sitting (sensitivity: laboratory model = 24.9%; recalibrated model = 95.7%). Automatic identification methods should be developed using data acquired in free-living conditions rather than data from standardized laboratory activity sets only, and their limits carefully tested before they are used in field studies.

Improving activity recognition using temporal coherence.

Assessment of daily physical activity using data from wearable sensors has recently become a prominent research area in the biomedical engineering field and a substantial application for pattern recognition. In this paper, we present an accelerometer-based activity recognition scheme on the basis of a hierarchical structured classifier. A first step consists of distinguishing static activities from dynamic ones in order to extract relevant features for each activity type. Next, a separate classifier is applied to detect more specific activities of the same type. On top of our activity recognition system, we introduce a novel approach to take into account the temporal coherence of activities. Inter-activity transition information is modeled by a directed graph Markov chain. Confidence measures in activity classes are then evaluated from conventional classifier's outputs and coupled with the graph to reinforce activity estimation. Accurate results and significant improvement of activity detection are obtained when applying our system for the recognition of 9 activities for 48 subjects.