Using mitochondrial and nuclear markers to evaluate the degree of genetic cohesion among Echinococcus populations.

Based on the distinctiveness of their mitochondrial haplotypes and other biological features, several recent publications have proposed that some Echinococcus granulosus strains should be regarded as separate species. However, the genetic cohesion of these species has not been extensively evaluated using nuclear markers. We assess the degree of polymorphism of the partial mitochondrial cox1 (366bp), the nuclear mdh (214bp) and EgAgB4 (281-283bp) genes of E. granulosus sensu lato isolates collected from areas where different strains occur sympatrically. Five distinct mitochondrial haplotypes were determined by direct sequencing (G1, G2, G5, G6 and G7). The mdh genotypes were first screened by SSCP: three alleles were identified (Md1-Md3), which were further confirmed by nucleotide sequencing. For EgAgB4, which was analysed by direct sequencing the PCR products, two groups of sequences were found: EgAgB4-1 and EgAgB4-2. No haplotype-specific mdh or EgAgB4 sequences occur. Nevertheless, alleles Md1 and Md2 and type 1 sequences of EgAgB4 showed a higher frequency within the group of haplotypes G1-G2, while allele Md3 and EgAgB4-2 are most frequent in the G5-G7 cluster. By AMOVA it is shown that 79% of the total genetic variability is found among haplotype groups. These findings are compatible with two not mutually exclusive evolutionary hypotheses: (a) that haplotypes share an ancestral polymorphism, or (b) that the reproductive isolation between parasites with distinct haplotypes is not complete, leading to gene introgression. The biologic and epidemiologic consequences of our findings are discussed.

Expression and diversity of Echinococcus multilocularis AgB genes in secondarily infected mice: evaluating the influence of T-cell immune selection on antigenic variation.

The T-cell-mediated immune response exhibits a crucial function in the control of the intrahepatic proliferation of Echinococcus multilocularis larvae in mice and humans, both being natural intermediate hosts of the parasite. Antigen B (AgB), a metabolized Echinococcus spp. lipoprotein, contributes to the modulation of the T-cell immune response, and distinct sites of the corresponding AgB1, AgB3 and AgB4 genes were shown to be under positive selection pressure. Since several AgB gene variants are present in a single Echinococcus metacestode, we used secondary E. multilocularis infections in BALB/c and in athymic nude mice (devoid of T-cell responses) to analyze the effect of the cellular immune response on the expression and diversity of EmAgB1-EmAgB4 genes. We demonstrated hereby that EmAgB transcripts were less abundant in nude mice during the early phase of infection (at one month post-infection), and that EmAgB2 is simultaneously down-regulated when compared to the other three genes. A negative relationship exists between the level of transcription and diversity of EmAgB genes. Moreover, no excess of non-synonymous substitutions was found among the distinct EmAgB alleles from a single host. Together, these results pointed to the effect of purifying selection, which seemed to eliminate the detrimental AgB variants generated during the development of the metacestode within the peritoneal cavity of its intermediate host.

Redundancy and recombination in the Echinococcus AgB multigene family: is there any similarity with protozoan contingency genes?

Numerous genetic variants of the Echinococcus antigen B (AgB) are encountered within a single metacestode. This could be a reflection of gene redundancy or the result of a somatic hypermutation process. We evaluate the complexity of the AgB multigene family by characterizing the upstream promoter regions of the 4 already known genes (EgAgB1-EgAgB4) and evaluating their redundancy in the genome of 3 Echinococcus species (E. granulosus, E. ortleppi and E. multilocularis) using PCR-based approaches. We have ascertained that the number of AgB gene copies is quite variable, both within and between species. The most repetitive gene seems to be AgB3, of which there are more than 110 copies in E. ortleppi. For E. granulosus, we have cloned and characterized 10 distinct upstream promoter regions of AgB3 from a single metacestode. Our sequences suggest that AgB1 and AgB3 are involved in gene conversion. These results are discussed in light of the role of gene redundancy and recombination in parasite evasion mechanisms of host immunity, which at present are known for protozoan organisms, but virtually unknown for multicellular parasites.

Searching for antigen B genes and their adaptive sites in distinct strains and species of the helminth Echinococcus.

Twenty-seven PCR-derived antigen B (AgB) nucleotide sequences from four Echinococcus species (Echinococcus granulosus, Echinococcus multilocularis, Echinococcus oligarthrus and Echinococcus vogeli) were aligned with 78 already published sequences, to generate a maximum likelihood phylogeny of the AgB multigene family. The phylogenetic analysis confirms that the family is constituted by four groups of genes present in each one of the four species (AgB1, AgB2, AgB3 and AgB4), and suggests that it originated by ancient duplication events preceding speciation within the genus. AgB5 sequences, which had been formerly suggested to correspond to a putatively new AgB subunit, cluster with AgB3. Likelihood tests suggest that AgB gene evolution may have been driven by heterogeneous selection pressures acting on particular AgB1, AgB3 and AgB4 codons. No selection is detected in AgB2. We discuss implications of our findings in terms of AgB biology and its use as a diagnostic tool.

The Echinococcus granulosus antigen B shows a high degree of genetic variability.

Echinococcus granulosus larvae secret a polymeric lipoprotein known as antigen B (AgB) into the metacestode hydatid fluid. Three similar AgB subunits have been previously identified (AgB1, AgB2, and AgB3), and their respective genes isolated, but the actual number of genes encoding AgB subunits remains uncertain. In this study, we characterize the variability of genes encoding the AgB2 subunit, using PCR and RT-PCR followed by cloning and sequencing. We have analyzed 32 cDNA and 34 genomic sequences from a single metacestode, showing a high degree of sequence polymorphism. In addition, we have identified a possibly new AgB subunit, which we call AgB4. Additionally, we describe an AgB2 genomic clone lacking (i) a segment corresponding to the intron and (ii) a short, 45 bp sequence within exon II. The 45 bp segment encompasses the conserved splicing signals and corresponds to a highly conserved insect promoter motif.

Contingent, non-neutral evolution in a multicellular parasite: natural selection and gene conversion in the Echinococcus granulosus antigen B gene family.

Recent studies have demonstrated that the Echinococcus granulosus antigen B (AgB) interferes with the intermediate hosts' immune response and is encoded by a multigene family. The number of members within the family is still uncertain, but there are several evidences of a large genetic variability. The E. granulosus AgB genomic sequences available in nucleotide databases can be grouped into four clades, corresponding to genes EgAgB1, EgAgB2, EgAgB3 and EgAgB4. In the present study, we use PCR amplifications followed by cloning and sequencing to evaluate the genetic variability for AgB isoforms. Two pairs of primers were independently used for PCR amplification. Both PCR reactions from each of three isolated protoscolex (larvae) were cloned in a plasmid vector and the plasmid inserts of 30 colonies from each cloning experiment were sequenced. Using phylogenetic tools, the 113 EgAgB clones are classified as follows: 25 are related to EgAgB1, 24 to EgAgB2, 9 to EgAgB3 and 39 to EgAgB4. The remaining 16 clones form a separate cluster, which we name EgAgB5, more closely related to EgAgB3 than to any of the other genes. Within each gene group, a number of variant sequences occur, which differ from one another by one or few nucleotides. One EgAgB3 clone has a premature stop codon (pseudogene) and an EgAgB2 clone lacks the region corresponding to the intron. The overall variation cannot be explained by differences among the asexual protoscoleces, or by experimental artifacts. Using Echinococcuss AgB genes from other species/strains as outgroups, neutrality is rejected for EgAgB2, and balancing selection is detected for EgAgB5, which also seems to be involved in gene conversion. We suggest that EgAgB1-EgAgB5 represent a family of contingency genes, that is, genes that are variably expressed, so that some but not others are expressed in each individual parasite. Contingency genes are common in parasitic protozoa and other microparasites, but the EgAgB family is the first set identified in a multicellular parasite.

Livestock trade history, geography, and parasite strains: the mitochondrial genetic structure of Echinococcus granulosus in Argentina.

A sample of 114 isolates of Echinococcus granulosus (Cestoda: Taeniidae) collected from different host species and sites in Argentina has been sequenced for 391 bp from the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I gene to analyze genetic variability and population structure. Nine different haplotypes were identified, 5 of which correspond to already characterized strains. Analysis of molecular variance and nested clade analysis of the distribution of haplotypes among localities within 3 main geographic regions indicate that geographic differentiation accounts for the overall pattern of genetic variability in E. granulosus populations. Significant geographic differentiation is also present when the sheep strain alone is considered. Our results suggest that geographic patterns are not due to actual restricted gene flow between regions but are rather a consequence of past history, probably related to the time and origin of livestock introduction in Argentina.

Evidence for clonal propagation in natural isolates of Plasmodium falciparum from Venezuela.

We have analyzed 75 isolates of Plasmodium falciparum, collected in Venezuela during both the dry (November) and rainy (May-July) seasons, with a range of genetic markers including antigen genes and 14 random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) primers. Thirteen P. falciparum stocks from Kenya and four other Plasmodium species are included in the analysis for comparison. Cross-hybridization shows that the 14 RAPD primers reveal 14 separate regions of the parasite's genome. The P. falciparum isolates are a monophyletic clade, significantly different from the other Plasmodium species. We identify three RAPD characters that could be useful as "tags" for rapid species identification. The Venezuelan genotypes fall into two discrete genetic subdivisions associated with either the dry or the rainy season; the isolates collected in the rainy season exhibit greater genetic diversity. There is significant linkage disequilibrium in each seasonal subsample and in the full sample. In contrast, no linkage disequilibrium is detected in the African sample. These results support the hypothesis that the population structure of P. falciparum in Venezuela, but not in Africa, is predominantly clonal. However, the impact of genetic recombination on Venezuelan P. falciparum seems higher than in parasitic species with long-term clonal evolution like Trypanosoma cruzi, the agent of Chagas' disease. The genetic structure of the Venezuelan samples is similar to that of Escherichia coli, a bacterium that propagates clonally, with occasional genetic recombination.

Malaria's Eve: evidence of a recent population bottleneck throughout the world populations of Plasmodium falciparum.

We have analyzed DNA sequences from world-wide geographic strains of Plasmodium falciparum and found a complete absence of synonymous DNA polymorphism at 10 gene loci. We hypothesize that all extant world populations of the parasite have recently derived (within several thousand years) from a single ancestral strain. The upper limit of the 95% confidence interval for the time when this most recent common ancestor lived is between 24,500 and 57,500 years ago (depending on different estimates of the nucleotide substitution rate); the actual time is likely to be much more recent. The recent origin of the P. falciparum populations could have resulted from either a demographic sweep (P. falciparum has only recently spread throughout the world from a small geographically confined population) or a selective sweep (one strain favored by natural selection has recently replaced all others). The selective sweep hypothesis requires that populations of P. falciparum be effectively clonal, despite the obligate sexual stage of the parasite life cycle. A demographic sweep that started several thousand years ago is consistent with worldwide climatic changes ensuing the last glaciation, increased anthropophilia of the mosquito vectors, and the spread of agriculture. P. falciparum may have rapidly spread from its African tropical origins to the tropical and subtropical regions of the world only within the last 6,000 years. The recent origin of the world-wide P. falciparum populations may account for its virulence, as the most malignant of human malarial parasites.

Trypanosoma and Leishmania have clonal population structures of epidemiological significance.

This paper presents three results concerning the population structure of Trypanosoma cruzi, the agent of Chagas disease: (1) The mode of propagation of T. cruzi in nature is clonal; sexual reproduction is either totally absent or so rare that it leaves no traces in the population structure of the parasite. (2) The genetic diversity of the clonal lineages is large: extant T. cruzi represent lineages of descent that have evolved independently for long time spans (up to 40 million years). (3) Some genetically identical clonal lineages ("clonets") are geographically widespread ("ubiquitous"). However, most clonets are endemic, restricted in geographic distribution. These results have each in turn consequences of epidemiological significance: (1) In a sexually-reproducing organism the individual genotype is ephemeral; the entity that persists and evolves is the species ("gene pool"), and a few individuals contain most of the genetic variability of the species. In a clonally-propagating organism, the entity that persists and evolves is the clonal lineage; the genetic diversity of the species can only be captured by extensive sampling of distinct lineages. (2) The extensive genetic divergence among clonal lineages implies proportionally diverse biological characteristics, which are likely to include pathological effects, host propensity, vulnerability to drugs and vaccines, and other medically significant attributes. The extant T. cruzi lineages diverged much before human origins; hence, specific adaptation to human hosts, to whichever extent it exists, has evolved independently in separate lineages, and may not have evolved at all in some T. cruzi. (3) Epidemiological surveys and medical characterization, including search for specific vaccines and drugs, should not proceed randomly; rather, preliminary surveys must identify those clonets that are ubiquitous and target them for investigation. Review of published literature shows that Leishmania (and other parasitic protozoa) also has a clonal population structure. We advance a taxonomic and nomenclatural proposal that is appropriate for clonal organisms, yet simple.

Natural populations of Trypanosoma cruzi, the agent of Chagas disease, have a complex multiclonal structure.

We have studied 15 gene loci coding for enzymes in 121 Trypanosoma cruzi stocks from a wide geographic range--from the United States and Mexico to Chile and southern Brazil. T. cruzi is diploid but reproduction is basically clonal, with very little if any sexuality remaining at present. We have identified 43 different clones by their genetic composition; the same genetic clone is often found in very distant places and in diverse hosts. There is much genetic heterogeneity among the different clones, and they cannot be readily classified into a few discrete groups that might represent natural taxa. These findings imply that the biological and medical characteristics need to be ascertained separately for each natural clone. The evidence indicates that clonal evolution is very ancient in T. cruzi. We propose two alternative hypotheses concerning the relationship between the biochemical diversity and the heterogeneity in other biological and medical characteristics of T. cruzi. One hypothesis is that the degree of diversity between strains simply reflects the time elapsed since their last common ancestor. The second hypothesis is that biological and medical heterogeneity is recent and reflects adaptation to different transmission cycles. A decision between the two hypotheses can be reached with appropriate studies, with important medical consequences.

Additional data on Trypanosoma cruzi isozymic strains encountered in Bolivian domestic transmission cycles.

We have collected in Bolivia 212 stocks of Trypanosoma cruzi from domestic transmission cycles and have assayed for nine enzyme systems (11 gene loci). Only a few different isozyme profiles exist, without recombination between them, a situation also encountered in previous Bolivian samples. The 212 stocks, combined with 207 stocks previously studied, have been analysed to uncover any spatial patterns. The frequency of heterozygous strains (2 and 2a) decreases westwards and with increasing altitude. Given that longitude and altitude are correlated with each other, it is not possible to decide which of these two geographic variables is the relevant one, or if both are. These associations might be due to climatic factors. Studies by other authors have shown, however, that heterozygous strains are rare or absent in the Amazon Basin, which is at low altitude.

Genetic differentiation within and between species of the Drosophila willistoni group.

We describe allelic variation at 28 loci in six Caribbean populations of four sympatric species of Drosophila. Within any one species the allelic frequencies are very similar from population to population, although there is evidence of local as well as regional genetic differentiation. The genetic distance is greater between populations from different islands than between populations of the same island. When the allelic frequencies are compared between different species, a remarkable pattern appears. In any pair of species nearly half of the loci have essentially identical allelic frequencies, while nearly the other half of the loci have different alleles and in different frequencies. The loci with nearly identical allelic frequencies are different when different pairs of species are compared. The patterns of allelic variation within and between species are inconsistent with the hypothesis that the variation is adaptively neutral. Migration or mutation cannot explain the patterns of genetic variation, either. Balancing natural selection is the main process maintaining protein polymorphisms in natural populations.

Enzyme variability in the Drosophila willistoni group. IV. Genic variation in natural populations of Drosophila willistoni.

We describe allelic variation at 28 gene loci in natural populations of D. willistoni. Seventy samples were studied from localities extending from Mexico and Florida, through Central America, the West Indies, and tropical South America, down to South Brazil. At least several hundred, and often several thousand, genomes were sampled for each locus. We have discovered a great deal of genetic variation. On the average, 58% loci are polymorphic in a given population. (A locus is considered polymorphic when the frequency of the most common allele is no greater than 0.95). An individual fly is heterozygous, on the average, at 18.4% loci.-Concerning the pattern of the variation, the most remarkable finding is the similarity of the configuration of allelic frequencies from locality to locality throughout the distribution of the species. Our observations support the conclusion that balancing natural selection is the major factor responsible for the considerable genetic variation observed in D. willistoni.

Polymorphisms in continental and island populations of Drosophila willistoni.

A comparative study of genic allozyme and chromosomal polymorphisms in four continental (South American) and six oceanic island (West Indies) populations of Drosophila willistoni has been made. The pattern of genic polymorphism is closely similar in all populations. Although regional and local differences in gene frequencies are found, generally the same alleles occur at high, intermediate, and low frequencies in all populations. An average individual is heterozygous at 18.4 and 16.2% of its loci in the continental and island populations, respectively. By contrast, chromosomal polymorphism is sharply reduced on the islands compared to most continental populations, and some chromosomal inversions are more frequent on some islands than on others. The observations are not compatible with the hypothesis that most of the gene variants are adaptively neutral. Balancing natural selection is responsible for most of the genic polymorphism in natural populations of D. willistoni.