Minor Variants of Orf1a, p33, and p23 Genes of VT Strain Citrus Tristeza Virus Isolates Show Symptomless Reactions on Sour Orange and Prevent Superinfection of Severe VT Isolates.

The control of tristeza quick decline (QD) of citrus is based on the use of rootstocks that are tolerant or resistant to the Citrus tristeza virus (CTV), but some of them show bio-agronomic limits. The application of cross-protection (CP) has been insufficiently explored. The present study examined the possibility of QD control by cross-protection (CP) following reports showing the dependence of the CP strategy on the close genetic relationships between the protective and challenging CTV isolates. Taking advantage of deep sequencing technologies, we located six naturally infected trees harboring no-seedling yellow (no-SY) and no QD decline (mild) VT isolates and used these for challenge inoculation with three QD VT isolates. Symptom monitoring showed that all six Sicilian mild no-SY isolates, based on their genomic relatedness and mild symptoms reactions, provide effective protection against the three severe local VT isolates. The differences between the six mild and three severe isolates were confined to just a few nucleotide variations conserved in eight positions of three CTV genes (p23, p33, and Orf1a). These results confirm that the superinfection exclusion (SIE mechanism) depends on close genetic relatedness between the protective and challenging severe VT strain isolates. Ten years of investigation suggest that CP could turn into an efficient strategy to contain CTV QD infections of sweet orange trees on SO rootstock.

Walking Together: Cross-Protection, Genome Conservation, and the Replication Machinery of Citrus tristeza virus.

"Cross-protection", a nearly 100 years-old virological term, is suggested to be changed to "close protection". Evidence for the need of such change has accumulated over the past six decades from the laboratory experiments and field tests conducted by plant pathologists and plant virologists working with different plant viruses, and, in particular, from research on Citrus tristeza virus (CTV). A direct confirmation of such close protection came with the finding that "pre-immunization" of citrus plants with the variants of the T36 strain of CTV but not with variants of other virus strains was providing protection against a fluorescent protein-tagged T36-based recombinant virus variant. Under natural conditions close protection is functional and is closely associated both with the conservation of the CTV genome sequence and prevention of superinfection by closely similar isolates. It is suggested that the mechanism is primarily directed to prevent the danger of virus population collapse that could be expected to result through quasispecies divergence of large RNA genomes of the CTV variants continuously replicating within long-living and highly voluminous fruit trees. This review article provides an overview of the CTV cross-protection research, along with a discussion of the phenomenon in the context of the CTV biology and genetics.

ICTV Virus Taxonomy Profile: Closteroviridae.

Viruses in the family Closteroviridae have a mono-, bi- or tripartite positive-sense RNA genome of 13-19 kb, and non-enveloped, filamentous particles 650-2200 nm long and 12 nm in diameter. They infect plants, mainly dicots, many of which are fruit crops. This is a summary of the ICTV Report on the family Closteroviridae, which is available at ictv.global/report/closteroviridae.

A Short Note on Reflections and Publications on Citrus tristeza virus (CTV) Methodologies.

My PhD thesis work of Citrus tristeza virus (CTV) purification was aimed to develop a rapid serological assay to replace biological indexing. The task turned difficult and was achieved after a lengthy struggle, rewarded by allowing (1) the rapid diagnosis of the first incidences of natural spread of a severe CTV-VT strain in our region and (2) finding that the CTV particle isolation protocol, with some modifications, was also useful for Beet yellows virus (BYV) particles, leading to their assignment in the Closterovirus group, the first group of elongated plant viruses with different modal lengths. Later, following the introduction of ELISA for large-scale diagnosis of tristeza-infected citrus trees, the CTV infection rates through the coastal citrus production areas were continually increasing, with many ELISA-positive samples appearing symptomless, prompting the need to develop strain-specific assays. Using CTV-VT cDNA fragments, as hybridization probes, the genetic diversity among local CTV isolates was demonstrated. With the emergence of the PCR technology, we developed a CTV-dsRNA cloning method based on the ligation of known oligonucleotide molecules to dsRNA ends and the use of complementary oligonucleotides for cDNA synthesis and PCR amplification. The method allowed the cloning of a cDNA molecule complementary to a defective dsRNA of 2.4 kb with intact 5 and 3 ends of the CTV-VT genome. A list of publications, resulting from continuous collaborative work with local and foreign associates and students on the development and adaptation of novel CTV methodologies, is present.

Deep sequencing and analysis of small RNAs in sweet orange grafted on sour orange infected with two citrus tristeza virus isolates prevalent in Sicily.

Two representative isolates of a citrus tristeza virus population in Sicily, SG29 (aggressive) and Bau282 (mild), were sequenced via viral small RNAs (vsRNA) produced in budlings of sweet orange grafted on sour orange. Phylogenetic relationships with Mediterranean and exotic isolates revealed that SG29 clustered within the "VT-Asian" subtype, whereas Bau282 belonged to the cluster T30. The study confirms that molecular data need to be integrated with bio-indexing in order to obtain adequate information for risk assessment.

Citrus tristeza virus: making an ally from an enemy.

Virus diseases of perennial trees and vines have characteristics not amenable to study using small model annual plants. Unique disease symptoms such as graft incompatibilities and stem pitting cause considerable crop losses. Also, viruses in these long-living plants tend to accumulate complex populations of viruses and strains. Considerable progress has been made in understanding the biology and genetics of Citrus tristeza virus (CTV) and in developing it into a tool for crop protection and improvement. The diseases in tree and vine crops have commonalities for which CTV can be used to develop a baseline. The purpose of this review is to provide a necessary background of systems and reagents developed for CTV that can be used for continued progress in this area and to point out the value of the CTV-citrus system in answering important questions on plant-virus interactions and developing new methods for controlling plant diseases.

The defective RNAs of Closteroviridae.

The family Closteroviridae consists of two genera, Closterovirus and Ampelovirus with monopartite genomes transmitted respectively by aphids and mealybugs and the Crinivirus with bipartite genomes transmitted by whiteflies. The Closteroviridae consists of more than 30 virus species, which differ considerably in their phytopathological significance. Some, like beet yellows virus and citrus tristeza virus (CTV) were associated for many decades with their respective hosts, sugar beets and citrus. Others, like the grapevine leafroll-associated ampeloviruses 1, and 3 were also associated with their grapevine hosts for long periods; however, difficulties in virus isolation hampered their molecular characterization. The majority of the recently identified Closteroviridae were probably associated with their vegetative propagated host plants for long periods and only detected through the considerable advances in dsRNA isolation and sequencing of PCR amplified replicons. Molecular characterization of CTV and several other Closteroviridae revealed that, in addition to genomic and subgenomic RNAs, infected plants contain several different subviral defective RNAs (dRNAs). The roles and biological functions of dRNAs associated with Closteroviridae remain terra incognita.

Characterization of the 5'- and 3'-terminal subgenomic RNAs produced by a capillovirus: Evidence for a CP subgenomic RNA.

The members of Capillovirus genus encode two overlapping open reading frames (ORFs): ORF1 encodes a large polyprotein containing the replication-associated proteins plus a coat protein (CP), and ORF2 encodes a movement protein (MP), located within ORF1 in a different reading frame. Organization of the CP sequence as part of the replicase ORF is unusual in capilloviruses. In this study, we examined the capillovirus genome expression strategy by characterizing viral RNAs produced by Citrus tatter leaf virus (CTLV), isolate ML, a Capillovirus. CTLV-ML produced a genome-length RNA of approximately 6.5-kb and two 3'-terminal sgRNAs in infected tissue that contain the MP and CP coding sequences (3'-sgRNA1), and the CP coding sequence (3'-sgRNA2), respectively. Both 3'-sgRNAs initiate at a conserved octanucleotide (UUGAAAGA), and are 1826 (3'-sgRNA1) and 869 (3'-sgRNA2) nts with 119 and 15 nt leader sequences, respectively, suggesting that these two 3'-sgRNAs could serve to express the MP and CP. Additionally, accumulation of two 5'-terminal sgRNAs of 5586 (5'-sgRNA1) and 4625 (5'-sgRNA2) nts was observed, and their 3'-termini mapped to 38-44 nts upstream of the transcription start sites of 3'-sgRNAs. The presence of a separate 3'-sgRNA corresponding to the CP coding sequence and its cognate 5'-terminal sgRNA (5'-sgRNA1) suggests that CTLV-ML produces a dedicated sg mRNA for the expression of its CP.

Vegetative propagation and its possible role as a genetic bottleneck in the shaping of the apple fruit crinkle viroid populations in apple and hop plants.

Apple fruit crinkle viroid (AFCVd) infects apples and hops. To analyze the genetic diversity of AFCVd, nine apple and six hop isolates were collected from several locations in Japan. In total, 76 independent cDNA clones were used for sequencing and phylogenetic analyses. Two major population clusters were identified. The first consisted of all four hop isolates from Akita and some from Yamagata. The second cluster consisted of some Yamagata hop and all apple isolates. On the basis of the polymorphism found in the nucleotide insertion between positions 142/143 of the AFCVd genome and the history of hop cultivation in the region, it appears likely that one of the AFCVd populations that pre-existed in the Yamagata hops served as a "founder" for the Akita hop cluster. In this scenario, a genetic bottleneck caused by vegetative propagation played an important role in the shaping of viroid populations in a cultivated crop.

Three genes of Citrus tristeza virus are dispensable for infection and movement throughout some varieties of citrus trees.

Citrus tristeza virus (CTV), a member of the Closteroviridae, possesses a 19.3-kb positive-stranded RNA genome that is organized into twelve open reading frames (ORFs). The CTV genome contains two sets of conserved genes, which are characteristic of this virus group, the replication gene block (ORF 1a and 1b) and the quintuple gene block (p6, HSP70 h, p61, CPm, and CP). With the exception of the p6 gene, they are required for replication and virion assembly. CTV contains five additional genes, p33, p18, p13, p20 and p23, in the 3' half of the genome, some of which (p33, p18 and p13) are not conserved among other members of this virus group, and have been proposed to have evolved for specific interactions with the citrus host. In the present study, the requirements for systemic infection of citrus trees of p33, p6, p18, p13 and p20 were examined. Viral mutants with a deletion in the p6 or the p20 ORF failed to infect citrus plants systemically, suggesting their possible roles in virus translocation/systemic infection. However, we found that deletions within the p33, p18 or p13 ORF individually resulted in no significant loss of ability of the virus to infect, multiply, and spread throughout citrus trees. Furthermore, deletions in the p33, p18 and p13 genes in all possible combinations including deletions in all three genes allowed the virus to systemically invade citrus trees. Green fluorescent protein-tagged CTV variants with deletions in the p33 ORF or the p33, p18 and p13 ORFs demonstrated that the movement and distribution of these deletion mutants were similar to that of the wild-type virus.

A stable RNA virus-based vector for citrus trees.

Virus-based vectors are important tools in plant molecular biology and plant genomics. A number of vectors based on viruses that infect herbaceous plants are in use for expression or silencing of genes in plants as well as screening unknown sequences for function. Yet there is a need for useful virus-based vectors for woody plants, which demand much greater stability because of the longer time required for systemic infection and analysis. We examined several strategies to develop a Citrus tristeza virus (CTV)-based vector for transient expression of foreign genes in citrus trees using a green fluorescent protein (GFP) as a reporter. These strategies included substitution of the p13 open reading frame (ORF) by the ORF of GFP, construction of a self-processing fusion of GFP in-frame with the major coat protein (CP), or expression of the GFP ORF as an extra gene from a subgenomic (sg) mRNA controlled either by a duplicated CTV CP sgRNA controller element (CE) or an introduced heterologous CE of Beet yellows virus. Engineered vector constructs were examined for replication, encapsidation, GFP expression during multiple passages in protoplasts, and for their ability to infect, move, express GFP, and be maintained in citrus plants. The most successful vectors based on the 'add-a-gene' strategy have been unusually stable, continuing to produce GFP fluorescence after more than 4 years in citrus trees.

Construction of a multiprobe for the simultaneous detection of viroids infecting citrus trees.

Infections with different viroid species are common among cultivated fruit trees and grapevines, and many old-clone citrus varieties contain up to five citrus viroids (CVds) within a single tree. This paper describes the construction of a CVd-Multiprobe consisting of full-length clones of Hop stunt viroid, Citrus exocortis viroid, Citrus bent leaf viroid and CVd-III. The CVd-Multiprobe was tested against RNA transcripts of the four viroids and RNA extracts from plants singly infected with CEVd or HSVd or multiply infected with different CVds. The viroids were effectively diagnosed with the DIG labeled CVd-Multiprobe when tested by Northern hybridization or dot blot analyses. The CVd-Multiprobe does not provide information on the specific viroid resulting in a positive signal. However, this should not be considered as a problem, since most citrus certification programs will discard budwood source trees infected with any of the known CVds.

Transgenes consisting of a dsRNA of an RNAi suppressor plus the 3' UTR provide resistance to Citrus tristeza virus sequences in Nicotiana benthamiana but not in citrus.

In an attempt to utilize post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) as a means to impart resistance against Citrus tristeza virus (CTV) into citrus plants, the p23 + 3'UTR sequence (p23U) of the VT strain of CTV was engineered to fold into a double-stranded (ds) RNA structure. The resulting construct (p23UI) was introduced into Nicotiana benthamiana and Alemow (Citrus macrophylla) plants by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Transgenic p23UI- N. benthamiana were resistant to infection with a viral vector made of Grapevine virus A (GVA) + p23U (GVA-p23U), as indicated by the absence of the chimeric virus from inoculated plants. Inoculation of transgenic p23UI Alemow plants with CTV resulted in delayed appearance of symptoms in 9 out of the 70 transgenic plants. However, none of the plants showed durable resistance, as indicated by the obtaining of similar Northern hybridization signals from both transgenic and non-transgenic citrus plants. The possible causes for the failure of transgenic citrus plants to confer durable resistance to CTV are discussed.

Mediterranean fruit fly as a potential vector of bacterial pathogens.

The Mediterranean fruit fly (Ceratitis capitata) is a cosmopolitan pest of hundreds of species of commercial and wild fruits. It is considered a major economic pest of commercial fruits in the world. Adult Mediterranean fruit flies feed on all sorts of protein sources, including animal excreta, in order to develop eggs. After reaching sexual maturity and copulating, female flies lay eggs in fruit by puncturing the skin with their ovipositors and injecting batches of eggs into the wounds. In view of the increase in food-borne illnesses associated with consumption of fresh produce and unpasteurized fruit juices, we investigated the potential of Mediterranean fruit fly to serve as a vector for transmission of human pathogens to fruits. Addition of green fluorescent protein (GFP)-tagged Escherichia coli to a Mediterranean fruit fly feeding solution resulted in a dose-dependent increase in the fly's bacterial load. Flies exposed to fecal material enriched with GFP-tagged E. coli were similarly contaminated and were capable of transmitting E. coli to intact apples in a cage model system. Washing contaminated apples with tap water did not eliminate the E. coli. Flies inoculated with E. coli harbored the bacteria for up to 7 days following contamination. Fluorescence microscopy demonstrated that the majority of fluorescent bacteria were confined along the pseudotrachea in the labelum edge of the fly proboscis. Wild flies captured at various geographic locations were found to carry coliforms, and in some cases presumptive identification of E. coli was made. These findings support the hypothesis that the common Mediterranean fruit fly is a potential vector of human pathogens to fruits.

Identification and genomic characterization of a new virus (Tymoviridae family) associated with citrus sudden death disease.

Citrus sudden death (CSD) is a new disease that has killed approximately 1 million orange trees in Brazil. Here we report the identification of a new virus associated with the disease. RNAs isolated from CSD-affected and nonaffected trees were used to construct cDNA libraries. A set of viral sequences present exclusively in libraries of CSD-affected trees was used to obtain the complete genome sequence of the new virus. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that this virus is a new member of the genus Marafivirus. Antibodies raised against the putative viral coat proteins allowed detection of viral antigens of expected sizes in affected plants. Electron microscopy of purified virus confirmed the presence of typical isometric Marafivirus particles. The screening of 773 affected and nonaffected citrus trees for the presence of the virus showed a 99.7% correlation between disease symptoms and the presence of the virus. We also detected the virus in aphids feeding on affected trees. These results suggest that this virus is likely to be the causative agent of CSD. The virus was named Citrus sudden death-associated virus.

Two classes of subgenomic RNA of grapevine virus A produced by internal controller elements.

Grapevine virus A (GVA), a species of the recently established genus Vitivirus, consists of an approximately 7.3-kb single-stranded RNA genome of positive polarity, organized into five open reading frames (ORFs). The virus, which is closely associated with the grapevine rugose wood disease complex, has been poorly investigated genetically. We explored the production of viral RNAs in a GVA-infected Nicotiana benthamiana herbaceous host and characterized one nested set of three 5'-terminal sgRNAs of 5.1, 5.5, and 6.0 kb, and another, of three 3'-terminal sgRNAs of 2.2, 1.8, and 1.0 kb that could serve for expression of ORFs 2-3, respectively. Neither 3'- nor 5'-terminal sgRNAs, which would correspond to ORF5, was detected, suggesting that expression of this ORF occurs via a bi- or polycistronic mRNA. The 5'-terminal sgRNAs were abundant in dsRNA-enriched extracts. Cloning and sequence analysis of the 3' end of 5.5-kb 5'-terminal sgRNA and the 5' end of the 1.8-kb 3'-terminal sgRNA suggested that a mechanism other than specific cleavage was involved in production of these sgRNAs. Apparently, the production of the 5'- and 3'-terminal sgRNAs was controlled by sequences upstream of the 5'-terminus of each of ORFs 2-4. Detection of both plus and minus strands of the 5'- and 3'-terminal sgRNAs, though in different levels of accumulation, suggested that each of these cis-acting elements is involved in production of four RNAs: a 3'-terminal plus-strand sgRNA which could act as an mRNA, the corresponding 3'-terminal minus-strand RNA, a 5'-terminal plus-strand sgRNA, and the corresponding 5'-terminal minus-strand RNA.

Defective RNAs of Citrus tristeza virus analogous to Crinivirus genomic RNAs.

The family Closteroviridae includes the genera Closterovirus and Ampelovirus with monopartite genomes and the genus Crinivirus with bipartite genomes. Plants infected with the Closterovirus, Citrus tristeza virus (CTV), often contain one or more populations of defective RNAs (dRNAs). Although most dRNAs are comparatively small (2-5 kb) consisting of the genomic RNA termini with large internal deletions, we recently characterized large dRNAs of approximately 12 kb that retained the open reading frames (ORFs) 1a plus 1b. These were self-replicating RNAs and appeared to be analogous to the genomic RNA 1 of the bipartite criniviruses. The present report describes the finding of an additional group of large dRNAs (LdRNAs) that retained all or most of the 10 3' ORFs and appeared to be analogous to genomic RNA 2 of criniviruses. Isolates associated with LdRNAs were found associated with double-recombinant dRNAs (DR-dRNAs) of various sizes (1.7 to 5.1 kb) that comprised the two termini and a noncontiguous internal sequence from ORF2. The genetic and epidemiological implications of the architectural identities of LdRNAs and DR dRNAs and their apparent analogy with the genomic RNA 2 of criniviruses are discussed.

Transcription strategy in a Closterovirus: a novel 5'-proximal controller element of Citrus Tristeza Virus produces 5'- and 3'-terminal subgenomic RNAs and differs from 3' open reading frame controller elements.

Citrus tristeza virus (CTV) produces more than thirty 3'- or 5'-terminal subgenomic RNAs (sgRNAs) that accumulate to various extents during replication in protoplasts and plants. Among the most unusual species are two abundant populations of small 5'-terminal sgRNAs of approximately 800 nucleotides (nt) termed low-molecular-weight tristeza (LMT1 and LMT2) RNAs. Remarkably, CTV replicons with all 10 3' genes deleted produce only the larger LMT1 RNAs. These 5'-terminal positive-sense sgRNAs do not have corresponding negative strands and were hypothesized to be produced by premature termination during plus-strand genomic RNA synthesis. We characterized a cis-acting element that controls the production of the LMT1 RNAs. Since manipulation of this cis-acting element in its native position (the L-ProI region of replicase) was not possible because the mutations negatively affect replication, a region (5'TR) surrounding the putative termination sites (nt approximately 550 to 1000) was duplicated in the 3' end of a CTV replicon to allow characterization. The duplicated sequence continued to produce a 5'-terminal plus-strand sgRNA, here much larger ( approximately 11 kb), apparently by termination. Surprisingly, a new 3'-terminal sgRNA was observed from the duplicated 5'TR. A large 3'-terminal sgRNA resulting from the putative promoter activity of the native 5'TR was not observed, possibly because of the down-regulation of a promoter approximately 19 kb from the 3' terminus. However, we were able to observe a sgRNA produced from the native 5'TR of a small defective RNA, which placed the native 5'TR closer to the 3' terminus, demonstrating sgRNA promoter activity of the native 5'TR. Deletion mutagenesis mapped the promoter and the terminator activities of the 5'TR (in the 3' position in the CTV replicon) to a 57-nt region, which was folded by the MFOLD computer program into two stem-loops. Mutations in the putative stem-loop structures equally reduced or prevented production of both the 3'- and 5'-terminal sgRNAs. These mutations, when introduced in frame in the native 5'TR, similarly abolished the synthesis of the LMT1 RNAs and presumably the large 3'-terminal sgRNA while having no impact on replication, demonstrating that neither 5'- nor 3'-terminal sgRNA is necessary for replication of the replicon or full-length CTV in protoplasts. Differences between the 5'TR, which produced two plus-strand sgRNAs, and the cis-acting elements controlling the 3' open reading frames, which produced additional minus-strand sgRNAs corresponding to the 3'-terminal mRNAs, suggest that the different sgRNA controller elements had different origins in the modular evolution of closteroviruses.

A novel class of large and infectious defective RNAs of Citrus tristeza virus.

Citrus tristeza virus (CTV)-infected plants contain one or more populations of defective RNAs (dRNAs), mostly with a size range of ca. 2.0 to 5.0 kb. Several CTV dRNAs have been characterized and found to consist mainly of the two termini of the genomic RNA, with extensive internal deletions. The present paper describes a new class of large ( approximately 12.0 kb) dRNAs from three different CTV isolates with two unusual features. First is their composition with intact replicase genes. These dRNAs contained a large 5' portion of the genomic RNA terminus, which apparently corresponded to the recently described 5' large single-stranded subgenomic RNA (sgRNA) of ORF1a+1b (Che et al., 2001). The 3' portion of the large dRNAs varied among the 10 different cDNA clones examined in this work. In 2 dRNAs this portion consisted of truncated ORF10 (p20), and in 5 dRNAs it contained truncated ORF11 (p23). Two dRNA molecules were found with a 3' portion that started in the exact 5' position of the intergenic region between the p20 and p23 ORFs. In one dRNA, this portion coincided with the full-length sgRNA corresponding to ORF10. The second unusual feature was their ability to be readily transmitted mechanically to citrus plants by stem slashing and also to Nicotiana benthamiana protoplasts. The possibility that these dRNAs may be encapsidated and be capable of self-replication is discussed.