Biochemical Methods to Monitor Autophagic Responses in Plants.

The study of autophagy in plants is rapidly increasing, due to its pivotal and fundamental roles in responding to stressful stimuli, recycling nutrients during senescence, and maintaining growth under normal conditions. Assays for detecting autophagy in plants have generally been based on microscopic observations, providing qualitative information on autophagy activity. Here, we discuss biochemical assays for detecting autophagy, which have the potential for providing more quantitative information, with a focus on immunoblotting with antibodies against ATG8, NBR1, or epitope tags fused to ATG proteins.

Interactions between syntaxins identify at least five SNARE complexes within the Golgi/prevacuolar system of the Arabidopsis cell.

The syntaxin family of soluble N-ethyl maleimide sensitive factor adaptor protein receptors (SNAREs) is known to play an important role in the fusion of transport vesicles with specific organelles. Twenty-four syntaxins are encoded in the genome of the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana. These 24 genes are found in 10 gene families and have been reclassified as syntaxins of plants (SYPs). Some of these gene families have been previously characterized, with the SYP2-type syntaxins being found in the prevacuolar compartment (PVC) and the SYP4-type syntaxins on the trans-Golgi network (TGN). Here we report on two previously uncharacterized syntaxin groups. The SYP5 group is encoded by a two-member gene family, whereas SYP61 is a single gene. Both types of syntaxins are localized to multiple compartments of the endomembrane system, including the TGN and the PVC. These two groups of syntaxins form SNARE complexes with each other, and with other Arabidopsis SNAREs. On the TGN, SYP61 forms complexes with the SNARE VTI12 and either SYP41 or SYP42. SYP51 and SYP61 interact with each other and with VTI12, most likely also on the TGN. On the PVC, a SYP5-type syntaxin interacts specifically with a SYP2-type syntaxin, as well as the SNARE VTI11, forming a SNARE complex likely involved in TGN-to-PVC trafficking.

AtVPS45 complex formation at the trans-Golgi network.

The Sec1p family of proteins are thought to be involved in the regulation of vesicle fusion reactions through interaction with t-SNAREs (target soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptors) at the target membrane. AtVPS45 is a member of this family from Arabidopsis thaliana that we now demonstrate to be present on the trans-Golgi network (TGN), where it colocalizes with the vacuolar cargo receptor AtELP. Unlike yeast Vps45p, AtVPS45 does not interact with, or colocalize with, the prevacuolar t-SNARE AtPEP12. Instead, AtVPS45 interacts with two t-SNAREs, AtTLG2a and AtTLG2b, that show similarity to the yeast t-SNARE Tlg2p. AtTLG2a and -b each colocalize with AtVPS45 at the TGN; however, AtTLG2a is in a different region of the TGN than AtTLG2b by immunogold electron microscopy. Therefore, we propose that complexes containing AtVPS45 and either AtTLG2a or -b define functional subdomains of the TGN and may be required for different trafficking events. Among other Arabidopsis SNAREs, AtVPS45 antibodies preferentially coprecipitate AtVTI1b over the closely related isoform AtVTI1a, implying that AtVTI1a and AtVTI1b also have distinct functions within the cell. These data point to a functional complexity within the plant secretory pathway, where proteins encoded by gene families have specialized functions, rather than functional redundancy.

Unique features of the plant vacuolar sorting machinery.

Multiple types of vacuoles can exist within the same plant cell, and different vesicle-trafficking pathways transport proteins to each of them. Recent work has identified proteins unique to each vacuole type, and the transport pathways have begun to be elucidated. Plant trafficking proteins are usually encoded by small gene families, the different members of which have distinct functions in the endomembrane system.

The pre-vacuolar t-SNARE AtPEP12p forms a 20S complex that dissociates in the presence of ATP.

Many proteins are transported to the plant vacuole through the secretory pathway in small transport vesicles by a series of vesicle budding and fusion reactions. Vesicles carrying vacuolar cargo bud from the trans-Golgi network are thought to fuse with a pre-vacuolar compartment before being finally transported to the vacuole. In mammals and yeast, the fusion of a vesicle with its target organelle is mediated by a 20S protein complex containing membrane and soluble proteins that appear to be conserved between different species. A number of membrane proteins have been identified in plants that show sequence similarity with a family of integral membrane proteins (t-SNAREs) on target organelles that are required for the fusion of transport vesicles with that organelle. However, the biochemical function of these proteins has remained elusive. Here, we demonstrate for the first time the formation of a 20S complex in plants that has characteristics of complexes involved in vesicle fusion. This complex contains AtPEP12p, an Arabidopsis protein thought to be involved in protein transport to the prevacuolar compartment. In addition, we have shown that AtPEP12p can bind to alpha-SNAP, indicating that AtPEP12p does indeed function as a SNAP receptor or SNARE. These preliminary data suggest that AtPEP12p may function jointly with alpha-SNAP and NSF in the fusion of transport vesicles containing vacuolar cargo proteins with the pre-vacuolar compartment.

An Arabidopsis VPS45p homolog implicated in protein transport to the vacuole.

The Sec1p family of proteins is required for vesicle-mediated protein trafficking between various organelles of the endomembrane system. This family includes Vps45p, which is required for transport to the vacuole in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae). We have isolated a cDNA encoding a VPS45 homolog from Arabidopsis thaliana (AtVPS45). The cDNA is able to complement both the temperature-sensitive growth defect and the vacuolar-targeting defect of a yeast vps45 mutant, indicating that the two proteins are functionally related. AtVPS45p is a peripheral membrane protein that associates with microsomal membranes. Sucrose-density gradient fractionation demonstrated that AtVPS45p co-fractionates with AtELP, a potential vacuolar protein sorting receptor, implying that they may reside on the same membrane populations. These results indicate that AtVPS45p is likely to function in the transport of proteins to the vacuole in plants.

The syntaxin homolog AtPEP12p resides on a late post-Golgi compartment in plants.

Soluble proteins are transported to the plant vacuole through the secretory pathway via membrane-bound vesicles. Targeting of vesicles to appropriate organelles requires several membrane-bound and soluble factors that have been characterized in yeast and mammalian systems. For example, the yeast PEP12 protein is a syntaxin homolog that is involved in protein transport to the yeast vacuole. Previously, we isolated an Arabidopsis thaliana homolog of PEP12 by functional complementation of the yeast pep12 mutant. Antibodies raised against the cytoplasmic portion of AtPEP12 have been prepared and used for intracellular localization of this protein. Biochemical analysis indicates that AtPEP12 does not localize to the endoplasmic reticulum, Golgi apparatus, plasma membrane, or tonoplast in Arabidopsis plants; furthermore, based on biochemical and electron microscopy immunogold labeling analyses, AtPEP12 is likely to be localized to a post-Golgi compartment in the vacuolar pathway.

Transport of proteins in eukaryotic cells: more questions ahead.

Some newly synthesized proteins contain signals that direct their transport to their final location within or outside of the cell. Targeting signals are recognized by specific protein receptors located either in the cytoplasm or in the membrane of the target organelle. Specific membrane protein complexes are involved in insertion and translocation of polypeptides across the membranes. Often, additional targeting signals are required for a polypeptide to be further transported to its site of function. In this review, we will describe the trafficking of proteins to various cellular organelles (nucleus, chloroplasts, mitochondria, peroxisomes) with emphasis on transport to and through the secretory pathway.

A putative Mg chelatase subunit from Arabidopsis thaliana cv C24. Sequence and transcript analysis of the gene, import of the protein into chloroplasts, and in situ localization of the transcript and protein.

We have isolated and sequenced a cDNA from Arabidopsis thaliana cv C24 that encodes a putative Mg chelatase subunit. The deduced amino acid sequence shows a very high level of identity to a gene previously characterized from Antirrhinum majus (olive and also high similarity to bchH, a bacterial gene involved in the Mg chelatase reaction of bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis. We suggest that this gene be called CHL H. Northern blot analyses were used to investigate the expression of CHL H, another putative Mg chelatase gene, ch-42, and ferrochelatase. The CHL H transcript was observed to undergo a dramatic diurnal variation, rising almost to its maximum level by the end of the dark period, then increasing slightly at the onset of the light and declining steadily to a minimum by the end of the light period; in contrast, transcripts for ch-42 and ferrochelatase remained constant. A model is proposed in which the CHL H protein plays a role in regulating the levels of chlorophyll during this cycle. In situ hybridization revealed that the transcripts are located over the surface of the chloroplasts, a feature in common with transcripts for the ch-42 gene. The CHL H protein was imported into the stromal compartment of the chloroplast and processed in an in vitro assay. Immunoblotting showed that the distribution of CHL H protein between the stroma and chloroplast membranes varies depending on the concentration of Mg+. In situ immunofluorescence was used to establish that the CHL H and CH-42 proteins are localized within the chloroplast in vivo.

Different sensitivity to wortmannin of two vacuolar sorting signals indicates the presence of distinct sorting machineries in tobacco cells.

Vacuolar matrix proteins in plant cells are sorted from the secretory pathway to the vacuoles at the Golgi apparatus. Previously, we reported that the NH2-terminal propeptide (NTPP) of the sporamin precursor and the COOH-terminal propeptide (CTPP) of the barley lectin precursor contain information for vacuolar sorting. To analyze whether these propeptides are interchangeable, we expressed constructs consisting of wild-type or mutated NTPP with the mature part of barley lectin and sporamin with CTPP and mutated NTPP in tobacco BY-2 cells. The vacuolar localization of these constructs indicated that the signals were interchangeable. We next analyzed the effect of wortmannin, a specific inhibitor of mammalian phosphatidylinositol (PI) 3-kinase on vacuolar delivery by NTPP and CTPP in tobacco cells. Pulse-chase analysis indicated that 33 microM wortmannin caused almost complete inhibition of CTPP-mediated transport to the vacuoles, while NTPP-mediated transport displayed almost no sensitivity to wortmannin at this concentration. This indicates that there are at least two different mechanisms for vacuolar sorting in tobacco cells, and the CTPP-mediated pathway is sensitive to wortmannin. We compared the dose dependencies of wortmannin on the inhibition of CTPP-mediated vacuolar delivery of proteins and on the inhibition of the synthesis of phospholipids in tobacco cells. Wortmannin inhibited PI 3- and PI 4-kinase activities and phospholipid synthesis. Missorting caused by wortmannin displays a dose dependency that is similar to the dose dependency for the inhibition of synthesis of PI 4-phosphate and major phospholipids. This is different, however, than the inhibition of synthesis of PI 3-phosphate. Thus, the synthesis of phospholipids could be involved in CTPP-mediated vacuolar transport.

An Arabidopsis syntaxin homologue isolated by functional complementation of a yeast pep12 mutant.

The syntaxin family of integral membrane proteins are thought to function as receptors for transport vesicles, with different isoforms of this family localized to various membranes throughout the cell. The yeast Pep12 protein is a syntaxin homologue which may function in the trafficking of vesicles from the trans-Golgi network to the vacuole. We have isolated an Arabidopsis thaliana cDNA by functional complementation of a yeast pep12 mutant. The Arabidopsis cDNA (aPEP12) potentially encodes a 31-kDa protein which is homologous to yeast Pep12 and to other members of the syntaxin family, indicating that this protein may function in the docking or fusion of transport vesicles with the vacuolar membrane in plant cells. Northern blot analysis indicates that the mRNA is expressed in all tissues examined, although at a very low level in leaves. The mRNA is found in all cell types in roots and leaves, as shown by in situ hybridization experiments. The existence of plant homologues of proteins of the syntaxin family indicates that the basic vesicle docking and fusion machinery may be conserved in plants as it is in yeast and mammals.

Mutations at the stromal processing peptidase cleavage site of a thylakoid lumen protein precursor affect the rate of processing but not the fidelity.

Nuclear-encoded stromal proteins are imported into the chloroplast by means of presequences, or transit peptides, which are removed after import by a stromal processing peptidase (SPP); the presequences of thylakoid lumen proteins are processed by SPP at intermediate sites prior to transport of these proteins across the thylakoid membrane. SPP has been previously shown to be a highly specific enzyme, but the basis for the reaction specificity is unclear, because the cleavage sites of different substrates display virtually no primary structure similarity. We have examined the influence of the cleavage site residues on the SPP reaction mechanism by introducing mutations at these positions (denoted -1 and +1, relative to the SPP cleavage site) within the presequence of the lumenal 33-kDa photosystem II protein. Substitution of the -1 Arg by Ala or Met leads to a 5-7-fold reduction in the rate of processing, whereas substitution by Glu almost completely blocks cleavage. The replacement of the +1 Ala by Lys likewise almost completely blocks cleavage. None of the introduced -1 mutations affect cleavage fidelity; we show that all three mutants are cleaved only at the correct site. All of the mutant precursors are efficiently imported into the thylakoid lumen of intact chloroplasts, indicating that this cleavage event is not an important element of the overall import pathway. The results indicate that the identity of the -1 residue, within the context of a given presequence, is important in terms of influencing processing efficiency, but that the site of cleavage is specified by other determinants. At least a proportion of the other determinants are likely to be in close proximity to the cleavage site, since the deletion of a 7-residue section spanning this site completely blocks processing.

Efficient but aberrant cleavage of mitochondrial precursor proteins by the chloroplast stromal processing peptidase.

Cytosol-synthesized chloroplast and mitochondrial precursor proteins are proteolytically processed after import by highly specific, metal-dependent soluble enzymes: the stromal processing peptidase (SPP) and the matrix processing peptidase (MPP), respectively. We have used in vitro processing assays to compare the reaction specificities of highly purified preparations of pea SPP and Neurospora crassa MPP, both of which are unable to cleave a variety of 'foreign' proteins. We show that SPP can cleave all five mitochondrial precursor proteins tested, namely cyclophilin, the beta subunit of the F1-ATPase complex, the Rieske FeS protein, the alpha-MPP subunit and cytochrome b2. In contrast, MPP is unable to cleave any chloroplast precursor proteins tested. Several of the mitochondrial precursor proteins are cleaved more efficiently by SPP than are many authentic chloroplast precursor proteins but, in each case, cleavage takes place at a site or sites which are N-terminal to the authentic MPP site; pre-cyclophilin is cleaved 5 residues upstream of the MPP site and the precursor of the beta subunit of the F1-ATPase complex is cleaved at sites 5 and 12 residues upstream. We discuss the implications of these data for the SPP reaction mechanism.

The stromal processing peptidase activities from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and Pisum sativum: unexpected similarities in reaction specificity.

We have partially purified the stromal processing peptidase from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and compared the properties of this activity with those of the pea counterpart. Whereas previous studies have suggested that the two enzymes may have significantly different reaction specificities, we find that they are in fact very similar. Both enzymes process precursors of two higher-plant thylakoid lumen proteins, and one C. reinhardtii lumenal protein, to similar intermediate-size forms. However, whereas the algal enzyme processes the precursor of C. reinhardtii Rubisco small subunit to the correct mature size, this precursor is cleaved only to an intermediate size by the pea enzyme. The small subunit precursor from pea appears to be cleaved by both enzymes in a similar manner. In terms of sensitivity to inhibitors, the two activities are notably different; the pea enzyme has previously been shown to be inhibited by several types of heavy-metal chelator, but we have found that none of these compounds affect the algal activity.

Transport of proteins into chloroplasts. Delineation of envelope "transit" and thylakoid "transfer" signals within the pre-sequences of three imported thylakoid lumen proteins.

The targeting of cytosolically synthesized proteins into the thylakoid lumen is mediated by an aminoterminal pre-sequence consisting of an "envelope transit" and a "thylakoid transfer" signal in tandem. We have investigated the structural characteristics of several thylakoid transfer signals by determining the intermediate sites at which the stromal processing peptidase cleaves to remove the transit sequences. Using this approach we have found that the thylakoid transfer signals of Silene pratensis plastocyanin, 23-kDa oxygen-evolving complex protein from wheat, and 33-kDa oxygen-evolving complex protein from wheat, are 25, 39, and 48 residues in length, respectively. All of the transfer signals contain hydrophobic core sequences and a "-3,-1" motif reminiscent of those found in signal sequences, but the amino-terminal regions of the transfer signals of the 23- and 33-kDa proteins are both longer and more highly charged. The net charge of each amino-terminal region of the transfer sequences is +1, including the amino-terminal amino group. In each case, the stromal processing peptidase cleaves immediately after a positively charged residue, but otherwise the cleavage sites exhibit no common elements of either primary or secondary structure.