Electronic health record signatures identify undiagnosed patients with common variable immunodeficiency disease.

Human inborn errors of immunity include rare disorders entailing functional and quantitative antibody deficiencies due to impaired B cells called the common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) phenotype. Patients with CVID face delayed diagnoses and treatments for 5 to 15 years after symptom onset because the disorders are rare (prevalence of ~1/25,000), and there is extensive heterogeneity in CVID phenotypes, ranging from infections to autoimmunity to inflammatory conditions, overlapping with other more common disorders. The prolonged diagnostic odyssey drives excessive system-wide costs before diagnosis. Because there is no single causal mechanism, there are no genetic tests to definitively diagnose CVID. Here, we present PheNet, a machine learning algorithm that identifies patients with CVID from their electronic health records (EHRs). PheNet learns phenotypic patterns from verified CVID cases and uses this knowledge to rank patients by likelihood of having CVID. PheNet could have diagnosed more than half of our patients with CVID 1 or more years earlier than they had been diagnosed. When applied to a large EHR dataset, followed by blinded chart review of the top 100 patients ranked by PheNet, we found that 74% were highly probable to have CVID. We externally validated PheNet using >6 million records from disparate medical systems in California and Tennessee. As artificial intelligence and machine learning make their way into health care, we show that algorithms such as PheNet can offer clinical benefits by expediting the diagnosis of rare diseases.

Voriconazole Metabolism is Associated with the Number of Skin Cancers Per Patient.

Voriconazole exposure is associated with skin cancer, but it is unknown how the full spectrum of its metabolizer phenotypes impacts this association. We conducted a retrospective cohort study to determine how variation in metabolism of voriconazole as measured by metabolizer status of CYP2C19 is associated with the total number of skin cancers a patient develops and the rate of development of the first skin cancer after treatment. There were 1,739 organ transplant recipients with data on CYP2C19 phenotype. Of these, 134 were exposed to voriconazole. There was a significant difference in the number of skin cancers after transplant based on exposure to voriconazole, metabolizer phenotype, and the interaction of these two (p < 0.01 for all three). This increase was driven primarily by number of squamous cell carcinomas among rapid metabolizes with voriconazole exposure (p < 0.01 for both). Patients exposed to voriconazole developed skin cancers more rapidly than those without exposure (Fine-Grey hazard ratio 1.78, 95% confidence interval 1.19-2.66). This association was similarly driven by development of SCC (Fine-Grey hazard ratio 1.83, 95% confidence interval 1.14-2.94). Differences in voriconazoles metabolism are associated with an increase in the number of skin cancers developed after transplant, particularly SCC.

Overcome the Limitation of Phenome-Wide Association Studies (PheWAS): Extension of PheWAS to Efficient and Robust Large-Scale ICD Codes Analysis.

The Phenome-wide association studies (PheWAS) have become widely used for efficient, high-throughput evaluation of relationship between a genetic factor and a large number of disease phenotypes, typically extracted from a DNA biobank linked with electronic medical records (EMR). Phecodes, billing code-derived disease case-control status, are usually used as outcome variables in PheWAS and logistic regression has been the standard choice of analysis method. Since the clinical diagnoses in EMR are often inaccurate with errors which can lead to biases in the odds ratio estimates, much effort has been put to accurately define the cases and controls to ensure an accurate analysis. Specifically in order to correctly classify controls in the population, an exclusion criteria list for each Phecode was manually compiled to obtain unbiased odds ratios. However, the accuracy of the list cannot be guaranteed without extensive data curation process. The costly curation process limits the efficiency of large-scale analyses that take full advantage of all structured phenotypic information available in EMR. Here, we proposed to estimate relative risks (RR) instead. We first demonstrated the desired nature of RR that overcomes the inaccuracy in the controls via theoretical formula. With simulation and real data application, we further confirmed that RR is unbiased without compiling exclusion criteria lists. With RR as estimates, we are able to efficiently extend PheWAS to a larger-scale, phenome construction agnostic analysis of phenotypes, using ICD 9/10 codes, which preserve much more disease-related clinical information than Phecodes.

Identifying and Extracting Rare Diseases and Their Phenotypes with Large Language Models.

Purpose: Phenotyping is critical for informing rare disease diagnosis and treatment, but disease phenotypes are often embedded in unstructured text. While natural language processing (NLP) can automate extraction, a major bottleneck is developing annotated corpora. Recently, prompt learning with large language models (LLMs) has been shown to lead to generalizable results without any (zero-shot) or few annotated samples (few-shot), but none have explored this for rare diseases. Our work is the first to study prompt learning for identifying and extracting rare disease phenotypes in the zero- and few-shot settings. Methods: We compared the performance of prompt learning with ChatGPT and fine-tuning with BioClinicalBERT. We engineered novel prompts for ChatGPT to identify and extract rare diseases and their phenotypes (e.g., diseases, symptoms, and signs), established a benchmark for evaluating its performance, and conducted an in-depth error analysis. Results: Overall, fine-tuning BioClinicalBERT resulted in higher performance (F1 of 0.689) than ChatGPT (F1 of 0.472 and 0.610 in the zero- and few-shot settings, respectively). However, ChatGPT achieved higher accuracy for rare diseases and signs in the one-shot setting (F1 of 0.778 and 0.725). Conversational, sentence-based prompts generally achieved higher accuracy than structured lists. Conclusion: Prompt learning using ChatGPT has the potential to match or outperform fine-tuning BioClinicalBERT at extracting rare diseases and signs with just one annotated sample. Given its accessibility, ChatGPT could be leveraged to extract these entities without relying on a large, annotated corpus. While LLMs can support rare disease phenotyping, researchers should critically evaluate model outputs to ensure phenotyping accuracy.

Clinical associations with a polygenic predisposition to benign lower white blood cell counts.

Polygenic variation unrelated to disease contributes to interindividual variation in baseline white blood cell (WBC) counts, but its clinical significance is uncharacterized. We investigated the clinical consequences of a genetic predisposition toward lower WBC counts among 89,559 biobank participants from tertiary care centers using a polygenic score for WBC count (PGSWBC) comprising single nucleotide polymorphisms not associated with disease. A predisposition to lower WBC counts was associated with a decreased risk of identifying pathology on a bone marrow biopsy performed for a low WBC count (odds-ratio = 0.55 per standard deviation increase in PGSWBC [95%CI, 0.30-0.94], p = 0.04), an increased risk of leukopenia (a low WBC count) when treated with a chemotherapeutic (n = 1724, hazard ratio [HR] = 0.78 [0.69-0.88], p = 4.0 × 10-5) or immunosuppressant (n = 354, HR = 0.61 [0.38-0.99], p = 0.04). A predisposition to benign lower WBC counts was associated with an increased risk of discontinuing azathioprine treatment (n = 1,466, HR = 0.62 [0.44-0.87], p = 0.006). Collectively, these findings suggest that there are genetically predisposed individuals who are susceptible to escalations or alterations in clinical care that may be harmful or of little benefit.

Undiagnosed Disease Network collaborative approach in diagnosing rare disease in a patient with a mosaic CACNA1D variant.

The Undiagnosed Disease Network (UDN) is comprised of clinical and research experts collaborating to diagnose rare disease. The UDN is funded by the National Institutes of Health and includes 12 different clinical sites (About Us, 2022). Here we highlight the success of collaborative efforts within the UDN Clinical Site at Vanderbilt University Medical Center (VUMC) in utilizing a cohort of experts in bioinformatics, structural biology, and genetics specialists in diagnosing rare disease. Our UDN team identified a de novo mosaic CACNA1D variant c.2299T>C in a 5-year-old female with a history of global developmental delay, dystonia, dyskinesis, and seizures. Using a collaborative multidisciplinary approach, our VUMC UDN team diagnosed the participant with Primary Aldosteronism, Seizures, and Neurologic abnormalities (PASNA) OMIM: 615474 due to a rare mosaic CACNA1D variant (O'Neill, 2013). Interestingly, this patient was mosaic, a phenotypic trait previously unreported in PASNA cases. This report highlights the importance of a multidisciplinary approach in diagnosing rare disease.

Comparison of phenomic profiles in the All of Us Research Program against the US general population and the UK Biobank.

IMPORTANCE: Knowledge gained from cohort studies has dramatically advanced both public and precision health. The All of Us Research Program seeks to enroll 1 million diverse participants who share multiple sources of data, providing unique opportunities for research. It is important to understand the phenomic profiles of its participants to conduct research in this cohort. OBJECTIVES: More than 280 000 participants have shared their electronic health records (EHRs) in the All of Us Research Program. We aim to understand the phenomic profiles of this cohort through comparisons with those in the US general population and a well-established nation-wide cohort, UK Biobank, and to test whether association results of selected commonly studied diseases in the All of Us cohort were comparable to those in UK Biobank. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We included participants with EHRs in All of Us and participants with health records from UK Biobank. The estimates of prevalence of diseases in the US general population were obtained from the Global Burden of Diseases (GBD) study. We conducted phenome-wide association studies (PheWAS) of 9 commonly studied diseases in both cohorts. RESULTS: This study included 287 012 participants from the All of Us EHR cohort and 502 477 participants from the UK Biobank. A total of 314 diseases curated by the GBD were evaluated in All of Us, 80.9% (N = 254) of which were more common in All of Us than in the US general population [prevalence ratio (PR) >1.1, P < 2 × 10-5]. Among 2515 diseases and phenotypes evaluated in both All of Us and UK Biobank, 85.6% (N = 2152) were more common in All of Us (PR >1.1, P < 2 × 10-5). The Pearson correlation coefficients of effect sizes from PheWAS between All of Us and UK Biobank were 0.61, 0.50, 0.60, 0.57, 0.40, 0.53, 0.46, 0.47, and 0.24 for ischemic heart diseases, lung cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, dementia, colorectal cancer, lower back pain, multiple sclerosis, lupus, and cystic fibrosis, respectively. DISCUSSION: Despite the differences in prevalence of diseases in All of Us compared to the US general population or the UK Biobank, our study supports that All of Us can facilitate rapid investigation of a broad range of diseases. CONCLUSION: Most diseases were more common in All of Us than in the general US population or the UK Biobank. Results of disease-disease association tests from All of Us are comparable to those estimated in another well-studied national cohort.

Data from electronic healthcare records expand our understanding of X-linked genetic diseases.

Disease specific cohort studies have reported details on X linked (XL) disorders affecting females. We investigated the spectrum and penetrance of XL disorders seen in electronic health records (EHR). We generated a cohort of individuals diagnosed with XL disorders at Vanderbilt University Medical Center over 20 years. Our cohort included 477 males and 203 females diagnosed with 108 different XL genetic disorders. We found large differences between the female/male (F/M) ratios for various XL disorders regardless of their OMIM annotated mode of inheritance. We identified four XL recessive disorders affecting women previously only described in men. Biomarkers for XL disease had unique gender-specific patterns differing between modes of inheritance. EHRs provide large cohorts of XL genetic disorders that give new insights compared to the literature. Differences in the F/M ratios and biomarkers of XL disorders observed likely result from disease specific and sex dependent penetrance. We conclude that observed gender ratios associated with specific XL disorders may be more useful than those predicted by Mendelian genetics provided by OMIM. Our findings of a gender specific penetrance and severity for XL disorders show unexpected differences from Mendelian predictions. Further work is required to validate our findings in larger combined EHR cohorts.

Diagnostic delay in monogenic disease: A scoping review.

PURPOSE: Diagnostic delay in monogenic disease is reportedly common. We conducted a scoping review investigating variability in study design, results, and conclusions. METHODS: We searched the academic literature on January 17, 2023, for original peer reviewed journals and conference articles that quantified diagnostic delay in monogenic disease. We abstracted the reported diagnostic delay, relevant study design features, and definitions. RESULTS: Our search identified 259 articles quantifying diagnostic delay in 111 distinct monogenetic diseases. Median reported diagnostic delay for all studies collectively in monogenetic diseases was 5.0 years (IQR 2-10). There was major variation in the reported delay within individual monogenetic diseases. Shorter delay was associated with disorders of childhood metabolism, immunity, and development. The majority (67.6%) of articles that studied delay reported an improvement with calendar time. Study design and definitions of delay were highly heterogenous. Three gaps were identified: (1) no studies were conducted in the least developed countries, (2) delay has not been studied for the majority of known, or (3) most prevalent genetic diseases. CONCLUSION: Heterogenous study design and definitions of diagnostic delay inhibit comparison across studies. Future efforts should focus on standardizing delay measurements, while expanding the research to low-income countries.

The Use of Electronic Health Records for Behavioral Phenotyping of School-Age Children With Unilateral Hearing Loss: A Methodological Approach.

PURPOSE: This methodological study describes a technique for extracting information from de-identified electronic health records (EHRs) to identify occurrences of permanent unilateral hearing loss (UHL) and associated educational comorbidities. METHOD: This was an exploratory methodological study utilizing approximately 3.3 million de-identified medical records. Structured and unstructured data were extracted using both automated and manual methods. When both methods were available, positive and negative predictive values were calculated to evaluate the utility of using automated methods. RESULTS: We defined a cohort of 471 records that met our criteria of school-age children with permanent UHL and no additional significant disabilities/diagnoses. Fifty-one percent of the children reflected in this cohort had indicators of adverse educational progress, defined as documentation of receiving educational services, speech-language therapy, and/or parental/teacher concern, with 12% of records reflecting overlapping services/concerns. Negative predictive values were generally high and positive predictive values were generally low, suggesting automated searches are useful for excluding factors of interest, but not finding them. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates the feasibility of using EHRs in examining UHL in school-age children. By restricting our cohort to individuals who were seen in audiology clinic, we were able to capture variables such as educational difficulty that are not routinely ascertained in medical contexts. The proportion of children in this cohort demonstrating a marker of adverse educational progress is consistent with numerous prior observational studies, thus providing validity to this ascertainment approach. We describe challenges encountered in creating this cohort and detail our hybrid approach to ascertaining key variables accurately.

Next-generation phenotyping: introducing phecodeX for enhanced discovery research in medical phenomics.

MOTIVATION: Phecodes are widely used and easily adapted phenotypes based on International Classification of Diseases codes. The current version of phecodes (v1.2) was designed primarily to study common/complex diseases diagnosed in adults; however, there are numerous limitations in the codes and their structure. RESULTS: Here, we present phecodeX, an expanded version of phecodes with a revised structure and 1,761 new codes. PhecodeX adds granularity to phenotypes in key disease domains that are under-represented in the current phecode structure-including infectious disease, pregnancy, congenital anomalies, and neonatology-and is a more robust representation of the medical phenome for global use in discovery research. AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION: phecodeX is available at https://github.com/PheWAS/phecodeX.

Systematic replication of smoking disease associations using survey responses and EHR data in the All of Us Research Program.

OBJECTIVE: The All of Us Research Program (All of Us) aims to recruit over a million participants to further precision medicine. Essential to the verification of biobanks is a replication of known associations to establish validity. Here, we evaluated how well All of Us data replicated known cigarette smoking associations. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We defined smoking exposure as follows: (1) an EHR Smoking exposure that used International Classification of Disease codes; (2) participant provided information (PPI) Ever Smoking; and, (3) PPI Current Smoking, both from the lifestyle survey. We performed a phenome-wide association study (PheWAS) for each smoking exposure measurement type. For each, we compared the effect sizes derived from the PheWAS to published meta-analyses that studied cigarette smoking from PubMed. We defined two levels of replication of meta-analyses: (1) nominally replicated: which required agreement of direction of effect size, and (2) fully replicated: which required overlap of confidence intervals. RESULTS: PheWASes with EHR Smoking, PPI Ever Smoking, and PPI Current Smoking revealed 736, 492, and 639 phenome-wide significant associations, respectively. We identified 165 meta-analyses representing 99 distinct phenotypes that could be matched to EHR phenotypes. At P < .05, 74 were nominally replicated and 55 were fully replicated. At P < 2.68 × 10-5 (Bonferroni threshold), 58 were nominally replicated and 40 were fully replicated. DISCUSSION: Most phenotypes found in published meta-analyses associated with smoking were nominally replicated in All of Us. Both survey and EHR definitions for smoking produced similar results. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrated the feasibility of studying common exposures using All of Us data.

Clinical consequences of a polygenic predisposition to benign lower white blood cell counts: Consequences of benign WBC count genetics.

Polygenic variation unrelated to disease contributes to interindividual variation in baseline white blood cell (WBC) counts, but its clinical significance is undefined. We investigated the clinical consequences of a genetic predisposition toward lower WBC counts among 89,559 biobank participants from tertiary care centers using a polygenic score for WBC count (PGSWBC) comprising single nucleotide polymorphisms not associated with disease. A predisposition to lower WBC counts was associated with a decreased risk of identifying pathology on a bone marrow biopsy performed for a low WBC count (odds-ratio=0.55 per standard deviation increase in PGSWBC [95%CI, 0.30 - 0.94], p=0.04), an increased risk of leukopenia (a low WBC count) when treated with a chemotherapeutic (n=1,724, hazard ratio [HR]=0.78 [0.69 - 0.88], p=4.0×10-5) or immunosuppressant (n=354, HR=0.61 [0.38 - 0.99], p=0.04). A predisposition to benign lower WBC counts was associated with an increased risk of discontinuing azathioprine treatment (n=1,466, HR=0.62 [0.44 - 0.87], p=0.006). Collectively, these findings suggest that a WBC count polygenic score identifies individuals who are susceptible to escalations or alterations in clinical care that may be harmful or of little benefit.

A test of automated use of electronic health records to aid in diagnosis of genetic disease.

PURPOSE: Automated use of electronic health records may aid in decreasing the diagnostic delay for rare diseases. The phenotype risk score (PheRS) is a weighted aggregate of syndromically related phenotypes that measures the similarity between an individual's conditions and features of a disease. For some diseases, there are individuals without a diagnosis of that disease who have scores similar to diagnosed patients. These individuals may have that disease but not yet be diagnosed. METHODS: We calculated the PheRS for cystic fibrosis (CF) for 965,626 subjects in the Vanderbilt University Medical Center electronic health record. RESULTS: Of the 400 subjects with the highest PheRS for CF, 248 (62%) had been diagnosed with CF. Twenty-six of the remaining participants, those who were alive and had DNA available in the linked DNA biobank, underwent clinical review and sequencing analysis of CFTR and SERPINA1. This uncovered a potential diagnosis for 2 subjects, 1 with CF and 1 with alpha-1-antitrypsin deficiency. An additional 7 subjects had pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants, 2 in CFTR and 5 in SERPINA1. CONCLUSION: These findings may be clinically actionable for the providers caring for these patients. Importantly, this study highlights feasibility and challenges for future implications of this approach.

Population genetic testing and SERPINA1 sequencing identifies unidentified alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency alleles and gene-environment interaction with hepatitis C infection.

Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency (AATD), a relatively common autosomal recessive genetic disorder, is underdiagnosed in symptomatic individuals. We sought to compare the risk of liver transplantation associated with hepatitis C infection with AATD heterozygotes and homozygotes and determine if SERPINA1 sequencing would identify undiagnosed AATD. We performed a retrospective cohort study in a deidentified Electronic Health Record (EHR)-linked DNA biobank with 72,027 individuals genotyped for the M, Z, and S alleles in SERPINA1. We investigated liver transplantation frequency by genotype group and compared with hepatitis C infection. We performed SERPINA1 sequencing in carriers of pathogenic AATD alleles who underwent liver transplantation. Liver transplantation was associated with the Z allele (ZZ: odds ratio [OR] = 1.31, p<2e-16; MZ: OR = 1.02, p = 1.2e-13) and with hepatitis C (OR = 1.20, p<2e-16). For liver transplantation, there was a significant interaction between genotype and hepatitis C (ZZ: interaction OR = 1.23, p = 4.7e-4; MZ: interaction OR = 1.11, p = 6.9e-13). Sequencing uncovered a second, rare, pathogenic SERPINA1 variant in six of 133 individuals with liver transplants and without hepatitis C. Liver transplantation was more common in individuals with AATD risk alleles (including heterozygotes), and AATD and hepatitis C demonstrated evidence of a gene-environment interaction in relation to liver transplantation. The current AATD screening strategy may miss diagnoses whereas SERPINA1 sequencing may increase diagnostic yield for AATD, stratify risk for liver disease, and inform clinical management for individuals with AATD risk alleles and liver disease risk factors.

The phenotype-genotype reference map: Improving biobank data science through replication.

Population-scale biobanks linked to electronic health record data provide vast opportunities to extend our knowledge of human genetics and discover new phenotype-genotype associations. Given their dense phenotype data, biobanks can also facilitate replication studies on a phenome-wide scale. Here, we introduce the phenotype-genotype reference map (PGRM), a set of 5,879 genetic associations from 523 GWAS publications that can be used for high-throughput replication experiments. PGRM phenotypes are standardized as phecodes, ensuring interoperability between biobanks. We applied the PGRM to five ancestry-specific cohorts from four independent biobanks and found evidence of robust replications across a wide array of phenotypes. We show how the PGRM can be used to detect data corruption and to empirically assess parameters for phenome-wide studies. Finally, we use the PGRM to explore factors associated with replicability of GWAS results.

CTLA-4 Pathway Is Instrumental in Giant Cell Arteritis.

BACKGROUND: Giant cell arteritis (GCA) causes severe inflammation of the aorta and its branches and is characterized by intense effector T-cell infiltration. The roles that immune checkpoints play in the pathogenesis of GCA are still unclear. Our aim was to study the immune checkpoint interplay in GCA. METHODS: First, we used VigiBase, the World Health Organization international pharmacovigilance database, to evaluate the relationship between GCA occurrence and immune checkpoint inhibitors treatments. We then further dissected the role of immune checkpoint inhibitors in the pathogenesis of GCA, using immunohistochemistry, immunofluorescence, transcriptomics, and flow cytometry on peripheral blood mononuclear cells and aortic tissues of GCA patients and appropriated controls. RESULTS: Using VigiBase, we identified GCA as a significant immune-related adverse event associated with anti-CTLA-4 (cytotoxic T-lymphocyte-associated protein-4) but not anti-PD-1 (anti-programmed death-1) nor anti-PD-L1 (anti-programmed death-ligand 1) treatment. We further dissected a critical role for the CTLA-4 pathway in GCA by identification of the dysregulation of CTLA-4-derived gene pathways and proteins in CD4+ (cluster of differentiation 4) T cells (and specifically regulatory T cells) present in blood and aorta of GCA patients versus controls. While regulatory T cells were less abundant and activated/suppressive in blood and aorta of GCA versus controls, they still specifically upregulated CTLA-4. Activated and proliferating CTLA-4+ Ki-67+ regulatory T cells from GCA were more sensitive to anti-CTLA-4 (ipilimumab)-mediated in vitro depletion versus controls. CONCLUSIONS: We highlighted the instrumental role of CTLA-4 immune checkpoint in GCA, which provides a strong rationale for targeting this pathway.

Heterozygous rare variants in NR2F2 cause a recognizable multiple congenital anomaly syndrome with developmental delays.

Nuclear receptor subfamily 2 group F member 2 (NR2F2 or COUP-TF2) encodes a transcription factor which is expressed at high levels during mammalian development. Rare heterozygous Mendelian variants in NR2F2 were initially identified in individuals with congenital heart disease (CHD), then subsequently in cohorts of congenital diaphragmatic hernia (CDH) and 46,XX ovotesticular disorders/differences of sexual development (DSD); however, the phenotypic spectrum associated with pathogenic variants in NR2F2 remains poorly characterized. Currently, less than 40 individuals with heterozygous pathogenic variants in NR2F2 have been reported. Here, we review the clinical and molecular details of 17 previously unreported individuals with rare heterozygous NR2F2 variants, the majority of which were de novo. Clinical features were variable, including intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR), CHD, CDH, genital anomalies, DSD, developmental delays, hypotonia, feeding difficulties, failure to thrive, congenital and acquired microcephaly, dysmorphic facial features, renal failure, hearing loss, strabismus, asplenia, and vascular malformations, thus expanding the phenotypic spectrum associated with NR2F2 variants. The variants seen were predicted loss of function, including a nonsense variant inherited from a mildly affected mosaic mother, missense and a large deletion including the NR2F2 gene. Our study presents evidence for rare, heterozygous NR2F2 variants causing a highly variable syndrome of congenital anomalies, commonly associated with heart defects, developmental delays/intellectual disability, dysmorphic features, feeding difficulties, hypotonia, and genital anomalies. Based on the new and previous cases, we provide clinical recommendations for evaluating individuals diagnosed with an NR2F2-associated disorder.

Phenotypic presentation of Mendelian disease across the diagnostic trajectory in electronic health records.

PURPOSE: To investigate the phenotypic presentation of Mendelian disease across the diagnostic trajectory in the electronic health record (EHR). METHODS: We applied a conceptual model to delineate the diagnostic trajectory of Mendelian disease to the EHRs of patients affected by 1 of 9 Mendelian diseases. We assessed data availability and phenotype ascertainment across the diagnostic trajectory using phenotype risk scores and validated our findings via chart review of patients with hereditary connective tissue disorders. RESULTS: We identified 896 individuals with genetically confirmed diagnoses, 216 (24%) of whom had fully ascertained diagnostic trajectories. Phenotype risk scores increased following clinical suspicion and diagnosis (P < 1 × 10-4, Wilcoxon rank sum test). We found that of all International Classification of Disease-based phenotypes in the EHR, 66% were recorded after clinical suspicion, and manual chart review yielded consistent results. CONCLUSION: Using a novel conceptual model to study the diagnostic trajectory of genetic disease in the EHR, we demonstrated that phenotype ascertainment is, in large part, driven by the clinical examinations and studies prompted by clinical suspicion of a genetic disease, a process we term diagnostic convergence. Algorithms designed to detect undiagnosed genetic disease should consider censoring EHR data at the first date of clinical suspicion to avoid data leakage.

Knowledgebase strategies to aid interpretation of clinical correlation research.

OBJECTIVE: Knowledgebases are needed to clarify correlations observed in real-world electronic health record (EHR) data. We posit design principles, present a unifying framework, and report a test of concept. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We structured a knowledge framework along 3 axes: condition of interest, knowledge source, and taxonomy. In our test of concept, we used hypertension as our condition of interest, literature and VanderbiltDDx knowledgebase as sources, and phecodes as our taxonomy. In a cohort of 832 566 deidentified EHRs, we modeled blood pressure and heart rate by sex and age, classified individuals by hypertensive status, and ran a Phenome-wide Association Study (PheWAS) for hypertension. We compared the correlations from PheWAS to the associations in our knowledgebase. RESULTS: We produced PhecodeKbHtn: a knowledgebase comprising 167 hypertension-associated diseases, 15 of which were also negatively associated with blood pressure (pos+neg). Our hypertension PheWAS included 1914 phecodes, 129 of which were in the PhecodeKbHtn. Among the PheWAS association results, phecodes that were in PhecodeKbHtn had larger effect sizes compared with those phecodes not in the knowledgebase. DISCUSSION: Each source contributed unique and additive associations. Models of blood pressure and heart rate by age and sex were consistent with prior cohort studies. All but 4 PheWAS positive and negative correlations for phecodes in PhecodeKbHtn may be explained by knowledgebase associations, hypertensive cardiac complications, or causes of hypertension independently associated with hypotension. CONCLUSION: It is feasible to assemble a knowledgebase that is compatible with EHR data to aid interpretation of clinical correlation research.