Our inability to predict thromboembolic events after prosthetic valve surgery.

BACKGROUND AND AIM OF THE STUDY: Thromboembolic and bleeding complications detract from outcome for patients with prosthetic heart valves. The study aim was to investigate whether measurement of coagulation activation markers and transcranial Doppler ultrasound microembolic signals (MES) could identify patients at subsequent higher risk of thromboembolism or bleeding events. METHODS: A total of 526 patients (mean age 66 years; 266 males, 260 females) who underwent elective valve replacement surgery was enrolled between April 1999 and October 2002. Clinical assessment and blood sampling for coagulation activation markers was performed preoperatively and at three and 12 months postoperatively. Transcranial Doppler MES were recorded in the first 144 patients. Status was reviewed between 21st April and 9th June 2005, with 99.4% follow up. RESULTS: Among patients, 62% had an aortic valve replaced, and mechanical valves constituted 60% of all implants. The mean follow up was 3.61 years; total follow up was 1,899.2 patient-years (pt-yr). In total, 115 patients died, while 61 experienced a total of 80 thromboembolic events: linearized event rates were 3.94% (mechanical valves) and 4.4% (bioprostheses). There was no difference between mitral and aortic implants, or among bileaflet, tilting-disc mechanical and porcine valves. Atrial fibrillation was not influential. Coagulation activation markers were not associated with thromboembolic events, except for an elevated von Willebrand factor (vWF), which was associated with a five-fold increase in embolic event rate. Fifty-one patients experienced 59 bleeding events; eight patients experienced multiple events. Linearized event rates were 3.37% (mechanical valves) and 2.49% (bioprostheses). The INR was suboptimal in 44-58% of patients. Transcranial Doppler MES were not associated with blood coagulation markers or thromboembolic events. CONCLUSION: Coagulation activation markers (except vWF) and MES did not predict thromboembolic events in valve replacement patients. Thromboembolic and bleeding event rates for West of Scotland patients generally exceeded reported rates: suboptimal anticoagulation appeared common and most likely influenced thromboembolic and bleeding event rates more than any other factor.

Comparison of prosthetic valve hydrodynamic function: objective testing using statistical multilevel modeling.

BACKGROUND AND AIM OF THE STUDY: The performance of novel prosthetic heart valves is assessed using in-vitro hydrodynamic function tests. The study aim was to examine the problem of objective discrimination of hydrodynamic performance to determine significant differences between valve designs, and illustrate proposed methodology using data collected from five different polyurethane tri-leaflet valve designs. METHODS: Two engineering designs were manufactured with leaflets of the same polyurethane (GE, LE); design L was manufactured using three further leaflet materials of differing material modulus (LL, L4, L5). Six valves were made in each design, each tested at five flow rates in a standard hydrodynamic test rig, with five test replications for each valve. The data were analyzed using multilevel statistical modeling methods, allowing simultaneous comparison of multiple regression lines describing valve performance. The multilevel model is hierarchical in structure, in this case with two levels of data, describing individual valves at level 2 and test replicates at level 1. In all cases, the multilevel model uses the hydrodynamic function measure of interest, e.g. mean pressure gradient or leakage, with logarithmic transformation as required as the dependent variable, Y. The independent variable, X, is, in all cases, the natural logarithm of the RMS flow measured through the valve. RESULTS: The two-design multilevel model enabled quantitative discrimination of designs GE and LE, showing that design GE had significantly better hydrodynamic function overall than design LE in this case (mean pressure gradient was estimated as 0.93 mmHg lower at low cardiac output, 14.74 mmHg lower at 9.6 l/min). The five-design multilevel model showed clearly the relatively poor hydrodynamic performance of designs L4 and L5 compared with others. The procedure was straightforward, and produced a statistical comparison among valve designs that is not easily achieved by other means. CONCLUSION: This methodology provides a useful means of objective assessment of valve function for valve developers. Variance estimates provided by the analysis also provide a basis for quality control of valve production and testing.

Mechanical and morphological study of biostable polyurethane heart valve leaflets explanted from sheep.

Two novel biostable polyurethanes, designated EV3.34 and EV3.35, were used to manufacture a flexible trileaflet heart valve. The valves were implanted in the mitral position in young adult (18 month) sheep. Six valves were electively explanted at 6 months and the remaining six valves at 9 months follow-up. The leaflet material was examined by surface Fourier transform infrared spectrometry (ATR/FTIR) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The leaflet material was also subjected to cyclic mechanical testing and, compared with unimplanted control material, to demonstrate any change in mechanical properties during implantation. There was no degradation of functional groups detected by ATR/FTIR, although there was a slight surface enrichment of siloxane soft segment. Surface morphology of the explanted leaflet material was similar to unimplanted control material. EV3.34 demonstrated similar inelastic energy loss behavior, with no significant change in residual strain in explanted compared with control material. EV3.35 demonstrated a reduction in inelastic energy and residual strain in explanted compared with control material. There is no evidence of biodegradation of these siloxane-based polyurethanes, in functional valves up to 9 months implantation in sheep. The FTIR and SEM findings are supported by the retention of mechanical properties of the materials.

Hydrodynamic function of polyurethane prosthetic heart valves: influences of Young's modulus and leaflet thickness.

The development of flexible polyurethane heart valves has been hindered by material degradation in vivo. Low modulus polyurethane leaflets are regarded as desirable to achieve good hydrodynamic function. However, low modulus materials may suffer high strain accumulation, hence poor durability. Higher modulus materials may improve durability, but may have poor hydrodynamic function. This study examines the hydrodynamic behaviour of biostable polyurethane valves, varying Young's modulus from 5 to 63.6 MPa and mean leaflet thickness from 48-238 microm. Parameters studied included mean pressure gradient, energy losses and regurgitation over 5 equivalent cardiac outputs (3.6, 4.9, 6.4, 8.0 and 9.61 min(-1)) At low cardiac output, modulus was not significantly correlated with any parameter of valve opening. At 9.61 min(-1), modulus significantly influenced mean pressure gradient (p = 0.033). Mean leaflet thickness significantly correlated with mean pressure gradient and energy losses during forward flow at all cardiac outputs (p<0.001). This study demonstrates that, over a wide range of moduli, valve hydrodynamic function is not affected significantly by the material modulus. Leaflet thickness is a highly significant factor. Higher modulus elastomers in a range up to 32.5 MPa may be useful in prosthetic heart valve leaflet manufacture, retaining good hydrodynamic function while potentially extending the lifetime of the valve.