Treatment costs of directly observed therapy and traditional therapy for Mycobacterium tuberculosis: a comparative analysis.

OBJECTIVE: Treatment of tuberculosis is a time-consuming and expensive process, often complicated by patient non-adherence. Directly observed therapy (DOT), an out-patient management strategy designed to ensure adherence, is not widely used because it is perceived to be too expensive. This study compared costs of tuberculosis treatment in DOT to the same factors in traditional therapy. DESIGN: A retrospective economic evaluation of 659 tuberculosis cases was reported to a major metropolitan county public health department between 1980 and 1994. Out-patient costs, in-patient costs and the cost impact of relapse and acquired resistance were estimated in 1995 dollars. RESULTS: Treatment costs were lower with DOT: $15,670 per case for in-patient care and $700 per case for out-patient care (P < 0.001). These cost differences resulted from shorter therapy duration (334 vs 550 days), fewer patient hospitalizations (58 vs 75%) and shorter hospital stays (26 vs 55 days per hospitalized patient). Relapse or acquired resistance occurred in 10.9% of patients and accounted for 35.7% of cost with traditional therapy, as compared to 1.2% of patients and 6.0% of cost with observed therapy. CONCLUSIONS: Directly observed therapy is less costly than traditional therapy.

The effect of directly observed therapy on the rates of drug resistance and relapse in tuberculosis.

BACKGROUND: Tuberculosis has reemerged as an important public health problem, and the frequency of drug resistance is increasing. A major reason for the development of resistant infections and relapse is poor compliance with medical regimens. In Tarrant County, Texas, we initiated a program of universal directly observed treatment for tuberculosis. We report the effect of the program on the rates of primary and acquired drug resistance and relapse among patients with tuberculosis. METHODS: We collected information on all patients with positive cultures for Mycobacterium tuberculosis in Tarrant County from January 1, 1980, through December 31, 1992. Through October 1986, patients received a traditional, unsupervised drug regimen. Beginning in November 1986, nearly all patients received therapy under direct observation by health care personnel. RESULTS: A total of 407 episodes in which patients received traditional treatment for tuberculosis (January 1980 through October 1986) were compared with 581 episodes in which therapy was directly observed (November 1986 through December 1992). Despite higher rates of intravenous drug use and homelessness and an increasing rate of tuberculosis during this 13-year period, the frequency of primary drug resistance decreased from 13.0 percent to 6.7 percent (P < 0.001) after the institution of direct observation of therapy, and the frequency of acquired resistance declined from 14.0 percent to 2.1 percent (P < 0.001). The relapse rate decreased from 20.9 percent to 5.5 percent (P < 0.001), and the number of relapses with multidrug-resistant organisms decreased from 25 to 5 (P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: The administration of therapy for M. tuberculosis infection under direct observation leads to significant reductions in the frequency of primary drug resistance, acquired drug resistance, and relapse.

Managing a patient with progressive HIV disease.

This monthly series was developed from the AOA Task Force on AIDS Writers' Workshop, held August 16 to 18, 1991, in New York. The workshop was sponsored by an education grant from Burroughs Wellcome. It will provide brief clinical updates and perspectives on the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Readers may request tear sheets from the AOA editorial offices.

Starting therapy for an HIV-infected patient.

This monthly series was developed from the AOA Task Force on AIDS Writers' Workshop, held August 16 to 18, 1991, in New York. The workshop was sponsored by an education grant from Burroughs Wellcome. It will provide brief clinical updates and perspectives on the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Readers may request tear sheets from the AOA editorial offices.

How to recognize patients at risk or infected with HIV.

This monthly series was developed from the AOA Task Force on AIDS Writers' Workshop, held August 16 to 18, 1991, in New York. The workshop was sponsored by an educational grant from Burroughs Wellcome. It will provide brief clinical updates and perspectives on the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Readers may request tear sheets from the AOA editorial offices.

Coumarin-induced skin necrosis.

Coumarin skin necrosis is a rare and usually unpredictable complication of coumarin therapy, occasionally leading to death. Onset is usually between the third and sixth day of coumarin therapy. The patient most commonly complains of pain in a region of abundant subcutaneous fat, with progression to erythema, petechiae, and gangrenous necrosis. Thrombosis of the dermal and the subcutaneous veins is demonstrated pathologically. We describe a case and review the pathogenesis, treatment, and prevention of this lesion.

Postviral bronchial hyperreactivity syndrome: recognizing asthma's great mimic.

Although there are no prospective studies regarding the frequency of postviral bronchial hyperreactivity syndrome, it is a common complication of upper and lower respiratory tract viral infections. The respiratory symptoms closely resemble those of asthma, but they are present for only 3 weeks to 3 months following the acute infection phase. Defining the mechanisms of this syndrome may provide insight into the pathogenesis of asthma. Postviral bronchial hyperreactivity syndrome is frequently misdiagnosed and inappropriately managed because many physicians are unfamiliar with this illness. Because of its characteristic history, diagnosis is straightforward when the physician knows what to look for, and response to therapy is excellent. This report presents a case history followed by a review of the proposed mechanisms of bronchial hyperreactivity following viral respiratory infections. The clinical features and criteria for diagnosing postviral bronchial hyperreactivity syndrome are also discussed.

Duration of handwashing in intensive care units: a descriptive study.

The duration of handwashing was studied in two community hospitals (teaching and nonteaching). The duration in seconds of 180 handwashes by health care personnel and 52 handwashes by non-health care personnel were recorded. The mean duration for health care personnel was 8.62 +/- 0.29 SEM; the degree of patient contact did not influence the duration of handwashing. The duration of handwashing was two times longer in health care personnel vs. non-health care personnel (8.62 +/- 0.29 vs. 4.14 +/- 0.42; t = 7.7; p less than 0.001). Comparisons revealed no statistically significant difference in duration between personnel at teaching and nonteaching hospitals or among those in different occupations. The data indicate that the duration of handwashing among health care personnel is below the standard recommended by authorities in hospital infection control. This may be an important factor in the transmission and persistence of nosocomial infection in critical care units. The antimicrobial efficacy of handwashing agents should be reevaluated considering the actual duration of handwashing by health care personnel within the hospital environment or efforts should be made to increase the duration of handwashing.

Movement of personnel and wound contamination.

We studied the association between the movement of operating room personnel and bacterial contamination of the operative field during 12 clean operations. Settle plates placed on the patient's chest and instrument table were exposed during the operation. As a control, settle plates were exposed in the same locations when no personnel and patients were in the room. Bacterial contamination of the aseptic field was categorized as disseminating (Group A: greater than 42 combined movements) and nondisseminating (Group B: less than 42 combined movements). There were 24 persons in each group. There was a highly significant difference between the two groups in the colony counts on settling plates. More vigorous movement was associated with increased bacterial contamination of the operative field. Low bacterial colony counts were found in the control plates, ruling out environmental sources of contamination. Bacterial fallout correlated with the movement of personnel. Measures to reduce excessive movement in the OR are recommended.