Application of explicit process of care measurement to rheumatoid arthritis: Moving from evidence to practice.

OBJECTIVE: To construct quality measures with measurement validity and meaning for clinicians. METHODS: We conducted a prospective cohort study of rates of change in disease-modifying antirheumatic drug (DMARD) and/or systemic corticosteroid drug or dose for 568 patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) across 6,159 clinical encounters within 12 months to examine how changes in clinical specifications change adherence. RESULTS: Rates of DMARD change were sensitive to specifications regarding the intensity of disease activity (severe or moderate), duration of specified disease activity, and length of the observation period. Over 12 months, the proportions of 377 patients with severe disease activity observed for 1-month, 2-month, and 3-month time blocks who had a change in DMARD drug or dose were 36%, 57%, and 74%, respectively. Over 12 months, a change in DMARD drug or dose was observed for 44%, 50%, and 68% of 377 patients with severe disease within 3 months, 6 months, and 12 months, respectively, of the patient meeting criteria for severe disease activity. A change in DMARD drug or dose was observed for 21%, 23%, and 34% of 149 patients with moderate disease activity within 3, 6, and 12 months, respectively, of the patient meeting criteria for moderate disease activity. CONCLUSION: Rates of pharmacologic interventions for patients with moderate and severe RA disease activity vary substantially by intensity and duration of disease activity and by duration of period for observing change. Lack of precision in explicit process criteria could substantially mislead comparisons of quality of care across comparison groups.

Direct and indirect costs associated with the onset of seropositive rheumatoid arthritis. Western Consortium of Practicing Rheumatologists.

OBJECTIVE: To examine the direct and indirect costs of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) during the first year of disease. METHODS: As part of a longitudinal observational study, 150 patients with seropositive RA of 5.9 +/- 2.9 mo duration were recruited through the Western Consortium of Practicing Rheumatologists. Subjects completed questionnaires about health care services and resources utilized and about the number of days of usual activity lost as a result of RA during the 6 month period prior to enrolment. RESULTS: Study participants had active RA as evidenced by mean tender and swollen joint counts of 24.9 +/- 13.5 and 20.6 +/- 11.6, respectively, and moderate functional impairment reflected by a mean Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ) score of 1.24 +/- 0.7. The average total direct cost of RA was $200/month. Health care visits, medications, and radiographs accounted for 78% of the total direct cost, while expenditures for hospitalizations accounted for only 3.5% of the total. The average number of days of usual activity lost per month because of RA was 3.8 +/- 7.7, translating into an average indirect cost of $281/month. Of the 95 subjects who were gainfully employed prior to disease onset, 12 were disabled and 5 were on sick leave as a result of RA, corresponding to a work disability rate of 18%. Work disabled subjects reported significantly lower total household incomes and higher HAQ disability and global disease activity scores than subjects who continued working. CONCLUSION: In this group of patients with seropositive RA substantial costs, both direct and indirect, were incurred during the first year of disease.

Relative contributions of the components of the American College of Rheumatology 20% criteria for improvement to responder status in patients with early seropositive rheumatoid arthritis.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate factors that influence the responses defined by the American College of Rheumatology (ACR) 20% criteria for improvement in rheumatoid arthritis (RA). METHODS: ACR 20% and 50% response rates were calculated from data collected for the intervals 0-6, 0-12, and 0-24 months for 180 RA patients participating in the Western Consortium of Practicing Rheumatologists long-term observational study of early seropositive RA (mean +/- SD duration of RA at study entry 6.0 +/- 3.4 months). Analyzable cases were patients with paired data for tender and swollen joint counts plus at least 3 of the following criteria: physician's and patient's global assessments of disease activity and patient's score for pain (by visual analog scale), physical function score on the Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ), and levels of an acute-phase reactant. Response rates were then recalculated by 3 different methods: 1) using only cases with complete paired data for all criteria, 2) sequentially assuming no improvement in each of the 5 secondary criteria, and 3) substituting grip strength for HAQ scores. RESULTS: Using 464 paired observations for all analyzable cases, ACR 20% (50%) improvement rates were 52.6% (33.0%), compared with 55.6% (34.8%) for 365 paired observations from the cases with complete data. Decreases in ACR response rates when secondary criteria were sequentially set at "no improvement" ranged from 11.7% (pain at 0-6 months) to 1.2% (C-reactive protein at 0-12 months), but these were not statistically different by the kappa statistic. Overall numerical rankings of the relative contributions of the secondary criteria to the ACR 20% or 50% response rates were physician's global assessment, pain, HAQ, patient's global assessment, and acute-phase reactant. Only 7.8% of paired grip strength observations showed > or =20% improvement, compared with 71% of paired HAQ observations. CONCLUSION: The use of all "analyzable" cases (paired data for tender and swollen joint counts plus > or =3 of the 5 secondary criteria) increases the number of subjects and only slightly decreases the ACR response rate compared with analyses limited to cases with complete data. The contributions of the secondary criteria are not statistically different, supporting their equal weighting in the ACR definition of improvement. The ACR 20% response rates are higher when the HAQ, rather than grip strength, is used to measure physical function.

Etanercept therapy in rheumatoid arthritis. A randomized, controlled trial.

BACKGROUND: In a phase II study, etanercept (recombinant human tumor necrosis factor receptor [p75]:Fc fusion protein) safely produced rapid, dose-dependent improvement in rheumatoid arthritis over 3 months. OBJECTIVE: To confirm the benefit of etanercept therapy of longer duration and simplified dosing in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. DESIGN: Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial with blinded joint assessors. SETTING: 13 North American centers. PATIENTS: 234 patients with active rheumatoid arthritis who had an inadequate response to disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs. INTERVENTION: Twice-weekly subcutaneous injections of etanercept, 10 or 25 mg, or placebo for 6 months. MEASUREMENTS: The primary end points were 20% and 50% improvement in disease activity according to American College of Rheumatology (ACR) responses at 3 and 6 months. Other end points were 70% ACR responses at 3 and 6 months and other measures of disease activity at 3 and 6 months. RESULTS: Etanercept significantly reduced disease activity in a dose-related fashion. At 3 months, 62% of the patients receiving 25 mg of etanercept and 23% of the placebo recipients achieved 20% ACR response (P < 0.001). At 6 months, 59% of the 25-mg group and 11% of the placebo group achieved a 20% ACR response (P < 0.001); 40% and 5%, respectively, achieved a 50% ACR response (P < 0.01). The respective mean percentage reduction in the number of tender and swollen joints at 6 months was 56% and 47% in the 25-mg group and 6% and -7% in the placebo group (P < 0.05). Significantly more etanercept recipients achieved a 70% ACR response, minimal disease status (0 to 5 affected joints), and improved quality of life. Etanercept was well tolerated, with no dose-limiting toxic effects. CONCLUSIONS: Etanercept can safely provide rapid, significant, and sustained benefit in patients with active rheumatoid arthritis.

A trial of etanercept, a recombinant tumor necrosis factor receptor:Fc fusion protein, in patients with rheumatoid arthritis receiving methotrexate.

BACKGROUND: Patients treated with methotrexate for rheumatoid arthritis often improve but continue to have active disease. This study was undertaken to determine whether the addition of etanercept, a soluble tumor necrosis factor receptor (p75):Fc fusion protein (TNFR:Fc), to methotrexate therapy would provide additional benefit to patients who had persistent rheumatoid arthritis despite receiving methotrexate. METHODS: In a 24-week, double-blind trial, we randomly assigned 89 patients with persistently active rheumatoid arthritis despite at least 6 months of methotrexate therapy at a stable dose of 15 to 25 mg per week (or as low as 10 mg per week for patients unable to tolerate higher doses) to receive either etanercept (25 mg) or placebo subcutaneously twice weekly while continuing to receive methotrexate. The primary measure of clinical response was the American College of Rheumatology criteria for a 20 percent improvement in measures of disease activity (ACR 20) at 24 weeks. RESULTS: The addition of etanercept to methotrexate therapy resulted in rapid and sustained improvement. At 24 weeks, 71 percent of the patients receiving etanercept plus methotrexate and 27 percent of those receiving placebo plus methotrexate met the ACR 20 criteria (P<0.001); 39 percent of the patients receiving etanercept plus methotrexate and 3 percent of those receiving placebo plus methotrexate met the ACR 50 criteria (for a 50 percent improvement) (P<0.001). Patients receiving etanercept plus methotrexate had significantly better outcomes according to all measures of disease activity. The only adverse events associated with etanercept were mild injection-site reactions, and no patient withdrew from the study because of adverse events associated with etanercept. CONCLUSIONS: In patients with persistently active rheumatoid arthritis, the combination of etanercept and methotrexate was safe and well tolerated and provided significantly greater clinical benefit than methotrexate alone.

Biologic therapies in rheumatoid arthritis.

Our growing understanding of the immune response mechanism has created a wave of novel biologic agents for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis. The domain of biologic agents includes: 1) Recombinant regulatory cytokines; 2) engineered molecules and monoclonal antibodies that target proinflammatory cytokines; 3) monoclonal antibodies against lymphocyte cell-surface proteins; 4) fusion proteins and monoclonal antibodies that block the second signal and induce anergy; 5) vaccines comprised of specific proteins from lymphocytes and antigen presenting cells; 6) monoclonal antibodies that block intercellular adhesion; and 6) gene therapy whereby antiarthritis genes are introduced directly into the joint. Most treatments remain under investigation; however, in 1998 two antagonists of tumor necrosis factor were approved marking the first approvals of antirheumatic biologic agents. For the first time anti-rheumatic therapies are being designed instead of borrowed.

CAMPATH-1H in rheumatoid arthritis--an intravenous dose-ranging study.

Forty-one patients with active and refractory rheumatoid arthritis(RA) received a total of 100, 250 or 400 mg of CAMPATH-1H (CAMPATH is a trademark of Glaxo-Wellcome group companies, registered in the US Patent and Trademark Office) over 5 or 10 days in an open, uncontrolled study. Following therapy, patients were monitored for adverse effects and disease activity for 6 months. Therapy was associated with prolonged peripheral blood lymphopenia in all dosing cohorts. During the month immediately following therapy, lymphopenia was most profound in the 400 mg cohorts. The first dose of monoclonal antibody (Mab) was associated with a 'flu'-like syndrome, more pronounced at higher initial doses. One patient developed haemolytic-uraemic syndrome. There were a number of dose-related infections during the early post-treatment period and one fatal opportunistic infection which followed additional immunosuppressive therapy. Antiglobulin responses developed in 9 of 31 patients tested. The majority of patients showed symptomatic improvement following therapy and 20% of patients maintained a 50% Paulus response at 6 months, all of whom were in the 250 or 400 mg cohorts. CAMPATH-1H appears to be an effective treatment for RA. Allowing for the small number of patients treated, infections were more common with higher doses, although this was not true for adverse events overall, and therapeutic responses were more sustained at higher dosing levels. The broad specificity of CAMPATH-1H may be appropriate for the immunotherapy of RA and future studies should aim to define a dose with an optimal therapeutic ratio.

CAMPATH-1H, a humanized monoclonal antibody, in refractory rheumatoid arthritis. An intravenous dose-escalation study.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the biologic response, tolerability, and potential clinical effect of a humanized antilymphocyte monoclonal antibody, CAMPATH-1H, in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA). METHODS: Forty adult patients with active, refractory RA were treated with CAMPATH-1H, given intravenously, in a multicenter, open, single-dose-escalation study. Patients were assigned to dose groups of 1, 3, 10, 30, 60, and 100 mg CAMPATH-1H. RESULTS: There was a profound, immediate, and sustained reduction of the peripheral lymphocyte count; the most susceptible were the levels of CD4+ and CD8+ cells, which remained depressed during the study period. Sixty-three percent of patients developed antibodies to CAMPATH-1H. Side effects occurred frequently throughout the first 24 hours following infusion, and included fever, headache, nausea, vomiting, and hypotension. All of the immediate drug toxicities resolved within the initial 24-hour postdosing period. One patient developed a reactivation of Mycobacterium xenopi infection 10 weeks following infusion. Sixty-five percent of patients developed a clinical response; the mean duration of response was 2 weeks. CONCLUSION: CAMPATH-1H is a lymphocyte-depleting antibody that is biologically potent even after single-dose therapy. There was no correlation between biologic effect and clinical response. Sustained lymphocyte suppression was observed. Acute infusion toxicities were observed in most patients. The role of depleting monoclonal antibodies in the treatment of RA should be reevaluated.

Rheumatoid arthritis. Outcome measures.

Rheumatologists have been pioneers in the development and use of clinical measures for outcome assessment. The Lansbury Index (1958) and the Empire Rheumatism Gold Trial (1960) used sophisticated double-blind pseudo-placebo-controlled trial designs and standardized prespecified clinical outcome measures to establish the clinical usefulness of a drug whose benefit did not become evident until it was administered for several months. Since these studies, other studies have establish the clinical and statistical groundwork for rheumatoid arthritis outcome measures. In 1980, the Health Assessment Questionnaire and the Arthritis Impact Measurement Scales were added. Future development of paradigms for the decision process in the clinical management of individual rheumatoid arthritis patients will no doubt incorporate standard outcome measures to provide the data upon which management decisions can be based.

DC-ART classification: review of relevant clinical studies.

The proposed disease controlling antirheumatic therapy (DC-ART) definition requires that the therapy change the course of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) for at least 1 year, evidenced by (1) sustained improvement in physical function, (2) decreased inflammatory synovitis, and (3) slowing or prevention of structural joint damage. Selected studies are reviewed. All studies were at least 1 year in duration, but most did not include all 3 of the DC-ART requirements. In these studies, patients treated with placebo generally had no improvement in inflammatory synovitis and progressive structural joint damage, judged by serial joint radiographs. A minority of studies significantly favored one or another of the available agents (gold injections, D-penicillamine, auranofin, antimalarials, azathioprine, sulfasalazine, methotrexate), but the evidence for any one agent is not convincing. For future DC-ART clinical trials patients with early RA should be studied. A hybrid study design may be useful, combining an initial double blind randomized controlled clinical trial with continuing longterm observation of all withdrawals using specified clinical, radiographic, and self report assessments at regular intervals, and an intent-to-treat analysis comparing longterm response rates of the original control and experimental therapy groups. Responsive subgroups should be sought, their characteristics identified, and their responsiveness confirmed in additional trials limited to the identified subgroup.

Early undifferentiated connective tissue disease: III. Outcome and prognostic indicators in early scleroderma (systemic sclerosis).

OBJECTIVE: To characterize the course of early scleroderma and to delineate prognostic factors present within 1 year of disease onset that might identify patients at high risk. DESIGN: Inception cohort study. SETTING: Ten university-based rheumatology clinics participating in the Cooperative Systematic Studies of Rheumatic Diseases Program. PATIENTS: Forty-eight patients who had had scleroderma for less than 1 year. MEASUREMENTS: Fifteen patients with early scleroderma who died were compared with those still living during the initial study period (1982 to 1992). Kaplan-Meier survival estimation and Cox proportional hazards analysis were used to analyze baseline variables for their ability to predict survival duration. RESULTS: Eight of 15 deaths were due to cardiac or pulmonary system failure. The estimated 5-year survival rate was 68%. Baseline factors that were the most predictive of a poor outcome included the presence of abnormal cardiopulmonary signs and abnormal urine sediment (pyuria, hematuria). CONCLUSION: Evidence of early cardiopulmonary disease, renal disease, inflammation, or immune activation may identify a subset of patients with scleroderma who will experience rapidly progressive disease and early death.

Neuromuscular manifestations of L-tryptophan-associated eosinophilia-myalgia syndrome: a histomorphologic analysis of 14 patients.

The recent delineation of a clinical syndrome marked by eosinophilia, myalgia, and scleroderma-like skin changes associated with L-tryptophan use has necessitated the Centers for Disease Control to initiate a health alert. The likely association of L-tryptophan ingestion with a syndrome that mimics eosinophilic fasciitis (Shulman's syndrome) further identifies an environmental agent associated with an inflammatory sclerosing rheumatic disease process. In this report, we present the clinical, morphologic, and enzyme histochemical findings in muscle, skin, and fascia biopsies from 14 cases fulfilling the Center for Disease Control diagnostic criteria for L-tryptophan-associated eosinophilia-myalgia syndrome. The clinical syndrome reveals a high incidence of arthralgia, elbow contracture, and clinical neuropathy. The absence of significant change in creatine kinase or sedimentation rate allows for diagnostic separation from other inflammatory myopathies. Histoenzymatic features in muscle biopsies reveal a preferential epimysial-perimysial noneosinophilic infiltration characterized by acid phosphatase reactive histiocytosis, nonnecrotizing venulitis, perineural inflammation within dermis and perimysium, type II fiber atrophy with superimposed denervation features, and perifascicular alkaline phosphatase reactivity representing early neofibroplasia. The constellation of changes in skin, fascia, and muscle, with the defined clinical syndrome, allows for accurate differentiation from allied syndromes, including eosinophilic polymyositis, scleroderma, idiopathic polymyositis/dermatomyositis, polyarteritis nodosa, and toxic oil syndrome. Accurate differentiation from eosinophilic fasciitis still rests on a history of L-tryptophan ingestion.

Association of L-tryptophan and an illness resembling eosinophilic fasciitis. Clinical and histopathologic findings in four patients with eosinophilia-myalgia syndrome.

The Centers for Disease Control has recently reported an association between the use of oral L-tryptophan preparations and a disease marked by severe myalgia, peripheral eosinophilia, and neuromuscular and cutaneous abnormalities. They have labeled the condition eosinophilia-myalgia syndrome. We report here the clinical and histopathologic findings in 4 patients who developed an illness resembling eosinophilic fasciitis following the initiation of oral L-tryptophan supplementation.

Systemic lupus erythematosus and concurrent cytomegalovirus vasculitis: diagnosis by antemortem skin biopsy.

A 45-year-old woman with a 4-year history of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) developed fever, decreased visual acuity and skin ulceration. A biopsy of a cutaneous ulcer demonstrated small vessel vasculitis with characteristic cytomegalovirus (CMV) inclusions in the vascular endothelium. The presence of CMV was confirmed by DNA hybridization immuno-histochemistry. Retinal artery vasculitis, previously associated with flares of her SLE, was also noted on ophthalmologic examination. Our case demonstrates that CMV infection can mimic the cutaneous manifestations of collagen vascular disease and that early identification can be made by biopsy of suspicious skin lesions.

Studies of sequence heterogeneity of mitochondrial DNA from rat and mouse tissues: evidence for an increased frequency of deletions/additions with aging.

To obtain information on the extent of random nucleotide changes in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) from different organs of young adult and senescent Fischer 344 rats, the temperature of thermal denaturation (tm) was measured in (1) the native mtDNA cut at a single SstI site and (2) the reannealed duplexes formed after the initial melting of the mtDNA sample. No change was found between the two tm values in either young or senescent mtDNA, suggesting that the overall mismatch in nucleotide sequence in these samples was below the resolution of the method estimated at about 0.2%. In another experiment, mtDNA samples from young adult or senescent BALB/c mouse liver were digested with EcoRI, denatured and allowed to reanneal. The duplexes formed by the 14-kb EcoRI fragment were analyzed in randomly taken electron micrographs for the occurrence of mismatched segments. About 1.8% of reconstituted duplexes in adult mtDNA and 11% of those in senescent mtDNA contained small loops or knobs suggestive of deletions/additions of about 400 +/- 150 nucleotides. These data correspond to about 1% of the native mtDNA population in adult liver and about 5% in senescent liver having deleted/inserted segments. Although deletions/insertions may occur at variable sites, their distribution appears to be non-random. These findings suggest that small sequence rearrangements, which have been observed previously in unicircular dimers of mouse and human mtDNA, occur also in monomeric mtDNA from normal tissues and accumulate with aging.

Structural and replicative forms of mitochondrial DNA in tissues from adult and senescent BALB/c mice and Fischer 344 rats.

Age-related changes in the structure and replication of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) were investigated in different organs from young adult (9-10 months' old) and senescent (28-29 months' old) BALB/c mice and Fischer 344 rats. Total mtDNA from brain, heart, kidney and liver was isolated by centrifugation in ethidium bromide-CsCl gradients and examined for the occurrence of complex forms and replicative intermediates by electron microscopy. The frequency of catenated mtDNA (interlinked molecules containing two or more circular units) varied from about 2.5% to 5% in adult tissues and showed a small increase in the majority of senescent organs. The frequency of double-sized circular molecules, or circular dimers, was very low in adult tissues, with an average of about 0.04% in mice and 0.1% in rats. The frequency of circular dimers increased with aging to 1.9% in mouse brain and 1.5% in rat kidney, with smaller increases (0.4% and 0.7%) in heart mtDNA from both species; there was no significant increase in the other organs. It is suggested that the increase in the frequency of circular dimer mtDNA reflects an overall deterioration of tissue physiology rather than intrinsic senescent changes in the mitochondria. The frequencies and types of the various replicative forms of mtDNA varied significantly according to tissue but not according to species or donor age. The only exception was a significant increase in the frequency of larger replicative forms in senescent mouse liver, to about 20% compared with 12% in adult liver, suggesting an age-related change in the rate of mtDNA replication and/or turnover in this organ.

Variation in the frequency of complex forms of mitochondrial DNA in different brain regions of senescent mice.

It was shown previously that the frequency of an aberrant form of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), double-sized circular molecules or circular dimers, increased significantly in the brain of senescent mice, to about 2% versus less than 0.1% in the brain of adult mice. To follow up these observations, we isolated total mtDNA from 6 different brain regions of 29-month-old male BALB/c mice and examined it for the occurrence of circular dimers and other complex forms by electron microscopy. There was a statistically highly significant variability in the occurrence of circular dimer mtDNA among the 6 brain regions. The frequencies of circular dimers were: medulla, 3.3%; cortex, 1.7%; midbrain, 1.1%; cerebellum, 0.9%; hippocampus, 0.5%; and striatum, 0.2%. The frequency of catenated (topologically interlinked) molecules varied only slightly, from 4 to 6%. On the basis of the available literature, a correlation appears to exist between age-related tissue pathology of the mouse brain and the increased incidence of circular dimer mtDNA. Although no cause-effect relationships can be established, it is suggested that the frequency of circular dimer mtDNA may be a useful marker in assessing the general physiological condition of the aging brain.